The Orlando Sentinel editorial board published a statement denouncing the current zeal for censorship in schools and school libraries. (To learn about the history of book banning and censorship in American schools, read my book THe Language Police). The rising tide of book banning threatens freedom of thought, academic freedom, and common sense.
Banning and burning books is nothing new. What’s new are the targets: Books about race and racism.
In Tennessee, zealots want to get rid of a picture book by Ruby Bridges, who became the first Black student at an all-white New Orleans school when she was just 6 years old.
Among the supposedly objectionable material in “Ruby Bridges Goes to School: My True Story” are photos that show white people holding signs that say, “We want segragation (sic),” and, “We don’t want to Integrate,” as well as another showing a young boy with a sign that reads, “We wont (sic) go to school with Negroes.”
These unacceptable images are real, historical photos illustrating a true story about a young Black girl breaking the barriers of racial segregation in the Deep South.
People of good will can make reasonable arguments about what should and should not be on public school reading lists and library shelves. Some material is too sexually explicit or too violent for some ages. Surely we can at least agree on that.
But the objections raised in Tennessee and other states, including Florida, are more about manipulating history than anything else.
In Tennessee, the objections to Ruby Bridges’ book, made by the far-right group Moms For Liberty, are objectively preposterous.
The Moms For Liberty, which has roots in Florida, told the Tennessee Education Department that “Ruby Bridges Goes to School” — as well as a book about Martin Luther King Jr.’s 1963 March on Washington — run afoul of a new Tennessee law that restricts the way racism can be taught in public schools to ensure no one’s feelings get hurt…
Florida’s Legislature is hot on Tennessee’s heels. The Florida Department of Education handed down a muddled and confusing rule last summer that bans teaching Critical Race Theory. And Brevard County state Rep. Randy Fine has followed up with proposed law — House Bill 57 — that’s a virtual carbon copy of Tennessee’s.
The Tennessee experience with a picture book for kids provides just a taste of what Florida schools are in for should Fine’s bill passes….
Because, absurd as it might seem, Florida’s rapidly adopting the official view that racism is a relic of the past.
This is going to get worse before it gets better.
Many forms of institutional racism are indeed things of the past. But that is no reason to ban books that paint the historical picture. I hope that Ruby Bridges also includes historical photos of Lyndon Johnson signing legislation that officially did away with the overt racism and discrimination that existed when Ruby entered first grade in 1960.
That story is told in schools and has been for some time.
Stop listening to the mischaracterizations of right wing media.
LBJ also thought we “did away” with all that when he wasn’t interested in taking the findings of the Kerner Report seriously in 1968.
exactly
This comment about Johnson reminds me of something that George Bush, Jr. (aka Shrub) once said:
“I solved the education problem on my first day in office.”
He was referring to signing the No Child Left Unpunished Act. Deliciously unintentionally comic. But also tragedy and farce.
I’m not sure that the actual signing was on his first day. He might have been referring to readying the bill for signing. Diane would know.
The point of the book banning is not, of course, to wipe out racism but to preserve it by hoping ignorance will prevent challenge.
Book Burning As A Function Of POWER & CONQUEST
But for Rebecca Knuth, author of Libricide: The Regime-Sponsored Destruction of Books and Libraries in the Twentieth Century + Burning Books and Leveling Libraries: Extremist Violence and Cultural Destruction, Qin and religious leaders like him are only a small part of the early book-burning equation. Chinese emperor Qin Shi Huang (more widely remembered for his terracotta army in Xian) ordered a bonfire of books as a way of consolidating power in his new empire.
“A lot of ancient book burning was a function of conquest,” Knuth says.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/brief-history-book-burning-printing-press-internet-archives-180964697/
Yeah, book burning is similar to mail lions’ killing of all the cubs when they take over a pride.
perfect analogy
I wonder where mail lions live.
Post office! Yikes, this crazy English language!
As the Eagles sang,
You can’t hide your lion eyes
Your “disgust” is a thin disguise
I thought by now, you’d realize
There ain’t no way to hide your lion eyes
Is that lion eyes or lionizing? Lionizing a lie? It’s a burning question.
Book Banning
A book is banned
But ideas stand
The flames are fanned
But but can’t be canned
Book Burning” would probably be better title
Though book’s consumed
The fire grows
And book’s exhumed
As phoenix knows
Great pieces again, SomeDAM!
I like these two poems a lot. Books can be burned, but the act of consumption lights the ideas behind the books aglow. The crazy rightwing is shining a revealing and unflattering light on itself. They might win a battle here and there, but every battle won loses their war.
Yes!
Unless it’s an eternal war. It so seems to me.
Oh, hell yes SomeDAM.
Reblogged this on dean ramser.
I am loathe to go off topic, ever, but I’ve noticed a trend recently that bears watching, immediate and thorough responses, and public awareness. In a political version of “I’m not, you are,” the fascist right is now misusing terms to create even more confusion and outrage among their cult and fellow travelers. Therefore, anything the Left does now is “fascism” and looney theories about Covid are “backed by science.” Beware, folks, pay attention to language and don’t let them get away with it. The goal, of course, is to brand “fascism” as the new “communism,” another term of which they have absolutely no grasp but are convinced of their certainty.
It’s connected with the post because controlling language is the first battleground of fascism. It justifies the violence and authoritarianism that they believe will soon follow.
Lacking imagination, whatever charge is leveled against the right, they lob it back. Two examples are “ditto head” and “fascist”.
When the right wing coined the moniker, “Snowflake”, for the left, it wasn’t lobbed back.
People on the left are better human beings. Decency and integrity matter to them.
Loath is an adjective, as in “I was loath to wear such ill-fitting pants.” Loathe is a verb, as in “I loathe those ill-fitting pants!”
Thanks for the correction, you are correct. Seriously, glad you pointed it out. Rewrite:
I loathe going off topic…
Do bots self appoint as spell check? Is it a default setting? Does bot cancel out expletives directed at the bot?
Request to Zuck, – opt out, “Linda”, from the program
Bot,
Has AI reached the point where, like humans, it can distinguish the unimportant from the important?
Loath to Loathe
I’m loath to loathe
But I suppose
If both proposed
Then loathe disposed
Indeed. Why the extra “e” there when it’s silent? I think just to annoy GregB and for the bots to carve out a living.
I was trying out my British accent in writing to make me sound more impressive. Guess it didn’t work. Next time I’ll try theatre or realise.
It’s always the silent type that you have to worry about.
And the lion eyes.
I, Loathebot
Isaac Asimov’s least known book
SomeDAM has always been the silent type you have to worry about?
Poet-
“I Loathebot”- sheer gold
The silent type”
The silent type will get you
Especially the e‘s
They really will affect you
Though silenc, if you pleas
Supposed to be
“Through silenc, if you pleas”
The silent autocorrect is arguably even more insidious than the silent e
They should make it ding every time it changes something.
Then again. It would be dinging all the time.
Never mind
“And Brevard County state Rep. Randy Fine has followed up with proposed law — House Bill 57 — that’s a virtual carbon copy of Tennessee’s.”
Behind the spreading of these laws is the Koch created ALEC.
After the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) faced a public backlash and exodus of corporate members over its promotion of controversial and racist voter ID and “stand your ground” gun laws a decade ago, it raised a white flag and claimed to abandon all model policy related to social issues and elections.
While it’s dubious whether ALEC ever really got out of the right-wing social legislation game, one thing is clear now: ALEC is back.
At the May meeting of the secretive, Christian-Right Council for National Policy, ALEC led two panel discussions on state legislation in which it claimed credit for helping to push and pass a host of laws to make it harder to vote, block public schools from teaching about racism in America, and protect employers from COVID-related lawsuits.
https://www.exposedbycmd.org/2021/09/07/alec-claims-credit-for-voter-suppression-and-anti-critical-race-theory-laws-at-secret-meeting/
The racist and, Covid-denying campaigns are likely linked. American authoritarians and the Kremlin are aligned to achieve the same goal, with help from Fox hosts trying to make book for themselves.
Russia has a history of treating its people as cannon fodder. Loss of life among right wing Americans whose sense of grievance has been stoked to the point of self-sacrifice means nothing to Putin and I doubt to Charles Koch either.
“self sacrifice” — the old “cut off your nose to spite your face” coming back into popularity
Their grievance keeps them from saving their own lives and their love one’s lives – for them, a mere pinprick is a step too far. There’s got to be a name for pseudo patriots for whom, the smallest Fox admonition, sends them into righteous inaction.
Under the iron fist of DeSantis Florida defies logic. It thinks it can eliminate racism by banning books, improve education by privatizing it and conquer a deadly virus by ignoring it. Florida is currently recruiting law enforcement rejects from New York by luring them with of a $5000 dollar signing bonus. Under the fascist leaning DeSantis logic and justice are rarely major considerations. https://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/florida/fl-ne-ftf-ny-police-florida-move-20211122-ir5zmozctjajfnomcudocck4a4-story.html
Can New Yorker’s contribute to that fund.
https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/book-burning
The agitprop campaign to secure complete Repugnican control of the U.S. government–House, Senate, Supreme Court, and Presidency, via the 2022 and 2024 elections is a stool with three legs: the current inflation, riling up parents about supposed pornography and Socialist teaching in their schools, and stoking of racism among those parents via The Great CRT Scare.
To change up the metaphor a bit, this is a tried-and-true play from the fascist playbook.
Those who don’t learn from history (or aren’t allowed to learn it) are condemned. There, that’s shorter and less redundant than is the usual aphorism.
“Those who don’t learn from history (or aren’t allowed to learn it) are condemned. ”
Repugnicants do know their history, this is why they use the well tried tools of suppression.
yup
Repugnicants! LOL!
Also Repugnicans and Repugnuts.
In other news, the Ghislaine Maxwell trial, the purpose of which is, I suppose, to prosecute ONE of those involved and so deflect outrage away from all the wealthy and powerful men involved in this, starts today.
Yes, we are addressing this case of colorectal cancer. We used six whole Band-Aids!
Endemic corruption. Token prosecutory theatre.
No, I am not suggesting that she’s some sort of innocent victim, so please, don’t go there. She has been accused of extremely serious and extremely egregious crimes.
What happened to Ruby Bridges as a child is not ancient history. I was alive when she went through her ordeal as a child. She is very much alive and active; her story should be told and retold. There are blacks alive today who have great grandparents, even grandparents who were born into slavery. For African-Americans, slavery, segregation, lynchings, Jim Crow laws and police brutality are not some mythical or theoretical proposition. Why should their stories be buried because it offends the sensibilities of some white folks. And for damn sure, the positive aspects of this country are taught too, so don’t hand me (this is to the right wingers) this nonsense that we are only emphasizing the negative or bad things about this country. And stop with the “woke” baloney nonsense; teaching real history is not being woke, it’s just common sense. It’s a bald faced lie that liberals are only teaching how horrible this country is and nothing else or that lefties are indoctrinating the kids to hate the USA. Lie, lie and more lies from the right wing GOP insurrectionist toads.
From the dailymail.com, 11-29-21: Carrie Meek, the grandchild of a slave who became one of the first black Floridians elected to Congress since Reconstruction, died Sunday [11-28-21] at the age of 95.
Meek died at her home in Miami after a long illness, her family said in a statement. The family did not specify a cause of death.
Meek, whose mother and father were both sharecroppers, started her congressional career at an age when many people begin retirement.
On her first day in Congress, Meek reflected that while her grandmother, a slave on a Georgia farm, could never have dreamed of such an accomplishment, her parents told her that anything was possible. end quote
Love this post and hope everyone reads the conclusion of the first paragraph:
“And stop with the “woke” baloney nonsense; teaching real history is not being woke, it’s just common sense. It’s a bald faced lie that liberals are only teaching how horrible this country is and nothing else or that lefties are indoctrinating the kids to hate the USA. Lie, lie and more lies from the right wing GOP insurrectionist toads.”
Now read it over and over again until you get it and can convey the message to others. Feel free to use stronger words than “toads.”
I try to behave myself in Diane’s living room. Thanks for the positive vibes.
I thought that “toads” was perfect. Bufo and Bravo!
And yeah, that’s a perfect paragraph. It’s a paragraph like a freaking Greek temple, it’s so beautiful.
I guess field trips to the National Memorial for Peace and Justice and the National Lynching Museum are off the table for students near Montgomery, Alabama. We wouldn’t want to make young people feel “uncomfortable.” While young people should not feel guilty, they should feel uncomfortable seeing this. Without knowledge and understanding, the mistakes of the past are more likely to be repeated. Sometimes discomfort leads to growth.
Magnificent, Joe Jersey! Truly magnificent!
Well said. Anything that happened in my lifetime; I would like to think is not ancient history !!!!!!!
i
LOL. Think again!
Dear fellow teachers. Your assignment for today is to write on the white board a statement following this form:
Attention, students! Please avoid reading the following books, which are far too controversial and mature for you to be reading them:
[list of books]
Book banning in schools has always meant the same thing: I don’t want my child to read anything that might cause them to learn about or challenge the way things are, especially with respect to race, inequity, gender, sex, or democracy. Not only that, I don’t want other people’s children to read about those things, either.
YUP.
Though I think it’s more specifically, I don’t want my child . . . to learn about or challenge my prejudices
Bob: A great response to book banning! Provide every student with a list of books they must never read. Never!
I celebrated Banned Books Week with my students this year.
Wonderful!
Awesome!
One of the long list of things I love about Diane Ravitch (let me count the ways) is that while she has bright lines (in more than one sense of “bright”), she has enormous tolerance for lively satire and debate and DETESTS kneejerk censorship. She has long, long been a staunch defender of freedom of thought and expression. If you haven’t read The Language Police, treat yourself.
I, for one, would find this blog a somewhat diminished thing without the occasional accidental comedy routine by a member of the Vladimir Putin Glee Club or the Trump “Clowns in Kevlar and Sharp Suits Improv Team.”
And, ofc:
“Let her and Falsehood grapple; who ever knew Truth put to the worse in a free and open encounter?” ― John Milton, Areopagitica
She does occasionally remind us that this is her living room. Respect for that, too. More than once I have heard, “My lord, Bob. You kiss your mother with that mouth?”
Thank you, Bob. No one better in education publishing than you!
Can Florida Schools ban the Internet?
They’ll have to ban the internet
To keep the books from kids
Cuz online books are theirs to get
Since websites have no lids
Coming soon to a former democracy near you!
I actually think that Internet is not needed in schools–unless of course they burn the books in the library.
I can imagine that 50 years from now, library will be the place where the weekly bookburning takes place, and kids would learn in history classes that originally kids read books in the library, and they would shiver at the thought that such a creepy place was once visited regularly by schoolchildren. Brrrr.
OK, Mate. Please turn this into a short story!
“that’s a virtual carbon copy of Tennessee’s.”
Can you say ALEC?
Yes, exactly as Mate said above. Thanks for reiterating this. Really important. This is all part of a well-designed, sick but effective STRATEGY for the 2022 and 2024 elections. The hapless Dems have no comparable devices.
Thanks for reminding me. I live in a sort of intellectual desert where government is concerned. For years, we have imitated like lower primates the ideas of the rest of the country. ALEC is just the latest fad to be joined. The state of Cordell Hull has become the state of despair. Or at least the despair tire.
LOL
A bunch of books in high school libraries in one district in Utah have been pulled from shelves, without even going through the district’s own process for challenging books. All the books in question are by Black or LGTBQIA+ authors
Really sorry to hear this, Threatened. Warm regards!
TOW-
Living in a community whose leaders recently passed a law against abortion, I am sorry at what is happening in both your community and mine.
Vice’s story about Idaho’s Christ Church is alarming.
Right wing reactionary actions are designed to stifle free thought and speech.
Attention, school administrators: It will be very important to your continued employment, in the current climate, for you to join the Grand Old Party Book Burning Brigade (GOP BBB). So, for your own preservation, immediately make up a list of banned books (anything the slightest bit controversial or mature), have copies printed up, and require that your teachers have these lists on their desks and posted in their classrooms at all times so that you can see that they are there during pop-in evaluations. The following format is suggested:
Attention, students! Please avoid reading the following books as they are much too controversial and mature for you. Thank you.
[list of books]
Ignorant, racist creeps hate it when their kids come home from school and say, “Stop being an ignorant, racist creep.” It is what it is.
But, alas, given the level of racism in the U.S. so vividly demonstrated by the Trump misadministration invitation for it all to come out into the open and rally, this makes for a GREAT strategy for the White Supremacist Party (formerly the GOP) for 2022 and 2024. No surprise, then, that Trump Mini-Mes who long to ASSUME THE ORANGE MANTLE themselves are ALL IN.
Perhaps the proper response is to publish lists of book banned or discouraged. It usually seems to work. People like banned books. Of course this presupposes a free society. I once had a conversation with a man who had been in publishing. He proudly told of how he has kept “Communist” writing out of the public eye. I took it he was pretty important during the 50s.
I had a beautiful little copy of Mao’s Little Red Book, printed in China, but in English. I used to pull it out and show it to my kids from time to time and say to them, “Be thankful that you live in a country where people can have this on their shelves without having the Gestapo break down their doors.”
The co-founder of the neo- confederate organization, League of the South, co-wrote a book with the pastor of Christ Church in Moscow, Idaho. The goal of the followers of Christ Church is to turn Moscow into a Christian community” and a theocratic state.
Critics claim that recruiting for the community and for jobs is based on hate. Prominent members of the church are leaders at the largest employer in Moscow. The church has a college, New St. Andrews.
Both Guardian (Nov. 2, 2021) and Vice, earlier, describe what beliefs the Church has. Vice goes into detail about what it is like for women in the Christian Church.
Women who vote Republican, shouldn’t. The GOP is no friend to women’s rights.
Yeah, that is a truly terrifying situation.
Joining this party late….
They don’t want to wipe out racism.
They want to wipe out BEING CALLED A RACIST because it’s real and true and evidence-based and cross-burned and spoken in code and yes to all the CRT followers, it IS SYSTEMIC.
Wait, what,
Good insight.
yes.
and spoken in code
Alas, that’s so easy to do that even Trump and his Clown Car Posse and his Citizens’ Militia Trumpanzees can do it.
Here’s the think about this code. Literally anyone who wants to can decipher it, but when one side points it out, the other side, get this, while acting on that code, will deny that it even exists. That’s because the don’t see race when they meet or see people.
yes
The men and women voting Republican who think that abortion is the only right that they will lose, are lying to themselves. The U.S. Supreme Court has already been taken over by one religious sect. Public schools are crowded out of the community by religious schools and the taxpayer is forced to pay for it. More than I in six American hospitals are owned by the religious and they provide no more charitable care than any other private hospital (public hospitals show much greater generosity to the indigent). The religious have exempted themselves from civil rights employment law. The 3rd largest U.S. employer is the tax-funded organizations of one religious sect, ….
In a theocracy, what individual rights will survive? Answer- Only those allowed by the despot with whom the religious have aligned.
Look to the Middle East to see what happens to citizens’ rights under theocratic/despot rule.
You make good points that should be considered. Americans have the tendency to believe that religion is well meaning, but that is not always the case.
Thank you for your comment, retired teacher.
It just struck me on a drive this afternoon. Teachers who use CRT in classes and make white kids feel bad about being white are today’s welfare queens! And they’re just as prevalent–not. They’ve just become more refined, following Lee Atwater’s dictum all the way.
Yes. Imaginary creatures to scare people with. Boo!
Reagan was a master of saying the racist thing but with a dab of plausible deniability. We now know, ofc, how “Nancy and I hate racism” Reagan talked in private.
But the public talk was clear enough, wasn’t it? The welfare queen in her Cadillac, drawing 20 different government checks and making over a hundred thousand a year (which was a goodly sum in those days). That was quite the fable.
OK. Here’s your current events quiz for Monday, Nov. 29. Are the following statements exculpatory?
“The charges against Ghislaine Maxwell are for things that Jeffrey Epstein did. But she is not Jeffrey Epstein.” –Defense Attorney Bobbi Sternham, in opening statements in the Ghislaine Maxwell Trial
“I was one of the many horses pulling the wagon and couldn’t escape left or right because of the will of the driver.” –Adolf Eichmann, from the stand at his trial
Here’s the way to encourage kids NOT to read. Get rid of all the books in the school library and the librarian and put in a ping pong table and some computers. Meanwhile the kids in English classes tell their teacher they’ve never been to a library. Happened at a school close to home…
No banning of books needed in our public school system (although we have a small group of parents who are protesting loudly and just brought criminal charges against the school system and BoEd)….the libraries have been banned for students for several years (at the MS and HS levels). The libraries are beautiful and well stocked but there are no librarians OR time for students to access the libraries. The students only use the libraries for testing and test prep on the numerous laptops stored in the “media center”. The only time that the libraries are “open” are for back to school nights and parent/teacher conference days when Admin “stock” the library full of students work to show off for the parents. OTOH, our public library system is very robust and widely used. And I know this how?…..I actually saw it with my own 2 eyes and then questioned a former librarian (repurposed to upgrade/handle the computers) and a few teachers. Why ban books when the system can just as easily ban the whole school library? If parents really knew…..
Lisa, that’s awful!
Common, I think, all across the country. First, computers were installed in the libraries, and the libraries were rebranded as “Media Centers.” Then, the Deformers instituted their test-and-punish regime, and the Media Centers were taken over by a) test prep, b) taking practice tests to prepare for the state tests, and c) taking the state tests. Billions and billions of dollars lost, billions of hours of instructional time, and libraries a thing of the past.
A few years back, I was hired to teach English, film, and theatre at a high school. One day after that, but before school started, I happened to be driving by, so I stopped in and asked the administrative secretary if I might have a look at the library. She gave me a look as though I had mentioned a SECRET TOO TERRIBLE TO BE MENTIONED ALOUD and then told me that no, no one was allowed in there before school opened.
So, when school did open, I found that the “Library/Media Center” consisted of rows of computers for practice testing arranged along the walls and TWO tiny bookshelves containing random old donated books from parents in no order–stuff like a couple Readers Digest Condensed Books from the 1950s, a couple random volumes from an old set of encyclopedias, and an old book on how to do electrical wiring. Weirdly, there was on these shelves a paperback copy of Bernhard Schlink’s quite explicit novel The Reader, which is about a teenaged boy who has an affair with a woman later tried for her actions as a Nazi prison guard. It seemed pretty clear that this stuff got there because some decided to throw out/”donate” some random old books in boxes from his or her attic.
And even if one did want students to use something in this putative “Library,” there wouldn’t be any access to it because it was always filled with students doing practice tests for the state exams.
I have a slightly different perspective. Growing up we had a school library and a public library (and even a bookmobile that came to our school once a month!) and I loved getting books from all those places. Especially since classrooms had “readers” – reading textbooks with lots of short stories and a second textbook that had perhaps 8 “novelizations” with much longer stories.
But what my kid’s school had were classrooms filled with books and books. Lots of books and the kids chose which ones they wanted to read from leveled book bins. (Although I’d have to write a different post to address the problems with that.)
So when the students at my kid’s school made visits to the school library, it never seemed quite the unique experience that I had — after all, they could often find multiple copies of those same books in their classrooms so they didn’t need to go to the library to have access to those books.
The other thing that libraries had were reference books — encyclopedias, readers guides to periodical literature. But so much of that is on-line. One of the most important skills that librarians are needed to teach students is how to differentiate between a good and bad on-line source.
I have no idea how I learned that using information from the “National Enquirer” or “Tiger Beat Magazine” or was not a good way to write a research paper, but I knew that by college. Maybe there are just too many sources now, but it used to be that people could tell the difference between a credible and not credible source. And a not credible source could be correct about something and still be a not credible source,because a credible source tries to adhere to certain standards and make corrections if wrong, and a not credible source does not care if what they print is true or not.