Many of the nation’s public schools are in poor physical condition. Since the Great Recession of 2008, states stopped or cut the funding necessary repairs and upgrades. President Biden’s infrastructure plan included $100 billion to upgrade the physical conditions of America’s schools. In the last hours of haggling before the bill was passed, this provision was cut, then eliminated.
In a major blow that left educators, school leaders and advocates stunned, Democrats pared back – and then eliminated – $100 billion that Joe Biden earmarked for school modernization in his spending bill.
The story details the woeful conditions of Philadelphia’s schools. Helen Gym, an education activist who was elected to the city council, has been outspoken about the need to invest in rebuilding obsolete schools.
“Our children deal with lead, asbestos and mold,” Gym says of the School District of Philadelphia, where schools are on average 70 years old. “We had to start school weeks later than schools in the suburbs because we don’t have air conditioning and classrooms can reach 90 degrees or higher on our hottest days, which are becoming more and more frequent.”
Gym, a potential 2023 mayoral contender and longtime education activist, had been arrested weeks prior to the rally for banging on the doors of the Senate gallery inside the state Capitol in Harrisburg to protest the way the state funds the city’s public school system – a longstanding issue that goes on trial in the commonwealth court next week.
“We have windows that don’t open fully,” she says. “Even now we struggle with the basics of functioning cafeterias, bathrooms that don’t flood and roofs that don’t cave in.”
Five years ago, when Philadelphia performed a cursory assessment of its buildings, it estimated that basic repairs to bring schools up to code would cost roughly $4.5 billion, to say nothing of long-standing larger renovation needs or modernizing its K-12 system top-to-bottom. In 2019, the school district took out a $500 million bond for routine capital projects to begin facilities improvements.
States need federal aid to upgrade their schools. We put our money into those things we care most about. Providing healthy and attractive buildings where children learn is not at the top of the list.

Why is it not common knowledge that politicians on both sides are working against public schools. If they are doing it… they should be asked the hard questions to explain it. I should not have to go to Twitter accounts and this blog to understand the dynamics behind political decisions around education issues.
LikeLike
Wondering which democrat insisted on the elimination of this funding in order to get republicans to vote for the bill?
LikeLiked by 1 person
No Republicans voted for the Bill. The Bill has not come for a vote yet . The question you should be asking is why this was not in the Senate Bill which was passed by the House.
LikeLike
$100 billion dropped for schools here, $100 billion dropped for climate change mitigation there.
No biggie.
Who’s even paying attention?
Besides, things like schools and climate change are waaay waaay down on The List (which gets shorter with each passing day, as Manchin and Sinema cross things off it, you know, cuz they are the Deciders who have the final say over everything in our government, probably even the nuclear football)
LikeLike
It’s the Manchin-Sinema Presidency.
LikeLiked by 1 person
in 100 years, what will history books write about this moment in US history: oops, will anyone be alive to read about it?
LikeLike
Ciedie, will the US be around in 100 years?
LikeLike
With the way things are going currently, will it still be around in 50 (or even 25) years? might be a better question.
Or will it even mean anything if it is?
Or will it be AINO? (America In Name Only)
LikeLike
America In Name Only
AINO
Like Drain-o
Not for the meek
Virus
Inside us
Grows as we speak
LikeLike
Drain-o
It’s plain, oh
Will not cure the ills
Although it
For Covid
Is better than pills
LikeLike
There ain’t no such thing as AINO. And that word’s gettin’ pretty close to bein’ obscene. We’re keeping an eye on you.
LikeLike
Ain’t no AINO?
Who told you that? Barney Fife?
LikeLike
Ain’t no AINO
“Ain’t no AINO”
Said Aint Bee, “No
Not a bit”
O’ truth to it!”
Ain’t no AINO (2)
“Ain’t no AINO”
Said Andee “No
Not a bit”
O’ truth to it!”
LikeLike
“Caint be Aint Bee” said Opey
LikeLike
On a related note,my dad and I drove through Mount Airy, NC last year , which is the hometown of Andy Griffith after which Mayberry in the TV series was patterned.
On the same trip (and also a previous trip) we ate at the Hillsville Diner in Virginia, which was originally located in Mount Airy and was used for a filming of one of the Andy Griffith episodes. Great food, by the way.
LikeLike
But alas, we didn’t run into Ain’t Bee, Andy, Barney or even Opey.
LikeLike
The Blue Ridge Mountains are a breathtakingly beautiful area, but sadly, the towns of the region have been hit particularly hard by the opioid epidemic.
In Hillsville, we ran into a fellow who was running for town sheriff who told us about the problem. Not sure if he was elected and can’t recall his name.
LikeLike
It’s the Tom Daschle Presidency. He’s exceptionally well positioned for his clients. He’s on the board of CAP (the pseudo left). He’s at the BiPartisan Policy Center. And, at the Daschle Group, he advises Baker Donelson. Tom knows the right won’t move so, the left gets forced to right wing positions.
Tom’s ace in the hole is Manchinema, the darling of K Street, who can, despite the bribes the two senators received from their party, be called upon to stick it to the average Joe or Jane.
Tom and his son, Nathan, gave to Sinema’s campaign this summer.
LikeLike
This compromise is unfortunate. Perhaps Democrats will be able to put up another bill to restore more funding if they do not get slaughtered in the midterms.
I grew up in Philly in the ’50s and ’60s. When I was in first grade, I was bused to another school for a good part of the year because my school was being renovated. When I returned, shiny movable desks replaced the old bolted to the floor desks with inkwells. When I went to high school, the brand new building, complete with the famous pink marble hallway, cheerfully greeted new students. In those days the city and commonwealth had the funds to improve and replace the physical plants of old, outdated buildings.
Perhaps if the city and commonwealth had not fallen hook, line and sinker for the privatization lie, there would be adequate funding available. Privatization never costs less. It always results in the people paying more for less. Politicians need a reality check. Privatization never benefits the people.
LikeLike
Many (if not most) of the things the Democrats have been dropping with no more thought than one gives to exfoliated skin cells are very popular among all Americans (not just Democrats).
The Democrats already sealed their fate in the upcoming midterms (and probably in 2024 as well) the second they allowed two Republican-lite clowns to effectively dictate policy.
LikeLike
SHADES OF GRAY
The CENSUS recently reported that “Public School Spending Per Pupil Increases by Largest Amount in 11 Years”
May 18, 2021
“State governments contributed the greatest share — 46.7% or $350.9 billion — of public school funding in fiscal year 2019.”
https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2021/public-school-spending-per-pupil.html
LikeLike
Duh…and what about fixing and upgrading our public schools’ VENTILATION SYSTEMS?
LikeLike
We can’t even use HEPA filters in my building because it’s too old. We have been promised to get a new building for 15 years, and yet our new building (our current one is 57 years old) keeps getting pushed off in order to build fancy new buildings in the wealthy part of the district (we are in the poor part of the district, so no one gives a darn about poor kids getting Covid, I guess).
LikeLike
I just looked at some photos, and one thing is obvious: you don’t teach at East High School. It’s entirely different from what I remember.
LikeLike
But that’s in the wealthy part of the district.
LikeLike
Not a single Democrat from the president on down was willing to fight for public schools? We don’t expect the GOP to give a rat’s patootie about public schools but for no Dem to leverage something for us? Pathetic.
LikeLike
It’s because the Democratic party is not the party to defend public schools.
LikeLike
And neither is the GOP…of course I assume that you know this. The same thing happened in Health Care and now we have a totally privatized system that only works for the wealthy who can afford it. Socialism for the rich.
LikeLike
At first, the wealthy power elite thought the pandemic would cheapen education by moving it online permanently. The headlines read: Is this the new normal. Then, when everyone gave negative customer feedback to the tech we used to “go to” school, the elite forcibly tried to get everyone back in the buildings, before the vaccines were available, safe or unsafe. Now that we are back in school buildings, the elite will not pay to rebuild that part of our crumbling infrastructure. Safe or unsafe, doesn’t matter to them. Infrastructure that aids commerce, yes; infrastructure that aids democratic society, no. And Elon Musk’s latest Twitter stunt is salt on the wound.
I had the football pregame show on this morning while I was adding grades to a progress report for the parents of my students. Terry Bradshaw, football commentator and former Pittsburgh quarterback, compared the players to the race horse he just purchased for $2 million. I’m not sure he was aware of his audience, discussing something like that on a pregame show. He’s part of the elite too, you know, a football commentator who does lots of TV ads. He can buy a race horse. The wealthy power elite are not intellectuals, and are not aware of their countrymen and women. That’s a serious problem.
Oh well. In a relatively short time, no one will know what the elite are up to, anyway. The Children of the Common Core will be the fourth estate, and all they will be able to write is “the text states…”.
LikeLike
and are not aware of their countrymen and women
No freaking clue whatsoever. Increasingly, they live every moment of their lives completely shielded from looking upon the rabble.
LikeLike
Some of them are vaguely aware that some of their country men have pitchforks.
LikeLike
Supposed to be Trumpkin Pie, but Trumpkin Pee works too.
LikeLike
CBS News did an interesting piece. It said to imagine that wealth in the U.S. were a piece of pumpkin pie divided into ten pieces, these would be distributed as follows:
Top 20 percent: 9 pieces
Next two plates (40 percent): 1 piece divided between them
Next 20 percent: a few crumbs
Bottom 20 percent: No pie, no crumbs, but a bill for pie
Happy Thanksgiving!
LikeLike
Pieces of that pumpkin pie:
top 20: 9 pieces
next 20: 80 percent of 1 piece
next 20: 20 percent of 1 piece
next 20: a few crumbs:
bottom 20: a bill for pie
LikeLike
Isn’t that actually a Trumpkin pie?
Trumpkin Pe
Trumpkin pie is nice
You get just a slice
Trump gets all the rest
For Thanksgiving fest
LikeLike
Let them eat bills for pie. Humble pie.
LikeLike
This is from 2016, but I’m sure that it’s worse now.
The consequences of neglected dental problems are reflected in some bleak statistics. Nearly 20 percent of adults over age sixty-five had no natural teeth in 2011–12. Of those who have some natural teeth, 68 percent have periodontitis, and about 20 percent have untreated tooth decay. And yet by 2014, almost 40 percent of adults over age sixty-five had not visited a dentist in the past year.
–Susan Jaffe, in the journal Health Affairs
But Joe Manchin just made sure that there would be no dental care for toothless old West Virginians. Heckuva job, Joe! Hey, how’s the Maserati?
LikeLike
Hey, Joe, where you goin’ with that bill in your hand?
I say, Hey ,Joe where you goin’ with that bill in your hand?
I’m going down to find me some scissors.
Cause this here ain’t no promised land.
Want to buy another Maserati
An’ pick up mo’ checks from “The Man.”
LikeLike
LikeLike
This was supposed to be posted under Bob’s pumpkin pie analogy.
LikeLike
I am so 🤬UTRAGED that I commented on the previous post (but actually, part was in answer as to why U.S. schools in most parts of cities can barely be open during a NORMAL school year, w/o Covid). &, now, there’s no money “available” to fix our schools.
DINOs, nearly all &, I’m sorry (& we all should be!), but the vast majority–neo-lib Dems–killed the public schools, not to mention their kids. I live near the city–Chicago– w/the people (if you can call them that: they’re its–just like 45–Arne, Rahm, Vallas & yes, Obama, picking Arne & Rahm (oh, he DIDN’T know?!) –who have destroyed our schools, our children.
There is too much more to say, but we all know it.
One thing: Our Revolution has been the most effective in getting Progressives elected. They deserve our support.
LikeLike
This is another example of two things that have troubled me, one about process, the other strategy. This is another example of why the concentration of power in a few is killing the legislative process. Because the committee process has basically become window dressing for policy making, there are no constituencies of power and/or expertise left anymore. It’s all about the leadership moving poker chips, details be damned. This is why I keep harping on the fact that the appropriations process must once again be made to work. It’s the only way to get back to a functioning process.
And I’m baffled to see the semblance of any strategy behind the Democratic leadership’s moves. In the good old days, when considering huge bills, there was usually a plan that led to an end game. During the past few months I’ve been wondering to myself, “I wonder what they really want to get out of this?” I considered the $3.5 trillion to be a negotiating number with an agreed upon minimum. Now I’m not sure that they ever had a strategy to begin with. They way they discarded programs like ballast on a sinking ship is not encouraging.
LikeLike
They are also discarding ballots overboard, although I doubt they appreciate it yet.
And when they do, it will be too late.
LikeLike
[…] By Diane Ravitch, Dianeravitch […]
LikeLike
Great details. Thank you very much
LikeLike
Great details here. Thanks
LikeLike
It is the best detail for us so far. Thanks for sharing such great information with us. Please keep supporting us and follow our blog website. We have shared some useful information and guidance for helicopter booking in India. Visit the official website(Helicopter Booking Online)
LikeLike
We are the only telecom company that works on Airtel tower installation and complaints in India. Airtel mini-towers, Airtel 5G towers, and Airtel booster works performed by our department.
LikeLike
Beyond a doubt, we are the best selection for the Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board helicopter service company in India. We do not compromise on quality or passenger security. We always care about pilgrims’ health. We offer low-budget helicopter tickets for the Amarnath Yatra. We have experienced staff that will guide you during the journey. Amarnath yatra is a cold yatra in India, which is why we arrange medical facilities for weak people. Our helicopter booking service is No. 1 on the internet. So no hesitation, choose our platform, and allow us to serve you with a high-quality helicopter ride.
LikeLike