Sorry to have missed this great story when Jan Resseger posted it. i happened to have been down and out with the flu. This is a story I wish I could include in SLAYING GOLIATH. The perpetrators returned to the scene of their crime and are shunned!
Jan Resseger writes:
Wisconsin and Ohio have the oldest school choice programs in the United States. Milwaukee’s voucher program is 30 years old and the Cleveland Voucher Program is 24 years old. Both states have expanded vouchers statewide beyond the two cities where they began. It ought to be a red flag that in these two states with the oldest programs, National School Choice Week may have been more contentious than anywhere else in the country.
National School Choice Week in Wisconsin
Last week Vice President Mike Pence and Education Secretary Betsy DeVos went to Madison, Wisconsin’s capital city, to honor National School Choice Week, a celebration of vouchers and charter schools that was established and is promoted every year by groups like the American Federation for Children—the group DeVos herself helped found and to which she has regularly donated generously—and Jeb Bush’s ExcelinEd.
Pence and DeVos were not welcomed by Wisconsin’s Democratic Governor Tony Evers, who skipped the event altogether. Before he was elected governor, Evers was the state’s Superintendent of Public Instruction, and before that he was a public school educator. Evers has devoted his career to leading and promoting the state’s public schools.
Neither Pence nor DeVos was welcomed by the Capital Times in Madison, which editorialized: “Pence parrots the talking points of the wealthy campaign donors he has always served…. That’s what Pence did Tuesday in Madison… Pence was promoting ongoing efforts to undermine public education with the usual cabal of billionaire-funded advocates for the agenda of the Trump-Pence administration’s ‘school choice’ agenda… Out-of-state billionaires like DeVos and politicians like Pence have for years targeted Wisconsin in their efforts to promote ‘school choice’ initiatives. They got traction when one of their lackeys, Republican Gov. Scott Walker, was in office. But Walker, a Pence crony, was swept out of office in 2018 by a supporter of public education, Democrat Tony Evers.”
The Capital Times‘ editorial board adds that this year, there has been pressure against school privatization in the city of Milwaukee itself: “(I)n the spring of 2019, critics of school choice and school privatization schemes swept school board elections in Milwaukee, the state’s largest city… Key to the pushback against the ‘school choice’ advocates was the activism of African American and Latino Milwaukeeans, and the determination of groups such as Black Leaders Organizing for Communities (BLOC) and Voces de la Frontera Action, Inc. to defend public education.”
On the very same day Pence and DeVos came to Madison to extol school choice, the Capital Times‘ Briana Reilly reportedthat State Representative, Jonathan Brostoff joined fellow Democratic lawmakers and public school advocates to reintroduce a bill that would phase out Wisconsin vouchers and reinstate a Student Achievement Guarantee in Education, to reduce public school class sizes and upgrade the curriculum in participating public schools.
Executive Director of the statewide Wisconsin Public Education Network, Heather DuBois Bourenane endorsed the Public Education Reinvestment Act being introduced. First she explained specific problems with private schools that receive vouchers: “They do not answer to a locally elected school board. They do not have to follow laws protecting students with disabilities. They do not have to follow the same stringent reporting and hiring requirements as public schools. They can use curriculum that is religious, unvetted and unscientific. They can—and frequently do—‘counsel out’ students who do not meet expectations, distorting the data on their performance and creating unfunded cost burdens for local public schools. This is unethical and we know it is wrong.”
As in other states, Wisconsin’s legislature has created “school choice” programs, but the same state legislature has neglected to pass the taxes that would fund the programs. In Wisconsin and other states, vouchers and charter schools have been funded at the expense of public schools. DuBois Bourenane described the fiscal disaster thrust on Wisconsin’s public schools by ever-expanding school vouchers: “Wisconsin is spending $351,180,390.29 this year to provide taxpayer funded tuition vouchers to 43,450 students at 317 schools, nearly 100 percent of which are religious schools. We know that nearly all of the students in the statewide program already attended these private schools… There are over 860,000 children whose parents choose to send them to the public schools that are the heart of our communities; public schools that accept, embrace, and proudly serve ALL students. Yet data from the Legislative Fiscal Bureau shows that even as the unaccountable voucher program has been recklessly expanded, our public schools have been increasingly underserved by the state. According to the Wisconsin Budget Project, ‘In 2021, the state will invest less in public school districts than it did in 2011…. In 2021, Wisconsin school districts will receive $75 million less in state aid than in 2011 in inflation-adjusted dollars.’”
National School Choice Week In Ohio
Tomorrow, February 1, parents are scheduled to begin claiming vouchers for Ohio’s EdChoice Voucher Program for the 2020-2021 school year, but as of this morning, nobody knows what the program will look like or how many students will be able to qualify.
As Jan has previously posted, Ohio’s legislators don’t care about the public schools that most students attend. They are obsessed with charters (most of which are failing) and vouchers (even though the only research on the Ohio program shows that it harms children, who lose ground in math and make no gains in reading).
But isn’t it wonderful to see the two big Goliaths—DeVos and Pence—get a chilly reception when they arrive in Madison to celebrate School Voice Week? I will save this for the next edition of SLAYING GOLIATH. The Resistance is winning in Wisconsin!
As the Beatles sang, “Money can’t buy you love.”
LOL. Well done!!!
Why is the right making this hard polay for “school choice”? Answer here: https://bobshepherdonline.wordpress.com/2020/02/05/bobs-ayahuasca-school-for-little-cosmic-voyagers-and-bobs-real-good-florida-skool/
cx: play
Last night, serial predator, reality TV star, President of Trump University, and now SOTU Televangelist Donald “J for Jabba” the Trump recited a rousing, partly memorized speech by Propaganda Minister Stephen “Goebbels” Miller exceptionally, even for the Don, full of lies about the economy and liberally (LOL) sprinkled with references to God, by whom, of course, the Don means the god he worships, Mammon. The speech will doubtless play very well with the rubes. For those interested in the facts, however, there is this:
https://www.factcheck.org/2020/02/factchecking-the-state-of-the-union-3/https://www.factcheck.org/2020/02/factchecking-the-state-of-the-union-3/
Charters are a HUGE MESS in Hawai’i, too.
CHARTER School FRAUD in Hawai’i:
Former Hawaii Island charter school official pleads guilty to wire fraud
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2020/02/05/former-hawaii-island-charter-school-official-pleads-guilty-wire-fraud/
Thanks to Jan for another wonderful report. The cold reception for Pence and DeVos gives hope, especially to LatinX and African Americans activists who have been chased by billionaires as if they should be prime supporters of corporate customer-choice programs.
See also Diane’s Time magazine article on the themes in her new book. The message is honed and urgent.
Trump & Devos are determined to pour more money into private schooling and Republicans are all in for this direction for federal policy. The insults to educators were topped by giving the presidential Medal of Freedom award to Rush Limbaugh. That award has forever been tarnished by the overt bigotry of Trump and Rush Limbaugh.
Limbaugh is one of the most despicable right wing demagogues in talk radio, he’s been spewing his hatred infused filth for decades. When labor activist Dolores Huerta received the Medal of Freedom in 2012, Limbaugh had a hissy fit and said that the Presidential Medal of Freedom had been rendered “Meaningless” since Dolores Huerta received the medal. Limbaugh and all his clones paved the way for the right wing coup d’etat which we are suffering under right now. We need to vote out the whole GOP cabal, especially Trump. Trump and Limbaugh, a marriage made in hell. I loved Nancy Pelosi’s reaction to Trump’s diatribe: her facial expressions and her ripping up of the speech. Brava, Nancy.
her action gave everyone watching a feeling of release: such anxiety and frustration was building up for many
Other states should look at Wisconsin as a cautionary tale. Vouchers simply make little economic or academic sense. Wealthy parents that send their children to private school anyway benefit, and poor students get poor vouchers to attend mostly religious schools of questionable quality. The tax payers and public schools pay dearly for schools over which the public has no accountability. Vouchers make the many in public schools pay for the wishes of a few. Over time vouchers will drain public schools that will be forced to cut programs, staff and quality. The result will be larger classes, poorly maintained buildings and fewer services for public school students. I do not believe any of this mess was ever intended by the framers of common schools for the common good. Vouchers provide no such common experience. Private schools should be paid for private money. We must stop pandering to the whims of biased ideologues like DeVos and Pence.
SOTU, Brute?
“Don’t call some Malcolm. Don’t call some Chandra.
Get me my Minister of Propaganda,”
So Jabba the Trump exclaimed from his lair,
while sliming down his Troll Doll hair.
“I need a SOTU that will not fail.
If I’m not reelected, I’m headed to jail!
We need some myth-making, a crowd-pleasing thriller,
so bring me my Stevie “Goebbels” Miller!’
And when they brought him the King before,
he was full of venom and lies by the score.
And of all these lies, I’ll give you the gist:
“You’ll play,” he said, “televangelist.
“You’ve got the tan and, sort of, the hair.
The truth you long have known to foreswear,
so reel in the rubes, the kooks, and the clods
by speaking all night of country and god.
“And as for the speech, I’ll more than assist
to make you a SOTU evangelist,
with poses to strike and lots of fine hammin’.
Fear not offending your true god, Mammon,
For you’ll speak of the miracle you have now wrought
in this country where every Republican’s bought
and whatever the truth of affairs economic
you’ll speak the contrary. Oh, that will be comic!”
“Oh thank you, Steve Miller,” said slick Dapper Don,
“You’ve helped me to stay the great King of the Con
And using the principles taught me by Cohn:
Repeat the lie bigger, opponents to own,
“When caught in a lie, just say it again,
but bigger, this time, to go for the win.”
And so at the SOTU, throughout the grand hall,
the Jabba then sounded his slick mating call.
and Repugnicans ate it up, as they now do.
For them coprophagy is better than stew.
Corrected, updated version of this poem is here: https://bobshepherdonline.wordpress.com/2020/02/05/sotu-brute-on-don-the-cons-2020-state-of-the-disunion-address/