This is a gripping account of the move to privatize large numbers of public schools in San Antonio. This is the work of the business community and a neoliberal Democratic establishment mayor, determined to turn public schools over to Out-of-state charter chains.
https://therivardreport.com/charter-takeovers-erode-san-antonios-public-school-system/
“While school privatization “reformers” are backed by big money donors and corporations, opponents include San Antonio’s Our Schools Coalition of community members, teachers, and parents, the Movement for Black Lives, the Network for Public Education, and the NAACP – the nation’s oldest and largest civil rights organization.
“It’s big corporate money versus civil rights organizations, community groups, and teachers. The choice could hardly be starker. That’s why charter advocates pretend this argument is about teachers’ contracts and unions that are scared of change: if they were to tell the public the truth, they’d lose the argument before it started.
“Who supports [Superintendent] Martinez’s plans for charter collaboration in SAISD? San Antonio Charter Moms, an advocacy group for charter expansion, and what is loosely referred to as “the business community.”
“Parents, teachers, students, community groups do not.
“In fact, in order to hand over Stewart Elementary to a New York-based charter company, Martinez and his board drowned out debate, community and teacher input, and consultation.
“Parents, community members, and teachers repeatedly called on Martinez and the board of trustees to consult and partner with them in deciding the future of their neighborhood school. Again and again their calls were ignored by the district leaders whose job is to serve them and act in their interests. Again and again district leaders refused to consider alternatives to plans which had been devised behind the scenes many months earlier. While the Stewart community was excluded at every turn, Democracy Prep was being courted by district leaders.
“Stewart teachers, parents, and students were effectively dismissed and denied the chance to escape the State’s “improvement required” rating by a district leadership unwilling even to make its contract with Democracy Prep conditional on the school’s failure to meet standards.
“But last week, preliminary STAAR scores indicated that Stewart Elementary could obtain a passing, or “met standard” rating from the state, SAISD Deputy Superintendent Pauline Dow said. While final STAAR results and the State’s accountability ratings won’t be released until August, those of us trained on the state calculators for school performance are certain Stewart Elementary will finally emerge from its “improvement required” status.
“Regardless, Democracy Prep is slated to take over Stewart on July 1.
“A campus that could be safe from state sanction is being dismembered and sold off, all but two of its teachers leaving rather than work for the charter company with high teacher turnover rates (34 percent across all campuses last year), low expectations for teacher qualifications (as few as 44 percent of teachers being certified), and regressive and punitive disciplinary practices (28 percent suspension rate). Many students have opted to leave, even under district pressure to remain, and the campus’s future remains uncertain.
“It could have been a different story, and now we have proof that our most underperforming campuses can turn themselves around without the “expertise” of outside charter companies.
“San Antonio’s public schools are far from perfect, and we should move boldly to transform them into the schools our children deserve. But handing them over to private, profit-seeking entities isn’t the way to proceed. Powerful forces are doing everything they can to cash in on the privatization of public education in this country. They are desperately working to shape a narrative which – if they succeed – will have you fighting the people you should be supporting, and supporting the people you should be fighting.”

Ed reformers are popping champagne corks over their big win against labor unions:
https://www.the74million.org/
Thank goodness they beat those evil unions back.
Now that THAT scourge is abolished equality will reign, incomes will magically rise, all schools and students will be “excellent!” and all structural problems in the United States will disappear.
I don’t know how they raise all that money from billionaires without beating up on the few remaining labor unions, though. We may be looking at job losses in the ed reform lobbyist sector.
What do politicians do now they can’t blame everything on labor union members? Who is the next convenient punching bag? I’m betting university professors. They don’t know it yet but they’re next. They’ll all be making 15 dollars an hour and working as 1099’s.
LikeLike
Must be awkward for Democratic ed reform politicians. The Movement is celebrating their huge anti-labor win but Democrats have to trick voters into believing they support labor and workplace rights.
Really complicates their campaign strategies. How to persuade voters you support workplace rights while belonging to a “movement” that works to gut them?
What’s the next big win for ed reform? Lowering wages? Abolishing any remaining workplace rights? Maybe they can work on getting rid of the 40 hour week, or health and safety protections. I’m sure their billionare backers will pony up for that.
LikeLike
Who will advocate for the 90% of kids who attend public schools without labor unions?
They were the only powerful advocates we had. With them abolished the entire lobbying force will consist of people paid to promote charters and private schools and the politicians who love them.
Our schools will be even more neglected and abandoned than they are now. Politicians rarely enter or mention our schools as it is- now we won’t have a single advocate at the table in state legislatures or the federal government.
We’ll have to work doubly hard to hire real advocates in government positions. Get rid of these lousy and ineffective advocates we’re stuck with now and find some people who value our kids and our schools and intend to contribute something.
LikeLike
I smell the footprint of the Koch brothers, ALEC, the American Enterprise Institute, the Walton Family Foundation, etc.
LikeLiked by 1 person
when the word footprint could just as well be written ‘throttling hand’
LikeLike
Is Martinez trying to emulate Rahm Emanuel? He is on the right track by being anti-democratic and unreasonable. Martinez should take a look at the mess Emanuel created in Chicago. Closing schools that are an anchor for the community is no great accomplishment.
LikeLike
There is a new wrinkle in reinventing school governance in Waco Texas. You out source the governance to a non-profit and prevent any of the board members of the non-profit from having been on the board of education you just tossed out. You also pay a huge salary to the school leader who comes in from another Texas District and with some his “get-to-know-you” time also being aided and paid for by retaining the former school leader, both overpaid.
This treatment of an unelected non-profit as if equivalent to elected officials is just one example of a more general move by non-profits into replacing and by-passing democratic governance of public institutions. The Gates Foundation among others has several schemes to invalidate local governance of schools and how local taxi dollars for schools are allocated. One of these schemes entails coopting superintendents to work as if a unified governance system even when the superintendents are from scattered geographic districts in a state. The superintendents sign MOUs that give a non-profit entity substantial control over policies for personnel, data gathering and the like. The prototype can be found in the CORE Districts of California.
https://nonprofitquarterly.org/2018/06/27/waco-looks-inward-to-turn-around-troubled-schools/?utm_source=NPQ+Newsletters&utm_campaign=37e946b6a9-DAILY_RSS_EMAIL_CAMPAIGN&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_94063a1d17-37e946b6a9-12896525
and
Click to access CORE-Cross-District-Collaboration-Report-August-2015.pdf
LikeLike