This is a powerful article about how schools are responding to the culture of gun violence. Why is this happening? Could it be because we have a Congress and a President whose loyalty has been purchased by the National Rifle Association? Our leaders refuse to enact meaningful control of guns. They send their thoughts and prayers. I’m counting on the younger generation to vote them out of office.
<a href=”https://nyti.ms/2GwHpoy“>This is school in America now.</a>
James Poniewozik, The Chief television critic of the New York Times, wrote it.
“The heartbreaking thing about the images — one heartbreaking thing among many — is the precision. The cooperation. The orderliness.
“Time after time, a report comes of another everyday nightmare at an American school, and with it, a harrowing ritual. We see the children — those who survived — filmed from news helicopters, leaving the building in neat lines. They’re 16 years old, or 11, or six. Their hands are in the air, or on one another’s shoulders. Heads down, or eyes looking around anxiously.
“It’s an image of relief and horror. They’re in transit, away from the killing zone but not entirely safe yet either.
“They came to school in cars or on buses. They walk away from it the way we’re used to seeing prisoners walk. Arms up. Fingers spread apart. Show us that you are safe, you are unarmed, you are not a threat.
“The news anchors narrating say that the children are leaving school, but make no mistake: What you are watching, this frightened, exhausted procession, is school now. It is what your children are taught. Lockdown drills, active shooter drills. It’s a procedure they have learned, and what you are seeing is a kind of horrible field trip, a deadly exam.
“You send your kids to school, and one of the things they learn is how not to die.
“It’s devastating how well they’ve absorbed the lesson. Every time I see another American class walk out, the lucky ones, I’m struck by the calm, the cooperation. In the worst imaginable moment, the hands go up, and they put faith in what adults have promised them: Just follow the rules, and you’ll be all right.
“The schools are in Texas, Florida, Connecticut, Washington, California — in different sizes and kinds of communities. But everywhere, in those aerial shots, you see the signs and symbols of a society’s investment in children’s future. The green athletic fields. The school buses lined up like yellow bricks. The expansive parking lots. The multicolored backpacks, with their books and papers emptied on the ground to prove that they are not weapons.
“I want to say that these images are powerful. “Powerful” isn’t really the right word, though, is it? They’re affecting. They’re wrenching. They’re painful. But “powerful” — that suggests that they achieve something, that they have an effect on the larger world, and honestly, do they?
“They feel as if they should. So many times we see these pictures, and even knowing that we’ve seen them before, it feels as if, this time, it should be different. The children were so young, or the death toll so high, or the repetition, simply, so great — it hurts so much, this time, that we’ll snap out of our inertia and our defensive stances and take some action.
“And there are actions, sometimes. The February shooting in Parkland, Fla., started a movement based not on the strength of adults’ actions, but on the mobilization of students who realized that they could only count on themselves.
“Still, change comes slow. Time drags on. People forget. Kids are smart — they’ve learned this lesson, too. After the mass shooting Friday in Santa Fe, Tex., a student told CBS News that the killings didn’t surprise her at all. “It’s been happening everywhere,” she said. “I’ve always kind of felt eventually it was going to happen here, too.”
“So the ritual goes on. Another group of children — our children — flees a school. They throw their hands up. Eventually, so do we.”
Sent from my iPad

Some hear MAGA HAT
🧢 🧢 🧢
I hear MAGGOT
🐛 🐛 🐛
LikeLike
Interesting. My hearing works in precisely the same way!
LikeLike
So where do we go from here? The marches and rallies appear to be over. Isn’t it obvious that it is too easy for people who should not have access to guns to get them? How many people have to die or be maimed?
LikeLike
imho, the fall, 2018 election will be one of the most important in the last 50 years.
It will be a national indication, as well as state by state indication, of whether most Americans reject or accept the hatred, intolerance, racism, sexism, etc. of what political scientists already are saying is one of the worst presidents American has ever had.
LikeLiked by 1 person
it is both terribly exciting and terribly frightening to wait for this elecion
LikeLike
Let me say that I am a Marine veteran. That I as a member of the NRA for years. I learned gun safety and shooting with .22 rifles when I was 12 years old. I am not afraid of guns per se. I am not a fanatical opponent of the 2nd Amendment. I believe a person has a right to defend his home with non-lethal (my first choice) and lethal means (in extremis). This having been said, as I said to my classes today, as we talked about the Bill of Rights and the amendment process, the 2nd amendment could be repealed or removed from the Constitution by an amendment. Not today, not tomorrow but it could happen because terrorism AND school shootings will cause the American people to want more restrictions on the purchases not only of guns -especially long rifles- but of ammunition. It is insane that I could fill my garage with 20,000 rounds of ammunition that I could buy in numerous local stores, Arizona, Texas or the internet, or even 100,000 rounds of ammunition. There would be no red flags and the FBI and ATF would not investigate me or visit my home because all these purchases would be legal and I pass all background checks. We should look to countries like Switzerland and Israel -where many people have access to guns and ammunition and see what they do. One of the things they do is monitor very carefully private gun ownership. Another thing they do is limit the amount of ammunition private civilians can possess in the home. When I was in the Marine Corps we kept ammunition locked up. Our rifles were locked up. There was almost no chance of a shooting in a barracks because there was no ammunition stored there. Only MP’s and officers (then) could carry loaded sidearms. You were much safer in Quantico than on the streets of New York, Chicago and Washington, DC. School security needs to be a top priority. But let’s be logical -only humans start forest fires. If you want to stop a fire you don’t start fires and your regulate open fires. You teach fire safety. And you have fire departments. But one thing you don’t do is hand out napalm and matches to kids. It seems very reasonable to me to limit some gun purchases to 21 or even 30-year-olds (unless they are honorably serving military or veterans) and it seems reasonable to me that we should monitor ammunition purchases very carefully. This calls for national action and national legislation. If we fail to do this then eventually there could be a movement to eliminate gun ownership by private individuals entirely. We cannot safeguard the 2nd Amendment unless we act rationally to protect our schools, houses of God and our communities.
LikeLike
Interesting comment. Considering how difficult it is to amend the U.S. Constitution, though, I have to wonder if any repeal of the 2nd amendment would ever happen in the foreseeable future? (You did write, “Not today, not tomorrow…”)
I don’t own any guns. It’s just not the culture I grew up in. I probably could use one considering where I live out here in the country. I remember one particular time my daughter and I were taking a walk one evening and a terribly injured deer (hit by a car, most likely) hobbled out of the woods near us. I would have liked to have put the deer out of its terrible distress. Thing is, I called a couple neighbors who do own rifles and because they didn’t want to shoot the deer outside of hunting season I ended up contacting the state police. A trooper eventually came out and spoke to us and soon after we heard two shots in the nearby woods. My peaceful, evening walk with my little girl had taken a very unexpected turn.
There are a lot of local people up here who grew up with firearms, use therm for hunting and sometimes rely on hunting season to feed their families. I respect these neighbors a lot. I agree with what I hear you saying…these firearm owners, former Marines like yourself, people who are knowledgeable and passionate about the 2nd amendment have to do something to protect us all. Because, at root, isn’t that what the second amendment is about….protecting our “SECURITY”, to use the word that is actually in the Constitution.
LikeLike
The fact is that Antonin Scalia basically rewrote the 2nd amendment in his Heller decision, changing the amendment’s meaning and intent from the militia (the state) to the individual.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/07-290.ZS.html
John Paul Stevens got it right in his dissent:
https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/07-290.ZD.html
LikeLike
I cannot help thinking that all of this school shooting accelerated when we did two things:
The first thing was using negative consequences to keep students in school when they did not want to be there. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, laws were passed that made it impossible to keep a driver liscence unless in school making good grades. Suddenly, students we used to see dropping out stayed, just to get a driver’s license.
The second thing was the pressure put on teachers to make these children behave a certain way on a standardized test.
There were plenty of shotguns and pistols in my county before these two top down approaches. Why were they not used for pernicious intent? Seems simple to me. It was easier to go away.
I do not know whether it was better that way. I am just making an observation.
LikeLike
Thank you.
LikeLike
What makes me sick is that this is going to occur over and over and over and over and over again. Nothing changes. Yes, Trump and Congress have been bought out by the NRA. Guns Do Kill.
One 11 year old was killed by a gun in Indiana about a week ago. He was a black student shot in the head. I’m sure this didn’t make national news. How many are killed and nobody except the loved ones grieve? Where are the mental health resources to help in poor communities after a kid has been worthlessly shot?
At what point will Americans insist that meaningful gun control laws be passed? We need an aggressive buyout program the same as in Australia. If someone wants a gun, let them go through exhausting, meaningful steps. Gus Do KILL!! and I’ve had enough.
LikeLike
“What makes me sick is that this is going to occur over and over and over and over and over again. Nothing changes.”
Yes, “this is going to occur over and over . . . ” See my response as to why below.
LikeLike
This is becoming at least a weekly occurrence. I’m sure there are many killings, especially in black communities that never get reported. Wake up America. We have corrupt politicians. People have to go through certain procedures to legally drive a car. Car manufacturers rebelled at the idea and lost. Why are gun manufacturers catered to…blame the NRA.
…………………………………..
‘This can’t be happening again’: Parkland survivors in disbelief
…As the mass shooting was unfolding at Santa Fe High School in Texas, students and teachers at another high school, Marjory Stoneman Douglas in Parkland, Florida, couldn’t help but relive the emotions of the rampage in their school three months earlier.
“I was just in disbelief,” Cordover, 18, told NBC News. “I was, like, this can’t be happening again. I couldn’t tell if other people were seeing what I was seeing.”
Fellow senior Allyson Adak heard the news a few minutes before she took her final AP exam.
“It felt like Valentine’s Day all over again, and your mind wanders off when you’re supposed to be concentrating on the test,” said Adak. “I started feeling anxious and I started feeling sad. I was almost about to cry…
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/parkland-survivors-react-latest-mass-shooting-texas-school-n875421
LikeLike
Joseph,
It’s more complex in some ways than what you pose.
Americans voted for Trump because he said precisely the things they needed to hear based on a decades-old climate in which the GOP and Democrats have largely abandoned the working class person. Both parties have had their focus on other things, most of which were self-serving policies, and some of which are good but lay well outside the realm of labor and redistributed wealth, making room for the explosive and devastating expansion of free market ideology and theory.
But I agree with you 100% that Americans will be compelled to “accept or reject” . . . . “, By shedding labels and differences, they will also be compelled to accept or reject collectivism vs. individualism and where those two institutionalized characteristics should lie on the American societal spectrum.
This is a golden opportunity for people to grow intellectually, politically, and also to grow up and join the rest of the modernized, industrialized, democratic world, the one in which taxation is fair and gradual, poverty rates are low, social safety nets are robust enough, paid vacation time is humanistic, women get at least 3 to 9 months of paid maternity leave, national healthcare covers all, Social Security is not a chip on the bargaining table, unions are strong, and public and higher education is well resourced and free for the most part.
“Accept or reject” is a process . . . a work of art in progress in the United States, I think.
LikeLike
Norwegian: “We need a golden opportunity to grow intellectually, politically,…..” It sounds a bit rosy to me. I just read and am posting part of an article telling how much CEO’s are making in this country. We are supposed to be enjoying the ‘huge tax cut for the middle class’ and not want $15 an hour minimum wage because companies can’t afford it. Here is a big example of just where our money is going. I’m waiting for an outcry from the GOP about this inequality. HA!
…..
Fortune 500 CEOs Are Paid Up to 5,000 Times More Than Their Employees
By Quentin Fottrell, MarketWatch
19 May 18
…Income inequality has soared in the U.S. over the last five decades, despite increases in worker productivity, the report said. “Incomes for most Americans have been stagnant for four decades,” the researchers wrote. “Instead, this increase in income inequality was almost entirely driven by soaring compensation levels for the top 1% of income earners.”…
Median-salaried employees in all but six companies would need to work for 45 years to earn what their CEO makes in one year.
The median total compensation for Fortune 500 CEOs who had been in their role for at least two years was $11.5 million in 2016, an 8.5% increase from the previous year, a joint report by the Associated Press and the executive pay data firm Equilar released last year found. Not accounting for inflation, CEO pay spiked 19.6%, helped by a buoyant stock market.
Since 1985, Wall Street bonuses soared 890%, seven times the rise in the federal minimum wage, according to data by the New York State Comptroller and analyzed by the Institute for Policy Studies, a left-wing think tank in Washington, D.C., released in March 2017. The average Wall Street bonus rose 1% to $138,210 last year, more than twice the median U.S. household annual income….
LikeLike
“Duck and Cover”
Duck and cover
From your peers
Or discover
Deepest fears
Greatest danger’s
From the fold
Not from strangers
As we’re told
LikeLike
For me, this goes all the way back to the late 20th century. When I taught at the high school level 1989 – 2005 we were doing lockdown drills that always ended with an orderly evacuation to the high school’s football stadium. There was a bill that signaled the lockdown and another bell to signal the evacuation after the police, EMTs, and firemen arrived on campus.
At least two or three times it wasn’t a drill. Once, a pipe bomb planted in an empty locker went off when a student saw it in the open, empty locker and picked it up. He lost three of his fingers and the entire school population was evacuated to the stadium while police and bomb-sniffing dogs searched the entire school.
One of the CPO’s told me that they suspect the boy that lost the fingers was the one that made the bomb and it went off as he was activating it inside the locker right before lunch.
I started teaching 5th grade in 1975. In 1978, I moved up to a middle school and taught 7th and 8th grade English. In 1989, I transferred to the high school to teach mandatory English and one elective class of journalism. Before and after lockdown and evacuation drills, we held drills to teach our students what to do in case of an earthquake.
LikeLike
When I entered teacher there we’re duck and cover drills on the assumption that a nuclear bomb could be survived by that action. Now there are echoes of that era and in ways well described herehttps://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/02/effects-of-active-shooter/554150/
LikeLike
I was in the fifth grade when we were required to hide under our desks to save us from a nuclear attack. How stupid to think this would save us from nuclear annihilation.
LikeLike
The problem is not with guns but the way we are bringing up our children. In schools, grades are going away because we don’t want anyone to feel bad by being compared to anyone else. In youth sports participation trophies are handed out so as not to hurt anyone’s feeling for losing. We are not teaching children to handle bad news. We are not teaching children how to handle situations that are tough. Many of these children are adults now and it gets compounded. The children and young adults who are really hurting have no outlet. They don’t fit in to our perfect little system. They see what others did to get their attention, they see TV shows, games, news that show violence and it seems ok because it’s accepted. Sure change the 2nd Amendment, take guns. These troubled people will use what ever means they can, and with all the choices on the news, TV, games, social media they will find other ways. Solve the problem at the source, not at the end.
LikeLike
Bill,
Gun violence can’t possibly have anything to do with guns, can it? What is so bad about selling them online or at gun shows to anyone with money? Why shouldn’t a 15-year-old own an AR-15? Why should gun owners be required to lock up their guns in safe storage? Why have background checks? Views like these are part of the problem. Why does the US have more gun deaths than any other “advanced” nation?
LikeLike
“This is a powerful article about how schools are responding to the culture of gun violence. Why is this happening? Could it be because we have a Congress and a President whose loyalty has been purchased by the National Rifle Association? Our leaders refuse to enact meaningful control of guns.”
As far as being purchased-no. And no, supposed “meaningful” control of guns will have no effect whatsoever. As I responded on the other post on “how to regulate guns”:
Why is it that after these shootings almost no one will point out the 6,000 lb elephant in the living room?
This country was built on the death and destruction not only of the original inhabitants but the now largely forgotten Africans who were chained and enslaved and brought to this land. That death and destruction, the lifeblood of this country, has been amplified and sanitized now since WW2, so much so, that to question the cult of death and destruction-especially the military, one is seen not only “unpatriotic” but not of a right mind. How goddamned sick is that?
Until we break the hold that death and destruction as epitomized by the US military and our militarized law enforcement, which seeps through the pores of this country like sweat on a 100 degree day, WE SHOULD EXPECT more mass murders and killings. But oh, we wail and moan when it happens. One reaps what one sows. Sad!
Death and destruction normalized-that is America today!
LikeLike
Duane: I agree. Stop the killing. We will never kill our way to peace. The whole idea that continuing destruction will somehow make the US loved in the world is not working. We need to put resources, both domestic and international, on helping people. There are too many who are in poverty and are suffering. Dropping more bombs and killing people does nothing to help.
Michael Moore talked about our love of guns in “Bowling for Columbine”. Nothing has changed since that documentary came out. The only difference is that the military is now in more countries with machines that kill more efficiently and we have more frequent mass killings inside this country. Killing is becoming the new normal. That is SICK!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Killing has been the new normal since at least Viet Nam. But one can go back even further as I referenced. What is that killing, death and destruction? It is a racket. Many people make a lot of money off of that death and destruction. One only has to read Smedley Butler to see just how long that money making has been going on: War is a Racket is his expose way back in the 30s of that racket. See: https://www.ratical.org/ratville/CAH/warisaracket.html
LikeLike
From Butler:
“WAR is a racket. It always has been.
It is possibly the oldest, easily the most profitable, surely the most vicious. It is the only one international in scope. It is the only one in which the profits are reckoned in dollars and the losses in lives.
A racket is best described, I believe, as something that is not what it seems to the majority of the people. Only a small “inside” group knows what it is about. It is conducted for the benefit of the very few, at the expense of the very many. Out of war a few people make huge fortunes.
In the World War [I] a mere handful garnered the profits of the conflict. At least 21,000 new millionaires and billionaires were made in the United States during the World War. That many admitted their huge blood gains in their income tax returns. How many other war millionaires falsified their tax returns no one knows.
How many of these war millionaires shouldered a rifle? How many of them dug a trench? How many of them knew what it meant to go hungry in a rat-infested dug-out? How many of them spent sleepless, frightened nights, ducking shells and shrapnel and machine gun bullets? How many of them parried a bayonet thrust of an enemy? How many of them were wounded or killed in battle?
Out of war nations acquire additional territory, if they are victorious. They just take it. This newly acquired territory promptly is exploited by the few — the selfsame few who wrung dollars out of blood in the war. The general public shoulders the bill.
And what is this bill?
This bill renders a horrible accounting. Newly placed gravestones. Mangled bodies. Shattered minds. Broken hearts and homes. Economic instability. Depression and all its attendant miseries. Back-breaking taxation for generations and generations.”
LikeLike
Duane: Sometimes I wonder if there is something inherently wrong with the human condition.
Humanity has existed for centuries but still depends upon fighting to control others. Jesus says to love all who are different and yet this never seems to happen. Why do those heavily involved in religions still want holy wars that destroy whole societies? Why is it acceptable to hate and jeer those who fail the ‘same as me’ test? I would hope that there is hope for humanity but we do seem to be extremely slow learners. The Christians in the dark ages fought to bring their version of Jesus to the Muslims. This contradicts what Jesus stands for but the killings happened then and still are happening now.
LikeLike
To a degree, Carol, I have given up trying to figure out why these things are the way they are. Now that doesn’t mean I will give up in trying to counteract the atrocities and insane thinking that you aptly describe. Believe me when I say that, generally, it wins me few friends to point out what I point out as most Americans are under the thrall of those who make bank on death and destruction.
Usually, I prefer to focus on the good, the wonderful different manifestations of human behavior around the world that serves to bring us up out of the miasma of that old tribal thinking. We’re all homo supposedly sapiens as far as that goes.
I know you’re a like thinker and I appreciate your comments as they are almost always spot on!
LikeLike
Here’s a new one that we haven’t thought of. What will be the NRA’s next creative reason for killings? Can’t be the easy availability of guns…nope. That would NEVER be a reason for mass killings. Since Oliver North was a marine, I wonder why he didn’t learn that guns kill? Why does our military carry guns if they don’t kill people? I don’t think guns are very decorative.
……………………………………….
NRA President Oliver North Says ‘Young Boys On Ritalin’ Are To Blame For School Shootings, Not Guns
‘Many of these young boys have been on Ritalin since they were in kindergarten. Now I’m certainly not a doctor, I’m a marine, but I can see those kinds of things happening and endangering those two gals.’
LikeLike