David Berliner, one of the nation’s most eminent education researchers, says teachers across the nation should walk out on May 1, to protest low wages, legislative attacks on their profession, and a hostile environment,ent for teachers.
“Enough! Enough B.S! Enough excuses! This must all end now. It is time to ensure the dignity of all who teach! May 1st would be a good day for teachers all over our great nation to walk out of schools and demand better from their legislators. May Day reminds us of two things. One, it is the day to commemorate the Haymarket massacre, where workers were striking for an 8-hour day, and many of them lost their lives. Workers are rarely given their dignity peacefully!”
Time to resist! Time for solidarity!
He writes: MAY DAY!
MARCHING FOR DIGNITY ON MAY DAY
When I was about 8 or 9 I overheard my mother crying, and begging my very gentle and dutiful father to cross the picket lines, since we had run out of food and could not pay the rent. He said he couldn’t do that. He had to fight for what was right. He had to stand with his fellow workers. I was scared, but even then, I remember being impressed by his resolve.
As I grew, strikes occurred a few more times. But when he retired after 30+ years from his clerks’ job in a drug store chain, he received time and a half when he had to work weekends; he earned two weeks off every year; he had a basic medical plan which was once used to save his life; and, when he retired, he had a small pension to accompany his social security. Most of all, what he had was his dignity.
He took his job in 1930, lucky to have any work at all during the great depression. And because jobs were scarce at that time, the chain store for whom he worked casually exploited its workers. But as 1930 gave way to the 1940s, the workers unionized and demanded (often through strikes) better working conditions. Pay and benefits were, of course, front and center—but what my father and his fellow workers were actually fighting for was their dignity. The pursuit of fair wages and benefits for their labor was, in large part, so that they and their families had a chance to lead a stable, decent enough, working-class family life.
Because of my history I am sure that were I a public-school teacher in West Virginia I would have marched for increased salary and benefits. But, just as importantly, I would have marched to maintain my sense of self-worth, my self-esteem, my self-respect, my dignity! I know I cannot be the role model I’d like to be for the children I have raised, or the youth that I teach, if my work is considered less worthy than that of many others by my governor and state legislators.
Do legislators and our governor here in Arizona know that some student teachers at Arizona State University asked not to be placed at a particular high school that serves the students of wealthy families? Was that because of violence at the school? No! Inadequate facilities? No! Inadequate tech support or training? No! Poor role models among our cooperating teachers? No—just the opposite!
The shunning of this school by our student teachers was because the students there called our student teachers “chumps”! The students at this public high school gloated that they had better cars, more stylish clothes, went to better places on vacations, had nicer houses to live in, and so forth. Their teachers, clearly, were chumps!
When our teachers are so denigrated by the offspring of the rich because they cannot afford even a middle-class life style for themselves and their families, it is way past time to worry a lot about our country. It was teachers who personified the middle class in so many of our towns and cities, throughout so much of our history. Firmly middle class was OK. Everyone who taught came to grips with that. All of knew that we weren’t going to get rich teaching.
But now, too many teachers are using food banks to help feed their families (I found this in New Mexico recently). Too many teachers are couch-surfing, and a few must occasionally live in cars because they cannot afford decent housing (go ahead: google homeless teachers!).
Enough! Enough B.S! Enough excuses! This must all end now. It is time to ensure the dignity of all who teach! May 1st would be a good day for teachers all over our great nation to walk out of schools and demand better from their legislators. May Day reminds us of two things. One, it is the day to commemorate the Haymarket massacre, where workers were striking for an 8-hour day, and many of them lost their lives. Workers are rarely given their dignity peacefully!
But the second reason to pick May 1st is that it is called May Day. We all know that May Day/May Day, is the internationally recognized call for help. Our American public education system needs help. May Day! May Day!
In my state of Arizona, in Oklahoma, and elsewhere, I would be proud to march with our teachers on May 1st or any other day chosen. I believe that parents across the nation would be supportive as well, despite the disruption to their lives that such a walkout would engender. We citizens need to stand in solidarity with our teachers and remember that they walk for their dignity, not merely for salary, benefits, and pension protection. The last thing Americans should ever want is for our children to be educated by beaten down public-school professionals, having trouble buying homes, and food, and day care for their own kids, as we ask them to educate the rest of America’s children. I cannot help but believe that if we support the teachers as they walk out, just as we supported the kids of Parkland this past weekend, something wonderful will happen: On May 1st I suspect that the ghosts of Woody Guthrie, Tom Joad, and my father, will march with teachers across the nation. If we stand in solidarity with our teachers we can help them regain the respect they deserve, and the pride they might again feel for the profession they have chosen.
David C. Berliner
Regents’ Professor Emeritus
Mary Lou Fulton Teachers College
Arizona State University

Another mass shooting, this time in Russia:
http://click1.crm.foreignpolicy.com/ViewMessage.do?m=wvjwlnw&r=gmycntwcn&s=olfwwvnqnfwtttkkfvmcnpzvvcqkmktqzml&q=1522069704&a=view
See also, near the bottom of the page, about Nigerian girls kidnapped.
LikeLike
Charles, you should take trolling classes, because so far you are completely incompetent.
LikeLike
Thanks for today’s Laugh of the Day!
LikeLike
My mistake, it was a fire, not a shooting.
LikeLike
This is an honest mistake. When you see dozens of people dead in a public crowded place you automatically think “mass shooting”. What else could it be?
LikeLike
Gruff,
This is your last warning.
Follow the rules of the blog or go away.
LikeLike
Sure wish/hope the students participate in this march.
LikeLike
May Day (aptly named day) should be a national strike across the board. We need to make it clear to both parties that supporting the rich and the big corporations at the expense of the American people will no longer be tolerated.
LikeLike
Exactly my sentiments, Dienne. We need a general strike, and sooner rather than later. Family and folks I know across Latin American cannot understand why we are not all already in the streets. I’m afraid we haven’t mobilized because people don’t understand the danger we are in.
LikeLike
Half of the American people can’t even bother to vote. This leads me to infer, that people are satisfied with the “status quo”.
LikeLike
There are many reasons people don’t vote besides being “satisfied”. If you had an ounce of empathy or ability to take another person’s perspective, you might be able to figure some of those out.
LikeLike
Actually, Chas, for me, the fact that half don’t vote is a sign of total disgust and lack of confidence in the system to make the kind of changes they would like to see. They’ve given up on the system. Too many people voting for the “lesser of two evils” has driven more people away from the system because they know in their hearts that choosing the lesser of two evils is still choosing evil.
LikeLike
Charles, haven’t you noticed how hard Republicans work to prevent people from voting?
LikeLike
Agreed, there are many reasons why people choose to disenfranchise themselves. Disgust, apathy, indifference, lack of confidence, etc.
However, the result of this disenfranchisement, is that all of us are stuck with results of what a majority of the voters select.
LikeLike
Charles, voters do not select results. At best they select representatives, who may or may not further voters’ cause.
LikeLike
@Michael. I have heard from some of my more liberal friends that some Republicans are in favor of less people voting. I have not seen any substantive proof that there is any organized conspiracy by any group, to deny voting rights to anyone.
True, a low turnout generally favors incumbents, but this maxim applies to democrats as well.
If you have any substantive proof, that any individual or group is undertaking to rescind voting rights, or attempting to interfere with people registering to vote, or attempting to bring back literacy tests or a poll tax,etc. You should immediately contact law enforcement or the FBI.
Most people, including myself, are in favor of all citizens voting. I volunteered once to be an election judge (a great experience,BTW). I have to insist on keeping the franchise restricted to eligible citizens. A person must have to prove citizenship, in order to register. And a person must present government-issued photo ID, to vote. These are not unreasonable requirements. Many (not all) states will provide a free photo ID to any citizen upon request.
LikeLike
Actually Charles there are court cases about voter suppression. Why don’t you google the term? I am busy and can’t do your research for you.
LikeLike
You didn’t see the recording of a Republican congressman claiming that the new voting iD laws in PA (I think PA) would result in a Republican victory? How about all the closures of voting stations in some states that created horrific lines to vote. Apparently you only see what you want to see.
http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2016/11/07/those_insanely_long_early_voting_lines_were_a_result_of_republican_voter.html
LikeLike
Many countries hold elections on Sundays to include the largest number of available people in the election. We hold elections on Tuesday which excludes a number of the people, especially the poor. States sometimes play games with the polling stations such as offering short hours in minority neighborhoods. In Miami some neighborhoods had a four hour wait to vote. This is anti-democratic, exclusionary practice.
LikeLike
Actually, I’m not sure the poor care what day of the week we vote. They are less likely to be tied to a Monday-Friday 9 to 5 schedule. . The non-working poor are available any day and the working poor may not ever be available, even with laws that require employers to give employees enough time to vote. When you’re trying to hustle your way between three different jobs and take care of kids in between, stopping to vote might not be high on your priority list, especially if you feel like there’s no one to vote for.
LikeLike
Factoid: The reason that we have elections on the first Tuesday in November, is that it enables farmers to get to the polling place, after the crops have been harvested, and that voting on the Sabbath is a sin.
I would like to see election day, moved to April 15 (tax day). That would tend to focus the mind!
LikeLike
Many states have vote-by-mail and early voting as well as absentee voting.
There are many ways to cast a vote.
LikeLike
Based on your statement about voting on April 15, I’m guessing you are a libertarian and resent paying taxes for the common good. This blog’s latest “troll of the month”.
LikeLike
@Michael: You guess wrong. I was making a point with some humor. I realize full well, that taxes are the bill that we all must pay for what we euphemistically call “civilization”. I have been on the public payroll for most of my life. Military, Diplomatic Service, Commerce Department, Defense Department, civilian contractor in Iraq/Afghanistan, and now I work as an analyst at the Pentagon. Taxes are a necessary part of living in a civilized nation.
I find that placing election day, in order to accommodate farmer’s harvest schedule, is quaint and anachronistic. Ditto with prohibiting voting on the Sabbath.
LikeLike
I volunteered to be an election judge in 2012. Of course, there are several alternate voting methods, in most states. Voting by mail requires a legitimate reason (illness, overseas military deployment, business travel, or other legitimate reason). Some (not all) states have provisions for early voting. (Election judges are required to vote early, so they can be free to work on election day).
Normally, a person must justify, in writing, the reason for alternate voting. A person cannot just ask for it. And it presents another “hurdle” in voting!
Until some major legislation is passed, we are stuck with Tuesday voting in November. The politicians which are in power, (generally) want to keep the participation low, which (generally) favors incumbents.
LikeLike
West Virginia strike happened despite opposition by union leaders. If Janus takes away the agency fees that guarantee union survival then there could be a real shot at same unions becoming much more militaristic to win better working conditions for their workers in return for voluntary payment of dues and continued union survival along with their nice salaries.
The rich and powerful never concede anything without a fight. When unions got agency fees by agreeing to avoid labor problems such as strikes they ceased to be unions and became something more like service organizations. You know: eye glass, dental, some prescription copayments, etc.
LikeLike
“We all know that May Day/May Day, is the internationally recognized call for help. Our American public education system needs help. May Day! May Day!”
Shades of exactly why I put an upside down American flag on the front cover of my book!
LikeLike
I will walk out. All of my colleagues will walk out, or never hear the end of it. A national walkout will gather terribly needed attention to the profession that has suffered the brunt of decades long attacks on professionals in general. Teachers, doctors, lawyers, reporters, we’re all losing the respect and compensation we once had. We’re all in this together. A strike would be more powerful, forcing the whole country to change its routine for a day. A strike might be necessary. A strike might be coming. A May Day walkout is necessary to start waking people in the meantime. Great thanks to David Berliner and Diane Ravitch.
LikeLike
As a retired teacher I say, ENOUGH is ENOUGH!
LikeLike
Bravo, David Berliner! Exactly right, a teachers’ strike is long overdue and painfully needed to stop the destruction of public education as well as the disregard for teacher professionalism. The strongest weapon working-class and middle-class people have is the strike, used effectively often in the past to win labor rights. The main reason teachers have not yet struck locally, nationally, and en masse is b/c of the renegade leadership of the two teacher unions, AFT and NEA, crony bureaucracies that function as labor police and adjuncts of the insider Wall St. Democratic Party. The chiefs of teacher union have cynically watched as their organized millions of members are never mobilized to fight back, sliced up instead by crooks, criminals, liars, and looters…shameful, disgraceful, an ugly chapter in labor history which is presiding over the demolition of the public sphere. If teachers do not go out on strike soon in wildcats which ignore their own crony leaders, there will be little left to rescue. Don’t wait for Randi and Lily. Follow David’s call–strike May 1, strike everywhere and often, strike until teachers force serious gains, real money and real improvements, not pennies and promises.
LikeLike
The two things I most admired about the West Virginia teachers were 1) that it became a wildcat strike and 2) that they did all they could for their students, even assuring that they had food during the strike.
We’re approaching the complete irrelevancy of the national leaders. Inspired by the Chicago Teachers Union, here in Massachusetts, the MTA (NEA) and the Boston Teachers Union (AFTMA) are forging a path of social justice advocacy and community involvement. That’s what leadership needs to look like.
LikeLike
I was just poking around on the inflation adjusted salaries for teachers. These are wildly different by state, and if the walkout is primarily about salaries, that could be a reason for very uneven participation, in addition to the contractual consequences for teachers in specific districts.
In other words the short list of issues ought to include salary, but not be limited to that. I think the biggie is disrespect, voiced by federal and state officials and billionaire foundations and individuals.
There is a work load issue, with absurd and useless “accountability” foisted on teachers and the marginalization of teacher voice on almost everything bearing on instruction in favor of dog and pony shows from outside consultants who have a magic formula for everything.
Shoving tech into schools with constant data gathering under the guise data-driven decisions for “continuous improvement” is out of control. In other words, the anti-union forces will be quick to assert that many states overpay their teachers for 9 months of work, short work days, and too many professional development days. Salary should be an issue, but not the only one. The other question is why the two national unions appear to be sitting on the sidelines.
LikeLike
I’m in if it happens.
LikeLike
Interesting…
LikeLike
To: Charles
(March 26, 2018 at 2:21 pm)
You reply to @Michael: […I realize full well, that taxes are the bill that we all must pay for what we euphemistically call “civilization” ]
Your confirmation in a sentence is:
[I have been on the public payroll for most of my life. Military, Diplomatic Service, Commerce Department, Defense Department, civilian contractor in Iraq/Afghanistan, and now I work as an analyst at the Pentagon.]
From your point of view and from your working background, would you agree that the current US President and his billionaire cabinet favor to tax cut for the rich in order to confirm that they are NOT civilized according to your SINCERE point of view?
If you are the true TROLL in this particular website, I must salute your courage. I admire your background which conflicts to your sincere view in a definition of civilization. I hope that your conscientiousness will help you to overcome the conflict within and to find your final inner peace. Back2basic
LikeLike
I can’t imagine New York teachers walking out. They are some of the highest paid teachers in the nation with good benefits and nice pensions. I’m not saying it’s right, but until things hit you personally, there’s little incentive to make waves.
LikeLike
Maybe it is time when an attack on workers in one segment of our economy is supported by all the workers throughout to fight back against abuse by the powerful. Think about the air controller’s strike when Reagan fired them. Every union worker throughout the nation should have gone on strike. That would have prevented the firing in my opinion and force the Reagan administration to intervene and help solve a problem rather than punish labor. I recall when Bloomberg attacked the union for drivers of students with disabilities. Bloomberg was determined to lower the cost by using non union workers. All unions in NYC should have threatened to strike in support of the driver’s union.
We need a little more “think French unions” in our unions, which will never happen as long as agency fees guarantee their survival and fat salaries for union leaders. Best example is the succesful wildcat strike in West Virginia that union leaders opposed! (Right-to-work state)
LikeLike
Why teachers don’t win any more. As closet Communists, they don’t even know when to avoid a Socialist holiday for their own demonstration. In adopting the “proletarian” class demands, they paint themselves reds. And most of you will respond, “What’s wrong with that?” Americans are capitalists and individualists, not collectivists. By its nature teaching is sorting for excellence. And the teachers don’t even know it. Sad, though, because the demands are legitimate. Thus charters thrive like fungi.
“The date was chosen by a pan-national organization of socialist and communist political parties to commemorate the Haymarket affair, which occurred in Chicago on 4 May 1886.[6] The 1904 Sixth Conference of the Second International, called on “all Social Democratic Party organisations and trade unions of all countries to demonstrate energetically on the First of May for the legal establishment of the 8-hour day, for the class demands of the proletariat, and for universal peace.”[7]”
LikeLike