Angela Merkel’s political star appeared to be on the decline until the pandemic erupted across the world.
Suddenly Germany had exactly the leader it needed. An experienced public figure with a scientific background and a calm demeanor.
The Atlantic has the story here.
BERLIN—Today, we face the global outbreak of a disease that has the potential to catalyze what the historian Eva Schlotheuber terms a “pandemic of the mind.” As misinformation proliferates and lines between fact and fiction are routinely and nonchalantly crossed, world leaders must, now more than ever, illuminate a thoughtful path forward, one reliant on science and evidence-based reasoning. Indeed, many have. One leader goes further still. Trusted by her people to navigate this outbreak’s murky waters, without inciting or succumbing to a pandemic of the mind, one politician is less a commander in chief and more a scientist in chief: Angela Merkel.
For weeks now, Germany’s leader has deployed her characteristic rationality, coupled with an uncharacteristic sentimentality, to guide the country through what has thus far been a relatively successful battle against COVID-19. The pandemic is proving to be the crowning challenge for a politician whose leadership style has consistently been described as analytical, unemotional, and cautious. In her quest for social and economic stability during this outbreak, Merkel enjoys several advantages: a well-respected, coordinated system of scientific and medical expertise distributed across Germany; the hard-earned trust of the public; and the undeniable fact that steady and sensible leadership is suddenly back in style. With 30 years of political experience, and facing an enormous challenge that begs calm, reasoned thinking, Merkel is at peak performance modeling the humble credibility of a scientist at work. And it seems to be paying off, both politically and scientifically…
On March 18, after the country had closed its schools, its economy, its way of life, she gave a rare televised speech that solidified her leadership.
Facing the camera from behind a desk, with both the German and European Union flags to her side, she began on an emotional note, by conceding that “our idea of normality, of public life, social togetherness—all of this is being put to the test as never before.” She emphasized the importance of democracy and of making transparent political decisions and she insisted that any information she shared about the pandemic was based on thorough research. Then, in an astonishing statement for a German leader, one she “must have considered endlessly,” Kornelius told me, she made reference to her country’s darkest hour. “Since the Second World War,” Merkel said, “there has not been a challenge for our country in which action in a spirit of solidarity on our part was so important.”
What stood out from the address was not so much Merkel’s medical advice, but her unusually direct appeal to the notion of social togetherness and to her own limitations as an individual and as a leader (“I firmly believe that we will pass this test if all citizens genuinely see this as their task”). Her rational assurances and her emotional appeal were crucial at a time of rising panic. While the mood isn’t quite so dark here anymore—thanks to a variety of factors, Germany appears to have dealt with the outbreak better than many other countries—Germans largely continue to heed the chancellor’s detailed directives. The number of people infected by the coronavirus has increased, as it has throughout the world. But unlike in Italy, where more than 22,000 have lost their life to COVID-19, or in the United States, where the death toll has surpassed that figure and continues to rise rapidly, total deaths in Germany have been inching up from 4,000. To put this in perspective, more than twice as many New Yorkers have lost their life to the coronavirus as have individuals in all of Germany to date.
While country-level comparative data may be somewhat unreliable, and the numbers can certainly take a turn for the worse in Germany as anywhere else, experts cite a number of possible factors for the country’s relatively low number of deaths: The average age of coronavirus patients has been lower here than elsewhere, which limits the risk; the number of people tested for the virus is higher than in other countries, and cases are for the most part carefully tracked; and the public health-care system has been efficient enough to ramp up the number of available intensive-care units to meet potential demand.
Imagine that: a leader who is rational and calm. A leader who believes in science and evidence. A leader who appeals to social solidarity in the face of a national crisis. A nation prepared to act on behalf of the public interest. No grandstanding. No vainglorious or egotistical rants.

The Mer(a)kel of Science
LikeLike
Thanks for posting this, Diane. One of the most useful concepts to teach kids studying literature is that of the foil, the character who provides stark contrast to another character. No two could differ more, the decent, educated, reflective, caring Merkel and the amoral, profoundly ignorant, heedless, self-absorbed Trump.
Trump got the big test of his Presidency. And he failed. Utterly. Catastrophically. And, of course, predictably. What clear examples these two provide of the concept that character is destiny!
We have been, during this crisis, leaderless.
BTW, there are reports today that 2020 is on track to be the hottest year on record. Something else extraordinarily important, requiring a scientifically based response, that the Trump maladministration has denied and done worse than nothing about.
LikeLike
Merkel vs. Trump.
A real leader vs. a reality TV leader.
One is real, the other is Memorex.
One is butter, the other is margarine.
LikeLike
Exactly. Well said, Diane!
LikeLike
We have the anti-Merkel-in-chief. Why are we so “blessed?” It’s up to Americans to vote out Trump by a huge margin. Please.
LikeLike
Agree.
We have the anti-Merkel-in-chief because the anti-HRCs didn’t care if Trump won as much as they cared about preventing someone like Merkel from winning because she just wasn’t progressive enough for their liking.
Merkel isn’t progressive either – in fact, she is quite conservative. If there are still self-described German progressives who dearly wish they could have a leader like Trump because preventing Merkel from having power would be worth it, then they are certainly not saying so publicly.
When defeating someone like Merkel becomes far more important to a person than defeating someone like Trump, that person has lost his or her way. Or secretly finds what Trump says perfectly reasonable but is unwilling to admit it.
LikeLike
Extremely important point, especially given the current presidential race. I am no fan of Status Quo Joe Biden. But I’ll take a scraped knee over intestinal cancer any day. Perspective.
LikeLike
So what are German leaders doing to make sure that people whose livelihoods have been affected by the shutdown can still pay bills, get food, keep their home, etc.? I’m guessing it’s a whole lot more than any American “leaders” (sic) are doing. I’m guessing that if Americans weren’t terrified of losing everything they have, they too would be more willing to listen to science and shelter at home and attendance at these “freedom” rallies would be cut by three quarters or more.
LikeLike
Truly mystified why anyone would believe that the reason that some deluded Americans agree with Trump about the virus being a hoax and shelter in place policies are bad is because they are mad at politicians for keeping them from working the terrible jobs that those very same politicians are forcing them to have because of their terrible policies.
Funny how you don’t see lots of African-Americans at those “freedom” rallies. I guess white people who love guns and believe everything Trump says and hate the Democrats far more than they hate Trump sure do love to find scapegoats whenever they act in a way that is in direct contradiction to reason and sense.
Those white “Americans” who supposedly are much more afraid of losing everything than the immigrants and people who are not white who do not attend those rallies did not listen to science and reason long before the virus began.
Those people were listening to Trump telling them that Obama was born in Kenya and Trump had the proof long before the virus began.
Lots of people are terrified of losing everything. I have no idea why anyone would look to excuse the ones who follow Trump and hate the Democrats because they are deluded by their hatred of anyone who is not sympathetic enough to the white people who they believe have been victimized by the Democrats.
It is a shame, since if Democrats had the power that Republicans had, a lot more would be done for those people.
LikeLike
The interesting part: Trump does NOT represent the majority of Americans, by something like – I don’t remember exactly – but thousands of votes, just as first got George W into office if memory is correct.
Trump has certainly been the antithesis of EVERYTHING I in which I was taught to believe.
WHY would people never think of going to a doctor, lawyer,- any professional who has not studied his profession but put in as president an incompetent, ignoramus who cares nothing for the truth ?
AND people who CLAIM to be Christian back a man who is the antithesis of everything Jesus ever taught regarding how we treat our neighbors, the poor etc.
I just cannot fathom it.
LikeLike
Hillary got about 3 million more votes than Trump.
LikeLike
In addition, Trump won the Electoral College by a razor-thin margin of about 77,000 votes in three battleground states where black voters were heavily targeted by Russia’s propaganda campaign to help elect the Kremlin’s Agent Orange.
The result of Russia’s disinformation campaign was the first drop in black voter turnout in decades (in the same three stats) by a margin much larger than the very thin wins Trump had in Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania.
“How Russia Helped Swing the Election for Trump”
“The effect of such manipulations could be momentous in an election as close as the 2016 race, in which Clinton got nearly 2.9 million more votes than Trump, and Trump won the Electoral College only because some eighty thousand votes went his way in Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania. In two hundred and twenty-four pages of extremely dry prose, with four appendixes of charts and graphs and fifty-four pages of footnotes, Jamieson makes a strong case that, in 2016, “Russian masterminds” pulled off a technological and political coup. Moreover, she concludes, the American media “inadvertently helped them achieve their goals.”
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/10/01/how-russia-helped-to-swing-the-election-for-trump
LikeLike
Republicans cheat.
LikeLike
And this is what tRump does. Invoke the 25th before he dies.
Trump spent 27 times longer attacking enemies than expressing sympathy for victims, analysis of press conferences shows https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/url-trump-coronavirus-press-conference-white-house-victims-enemies-a9486316.html
LikeLike
Trump didn’t appoint himself president. Hopefully is idiotic rants will force some voters who voted for him to reconsider.
LikeLike
I take time to read Diane’s posts at least once a day. Because of my anger over the past few months, I’ve decided that it’s probably better for me to quit reading any of the comments. I will no longer comment on anyone’s comments from now on. I’ll close my eyes and only comment on the posts about which I have strong feelings. This is the first that fits the bill.
I am a first generation American immigrant who is solidly a German Social Democrat of the Willy Brandt school. As such, I was long dismissive of Angela Merkel’s views because she is a protege of Helmut Kohl, who is kind of like Germany’s Ronald Reagan—seemingly shallow and never one who worked overtime in the interest of average citizens. But she has proven me wrong over and over again; she is a politician who understands the obligations that come with governing. In other words, a statesman in an ere in which statesmen don’t exist, especially in the US of A. I would likely not vote for her if I could, mostly because the CDU/CSU is filled with similar sycophants who make the Republican party a thing—ideology and party affiliation over empirical facts and a pragmatism that recognizes the hypocrites of expediency and power.
The thing that sets her apart is that she takes the duties and obligations of governing more than seriously, especially more than the hacks in her party. She understands that the office of chancellor is a temporary post that has disproportional effects on the everyday lives of average people, most of whom live in the margins of socio-economic expectations and reality. She sees it as a duty. [Fun fact, the German word for work is Arbeit, but the word for people who work in government is Dienst—which translates as duty. Work is one thing, duty is another; it is something much more sacred than “work.”.]
Merkel is our generation’s E.F. Hutton, so to speak. Pay attention to her views, especially if you are American. I believe this is because she grew up in and her early adult life was in East Germany. She understands the psychological burden totalitarianism imposes on people better than any “Western” politician. That’s why we should have rapt attention every time she opens her mouth. Since the Idiot has abdicated all of the responsible recommendations of knowledgeable policy makers, Merkel has become the de facto leader of world politics. And that’s a very good thing.
LikeLike
…she insisted that any information she shared about the pandemic was based on thorough research.
It is sickening to watch medical experts cower next to Trump so that they can use their expertise to squeak out some message that is vital. I’m sick of Trump’s magnificent gut that is stupider than a__________. Can’t think of anything that stupid.
LikeLike
This is what national leadership DOES NOT look like.
…………………………………………..
Trump Says U.S. Will Run 5 Million Daily Virus Tests ‘Very Soon.’ His Testing Chief Says That’s Impossible
APRIL 28, 2020
President Donald Trump declared Tuesday that the U.S. will be able to carry out five million coronavirus tests per day, but the top official overseeing testing strategy told TIME earlier in the day that goal wasn’t feasible given current technology.
Admiral Brett Giroir, the assistant secretary of health who is in charge of the government’s testing response, said during an interview on Tuesday morning that “there is absolutely no way on Earth, on this planet or any other planet, that we can do 20 million tests a day, or even five million tests a day.”
Since the beginning of the year, the Administration has conducted 5.7 million tests in total, he said…
https://time.com/5828843/trump-coronavirus-testing-giroir/?utm_source=emailshare&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=email-share-article&utm_content=20200429
LikeLike
Has anyone started one of those betting pools to predict when Admiral Brett Giroir, the assistant secretary of health will lose his job because Trump had him fired or Trump fired him in a Tweet and/or while blaming him for the pandemic?
LikeLike
Pence must think his face needs more recognition. [Can’t let Trump get all the news photos.] Why else would he refuse to wear a mask? Maybe he’s just that stupid. People follow this fellow and now think wearing a mask in a hospital isn’t necessary.
Mayo Clinic physicians actually were seeking answers from leadership? Pence is the coronavirus czar. No help there…nor from the Orange Moron.
…………………………………
— The PR disaster was entirely preventable and even predictable. POLITICO had reached out on Monday to both Mayo Clinic and Pence’s office, asking if the VP who famously eschewed masks would comply with the clinic’s mandatory policy to wear one. (The clinic referred questions to Pence’s office, which didn’t respond.)
Pence was offered a mask when he arrived but declined, said two people — a decision that can only be understood as putting optics over CDC recommendations.
But Mayo Clinic made multiple blunders of its own. The hospital allowed a maskless Pence to tour the facility in violation of its policy; continued with a scheduled photo opportunity with a patient rather than canceling it; tweeted a subtle rebuke of Pence and then deleted it; and then put out a bland statement expressing thanks to Pence while refusing to answer reporters’ follow-up questions. Multiple Mayo Clinic physicians and staff reached out to PULSE, saying that they were seeking answers from leadership.
— Pence later defended his decision by saying that he gets regularly tested for Covid-19 and wasn’t putting anyone at risk. The White House has previously said that Pence is only tested weekly.
LikeLike
Why the Wealthy Fear Pandemics
The coronavirus, like other plagues before it, could shift the balance between rich and poor.
…In looking for illumination from the past on our current pandemic, we must be wary of superficial analogies. Even in the worst-case scenario, Covid-19 will kill a far smaller share of the world’s population than any of these earlier disasters did, and it will touch the active work force and the next generation even more lightly. Labor won’t become scarce enough to drive up wages, nor will the value of real estate plummet. And our economies no longer rely on farmland and manual labor.
Yet the most important lesson of history endures. The impact of any pandemic goes well beyond lives lost and commerce curtailed. Today, America faces a fundamental choice between defending the status quo and embracing progressive change. The current crisis could prompt redistributive reforms akin to those triggered by the Great Depression and World War II, unless entrenched interests prove too powerful to overcome.
LikeLike
This was listed as ‘news from the WH’. Has this doctor lost his brains?
…………………………
I’ve worked the coronavirus front line — and I say it’s time to start opening up
By Daniel G. Murphy
April 27, 2020
I’m an emergency physician at St. Barnabas Hospital in The Bronx. I have been in the ER every day these last few weeks, either supervising or providing direct care. I contracted a COVID-19 infection very early in the outbreak, as did two of my daughters, one of whom is a nurse. We are all well, thank God.COVID-19 has been the worst health care disaster of my 30-year career, because of its intensity, duration and potential for lasting impact.
The lasting impact is what worries me the most. And it’s why I now believe we should end the lockdown and rapidly get back to work.
https://nypost.com/2020/04/27/ive-worked-the-coronavirus-front-line-and-i-say-its-time-to-start-opening-up/?utm_source=url_sitebuttons&utm_medium=site%20buttons&utm_campaign=site%20buttons
LikeLike
How about one more example of National Leadership!! The US is phucked big time.
…………………………….
CANADA
Trudeau’s daily coronavirus update: More financial support for students over the summer (Full transcript)
In his April 29 briefing to Canadians, the PM announced the new Canada Student Service Grant for those helping with the fight against COVID-19, as well as extended scholarships and fellowships for graduate students
By Maclean’s
April 29, 2020
…So last week, we unveiled a $9 billion plan to help you to get through this crisis. First of all, we announced the Canada Emergency Student Benefit, which will provide $1,250 a month to students during the summer. And if you have a disability, you will be receiving more. At the same time, we are investing to create 76,000 additional jobs for students in those sectors that need a hand or are actively contributing to the fight against COVID-19. These jobs can be added to those that are also available under the Canada Summer Jobs Program. [end of translation]
If you can’t find a job this summer but want to contribute in the fight against COVID-19, we’re going to make sure you have support, too. Students helping in the fight against COVID-19 this summer will soon be eligible for a $1,000 to $5,000 through the new Canada Student Service Grant for volunteer hours. We’re also going to be providing specific support for First Nations, Inuit and Métis Nation students. For graduate students and those conducting research, we’re going to extend scholarships, fellowships and grants so your work can continue. And we are doubling student grants for low- and middle-income students for 2020-2021. Taken together, our government has a $9 billion plan to help students and recent grads get through the next few months. Since we introduced this plan, we’ve been working with the opposition parties on legislation that will get this help to young people as quickly as possible. I’ll be heading to Parliament shortly, where we will introduce a bill to put the Canada Emergency Student Benefit in place…
https://www.macleans.ca/news/canada/trudeaus-daily-coronavirus-update-more-financial-support-for-students-over-the-summer-full-transcript/
LikeLike
260,000 Words, Full of Self-Praise, From Trump on the Virus
Three journalists from The New York Times reviewed more than 260,000 words spoken by President Trump during the pandemic. Here’s what we learned.
April 26, 2020
…The New York Times analyzed every word Mr. Trump spoke at his White House briefings and other presidential remarks on the virus — more than 260,000 words — from March 9, when the outbreak began leading to widespread disruptions in daily life, through mid-April. The transcripts show striking patterns and repetitions in the messages he has conveyed, revealing a display of presidential hubris and self-pity unlike anything historians say they have seen before.
By far the most recurring utterances from Mr. Trump in the briefings are self-congratulations, roughly 600 of them, which are often predicated on exaggerations and falsehoods. He does credit others (more than 360 times) for their work, but he also blames others (more than 110 times) for inadequacies in the state and federal response.
Mr. Trump’s attempts to display empathy or appeal to national unity (about 160 instances) amount to only a quarter of the number of times he complimented himself or a top member of his team…
LikeLike
Fantastic Carol. REAL research
LikeLike
Jared declares that ‘this is a great success story’. Only 58,368 people have died. Is there something wrong with him?
……………………………………………………
President Trump’s son-in-law Jared Kushner, who has been largely absent amid the coronavirus crisis in recent weeks, said on Wednesday that “this is a great success story” as the death toll nears 60,000, with more than one million COVID-19 cases recorded.
“We’re on the other side of the medical aspect of this,” Kushner said in an interview with Fox News. “We’ve achieved all the different milestones that are needed. The federal government rose to the challenge, and this is a great success story.” As of Wednesday, the United States recorded at least 58,368 deaths related to the coronavirus and 1,013,168 confirmed cases, according to a Johns Hopkins University tracker. On Tuesday, the death toll surpassed the number of American fatalities—58,220—in the Vietnam War.
Read it at Twitter
LikeLike
News from the WH on April 29, 2020:
“The data is on our side, and President Trump has created a pathway to safely open up our country,” Senior Advisor Jared Kushner told Fox News today.
LikeLike
Trump is werking to get rid of his supporters….GO TRUMP! Hold those rallies. Who cares what Jared says?
……………………………………………….
WASHINGTON – President Donald Trump said Wednesday the federal government will not be extending its coronavirus social distancing guidelines once they expire Thursday, and his son-in-law and adviser, Jared Kushner, predicted that by July the country will be “really rocking again.” Trump said he plans to resume official travel with a trip to Arizona next week. And he said he’s hoping to hold mass campaign rallies in the coming months with thousands of supporters, even though medical experts have said there is little hope of having a vaccine by then.
LikeLike
Yes!!
Let’s hope he shakes a lot of hands.
LikeLike
SUSAN RICE SLAMS KUSHNER’S ‘RIDICULOUS’ BOAST
Former national security adviser Susan Rice tore into Jared Kushner for claiming the federal government’s handling of the coronavirus outbreak has been a “great success story.” Kushner made his comments after the U.S. topped 1 million cases of the virus and more than 59,000 deaths. He didn’t mention the U.S. death toll ― higher than any other country in the world ― the persistently inadequate testing, shortages of critical medical equipment and the lack of preparation that have plagued the administration’s crisis response. [HuffPost]
LikeLike
Two Georgia men drink liquid cleaning products in misguided attempt to ward off coronavirus
4/28/20
Two men in Georgia reportedly drank cleaning solutions as a preventative measure to avoid contracting the coronavirus.
One individual consumed bleach on Saturday in order “to prevent COVID,” according to WJCL. Another individual ingested a mixture of pine cleaner, beer, mouthwash and pain medication on Sunday. While both men allegedly had histories of mental illness, they were both discharged from the hospital, according to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
Georgia Poison Center Director Gaylord Lopez said he did not know if the men drank the harmful substances because of statements made by President Donald Trump, suggesting that ingesting a disinfectant could be an effective therapeutic treatment for coronavirus…
https://www.newsweek.com/two-georgia-men-drink-liquid-cleaning-products-misguided-attempt-ward-off-coronavirus-1500796
LikeLike
I got this from a friend in Canada. Love the last line!!
……………………………………..
THE COVID IS RAGING
MY LIFE IS A MESS
I LIVE IN PAJAMAS
AND DON’T HAVE TO DRESS
I’M IN ISOLATION
JUST STAYING AT HOME
AND WOULD GIVE MY LAST DOLLAR
TO BE FREE TO ROAM
I’M SERIOUSLY AT RISK
(OR THAT’S WHAT THEY SAY)
TELLING ME TO STAY IN
AND NOT GO OUT EACH DAY
IN MY HEAD I’M SO YOUNG
THOUGH MY LICENCE REVEALS
I’M A 70-PLUS SENIOR
(BUT THAT’S NOT HOW IT FEELS!)
WHEN I RUN OUT OF FOOD
AND DELIVERIES ARE LATE
I HAVE TO BUY GROCERIES
BETWEEN 7 AND 8
SO EARLY IN THE MORNING
I HEAD OUT TO RESTOCK
AND DISCOVER A LINE UP
THAT WINDS ‘ROUND THE BLOCK
ALL 6 FEET APART
MAKE ME WONDER JUST WHEN
I BECAME AN OLD FART
SOCIAL DISTANCING SENIORS
MY MEALS ARE REPETITIVE
(A LOT LIKE MY GAS!)
AND I’M TIRED OF DISCUSSING
WHY TRUMP IS AN ASS
MY LATEST NEW OUTFIT
IS GLOVES AND A MASK
AND I’M STARTING TO WONDER
IF I’M UP TO THIS TASK
I WASH ALL MY GROCERIES
ALL FRUIT, MEAT AND VEG…….
WILL THIS ADDITIONAL PRECAUTION
TIP ME OVER THE EDGE?
MY BEAUTIFUL BLONDE HAIR
HAS WIDE ROOTS OF GREY
NO HAIRDRESSERS AROUND
TO HELP WASH THEM AWAY
I’VE BEEN TALKING TO MYSELF
NOW I’M ANSWERING BACK
IS IT MONDAY OR FRIDAY
I’VE REALLY LOST TRACK
I’VE STOPPED DOING HOUSEWORK
IT’S WEEKS SINCE I’VE DUSTED
AND I KNOW WITHOUT VISITORS
I’LL NEVER GET BUSTED
I FACETIME MY FRIENDS
OR WE GROUP CHAT ON ZOOM
AND TRY TO PRETEND
WE’RE ALL IN THE SAME ROOM
THANK GOD LIQUOR STORES
ARE CONSIDERED ‘ESSENTIAL’
WITHOUT DAILY DRINKS
THIS WOULD DRIVE US ALL MENTAL
EVERY ONCE IN A WHILE
IT IS GOOD TO REFLECT
ON WHAT THIS ALL MEANS
AND WHAT WE CAN EXPECT
IT’S A TIME TO BE GRATEFUL
FOR ALL THAT WE’VE GOT
LIKE A WARM HOUSE AND FOOD
THAT OTHERS HAVE NOT
THE BOTTOM LINE HERE
BY THE TIME THIS ALL ENDS
IS THAT WE’LL GET THROUGH IT
WITH OUR FAMILY AND FRIENDS
SO EVEN IF YOUR PARTNER
IS A BIT OF A GRUMP
YOU CAN REALLY BE GRATEFUL
YOU’RE NOT MARRIED TO TRUMP!
LikeLike