Thom Hartmann is a journalist who writes a regular commentary, the Hartmann report. He wrote this on November 20.
— The singlemost ransacked office in the Capitol on January 6th was the office of the Parliamentarian, where the Electoral College ballots were supposed to be stored. This shocking bit of information, courtesy of Johnathan Karl’s new book Betrayal, is proof positive that this wasn’t just a “protest” or a “riot”: it was an actual, naked attempt to blow up the counting of the Electoral College votes. An attempted coup. Treason. The ballots were stored, according to Karl, in “three dark and shiny mahogany boxes brought in by the parliamentarian’s office to be carried along as the senators walked over to the House. The boxes looked like relics from a time long past—each one held shut by wide leather straps with brass clasps and locked with a skeleton key.” And if those ballots, which had literally been transported there from the states under seal and over official signatures, had been destroyed there was no provision in the Constitution for what to do next. Trump would continue as president, the traitors believed, and that would be the end of the Joe Biden presidency that Steve Bannon had proclaimed he and his fellow conspirators would “kill in the crib.” Fortunately for America and the world, the ballots had been spirited away by a quick-thinking young woman who worked for the Parliamentarian and doesn’t want her name known for fear of drawing death threats from Trump’s goons. She may well have saved American democracy.

“She may well have saved American democracy.”
I single person can make a huge difference even in world events, and often that person holds no high office. I am sure history has thousands of these cases, but they don’t make it to the history books or even papers on history.
LikeLike
I kind of think democracy was on the brink the day the DNC (a private organization, as supported by the courts) decided to use a global pandemic to override the leading candidate at the time in favor of the fourth-place septuagenarian racist war-mongering sex-pest to run against the other septuagenarian racist war-mongering sex-pest, but that’s just me.
LikeLike
As I recall, the Democratic candidate who won the nomination in 2020 (and in 2016) won the most delegates.
LikeLike
Diane Ravitch posts an important comment about how there was clearly a directed effort by right wingers to prevent Biden from taking office. What happened is NOT NORMAL. Had the ballots remained in the room, it could have been even more ugly than it has been.
And the response from our resident faux progressive is to change the subject to one of the far right’s favorite false narratives about how evil the Democrats are.
Bernie Sanders himself does not push this false narrative about how the Democrats “stole” the nomination from him and “canceled” him by making him Chairman of the Senate Budget Committee.
Purveyors of dishonest right wing propaganda need to be marginalized. Until we do so, it is hypocritical for us to ask why the Democrats just can’t get their message through.
LikeLike
Anyone remember our resident faux progressive who describes Biden as a “warmonger” posting any positive comments when Biden withdrew from Afghanistan while safely evacuating over 100,000 people?
Nope. Because faux progressives are here to amplify right wing propaganda only.
They need to be marginalized, not treated as if their false narratives are just as valid as the truth.
LikeLike
Are you speaking of me?
Anyone who sends Blinken to antagonize China is a warmonger. Anyone who continues to declare Central American elections to be ‘fraudulent’ and refuses to recognize a leader that won almost a 70% majority is a warmonger. Anyone continuing to allow covert US incursions supporting ‘regime change’ in Africa and Latin America is a war monger. Anyone signing the largest ‘defense’ budget in history is a war monger. Gosh, just look at Biden’s voting record in the Senate. Any war he didn’t support?
FURTHERMORE, Biden pointed out that his ‘withdrawal’ from Afghanistan only meant that ‘we’ would still have ‘over the horizon capabilities’ (drones). And only ‘troops’ were withdrawn, not US ‘contractors’ (mercenaries).
BTW, I’m about as ‘faux progressive’ as Bob LaFolette, or Henry Wallace.
LikeLike
Daedalus says “Are you speaking of me?”
Only if you are currently posting under two different names. Are you? Not sure why anyone would feel the need to change the subject from our democracy being on the brink except someone that hoped that the Republicans could get away with that until they succeed, at which point our criticism becomes moot as our voices will be silenced.
” Anyone who continues to declare Central American elections to be ‘fraudulent’ and refuses to recognize a leader that won almost a 70% majority is a warmonger.”
Let’s see what the Biden White House statement actually is:
“What Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega and his wife, Vice President Rosario Murillo, orchestrated today was a pantomime election that was neither free nor fair, and most certainly not democratic. The arbitrary imprisonment of nearly 40 opposition figures since May, including seven potential presidential candidates, and the blocking of political parties from participation rigged the outcome well before election day. They shuttered independent media, locked up journalists and members of the private sector, and bullied civil society organizations into closing their doors. Long unpopular and now without a democratic mandate, the Ortega and Murillo family now rule Nicaragua as autocrats, no different from the Somoza family that Ortega and the Sandinistas fought four decades ago. ”
Really? That’s all okay with you because “Ortega won a 70% majority”?
But no problem. I can definitely understand why those who think it is perfectly fine to do the above would find Republicans fomenting and condoning violent folks storming the Capitol to prevent a count of ballots that would certify the democratically elected president from taking office and totally empower the guy who lost instead nothing worth mentioning.
We will have to agree to disagree. Putin “wins” a big majority, too.
LikeLike
I’d rather take the word of international inspectors than that of the Biden press release.
LikeLike
But there were no international inspectors allowed. Exactly whose word are you taking?
There were a lot of parallels to the way that Ortega ran the election and the way that the Trump Republican party wants to run an election. Lock up opponents. Voter intimidation. They decide who gets to vote and who doesn’t.
I doubt very much you can cite international inspectors but if you can provide more information, I would look at it. I tried to find any information about it — I am fair-minded and was perfectly open to being wrong. But all I could find were references to international inspectors not being allowed. I assume you are a Trump voter so I can understand why you idealize the Nicaragua election as one that you hope that the Republicans are able to impose in this country.
LikeLike
Cynicism kills democracy.
LikeLike
Very spooky. Very.
LikeLike
D-77 lives in some alternate universe light years from reality and enlightened human comprehension. She keeps referring to the septuagenarians, does she have a bias against septuagenarians who are otherwise healthy, or septuagenarians in general? She is equating Trump with Biden!!!!! Trump, the guy who encouraged an insurrection, an almost coup d’etat. Biden: he’s a decent person who has made a strong effort to enact social programs that will help all Americans, including septuagenarians. Biden is so much better than Trump, it should be obvious to any sentient human being unless you are a dyed-in-the-wool GOPer, fascist, neo-Nazi or far, far right wing nut.
LikeLike
To emphasize the argument, in physics, light years does not refer to our conception of time. It represents numbers from the hundreds of thousands to the most recent estimate of the outer edges of the universe, more than 14 billion light years (where’s Carl Sagan when you really need him?)! So when we use the term light years, that’s REALLY far out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
D-77 is far out. She swoops in aboard her dive bomber, drops her stink bombs, then soars off into the wild blue yonder, probably chuckling at what she thinks is some big score.
Thanks for the info.
LikeLike
You just reminded me of the great George Gobel joke about when he was in the air national guard stationed in Oklahoma during WWII. He reasoned he must have been effective because Japan never dared to try to invade Oklahoma.
LikeLike
The confusion about light years is pretty common.
For example, Joan Baez thought light years was a measure of time.
Well, I’ll be damned
Here comes your ghost again
But that’s not unusual
It’s just that the moon is full
And you happened to call
And here I sit
Hand on the telephone
Hearing a voice I’d known
A couple of light years ago
Heading straight for a fall
And Joan’s father was a physicist and her brother is a mathematician.
LikeLike
Democracy will teeter on the brink of authoritarianism, while liberalism is quashed, for as long as so many Americans studiously ignore (1) conservative religion’s marshaling of support for views like those proposed by Patrick Deneen at Note Dame University (2) the clout of conservative Catholic SCOTUS judges and Leonard Leo’s judges (Federalist Society) (3) the politicking of state religious conferences specific to one sect and, (4) the right wing wealthy’s financing of policy research at private schools like Georgetown.
In 2013, Frank H. McCourt (not the author), the former Dodgers owner, gave the Catholic Georgetown University (located in D.C.) its largest donation in history, directed to the public policy school. Then, recently he doubled his pledge to the school.
Wikipedia reports that McCourt developed a separate endeavor whose coalition partners are the Aspen Institute and Heartland Forward, a Walton-linked group.
To understand McCourt’s socioeconomic background, his grandfather was a co- owner of a national ball team.
LikeLike
Geeze!!! Where are the billionaire donors propagandizing for the real actual public schools? Where are the billionaire funded pro public school foundations and think tanks? There is the NPE, which is a rarity but very welcome and thanks to Diane’s efforts. There are tons of the pro privation groups, foundations and think tanks, it’s not an even playing field.
LikeLike
Diane sacrifices a great deal for her country. Few others do.
LikeLike
Georgetown grad, Jamie McCourt (divorced from Frank in 2011), was Trump’s ambassador to France. She gave his victory fund $400,000. Open Secrets reports Frank’s 2016 donation to “Hillary Victory Fund” was $50,000.
LikeLike
Thom Hartman is known as an independent journalist that does his homework and provides insights into political turning points such as the Jan. 6th attempted coup. For more skin crawling insights, listen to his podcasts or read his articles about how Republicans intend to lie, cheat and steal their way in future elections. Once considered too alarmist for mainstream consumption, Hartmanis getting more attention for sounding bona fide alarm bells.
LikeLike
cx: Hartmann is
LikeLike
Trump’s cuckoo coup was the Beer Hall Putsch. The real show is coming. It starts with the fascist party in the United States winning the House and the Senate in 2022 because Democrats can’t be bothered to go out in vote and with DeSantis’s election to the Presidency in 2024.
Not with a bang but a whimper.
Joe Biden is much better than Trump, but his administration is not acting as though it understands what is at stake. It needs to be aggressively pursuing prosecution of Trump and his criminal, treasonous capos. Not a time for namby-pampyism. Democracy is at stake. This is as serious as it gets, short of nuclear war.
Putin is having a good laugh right now.
LikeLike
the promise of enforcement of the Hatch Act… the lawsuits that have been on the horizon for some time…the second district of New York…Matt Gaetz…hope wanes.
Only the poor guy without access to the right wing money backing White supremacy gets punished.
LikeLike
If you are I had done what Gaetz did, we would long ago have been in prison. First whiff, we would have been arrested and held without bail. Two separate legal systems. One for the wealthy and/or powerful. Another for the rest of us. A joke.
LikeLike
cx: you or I or anyone on this blog
LikeLike
Bob-
World Population Review posted research about the most racist cities in America (2021). The top 4 are in Iowa, Wis. (2) and Minnesota.
The George Floyd and Kyle Rittenhouse cases were not an aberration.
LikeLike
The only penalty for violation of the Hatch Act is removal from the office held at the time. So, OF COURSE, the DOJ is pursuing these violations because they will make precisely no difference.
LikeLike
Agreed, Bob. German authorities coddled Hitler. Never saw him as a threat until it was too late.
LikeLike
Exactly, Diane. This is exactly what is happening. And then it will be too late.
LikeLike
This is the thing that just makes me weep, Diane. We have learned nothing. We are absolutely doing it again.
LikeLike
A dragon is burning down the village? Go ask him to come in for a nice cup of tea, and warn him that we have set up a committee to investigate where that hoard of gold came from.
LikeLike
That committee will issue a VERY STRONG non-binding resolution suggesting that gold hoarding is not in the public interest. Take that, dragon!
LikeLike
According to Adam Schiff said that the Justice Department is unwilling to pursue Trump for his interference in the Georgia election. People that care about the future of the democracy should insist that Merrick Garland do his job and pursue all avenues of potential illegal activities by Trump and associates. Otherwise, Democrats will continue to be perceived as weak and failing. Biden’s accomplishments will be lost in the same way that the Obama lost the House after the passage of the ACA. The American people have a short memory for some things and a long memory for others.
LikeLike
There will be no accountability. This is now clear. These people will whistle while the house burns.
LikeLike
What did we learn from our mid-20th-century history lesson.
Well, we didn’t learn the crucial thing–the one that makes a difference.
LikeLike
If the analogies suggested here with the rise of the NAZI movement play out, it will be strange. While Germany and the world were mired in 1933 in a world depression not matched since, we are not doing so bad, given the pandemic and all that.
A better analogy might be with the Japanese struggle between democrats and oligarchs in the early 1900s. Oligarchs found ways to make society pay attention to the pageant of life while they consolidated their power.
LikeLike
Emphatically do not agree, Roy. The analogy with the situation in Germany is solid on many, many fronts.
LikeLike
GregB, you can pitch in here any time.
LikeLike
I think the time to debate analogies has come and gone. In 2016, I joined this blog because I had long been aware of Diane’s writings, understood the fundamental connection between public education and governing–that one could not live without the other, and felt the erosion of public education was a “canary in a coal mine” about bigger, more disturbing trends. I spent a lot of time rereading The Origins of Totalitarianism, Isaiah Berlin, and histories and literature from the 1910s-1930s and realized I was not overreacting. Indeed, in retrospect, I under-reacted. Back then I warned that the Idiot was a fascist to be taken as such. What I didn’t appreciate was the depth of the hate for social change and the cravenness of the reaction. And I am convinced that I was part of the problem for not taking my misgiving to their logical conclusion. We see it now. But rather than debate if the better analogy is 1930s Germany or turn of the century Japan, I’d rather go in a different direction and consider how Americans have influenced totalitarianism (the answer, by the way, is the former). Here’s an excerpt of what I wrote in my notes about Victor Klemperer’s LTI, a collection of essays he wrote about the language of the Third Reich and how it was used to maintain power:
Among his more interesting observations is how much of Nazi propaganda was based on Americanisms—an overuse of bombastic superlatives, consistent attributions of greatness and superiority, the constant use of the jargon of sports and competition, and ranking subjective, unquantifiable concepts. Ideas and language like American exceptionalism (“the greatest country in the world”), inane debates of which athletes from different eras are “better,” or “competitions” like the Oscars, which claim to elevate various categories of film production as “best,” were copied in their own way in Nazi Germany. Even the Hitlerian idea of Lebensraum, as Timothy Snyder noted in Bloodlands, found its inspiration in the American idea of Manifest Destiny. Taken together, all these Americanisms helped support the fanaticism Nazis craved and demanded of their followers.
When Republicans use this kind of language, it’s time to beware. When Democrats do, it’s time to call them out on it and point out how they lose the debate before it begins. Let me be clear, I think we are losing and will continue to lose this battle until we become an authoritarian, openly racist state. The best we can do is hope to create a younger generation that’s ready to resist. And that ain’t looking one bit good right now.
LikeLike
Powerfully written, thanks Greg.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Did you watch the last Repugnican convention, Roy? I sat through it, watching how the presented themselves and what they were calling for and thought, where is Leni Riefenstahl to turn this into a movie. All the fascist tropes were there.
LikeLike
Notes from rereading of The Origins of Totalitarianism a couple of days after the 2016 GOP convention:
The 2016 Republican convention, especially when viewed through the propagandistic lens of Fox News (our friends outside of the U.S. really would have a hard time understanding how this can exist and thrive in “the land of the free and the home of the brave”), provided a Petri dish-like environment to examine how leaders with totalitarian tendencies control their “fellow-travelers.” Compare some of her observations with what we witnessed in Cleveland; how the members of the movement with “a curiously varying mixture of gullibility and cynicism” are “expected to react to the changing lying statements of the leaders and the central unchanging ideological fiction of the movement.” Or how the fellow-travelers “had reached the point where they would, at the same time, believe everything or nothing, think that everything was possible and that nothing was true” and “how its audience was ready at all times to believe the worst, no matter how absurd.”
It is easy to dismiss linkages of current politics to Nazism and Stalinism because of their extreme experience with eliminating “objective enemies” through terror and death camps. The current brand of American xenophobia won’t go that far—at least not in public. It has, unfortunately, in Syria and Iraq. Some of these contemporary ideas share a fantasy of labeling some “whose past justifies suspicion” and are “‘carrier[s] of tendencies’ like the carrier[s] of a disease” and, in order for the system to function, it “constantly meets with new obstacles that have to be eliminated.” Elimination doesn’t necessarily mean death; it also can be restriction, confinement, or deportation. It can include “torture” which “in this context is only the desperate and eternally futile attempt to achieve what cannot be achieved.” And it breeds “mutual suspicion” that “permeates all social relationships” and “provocation…becomes a method of dealing with…neighbor[s]” in “which everybody, willing or unwilling, is forced to follow.” Sounds a lot like Trumpism to me.
LikeLike
The current brand of American xenophobia won’t go that far—at least not in public.
I wouldn’t be so sure ten, fifteen years out.
LikeLike
My take: The Republican Party in the era of Trump has become extremely radicalized. At the same time, the oligarchs who control the purse strings of that party understand that they have a short window in which to lock in control. The kids coming up, who will be voters before long, are against them, overwhelmingly, on all the issues. And, the changing demographics of the country are also against them. Biden got 93 percent of the Black vote in 2020.
But, they can stop the current of history in its tracks with of the House, the Senate, the Presidency, and the Supreme Court in 2024. With all that in place, they can pack the court and set about rewriting US law to lock in a Fourth Reich. Repressive voting restriction laws, a nationalist curriculum, militarization of the police, the use of the military as police, mass arrests and incarceration of dissenters, expulsion of immigrants, new controls on social media–all already called for at the last Republican Convention.
What’s coming up is their window of opportunity, and they must seize it with authoritarian fervor or they will cease to exist.
LikeLike
And, ofc, they must pack the court with even more extreme right-wingers, which they can easily do with a simple majority. Kevvin McCarthy just promised to give Gosar and Greene assignments on the most important committees. This is what the new Repugnican Fascist Party looks like.
LikeLike
And this idea, among Repugnicans, has a name: “White Replacement Theory.” Even IQ45, as dumb as he is, sees that the future looks bleak for Republicans unless they seize the moment. That’s what’s behind his “you’re not going to have a [white] country any more.”
LikeLike
The Trump maladministration already tried, and failed, to turn the military on dissenters. Milley and Esper wouldn’t let them. The next guy will be smarter than Trump by far, but he’ll have the same level of respect for democratic processes, which is none at all, and the same commitment to an imperial presidency.
LikeLike
If I could add to your take: I think Republicans have ceased to be a political party. It is very much a cult of power driven by a resinous form of racism. It recognized in the first run that permanently destroying the mechanisms of government is surprisingly easy when they have them. And sadly, far too few in the Democratic Party realize just how serious this is or how to convey it to their voters.
LikeLike
To your point, Greg: they didn’t even bother to draft a platform at the last convention. The platform was Glorious Leader.
LikeLike
” resinous form” Great word choice
LikeLike
Bob and GregB,
This is a very interesting discussion that is scaring the heck out of me, and I’ve already been scared for years!
LikeLike
Dems better be afraid enough to get themselves and others to the polls!
LikeLike
And, we have record food and gas prices, and some group is placing stickers with pic so Biden and the words “I did this” next to the price at the pumps.
LikeLike
Oversimplification of complex ideas, distilling them into conspiracy theories and fabricated history, is essential to making fascism function. Or conversely, as Richard Evans put it in his conclusion of The Hitler Conspiracies: “Working out what really happened in history is difficult: it requires a great deal of hard work, it demands direct examination of the evidence, it presupposes a willingness to change one’s mind, it involves the abandonment of one’s prejudices and preconceptions in the face of evidence that tells against them.”
LikeLike
LikeLike
LikeLike
The beer hall putsch. The armed brownshirts in the streets. The call for a new nationalism. The cult leader. The praise for vigilante murderers. The identification of scapegoats. And the coddling of people who tried to overthrow the government. This is what makes me weep. We have learned nothing, and it’s all happening again.
LikeLike
Re: Putsch. In case you don’t know about Georg Elser, you should: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/793536642?book_show_action=false&from_review_page=1
LikeLike
Not sure why you are mentioning this guy, Greg.
LikeLike
Greg, this is a fascinating review. Reminds us of the “what ifs” of history.
LikeLike
When you mentioned putsch, I thought this might interest you. It’s a history few Germans know. There was a pretty good movie based on this book a few years ago, 13 Minutes.
LikeLike
I knew about the attempt on his life but didn’t remember the name. Thanks, Greg.
LikeLike
AND, of course, the whole thing wrapped in a great big shiny package of racism.
LikeLike
I think that this is apples and oranges, Roy. Since the 1850s, Japan had had a poll tax that basically restricted the vote to a small percentage of, the wealthiest portion of, the population. It was not historically a democracy. The flirtation with democratic reforms was brief.
LikeLike
“we are not doing so bad, given the pandemic and all that.”
It is amazing what one can accomplish with smoke and mirrors.
Few people (including few economists) recognized the precarious nature of the world economy before the 2007 meltdown either.
And little has changed since, other than that a lot of big banks have learned that they are too big to fail so no matter what they do, they will be bailed out. Or so they believe.
But the next time it might be a great depression rather than a Great Recession.
LikeLike
Any ideas about how to fix the economy?
LikeLike
Flerp: a far more steeply progressive tax system; a livable minimum wage with a regional COLA adjustment; Medicare for all; major investments in new infrastructure and alternative fuels; new generation nuclear plants and electric cars and a program for gradual movement away from an automobile-based society to a public transportation-based one; a WPA to put the unemployed and underemployed to work creating value in the form of new infrastructure; a bill capping executive salaries at some percentage of the salary of the lowest-paid worker; a revision of the regulations governing freelance/gig employment, such as forcing freelancers to pay double the social security deduction; a dramatic reduction in the length of time that people can hold copyrights; the outlawing of “right to work” laws to jump start unionism; strong tax incentives for employee stock ownership plans with voting rights with regard to corporate governance. A few off the top of my head.
LikeLike
cx: with a regional COLA. LOL. No adjustment adjustment.
LikeLike
LikeLike
Thanks for the post, Poet
LikeLike
In my humble opinion, Big Tech and the implacable technology trends that they’ve created are a far more dangerous long-term threat to America than Trumpism. That anyone could be confused about this is a testament to the threat — the degree to which regular people aren’t aware of it, like fish in water. And unlike Trumpism, the technology trends are 100% guaranteed not only to continue but to intensify on an exponential scale. We are all frogs in the pot.
LikeLike
That’s like saying Stalin was a far more dangerous long-term threat than Hitler.
No doubt that’s really comforting to the six million Jews who died, and the other millions who would have joined them if those who saw Stalin as the “far more dangerous long-term threat” had their way.
How would that work for the US to have limited Stalin’s power for that long term with Hitler in power throughout the UK and most of Europe?
Maybe the US could have made a nice little pact with Hitler, handed over the Jews in return for Hitler working with the US to contain Stalin?
Maybe the Democrats need to let the Republicans take over our democracy, and then they can beg the Republicans to address the dangers in technology trends?
All I know is that one has to be in a position of privilege and security to try to move the discussion from the most urgent threat – the end of democracy in this country – to the more long-term threat – the technology trends.
Do we need to have an autocrat or fascist government to address the dangers of technology trends? No doubt the Republicans if totally empowered could do just what the so-called beacon of democracy Ortega did and simply shut down those that the leader wants shut down.
I’m of the opinion that the problems can’t be addressed without democratically elected leaders. We need to protect our democracy first.
LikeLike
NYC-
An argument style that positions things that aren’t similar to each other as if they were and then ranks them, serves the purpose of distraction.
Another argument style is to bring up a tangential issue which refocuses discussion away from the central issue.
LikeLike
Linda,
You are right. I’m starting to think a few posters are just trolls.
We should be able to have a conversation about something that is of grave concern. But the same two or three posters always demand we change the subject to frame it to the discussion that just happens to be the one that the right wing wants us to have.
To wit: “Are the evil Republicans a tiny bit worse than the evil Democrats or are they just equally evil?” “Republicans may have done something distasteful, but look over here at this other distasteful thing that has nothing to do with the Republicans that we must discuss instead.”
Thank you for identifying the methods used.
LikeLike
Flerp!
So good to see you (or rather read you) again!
LikeLike
If I could go back to BED after reading this I would. But I never can, ha, ha.
Gotta get ready to go teach government. (Or, attempt to teach government in a nation that is becoming increasingly, tragically ungovernable, at least by democratic means.)
T-minus 83 minutes and counting until the Pledge of Allegiance.
My wife read me a poem yesterday while I was on this machine, feverishly typing in teacher-type stuff.
“America is a Gun” by Tania Sheko.
I’ll try to post the link:
View at Medium.com
The poem fit in perfectly with news wafting around on TV in the background…Kyle Rittenhouse, Ahmaud Arbery, and _______________ (fill in the blank of the next protagonist).
Or, I should say, blankS: ________________, __________________, _____________,______________, _______________, _____________, _____________ etc…etc…
Take care, all!
LikeLike
Have to get to the bottom of who supplied the insurrectionists with the importance and location of that office. Then make them pay.
LikeLike
I subscribe to Thomas Hartman’s newsletter and read that wonderful essay.
I also suscribe to Robert Hubbell, wehrote this about the insurrection https://roberthubbell.substack.com/p/todays-edition-the-lessons-of-january?token=eyJ1c2VyX2lkIjozNDgxNTc0NSwicG9zdF9pZCI6Mzg0NjQwOTUsIl8iOiJ2OElONiIsImlhdCI6MTYzNzYwMjAzMSwiZXhwIjoxNjM3NjA1NjMxLCJpc3MiOiJwdWItMjcxMzU4Iiwic3ViIjoicG9zdC1yZWFjdGlvbiJ9.sGTSM3iyQi6nepnnqIBYr4sAYQGBQRBIcyBpxtaQbbI
He writes: “ Six months ago, former President Trump incited an assault on the Capitol. It was the most serious attack on American democracy in more than 150 years. Efforts at accountability have been slow and disjointed. It is not clear who represents America in seeking redress.
What is the lesson that Americans will take away from January 6th? The answer depends on whether and how the United States pursues justice against the perpetrators. One lesson could be that the most likely charge for assaulting the Capitol is trespassing. Another could be that attempting to interfere with a constitutional function of Congress will not be the basis of any charges against “trespassers.” Another could be that future insurrectionists should not document their crimes on social media because in the absence of such evidence, no prosecutor will pursue the “trespassers.” Yet another could be that elected officials who organize and incite violence against the United States can do so with impunity because America lacks the courage to hold them accountable.
To state the obvious, those are not the lessons that democracy-loving Americans want to draw from the aftermath of the Capitol Insurrection. But unless Congress, the President, and the Department of Justice begin to act with urgency and resolve, those may be the unwanted lessons that will be marked in the annals of American democracy. There is still time to get it right, but we must tell our congressional representatives and the President that we demand justice—so that the lesson of January 6th is not that the next insurrection need only be better organized but less publicized to succeed.
The natural place for the pursuit of justice for the perpetrators of the Capitol Insurrection is the Department of Justice. I have worn out my welcome with readers in criticizing Attorney General Merrick Garland’s failure to demonstrate leadership in pursuing justice against the perpetrators of the insurrection. So, let me recommend an opinion piece by Ankush Khardori in Politico, “What the DOJ Isn’t Telling Us About Jan. 6.” Khardori notes that although the DOJ has taken the lead in the response to January 6th by charging more than 500 participants, the only thing the public knows about the DOJ investigations is contained in the indictments of those defendants. While that information is helpful, scattered indictments tell us nothing about important questions, such as:
LikeLike