I like Twitter and post there daily. All of the posts here go automatically to Twitter, and I often send tweets from the New York Times, the Washington Post, The New Yorker, the Onion, etc. whatever strikes my fancy. I often respond to Tweets directed at me, and I scan other’s Tweets for good stories and comments. On the other hand, I deleted Facebook because I object to its invasion of privacy, mine and others.
I have 149,000 followers, and I seldom look at their names. But one day recently I looked at the most recent additions and saw that one identified himself as a Sheik from Dubai, Prince Sheik Hamdan. I was impressed and intrigued. I followed him and asked by private message whether he was interested in American education. He responded promptly and said he was. We then had several exchanges in which he described his background and education and asked about mine. I googled him and he looked authentic. I told him things about me that are public knowledge—what I do, where I was born, where I went to college, in response to his questions.
I began to have fantasies of flying to Dubai to give him advice about education. I wondered how he would react when he learned I am Jewish.
But, born skeptic that I am, I began to wonder if I was being hoaxed. Everything he told me was on his Wikipedia page, but then a fraudster would know that information too.
He wrote:
“I know you maybe asking yourself the meaning of the name Hamdan,(Hamdān) is a name of Arab origin. It is a name of an ancient tribe in Yemen, which can also be found in modern Yemen. It is different from the name Hamdan (Arabic: حمدان Ĥamdān) although in English both names appear with the same spelling. I would love to know you better if you don’t mind.”
Then he wrote:
“I’m the third post-federation ruler, heads the Dubai Executive Council which supervises public sector and development strategies in the emirate. I was Born on November 14, 1982, began schooling in Dubai before moving to Britain, where i graduated from the Sandhurst military academy. Where did you school and how old are you?”
I replied with publicly available information about where I was born and educated.
He wrote:
“I really want us to be good friends. This year marks 11 years since His Highness Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, who is also Vice-President and Prime Minister of UAE, became the ruler of Dubai on Friday He did appoint me Shaikh Hamdan Bin Mohammad Al Maktoum as Crown Prince of Dubai.”
Like, how lonely is this guy? I noticed in his bio that he writes poetry, and I complimented him.
He thanked me, then wrote:
“In September 2006 i was appointed as chairman of the Dubai Executive Council, entrusted with overseeing Dubai government entities. Also made significant contributions to the council, which was highlighted particularly by the Dubai Strategic Plan 2015 that was launched in February 2007. what do you do for a living??? have you appointed to handle any office since you were born??”
Ah, we hardly knew one another but a day, and he wants to know me. I’m not that lonely. I say I am writing a book. I write:
“So, this is an awkward question. How do I know you are who you say you are and not a fake Twitter account. I am a public figure in the US, perhaps the leading name in US education. There are many pretenders on Twitter.” I was boasting, but then what do you say to a very important prince?
He responds:
“The internet has been grossly abused by scam artist and miscreants whose intention is to hurt. In as much as one should be careful, same time we should not allow negative to kill the positive potential in a realistic business, please read my proposal carefully is 100% Risk-free. So what do you do for a living ??”
Uh-oh. Here comes the pitch. My antennae are way up. I respond:
“I write and lecture for a living. I am writing a book now. What is your risk-free proposal? I am not in need of money or fame. I live to do good for others when I can.”
Pretentious, I know, but I was sending a signal that I am not interested in a big money grab.
But here it comes.
“I discover documents of a late client Mr. Andreas Schranner A German business magnate who work in devolpment of our great country Dubai. I discovered from my employers that Mr. Andreas Schranner, died in the plane crash Monday, 31 July 2000, (an air France jet liner) with his entire family, as you can confirm it yourself via the website below for (BBCNEWS: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/859479.stm … …According to United Arab emirates/Dubai banking law after the expiration of 14 (fourteen ) years, if nobody apply for the claim it will confiscate as state treasury if
nobody apply for the claim, I am seeking for your support to stand as next of kin/ beneficiary to claim these funds”
Can you believe this? Am I that stupid? No. Do I want to claim to be the beneficiary of a stranger who died in a plane crash? No.
I replied:
“Congratulations.
“You don’t need my support. And you don’t need his money either.
“Why are you asking me to help you? You don’t need me.”
His answer:
“$12M (Twelve Million United State Dollars,) I have the power/right to add your name on the list as the legal beneficiary, the scan documents name list is right in my position. I am ready to share with you 40% for you and 60% will be kept for the Charity Project which you will have to help me supervise during the process of building this Charity Foundation.”
I didn’t answer.
No prince. No Sheik. No trip to Dubai.
Beware.

Diane Wow. These are really become nuanced. I have received two requests in the last three weeks via e-mail that were much more easy-to-spot (right up front with the request); so I trashed them immediately. But yours is really nuanced. I applaud you for talking openly about where our imaginations can go when we think “maybe this could go somewhere.” A special place in hell for these cancerous lowlifes. CBK
LikeLike
I keep getting a letter in snail mail telling me that my car warranty is about to expire. My car is 11 years old. Yeah, I guess it is about to expire.
I keep getting a phone call that reads invalid phone number.
You really don’t want 40% of $12 million?
LikeLike
I have gotten those letters to about the car warranty scam. No where on the letter is there a name or address of the company.
LikeLike
Oh gee, I had a similar experience. Mine was from this Canadian Bank executive and he claimed someone with my last name died 18 years ago leaving millions. He wanted me to claimi was a relative and we would split 8 million dollars. The bank was real but he did not work for them. And the bank knew about the scam. He sent emails to lots of foolish people. I am sure a few feel for it.
LikeLike
There is no end to these Internet scams and telephone scams as well. I got an email from my CPA but it turned out it was someone pretending to be her; the email might have originated from the Philippines. One voice mail message (a synthetic voice) said that the local cops were after me and that I had better call their number. I never called of course because it was an obvious hoax; I looked up the number on Duckduckgo and it was indeed a phone number of a scam operation.
LikeLike
I think once you are a senior citizen, you get on the “golden years” click bait scam list. Your example is highly sophisticated. I only answer the phone to numbers I know after being told that the “IRS” has a warrant out for my arrest multiple times.
LikeLike
You have to be very careful what and how much you say on the phone these days because it is now possible to record short bits of things you say and from that create accurate fabrications of things you have NEVER said.
There is even a dirtbag company in Canada that sells software to do just that.
LikeLike
Yes. and these can also what you say can be syncronized with any videos of you with sound tracks. This is a new digital craft skill. Some versions are so persuasive that Putin can be shown as if speaking Trump’s words in Trumps own voice. Detection of these fakes in being done by examining the blood flow levels in the original images versus those “invented” by workers in the arts of digital deception.
LikeLike
I read a story in the NYT, I think it was the NYT, some time ago (a few years) by a columnist who was contacted by one of these frauds and he, the columnist, managed to twist it around (on purpose to see how far he could get with the crook) and he told the con-man he couldn’t help them unless they paid him first, because the columnist said he couldn’t access his money because it was in a trust and to get into the trust he needed thousands of dollars from the con first to pay a lawyer.
They even started having conversations on the phone and that allowed the con to be traced to Africa.
His column, after the game played out, was hilarious. The international con-man never paid up so the game fizzled to an end and then the columnist wrote about it.
Once it was over since he was using his private phone, he had the phone number canceled and the phone company issued him a new one.
LikeLike
Don’t feel bad.
Millions of people are duped on Twitter every day.
There is a reason Twitter’s motto is “How to dupe someone in 140 characters or less”
LikeLike
“Twitter”
If less is more
Then Twitter’s king
And lowest bar
Is everything
LikeLike
FYI, since last year, the maximum number of characters on Twitter has been extended to 280.
LikeLike
I am seriously thinking about canceling my home phone only because the only phone calls I get is a) This is your ISP and your computer is throwing errors, b) the IRS has filed a warrant for your arrest and the cops will be at my door in 48 hours, c) there is no problem with your credit card, d) donate to the volunteer firemen so they can support legislatures, or e) a click of a hang up.
And I don’t have a Facebook page or a twitter account.
LikeLike
I get calls from fundraisers and political campaigns constantly even though I registered my phone with the federal “Do Not Call” list
LikeLike
Diane, I also have put my phone number on the do not call list. I now no longer answer the phone unless I know who is calling. I do not want telemarketers nor scams.
Once I kept getting repeated calls from some ‘company’ that kept telling me that my computer needed fixing. The voice had an accent. I kept telling them, in my most not nice voice, to stop calling me. Eventually they did.
LikeLike
Me too, Diane. Invasion of privacy and scamming are real issues.
LikeLike
This scam has been out there in various flavors for a long time. Just before reading Diane’s post, I had put in place a rule to block and permanently delete a “Compliment of the day” flavor of the scam.
LikeLike
Diane, this post is most important. Thank you.
I was almost scammed, too. Person disguised self using a compromised FB account.
I filed a complaint with my state Govt. and the FCC.
This online world is scary and risky…one reason why kids need to be protected and educated re: online and in person predators.
Nothing is as it appears to be. I am so sick of the horse hockies.
LikeLike
I do not Tweet of do Facebook. I am solicited to death by emails, rarely by phone. This is something you should know about.
Several days ago, the Cincinnati Enquirer republished a full page story about Twitter trolls from Russia who tried to influence voters in selected Ohio counties. The tale of this discovery is complicated so I will try to summarize it in stages.
Twitter actually had a huge databank of Tweets from fake accounts set up by Russian trolls. Twitter deleted some of the fake accounts but the non-profit news statistic site, FiveThirtyEight obtained 2, 973,371 Tweets from 2, 848 Twitter “handles” associated with the Russia’s Internet Research Agency (a troll factory where bot accounts are run by computers not humans).
The Tweets are public thanks to the work of two Clemson University Professors, Darren Linvill and PatrickWarren. Using advanced software, they downloaded over 3 million individual tweets (well more than Twitter’s “official” revelations). Linvill and Warren used software from Clemson’s advanced Social Media Listening Center to pull Tweets from June 19, 2015 to Dec, 31, 2017. The two professors shared their data with the non-profit news statistics site, FiveThirtyEight, for use by other researchers.
http://newsstand.clemson.edu/faculty-measure-impact-of-underreported-activity-of-political-twitter-trolls/
FiveThirtyEight download the data to a GitHub site, which allowed investigative reporters to use key word searches, sentiment analysis and the like for their own analyses. https://boostlog.io/@anshulc95/twitter-sentiment-analysis-using-nodejs-5ad1331247018500491f3b6a
Journalist Darrel Rowland and Researcher Julie Fulton of the Columbus OH Dispatch downloaded from GitHub 6.669 Tweets with the word “Ohio.” In addition to legitimate news, these Tweets included State of the State speech by Kasich, sports reports, and tabloid hype. But there was also a clear effort to spread lies—fake news, including relays from Guccifer 2.0 the front for a Russian Intelligence Officer (among 11 indicted by a federal grand jury in July for hacking the Democratic National Party). The account LEROYLOVESUSA relayed messages from Guccifer 2.0 and from the Russian (Military) Intelligence Agency GRU. According to Clemson University data guru, Darren Linvill, Ohio was one of only four states to have a Guccifer 2.0 Tweet.
LEROYLOVESUSA falsely warned that “Democrats may rig the elections in November,” claimed that “software installed in the Federal Election Commission Networks by large IT companies” would make that possible (No role for the FEC in vote-counting, votes in Ohio are not Internet linked).
Partisan Tweets made absurd claims about Hillary Clinton—holding a staged rally, fake ballots everywhere with her name on them, thousands of Clinton votes found in warehouse. She was heard at a rally saying ”Obama lies about being Muslim.” Tweets of this kind had hashtags such as these: #Crooked Hillary #Trump 2016 #Trump Train; #ImWithHer not! #MAGA #Trump # America First; #VoterFraud #podestaemails26 #VoteTrumpPence16. In September 2016, one Tweet was “Good News White Folks! Trump’s Ohio Campaign Chair says black folks invented racism.”
This report shows that Russian Tweets targeting Ohio have continued since the election. Governor Kasich and Ohio Postal Workers have been mentioned with fake headlines, along with references to Black Lives Matter, the KKK and Tweets such as this: “Muslim Refugees Riot For Subsidized Housing in Columbus Ohio While Our Veterans Sleep On The Streets.”
I could not find a link to the Columbus Dispatch full page story, but it has been picked up by other newspapers. I applauf their efforts and hope others will take the time to do such detailed and revealing reports on the damage done but faith in tweeting as a source of reliable information.
The original story is here. It is complicated.
http://www.cantonrep.com/news/20180812/heres-how-russian-trolls-tried-to-influence-ohioans-using-twitter
LikeLike
For a very public and well known individual, Diane, you are unusually accessible, which is one of your great attributes. I hope that never changes. Of course, the sort of deception you describe is one of the downsides of that accessibility. It comes with the territory in our 21st century world.
It sounds like you handled the mess as well as anyone could. As for your comment: “I live to do good for others when I can,” well, that’s 100% accurate as far as I can see.
If only we had a president who could say the same. If only….
LikeLike
I tried my best to impress upon him that I wanted no ill-gotten gains, and neither should he.
LikeLike
Wait – – – refer him to the Charter School Networks! They’d fall for it hook, line, and sinker!
LikeLike
They are prolly the ones behind the scam, so that would be a self reference.
LikeLike
Diane, I just noticed on Twitter that you don’t have by your name the blue circle with a white check mark inside of it, which is how Twitter verifies famous people so others don’t get scammed by imposters and con-artists. I looked and all of the guys I found there named Prince Sheik Hamdan don’t have that check mark either.
You should contact Twitter and ask to be verified so you can get the check and people will know that you are for real. Also, be sure to take note of the folks who do and don’t have the checks.
LikeLike
“all of the guys I found there named Prince Sheik Hamdan don’t have that check mark either.”
Ha ha ha!
Reminds me of the old TV game show “To tell the truth”
Contestant number 1, what is your name please?
My name is “Prince Sheik Hamdan”
Contestant number 2, what is your name please?
My name is “Prince Sheik Hamdan”
Contestant number 3, what is your name please?
My name is “Prince Sheik Hamdan”
…..
Will the real Prince Sheik Hamdan please stand up!
LikeLike
People did initially take the names of famous people and pretended to be them a lot before Twitter adopted the check mark verification system some years back. That’s why when the real people went on Twitter themselves and wanted their own names, but found they were already taken, some of them added “real” in front, as in @realDonaldTrump and @therealroseanne (Barr)
LikeLike
How do you get the check mark from a Twitter? Who do you call?
LikeLike
Sorry, Diane, I should have looked into it first. Apparently, since last November, verification has been done rarely, on an ad hoc basis, primarily due to controversies around their having verified people in the the alt-right. See: https://betanews.com/2018/07/18/twitter-verification-fix/
However, it sounds like they do still want to permit the verification of people when they “think it serves the public conversation.” I think you could make that case legitimately, since you are famous, have a large following on Twitter (149K), and because our elections matter to them –and your voice is important due to the importance of electing officials who genuinely support public education across the country, since public schools are so at-risk of being privatized by politicians and the federal DoE now. Maybe you could try a DM and a tweet to this Twitter spokesperson: Kayvon Beykpour @kayvz
The verification form isn’t online right now, but you can see what they are looking for to determine verification here: https://metricool.com/how-to-verify-twitter-account-2/
LikeLike
Thanks
LikeLike
I think we need a check mark system here, so people do not pretend to be SomeDAM Poet.
LikeLike
Above is from therealSomeDAM Poet
LikeLike
SomeDAM Poet is a fake.
Not even a real poet.
LikeLike
I am Spartacus.
LikeLike
Did you report the fake sheik’s scam to Twitter? It sounds a lot like some famous scams out of Nigeria, though I saw tweets from folks saying they got similar messages and thought it was a Russian bot. I think what he did is a violation of Twitter’s policies (though much of what Trump tweets is, too, IMHO). You can find the forms for filing reports here: https://help.twitter.com/forms
LikeLike
No, I didn’t. Don’t know if I have the time to pursue it.
LikeLike
“The Fake Sheik should be shook”
The sheik is a fake
A phony pharaoh
A counterfeit caliph
A make-believe monarch
A pseudo sultan
A manipulating maharajah
A conniving king
A conning khan
A recreant rajah
A scamming shah
The sheik should be shook
From trusty Twitter
For trust that he took
We should be bitter
LikeLike
I think the joke is on the sheik. He just wasted a lot of ink on a really nice person who was not about to be taken in. Reminds me of a couple of missionaries that used to stop by and proselytizing me and a friend would last deep into conversation. They quit coming when my buddy offered them a beer. I think they were sorely tempted. Theirs was a fools errand. Just like that Sheik. He might as well been trying to milk a chicken. You probably ruined his hourly wage.
LikeLike
Holy cow!
Incredible.
LikeLike
My favorite is the call in which a person tells me that I have something wrong with my computer. Usually the caller is pretending to be a Microsoft employee. I let them go on and on, and then when they get to the end, I say that I really appreciate them telling me about the issue. Then I let them know that my partner works in IT (truth!) and that I’ll be sure to have my partner examine my machine and call back in the event that the issue can’t be resolved.
Then the caller hangs up on me! 😉
Always leaves me with a good chuckle and brightens my day!
LikeLike
“It’s not lies. It’s Sheik and Fake — and Twitter helped.”
LikeLike
Hopefully you enlightened the scammer. I don’t have Facebook or tweet but once my email was hacked into. Everyone started contacting me thinking I was stranded in a foreign country.
My sister sent me this article. We have to be extra careful these days about what we read and check out who is behind the writing.
http://time.com/5362183/the-real-fake-news-crisis/
LikeLike
I have had about five emails about being stranded in a foreign country, all seeking money. Did not buy into the scam.
LikeLike
Laura: I”ve gotten two of them giving names of people that I know. Supposedly, one person was stranded in the Philippines and one was someplace in Europe [Spain?]. Of course they were desperate for money.
I emailed one person whose name was given and he said he didn’t send that email. Scam.
LikeLike
http://www.knowlouisiana.org/entry-audio/sheik-of-araby
More useless trivia: Araby refers to the small town of Arabi just southeast of the city.
LikeLike
I was thinking of an old pop song: “I’m the Sheik of Araby, your love belongs to me. At night when you’re asleep, into your tent I’ll creep. The light That shines above, will light our way to love. Spend your life with me, the Sheik of Araby.”
LikeLike
I’m the Sheik of Araby, your money belongs to me. At night when you’re asleep, into your bank account i’ll creep. The scam laid out above, will pave my way to riches. Spend your dollars on me, the Sheik of Araby.”
LikeLike
I’m the Sheik of Reform (one of the Movers and Sheikers of Education) , your child belongs to me. At night when you’re asleep, into her cradle I’ll creep and plant a microchip in her brain for data download and retrieval. Data will pave my way to riches. Spend your tax dollars on me, the Sheik of Reform”
Sincerely, The Real Sheik of Reform
LikeLike
Whoops, southeast of New Orleans. The two songs are related. It’s an old song with numerous versions. The title is just another way of saying, beware of the loudmouthed, smooth kid from hick town. I wonder if the old monied interests in Manhattan refer to the usurper from Queens as the Sheik? It would be fitting in many ways.
LikeLike
Last night my home phone rang. I rarely answer that line, so I just looked at the caller ID. It said “Illegal Scam”. Really? They know it’s an illegal scam, yet they let the call go through? They can’t block the number? Report it to the police? Just a warning in case you happened to look at your caller ID. Nice world we live in.
LikeLike
I get the same message on caller ID.
LikeLike
Does your caller ID distinguish between “illegal scam” and “legal scam”?
LikeLike
Diane Ravitch, perhaps the leading name in education. I think you are.
So many names for influencers and leaders, like influencers and thought leaders, gurus, the first name, the leading name. Yet you aren’t peddling anything but a better education for all. And we can all comment here, in this greatly visible space, perhaps the leading blog in US education, anonymously if we like.
LikeLike
I was duped by a system that I though was dumb and beaurocratic yet relatively fair due to political advocates constantly jumping up and down on both sides crying foul.
Then when almost forced to some digging and processing, I found the system itself was violently political and hugely askew, that research and coverage was either deeply biased or ignored, and money and influence were driving a simplistic, stupid and destructive agenda.
LikeLike
I was duped by a system that I thought was dumb and beaurocratic yet relatively fair due to political advocates constantly jumping up and down on both sides crying foul.
Then when almost forced to do some digging and processing, I found the system itself was violently political and hugely askew, that research and coverage was either deeply biased or ignored, and money and influence were driving a simplistic, stupid and destructive agenda.
LikeLike
“All that twitters is not gold”
“All that twitters is gold”
Tweeted Faker Sheik
“All that I have told
Not a word is fake”
LikeLike
Sheik sheik sheik
Sheik sheik sheik
Sheik your booty
Sheik your booty
Sheik sheik sheik
Sheik sheik sheik
Sheik your booty
Sheik your booty
LikeLike