Trump froze funding to the World Health Organization on grounds that it had not given forewarning about the virus but had parroted the Chinese government line that it was contained. Dr. Birx dutifully parroted the Trump line.
The Washington Post disagreed in an editorial.
More than a dozen U.S. researchers, physicians and public health experts, many of them from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, were working full time at the Geneva headquarters of the World Health Organization as the novel coronavirus emerged late last year and transmitted real-time information about its discovery and spread in China to the Trump administration, according to U.S. and international officials.
A number of CDC staffers are regularly detailed to work at WHO in Geneva as part of a rotation that has operated for years. Senior Trump-appointed health officials also consulted regularly at the highest levels with the WHO as the crisis unfolded, the officials said.
The presence of so many U.S. officials undercuts President Trump’s charge that the WHO’s failure to communicate the extent of the threat, born of a desire to protect China, is largely responsible for the rapid spread of the virus in the United States.
The administration has also sharply criticized the Chinese government for withholding information.
But the president, who often touts a personal relationship with Chinese President Xi Jinping and is reluctant to inflict damage on a trade deal with Beijing, appears to see the WHO as a more defenseless target.
Asked early Sunday about the presence of CDC and other officials at the WHO, and whether it was “fair to blame the WHO for covering up the spread of this virus,” Deborah Birx, the State Department expert who is part of the White House pandemic team, gently shifted the onus to China, and the need to “over-communicate.”
Sign up for our Coronavirus Updates newsletter to track the outbreak. All stories linked in the newsletter are free to access.
“It’s always the first country that get exposed to the pandemic that has a — really a higher moral obligation on communicating, on transparency, because all the other countries around the world are making decisions on that,” Birx told ABC’s This Week. “And when we get through this as a global community, we can figure out really what has to happen for first alerts and transparency and understanding very early on about … how incredibly contagious this virus is.”

Okay–so Trump lies and tries to rewrite history so that he comes out on top . . . again and again . . . and we should never stop being informed and outraged about it.
However, our new question is: Why does his “base” keep on supporting him; and how to get across to those supporters that they are involved in the biggest con job in history? CBK
LikeLike
The Trump base gets its “news” from FOX. How can you reach them?
LikeLike
Hello Diane: I am speaking also from personal experience of a relative who just sent me a link and some literature . . . the link is to a website for conspiracy theories and the literature is bald-faced propaganda. I cannot talk to her anymore. (BTW, did you “know” that Bill and Melinda Gates started the virus on purpose? <–that’s this particular conspiracy theory.)
But she is just one. I don’t know, Diane. But I’m not the first person to recognize cult-thinking at work . . . only this has its fake press (Fox) and Congressional and Justice Department enablers. I think the jack-boots have to show up on their driveways for them to “think twice” about their support of Trump, and then it’ll probably be too late. CBK
LikeLike
My Trumper relatives know that they should not send me conspiracy theories. A very large percentage of the population (about 30-40%) thinks that the virus was created in a lab. By whom? Depends on their prejudices, whether it is anti-Chinese or some other group. I anticipate someone will say “the Jews” did it. That’s always a winner.
LikeLike
Diane . . . dark, dark humor and with a dose of historical truth in it. CBK
LikeLike
Diane You ask about Fox News. I have suggested here before that, as with other cult thinking, there needs to be an “intervention.” Only for Fox News, the intervention needs to be a HUGE STATEMENT, and come from all other legitimate news organizations and specific journalists.
But like Trump goes beyond the Constitution and his own oath, Fox has taken “freedom of the press” beyond its reasonable boundaries (adherence to the truth) to “WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT WE SAY.” Fox dabbles in news at times, but only to cover for its being a place where low-life political operatives work at spreading their cultural poison.
Fox “News” is to the Corona Virus what the reality of a metaphor is to its concrete reference. CBK
LikeLike
The free press should take responsibility by refusing to cover Trump’s daily propaganda circuses.
Let FOX do it, then present a summary at the regular news time, if there is anything new.
LikeLike
@Catherine King. I read that same fact propaganda piece. I believe it was likely posted on every republican FB page or website. Someone I know took a screen shot of it. Bill Gates is not liked very much by the far right wingers and he should “hunker in his bunker” for a while….it really seems like these people want him “taken care of”. The propaganda piece was very scary to read and I’m still thinking about 2 days later.
LikeLike
LisaM Me. too. I just e-mailed her back with a big LOL! and said thanks for the funny example of a conspiracy theory and surrounding propaganda! . . . LOL! She didn’t write back. CBK
LikeLike
I suspect, as you probably do as well, that the notion that the virus was created in a lab by the Chinese is a piece of election disinformation of the kind that worked so well for Trump in 2016. Trump loves it and has made dog-whistling allusions to it in his recent daily briefings. It fits with his whole anti-immigrant, xenophobic shtick, which plays so well with his base, and it deflects from the utter incompetence of Trump’s response to the pandemic by providing another target to blame things one. Could this be another piece of Trump-supporting disinformation originating from the Russian GRU of the kind that got Trumpinski elected in 2016? I wonder.
LikeLike
Here is a piece about studies (plural) of the virus to determine if gene editing had taken place and those scientific studies revealed that the virus was natural and that it matched other viruses in animals that had not crossed over to humans … until now.
It is possible to sequence the DNA of a virus and detect if gene editing has taken place. This is not a theory. It is a fact but, irrefutable facts have never stopped Trump from lying and his deplorable follows from believing his lies.
“An analysis of public genome sequence data from SARS-CoV-2 and related viruses found no evidence that the virus was made in a laboratory or otherwise engineered.”
“By comparing the available genome sequence data for known coronavirus strains, we can firmly determine that SARS-CoV-2 originated through natural processes,” said Kristian Andersen, PhD, an associate professor of immunology and microbiology at Scripps Research and corresponding author on the paper.
“In addition to Andersen, authors on the paper, “The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2,” include Robert F. Garry, of Tulane University; Edward Holmes, of the University of Sydney; Andrew Rambaut, of University of Edinburgh; W. Ian Lipkin, of Columbia University.”
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/03/200317175442.htm
But, to Trump, alternative facts (definition: any lie Trump says is an alternative fact and therefore cannot be a lie because if he says it enough times it will become the truth) are more reliable than hard science that is not based on theories.
LikeLike
Thanks for this, Lloyd.
LikeLike
Do your research. B Gates is tied to the WHO. He was a disaster with education why do you think he would do a better job with health care. He is not an educator or a doctor!
LikeLike
If Trump hasn’t already done it, if he does respond to this latest fact-checking of his endless stream of lies, his response will be, “That’s fake news.” And his deplorable base will believe him and reject all the evidence.
Hitler had his deplorable base, too. They were called the “Brownshirts.”
Hitler’s Bullyboys: the Role of the SA in Nazi Germany
“Hitler formed SA in Munich in 1921, drawing membership from violent anti-leftist and anti-democratic former soldiers in order to lend muscle to the young Nazi Party. Recognizable by their brown uniforms (hence, why they were called the “Brownshirts”), similar to those of Mussolini’s Blackshirts, the SA functioned as a ‘security’ force at Nazi rallies and meetings, using threats and outright violence to secure votes and overcome Hitler’s political enemies.”
https://www.historyhit.com/hitlers-bullyboys-the-role-of-the-sa-in-nazi-germany/
How many times have we seen members of Trump’s deplorable base doing the same things that Hitler’s brownshirts did?
Fifty years from now, historians will probably be calling Trump’s deplorable base the “MAGA Hats.”
LikeLike
And then the Brownshirts were taken out in the Night of the Long Knives.
That’s what these Trump cronies don’t seem to realize. When Trump is done using them, he tosses them aside. He bashes them and lets them go to prison (see: Michael Cohen).
Loyalty doesn’t matter to Trump. He’ll do to these brownnosers what Hitler did to the Brownshirts.
But they don’t see that. They just want to make a quick buck or name for themselves by hitching their wagons to Trump’s crashing star.
LikeLike
“When Trump is done using them, he tosses them aside” just like Hitler did with his Brownshirts and Mao did with the Little Red Guard.
Mao did the same thing. When he decided the teenagers turning China upside down had done enough, he sent millions of those young Chinese to labor camps to get them out of the way so he could rebuild what they had destroyed.
LikeLike
How to get across to those supporters that they are involved in the biggest con job in history?
1) Ignore the “do unto others as you would have done unto you” hint.
A) Judge them as though they won’t return the favor.
B) Call them names.
C) Insist YOU are the smart ones and they are unwashed dumbskuls.
D).Tell them you know what they’re thinking, as if you’re a mind-reader.
E) Unveil the/their future, as if you were a medium, gifted with the
phenomena of clairvoyance.
F) Invoke authority, use the “show me your papers (credentials)” gambit.
G) Scold them, as if you are somehow in charge of how they think and act.
H) Insist “your” tribe has access to the truths they fail to discern.
In short, keep breaking them ’till they’re fixed…
LikeLike
One of my Trump/Fox friends found out recently that her husband, who is in a nursing facility, is now dying from coronavirus. I am very sad about that.
I noticed when I spoke with her this morning that she is against the lack of masks and has noticed that the people who are walking on the beaches in Jacksonville, FL are too close together. She says that the ‘go back to work’ is coming too soon because more people are getting infected and that state rates of infections are still rising.
Reality has hit her. I doubt that she would actually recognize that what she now thinks goes against Trump and Fox.
LikeLike
I just walked away from today’s election/propaganda campaign from Trump, built around the same misleading reports on the thousands of this or that produced and so on, plus his blunt force verbal attacks on journalists as low IQ people, not enough brains, and today a full report on a Wall Street Jounal opinion piece praising him for decisive action, honoring federalism and so on.
I like Diane’s idea of depriving him from reporters, or perhaps questions from reporters, except his Fox News buddies. He is hell-bent on insulting anyone other than FOX reporters. Reporters can watch these marathons, do timestamps for lies and produce the fact-checks, distribute these as widely as possible. Trump loves to extend these briefings by calling for questions from the press then blasting them and spinning.
Today the repetions of the same adjectives, phrases, and points in praise of himself were really cringe-worthy. His efforts to display empathy earn a solid F, even in acting.
LikeLike
I can’t watch.
LikeLike
Trump Is Our Leader, So We Have No Leader
A Moronovirus trumpinski orangii briefing
LikeLike
Trump and prayer. What a laugh. This comes from a R wing “Christian news’ rag. Notice that the ‘prayer’ by Trump has complete sentences. It definitely didn’t come from him. This great ‘task force’ includes Ivanka and Jared…definitely experts in everything.
…………………………………………………………
Prayer Alert: President Trump Facing ‘Biggest Decision’ of His Presidency; When and How to Reopen the US Economy as COVID-19 Curve Begins to ‘Flatten’
PPT Staff (Apr 14, 2020)
“I ask all Americans to pray that God will heal our nation; to bring comfort to those who are grieving; to give strength to the doctors, nurses, and healthcare workers; to restore health to the sick; and to renew the hope in every person who is suffering. Our nation will come through like never before.” – President Donald J. Trump
[Presidential Prayer Team] Reopening the economy—when and how—is what President Donald Trump has referred to as the “biggest decision” he has had to face in his term as president. To give him both information and advice, he has assembled an “Opening Our Country” task force at the White House. (Image: via Presidential Prayer Team)
This second task force will be formally introduced on Tuesday and will be chaired by White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows. A number of Cabinet members and senior White House advisers are also scheduled to be on that task force.
The president first announced the new advisory group on Friday during a coronavirus task force briefing, saying that he understands the gravity of the situation as he prepares to make a decision on whether to ease social distancing guidelines to open the economy, which has been largely shuttered in many states to curb transmission.
“I would say without question it’s the biggest decision I’ve ever had to make,” President Trump said.
“It’s been my honor to be the president for the American people… I have a big decision coming up and I only hope to God it’s the right decision,” the president said.
He also asked “all Americans to pray that God will heal our nation, to bring comfort to those who are grieving, to give strength to the doctors, nurses and healthcare workers, to restore the sick and to renew the hope in every person who is suffering.” He also thanked Americans who have prayed for him and the first family. Subscribe for free to Breaking Christian News here
AS THE LORD LEADS, PRAY WITH US:
For God to guide President Trump and the members of the new task force in supernatural ways beyond their own understanding as they work through the decisions to be made on reopening America’s economy.
For the president and for the work being done to stem the tide of the coronavirus.
For God’s truth to be made clear and that He would bring to light anyone who is seeking to harm the United States during this time.
LikeLike
Trump now has something to brag about. THE US IS #1 ONCE AGAIN!! MAGA is true!
………………………………..
Coronavirus Live Updates: Read The Latest About The COVID-19 Outbreak
U.S. COVID-19 Cases Surpass 750,000 — 4/20/20, 2:01 a.m. ET
The United States has recorded at least 750,000 confirmed coronavirus cases, Reuters reported Sunday. The death toll there has surpassed 40,000.
Although it’s home to about 4% of the world’s population, the U.S. now accounts for more than 30% of the world’s total COVID-19 cases. Spain, which has recorded the second-highest number of cases globally, has reported more than 198,000 cases to date.
— Dominique Mosbergen
U.S. Death Toll Tops 40,000 — 4/19/20, 3:55 p.m. ET
COVID-19 has now claimed the lives of at least 40,000 people in the U.S., according to data compiled by Johns Hopkins University. The death toll in the U.S. is nearly twice as high as that in Spain, the country with the second most virus-related deaths in the world.
With more than 13,000 deaths, New York has by far suffered the highest number of deaths, compared to any other state. Roughly 70% of those deaths were in New York City.
— Hayley Miller
Article: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/coronavirus-covid-19-updates-latest-news_n_5e99aadac5b63639081d3bee?ncid=engmodushpmg00000006
LikeLike
Washington Post: Trump’s Claims About WHO Were Wrong”
Why are they asking us?
Isn’t that what journalists are supposed to find out?
LikeLike
Yep. Best president ever. He should be held personally responsible for this tragedy. How many are going to be damaged permanently from catching COVID-19 and how many will die due to his negligence and ineptitude?
………………………………………
States still baffled over how to get coronavirus supplies from Trump
04/13/2020
…The federal government’s haphazard approach to distributing its limited supplies has left states trying everything — filling out lengthy FEMA applications, calling Trump, contacting Pence, sending messages to Jared Kushner, Trump’s son-in-law, and trade adviser Peter Navarro, who are both leading different efforts to find supplies, according to local and states officials in more than a half-dozen states. They’re even asking mutual friends to call Trump or sending him signals on TV and Twitter.
Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn’t.
“This is not something that we should ever be faced with,” Kansas Gov. Laura Kelly, a Democrat, said in an interview. “It really is the federal government’s responsibility to build those stockpiles, and distribute those during the time of crisis.”
In Illinois, Democratic Gov. J.B. Pritzker got results after he tweeted at the president and complained on TV. In California, Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom, a frequent sparring partner for Trump, chose to instead heap praise on the president. And in Kansas, Kelly submitted seven requests for millions of masks, gowns and gloves that went unheeded until a reporter asked Pence about the situation in a briefing. Pence pledged to call her…
https://www.politico.com/news/2020/04/13/states-baffled-coronavirus-supplies-trump-179199
LikeLike
Is this real? It is a U-tube of Cuomo saying the impossible. Please comment on this one.
………………………………….
Gov Cuomo: “Undeniable Fact” Federal Gov’t Coronavirus Response Was A “Phenomenal Accomplishment”
Apr 19, 2020
New York Democrat Gov. Andrew Cuomo discussed how it is an “undeniable fact” that President Donald Trump and the federal government’s coronavirus response has been a “phenomenal accomplishment.”
LikeLike
Cuomo is a phenomenal idiot.
LikeLike
Inkstone…news from Hong Kong…Hong Kong reported no new COVID-19 patients yesterday [started wearing masks, washing hands and social distancing early]
EDITION
APR
21
Hi Inkstoners!
For the first time in six weeks, Hong Kong yesterday reported no new Covid-19 patients.
For more than a week, the city of 7 million people has reported only a handful of new, mostly imported, cases. It’s safe to say that the city has all but eliminated the local spread of the coronavirus.
Before I go on, I should make it clear that no one should rush to declare “mission accomplished.”
The sudden surge in the number of cases in Singapore – another densely populated transport hub in Asia – has demonstrated how little it takes to start a fresh outbreak and turn a poster boy in the war against the pandemic into a cautionary tale. It ain’t over till it’s over.
But it’s worth reviewing what Hong Kong has managed to do so far and the lessons it has learned. Our first story today discusses this in greater detail.
Particularly worth noting is that the city has kept the number of infections low despite having imposed no drastic restrictions on people’s everyday lives.
A recent study, peer-reviewed and published in Lancet Public Health, has shed light on an under-appreciated aspect of Hong Kong’s fight against the coronavirus: the voluntary changes in people’s behavior, including wearing masks, avoiding crowds and upping their handwashing game.
These practices wouldn’t surprise me or any other locals here. Even before the coronavirus pandemic, it was common to see people press the elevator button with their keys or hold on to escalator handrails with only their fingers to avoid touching public surfaces.
We’re not born germaphobes. We just learned to be hypervigilant after the 2002-2003 Sars outbreak and internalized the lessons.
We know anecdotally that almost everyone here in Hong Kong started wearing masks in public as early as January. It happened almost as a matter of reflex when news reports about a new communicable disease started to trickle into the public consciousness.
The new Lancet paper put numbers on the phenomenon. A staggering 74.5% of survey respondents said they began wearing masks in January. 97.5% and 98.8% of people said they did in February and March.
An overwhelming majority of people said they also started avoiding crowds and sanitizing their hands more frequently over the period.
This contrasts with the apparent reluctance in the US and Europe to take precautions as late as March. The resistance in some pockets of American society to social distancing recommendations is immortalized in a video of a 22-year-old partygoer declaring, “If I get corona, I get corona.” He would come to regret his words.
It’s notable, however, that the Hong Kong surveys suggested a drop in the level of alertness in March, indicated by a decrease in the number of respondents who said they were avoiding crowds.
The researchers at the University of Hong Kong ascribed the change to fatigue. It’s something that policymakers would do well to manage.
In the US, a small number of people fed up with social distancing rules are already out on the streets protesting various governments for taking away their freedom.
The worst among them have called Covid-19 a hoax and dismissed medical workers’ effort in keeping everyone, including the protesters themselves, safe.
Separate studies have suggested that we need to be prepared to practice intermittent social distancing until 2022.
Covid-19 will continue to be a test of the strength and stamina of medical systems around the world. The greater challenge is how to manage the billions of people whose behavior, more important than anything else, will dictate the course of the pandemic.
LikeLike
Here is the conundrum. Hospitalization rates in Hong Kong dropped to zero because everyone followed the precautions. If they now take off their face masks and gloves and resume normal interaction, the rates will rise again.
LikeLike
Diane:”Hospitalization rates in Hong Kong dropped to zero because everyone followed the precautions.”
What is going to happen to this country when some states never mandated a close down and Trump is encouraging states with Democratic governors to protest? The beach sidewalks in Ft. Lauderdale are swarming with people who are NOT wearing masks, like ants says my friend who viewed the beach this last Sunday. Ft. Lauderdale is on a lockdown but even police can’t get people to obey the laws. The police are not even ticketing people.
We are in a huge mess and we have no decent leadership.
LikeLike