The Republican Tax Plan will have devastating impact in many sectors of society, including education and healthcare. It will dramatically increase income inequality, by reducing taxes on the wealthiest and on corporations. The Republicans blithely assume that cutting corporate tax rates will lead to more job creation and economic growth, but past experience suggests that the bonuses for corporations will fatten profits for investors and have minimal impact on jobs.
“The tax plan has been marketed by President Trump and Republican leaders as a straightforward if enormous rebate for the masses, a $1.5 trillion package of cuts to spur hiring and economic growth. But as the bill has been rushed through Congress with scant debate, its far broader ramifications have come into focus, revealing a catchall legislative creation that could reshape major areas of American life, from education to health care.
“Some of this re-engineering is straight out of the traditional Republican playbook. Corporate taxes, along with those on wealthy Americans, would be slashed on the presumption that when people in penthouses get relief, the benefits flow down to basement tenements.
“Some measures are barely connected to the realm of taxation, such as the lifting of a 1954 ban on political activism by churches and the conferring of a new legal right for fetuses in the House bill — both on the wish list of the evangelical right.
“With a potentially far-reaching dimension, elements in both the House and Senate bills could constrain the ability of states and local governments to levy their own taxes, pressuring them to limit spending on health care, education, public transportation and social services. In their longstanding battle to shrink government, Republicans have found in the tax bill a vehicle to broaden the fight beyond Washington.
“The result is a behemoth piece of legislation that could widen American economic inequality while diminishing the power of local communities to marshal relief for vulnerable people — especially in high-tax states like California and New York, which, not coincidentally, tend to vote Democratic.
“All of this is taking shape at such extraordinary velocity, absent the usual analyses and hearings, that even the most savvy Washington lobbyist cannot be fully certain of the implications.
“Mr. Trump and the Republican leadership in Congress — stymied in their efforts to repeal Obamacare, and short of legislative achievements — have signaled absolute resolve to get a tax bill passed by the end of the year. As the sense has taken hold that Washington is now a trading floor where any deal is worth entertaining so long as it brings votes, interest groups have fixed on the tax bill as a unique opportunity to further their agendas.
“There’s a Christmas-tree aspect to the bill,” said C. Eugene Steuerle, a Treasury official during the Reagan administration and now a senior fellow at the Urban Institute. As an example, he cited the provisions in the House bill designed to appeal to the religious right…
“Economists and tax experts are overwhelmingly skeptical that the bills in the House and Senate can generate meaningful job growth and economic expansion. Many view the legislation not as a product of genuine deliberation, but as a transfer of wealth to corporations and affluent individuals — both generous purveyors of campaign contributions. By 2027, people making $40,000 to $50,000 would pay a combined $5.3 billion more in taxes, while the group earning $1 million or more would get a $5.8 billion cut, according to the Joint Committee on Taxation and the Congressional Budget Office.
“When you put all these pieces together, what you’re left with is we are squandering a giant sum of money,” said Edward D. Kleinbard, a former chief of staff at the Congressional Joint Committee on Taxation who teaches law at the University of Southern California. “It’s not aimed at growth. It is not aimed at the middle class. It is at every turn carefully engineered to deliver a kiss to the donor class.”
“In a recent University of Chicago survey of 38 prominent economists across the ideological spectrum, only one said the proposed tax cuts would yield substantial economic growth. Unanimously, the economists said the tax cuts would add to the long-term federal debt burden, now estimated at more than $20 trillion.”
The basic idea of trickle-down economics is that enriching those with the most will encourage them to invest in productive industries, create jobs, and thus help those at the bottom, as Money trickles down from the top.
The late Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan described this as feeding the horses to feed the sparrows.

AARP: 5.2 Million Seniors Will See Taxes Increased by GOP Bill
By John Bowden, The Hill
30 November 17
Millions of senior citizens could see tax increases under the Senate version of the GOP’s tax-reform plan, according to an analysis from the AARP.
In an article published Wednesday on the group’s website, the AARP’s vice president and policy director argue that 1 in 5 seniors, about 6.3 million taxpayers, will see either no change or a tax increase in 2019 under the plan passed by the Senate Budget Committee. Of those individuals, 1.2 million people would get a tax hike.
The authors argue that number will jump “more than four times” by 2027 to 5.2 million seniors “as a result of sunsetting the middle-class tax cuts.”
Another issue of concern for older Americans, the AARP says, is the automatic cuts to Medicare and other services under the GOP plan.
“The bottom line is that even today’s 65+ as well as those who turn 65 by 2027 who benefit initially may end up paying higher and ever increasing taxes soon thereafter,” the authors write.
“Further, as the result of growing deficits, they may receive reduced value from Medicare or other programs that are central to older Americans’ wellbeing.”
The Senate Finance Committee approved the chamber’s tax bill earlier this month, and on Tuesday, the Senate Budget Committee advanced the bill on a party-line vote. It will now head to the full Senate floor for a vote.
Protesters repeatedly interrupted Tuesday’s Budget Committee meeting, chanting phrases such as “stop the tax scam” and “kill the bill.” Thirty-six demonstrators were arrested by Capitol Police.
A similar bill passed the House earlier this month by a margin of 227-205, with no Democratic support. More than a dozen Republicans broke ranks to oppose it.
LikeLike
“Trickle down”
Feeding a horse
To feed a bird
Trickle-down course
Is quite absurd
Feeding the corps
To feed the kids
Bleeding a corpse
Is what it is
LikeLike
“But wait, there’s more!” The Senate is reportedly considering scrapping the repeal of the individual Alternative Minimum Tax, which would be the only bright spot in the otherwise abominable plan for upper-middle class taxpayers in high-tax regions like NY, NJ, and California. And God knows what horrific trigger mechanisms Bob Corker is negotiating now.
LikeLike
You got to love it .
So why have we not been on Wall and Broad . There is no such thing as a corporate tax break . In spite of citizens united. Corporations are not people however their Boards ,CEO , and Major share holders are and they will all structure this windfall at the long term gains rate.
Time for an economic civil war . Time to gut the federal budget till the citizens of the Red states hang their political leaders from nearest tree.
LikeLike
“So why have we not been on Wall and Broad .”
It’s so depressing. Where is the outrage that led to the Women’s March? It’s difficult not to conclude that the professional classes are incapable of outrage over economic issues, even when their own pockets are being picked.
LikeLike
Now that Republicans know their tax plan will increase the deficit by $1 trillion, they are already
planning new tax increases. Later on, not now. First, they must pass this monster bill.
LikeLike
If this was a decent bill, the Repubs wouldn’t be trying so hard to pass it silently and quickly..before the public understands just how bad it is.
LikeLike
That repeal is in the Senate version they’re voting on today. In an article responding to Trump’s claim that ‘this bill will hurt me a lot’, it was noted that on the sole Trump tax return available (2005) he would have paid $30million more without the alternative minimum tax…
LikeLike
The truly rich don’t need AMT repeal.
LikeLike
Diane Yay! No more money in offshore accounts, . . . right?
But really, folks: couple (a) the “Billionaires’ Tax Relief Bill” with (b) the proposed/upcoming Constitutional Convention, which will probably be supported by all-things neo-liberal, not to mention ALEC, and we can assume a neo-democracy (double-speak for oligarchy/fascist state) where all good things are coming to all.
Oh, by the way: If religious organizations can become openly political, will they still be tax exempt?
LikeLike
To answer your questions, Catherine:
NO!
OF COURSE!
LikeLike
John McCain says he’s voting yes.
LikeLike
Speaking of $30million… a blurb today noted that’s how much McCain’s wife’s estate will increase without the estate tax…
LikeLike
The worst part to me is when the cuts have the intended effect and young people have far fewer opportunities than I did, the same set of billionaires will fan out across the country to scold us on how we lack “skills” and how it’s all the fault of a teacher who makes 42k a year.
Jeb Bush and Betsy DeVos are kicking it off today. Two heirs to family fortunes, neither of whom has ANY direct experience in ANYTHING they scold the unwashed masses on.
Insufferable. Those two alone are a great argument for the estate tax.
LikeLike
Indeed, Chiara, indeed on your last thought!
LikeLike
If this tax bill is adopted, the wealthy will reach a point of diminishing return when the working people will stop buying a lot of the goods and services produced by corporations and the 1%. It will shrink and stagnate our economy. This plan is from the same team that was so obsessed with our national debt under Obama that they shut down the government. Hypocrites!
LikeLike
IMPEACH.
LikeLike
Public education has a critical role to play here. And it’s not STEM. It isn’t “college and careers.” It’s not higher SAT and ACT scores. It surely isn’t Advanced Placement.
It’s education for democratic citizenship, a la Horace Mann, and John Dewy, and George Counts, and Earl Johnson, and Smth & Hullfish, and Hunt & Metcalf.
Is there anyone in public education ‘leadership’ who actually cares about such things any more?
LikeLike
Agreed.
LikeLike
“The late Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan described this as feeding the horses to feed the sparrows.”
I’d replace horses with bulls in the above, and note that even sparrows cannot live on bullcrap diet.
LikeLike
Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) has announced that he will vote for the Republican tax cut bill that will add $1.5 trillion to the deficit and pretty much ruin the country. And he is willing to lie through his teeth to justify it. Here’s how his statement starts.
“After careful thought and consideration, I have decided to support the Senate tax reform bill. I believe this legislation, though far from perfect, would enhance American competitiveness, boost the economy, and provide long overdue tax relief for middle class families.
“For too long, hardworking people in Arizona and around the country have not seen a raise in their paychecks. This bill would directly benefit all Americans, allowing them to keep a higher percentage of what they earn. According to the non-partisan Joint Committee on Taxation, every income bracket would see tax relief under this bill.
Until 2026, he does not add. The JCT also found that after that year, everyone making less than $75,000 is going to see a tax hike, because the stuff they’re putting in to help people expires then. But the corporate tax cuts (which he touts as making “our markets far more attractive for investment”) will be permanent.
We know the tax bill is going to take $25 billion from Medicare immediately, because it will trigger automatic spending cuts and only part of Medicare won’t be shielded. The part that will be cut is the part that pays for expensive chemotherapy drugs. The last time these cuts were triggered, cancer patients were denied treatment. And it’s going to happen again. The last time it was resolved when the government shutdown ended. This time it’s permanent.
And John McCain doesn’t care.
Jam your senators’ phone lines at (202) 224-3121. Tell them to vote “no” on the Republican tax bill.
LikeLike
This is an email from the WH:
The Senate closes in on tax reform
Today could prove to be a monumental one for the United States, as the Senate moves ever closer to passing the most ambitious tax reform bill in three decades. While Senators do the tough and necessary work of finalizing the legislation’s terms, the past 48 hours has given Americans plenty of reason to be optimistic that a tax cut will arrive in time for Christmas:
On Wednesday, 137 economists sent an open letter to Congress backing the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. The letter is worth reading in full, but here’s the money quote: “Left virtually untouched for the last 31 years, our chart-topping corporate tax rate . . . [sent] 4,700 companies from 2004 to 2016 to cheaper shores abroad.”
Yesterday, Senators John McCain (R-AZ) and Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) said they’ll be voting yes on the bill; this morning, Senators Ron Johnson (R-WI) and Steve Daines (R-MT) also confirmed their support, giving the legislation a major boost.
The sense of forward momentum from Republicans on Capitol Hill is palpable. “We’re heading down the home stretch,” said Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell yesterday. President Donald J. Trump stands ready to sign this historic legislation.
Read more about the President’s vision to jolt economic growth.
LikeLike
“Today could prove to be a monumental one for the United States, ”
Yup, it marks the beginning of the end of the era of the billionaires and the politicians serving them. I think these politicians know this (they cannot be that stupid), and they want to leave the scene with a bang.
LikeLike
“Read more about the President’s vision to jolt economic growth.”
The economy will be overjolted.
LikeLike
Sen. Marco Rubio: GOP will cut Social Security and Medicare
Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) acknowledged that the Republican drive to cut taxes for the wealthy is the prelude to a larger attack on Social Security and Medicare. On Wednesday, he told a group of lobbyists that hiking the deficit with the GOP tax bill is the first step in dismantling the programs.
Responding to a question from Politico interviewers about how to address the federal deficit, he replied, “We have to do two things. We have to generate economic growth which generates revenue, while reducing spending. That will mean instituting structural changes to Social Security and Medicare for the future.”
A video of Rubio’s appearance is here. His remarks about Social Security and Medicare begin at the 21:45 mark.
“Sen. Rubio may have just told a secret that he was not supposed to spill,” said Joseph Peters, Jr., Secretary-Treasurer of the Alliance. “The GOP strategy of increasing the debt and then saying we need to cut Social Security and Medicare usually flies under the radar.
LikeLike
Republicans have been under a lot of pressure to get this tax reform done. Here are three actual quotes:
Colorado Senator Cory Gardner: “Donors are furious”
New York Republican Rep. Chris Collins: “My donors are basically saying: ‘Get it done or don’t ever call me again.’”
South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham: “The financial contributions will stop.”
This bill gets talked about in the press as a $1.5 trillion tax cut. It’s not. It is, broadly speaking, a $6 trillion tax cut for some people paid for by a $4.5 trillion tax hike on other people.
The GOP has a list of more than a hundred economists who say that it’s a great idea! The Intercept’s Lee Fang took a closer look at the list and found it was populated by ghosts, cranks, office assistants, an ex-felon (not that there’s anything wrong with that) and a lot of retired economists who were claiming to still be working.
LikeLike
This information came from Ryan Grim info@actionnetwork.org
LikeLike
“an ex-felon (not that there’s anything wrong with that) ”
D)
LikeLike
Bernie Sanders is a voice of reason. Imagine what this country could do if there were more like him.
………………
Throughout my political career, I have asked us all to imagine what our nation’s future could be:
A country with a minimum wage that is a living wage; with students who can graduate college without crushing debt; where health care is recognized as a right for every man, woman, and child; and where we lead other nations in the fight against climate change.
I have asked us to believe that we could level the playing field and create a vibrant democracy where the billionaire class would no longer be able to buy and sell our candidates and elections.
I will always believe in that America — even after last night, when I watched my Republican colleagues in the Senate pass a tax scam that is literally the opposite of the vision you and I both believe in.
The current Republican “tax cut” bill, paid for by the Koch brothers and other billionaire campaign contributors, continues the push to make the rich richer at the expense of everyone else. It would raise taxes on middle class families making $75,000 a year or less and would throw 13 million Americans off of health insurance. And it would do all of these things to provide permanent tax cuts to the wealthiest Americans and profitable corporations that ship American jobs to China while moving their American profits to the Cayman Islands.
And just this past week, Senator Marco Rubio said the Republican Party’s next step was to cut Social Security.
That is why I am going on the road this weekend with MoveOn and the Not One Penny campaign to talk directly to working people in Ohio and Pennsylvania about this disastrous piece of legislation — and I’m asking you to make your voice heard.
I hope you’ll join us in speaking up for working families by sharing this post urging action against this immoral tax scam bill.
Make no mistake, this bill is not simply about cutting taxes for some of the richest people and most powerful corporations in America — its ultimate goal is to radically transform American society and the role that government plays in the lives of the working families of our country.
This is not moral. This is not what the American people want. This is not what our country and our pledge for “liberty and justice for all” is supposed to be about.
We have to fight this tax scam and stop it. That’s why I’m hitting the road with MoveOn and the Not One Penny campaign, and why I’m asking you to support the work that we’re doing.
In solidarity,
Bernie Sanders
LikeLike
I can hardly wait for my ‘big, beautiful tax cut’. Medicare will be cut so I can enjoy paying for more out of my pocket.
…………….
Analysis | The Senate just passed a massive tax bill. Here’s what is in it from The Washington Post
The Senate just approved the largest change to the U.S. tax code in 30 years. Lowering taxes for American businesses and families is the heart of President Trump’s plan to boost the economy, although not everyone gets a tax cut in the plan.
“We are going to be saying Merry Christmas again, with a big, beautiful tax cut,” Trump said Wednesday at a speech in Missouri.
http://wapo.st/2j4hk7u?tid=ss_mail&utm_term=.a7ac3883219c
LikeLike
This was posted in the WaPo article on the massive tax bill.
………………….
Double the teacher expense credit. The Senate bill doubles the amount teachers are able to deduct for buying supplies for their classrooms. The current amount is $250. The Senate plan raises it to $500. (The House plan scraps this credit entirely, one of many differences between the bills.)
LikeLike
Who cares about the environment? Destroying it one step at a time will eventually become a disaster for all life on earth. Sea animals are dying from the pollution in the oceans. We are living in an environment of extreme pollution. I have air purifiers inside my condo and drink only filtered water. Gad. It will only get worse if the Repubs get rid of the EPA. The wave of the future is in green energy…wind and solar.
………………………
The Environmental Disaster Tucked Into the Tax Bill
The Republican tax bill opens up a wildlife refuge in Alaska to oil drilling.
The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge—recognized for its picturesque vistas and wildlife—has been a battleground for Democrats and Republicans for years. The 20-million-acre park sits above large oil and gas reserves, which Republicans, including Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska), have eyed as a huge source of revenue for the state.
…Within the folds of the tax bill is a little-know drilling measure, which would allow for gas and oil production within a 1.5-million-acre portion of the refuge. This would generate an estimated $1.1 billion over the course of a decade, according to the Congressional Budget Office. Environmentalists, however, say the site is a critical habitat for hundreds of animal species, including foxes, polar bears, and caribou, and therefore in need of protection. Drilling could also threaten sacred lands for the Native Alaskan Gwich’in tribe.
“The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge is one of the crowned jewels of our public lands,” Ana Unruh Cohen, the director of government affairs at the Natural Resources Defense Council tells Mother Jones. “Drilling there would totally mar this beautiful place.”…
http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2017/11/the-environmental-disaster-tucked-into-the-tax-bill/
LikeLike
Here is another email that just came from the WH. How nice that this ‘indispensable component of American democracy will ensure that all voices are heard’. My voice certainly wasn’t heard. Quite frankly, I don’t like having Medicare cut. I don’t like having the deficit raised $1.5 trillion so that Social Security can be next on the chopping block. I don’t believe that the wealthy and hugely profitable corporations need more money at my expense. The President applauds the Senate because he will be making billions. Can’t think of anyone who deserves it more. [Sarcasm]
……………….
The road ahead for tax reform
After a busy week of discussions and compromise, Senate Republicans backed up a major promise to the American people by passing the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act early Saturday morning.
The bill now advances to a congressional conference committee, which will reconcile any differences between the Senate’s version and similar legislation passed by the House last month. This process—an indispensable component of American democracy—will ensure that all voices are heard and that the final product sent to President Donald J. Trump later this month is the bill’s strongest version yet.
The President applauds the Senate for its work and looks forward to signing this momentous tax cut into law in time for Christmas.
LikeLike
My Senator Todd Young (R) of NW Indiana sent out this pack of lies. He is pandering to the ignorance of the majority in a red state. Here is an editorial that he wrote for the Indianapolis Star. Makes me sick. I have written numerous emails and called a handful of times and yet this is what he sends out.
……….
Senate Tax Bill Benefits Hoosiers
By: U.S. Senator Todd Young (R-Ind.)
Indianapolis Star
December 3, 2017
“The world has changed a lot in the last three decades, but our outdated tax code remains the same. This week, the Senate delivered on our promise to the American people by taking action to reform the tax code and end the Obamacare individual mandate tax.
“Over the last seven years, I have traveled the state talking to Hoosiers and soliciting their ideas on what Washington can do to help improve their lives. One thing I’ve heard consistently is that our current tax code places more burdens on growth and opportunity than it does to incentivize them. This is completely backwards. Our code should incentivize work, saving, and investment, not constrain it.
“Our guiding principle for tax reform was simple: allow hardworking Hoosiers to keep and control more of their money. The goal throughout this process has been to ensure middle-class families and those of modest means see real tax relief. Many American workers have not seen a pay raise in a decade. And over fifty percent of American families are living paycheck to paycheck. This is the pay raise Hoosiers have been waiting for.
“We needed to fix our broken tax structure for people like Nathan from Indianapolis, who recently emailed my office about why he needs tax reform. ‘After taxes I’m struggling from paycheck to paycheck just to make ends meet, and being able to keep more of what I’ve earned would definitely help me out immensely,’ he wrote.
“Tax reform will help our small and medium-sized businesses grow, too.
“Debbie from Clark County contacted my office about her business’ challenges. ‘We are constantly striving to reinvest in our company through new equipment, and increased wages to hire and retain good employees. A lower corporate tax will allow us to buy more equipment, offer benefits and better wages.’
“American-based businesses see some of the highest tax rates of any in the industrialized world. This limits innovation and job growth and causes wages to remain stagnant. We must create an environment that fosters the creation of good-paying jobs and keeps our businesses competitive in an increasingly global economy.
“Since our last reform thirty years ago, the code has become littered with special interest tax breaks and loopholes that have created a complex and unfair tax regime. ‘Our tax system has become so complicated, the average person needs to hire someone with expertise to help. If most of us didn’t have to hire help, right there we’d be saving money,’ says Susan from Indianapolis.
“In fact, according to the Tax Foundation, taxpayers spend a combined $99 billion each year complying with individual income tax returns and U.S. businesses spend over $147 billion. By simplifying the code, we will reduce compliance costs so individuals and businesses can keep and invest their hard-earned money.
“By passing the Senate’s Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, we also made good on our promise to repeal the individual mandate tax – the most unpopular part of Obamacare. In Indiana, nearly 140,000 Hoosiers choose to pay the tax instead of buying insurance they don’t want or can’t afford. Eighty-one percent of those who paid the tax made less than $50,000 per year, and 40 percent made less than $25,000.
“Repealing the Obamacare tax, doubling the standard deduction, doubling the Child Tax Credit, and lowering rates for middle-income Americans makes hard-working Hoosiers big winners in this bill.
“The world has changed at an extraordinary pace in the past thirty years. Americans have changed the way we travel, how we communicate, and how we work, but our tax code has not kept up. The Senate took a major step toward bringing our outdated tax system into the 21st century this week with the passage of this bill.”
LikeLike
Why aren;t you paying the estate tax? Maybe because you bought 311,000 bottles of whisky.
The argument, then: If, instead of blowing your money on booze and “women,” you were to invest it, you too could have an estate large enough to qualify.
How much are we talking about? Well, in 2017, the estate tax applies only to estates worth $5.49 million or more. In the interest of providing life advice to our readers, we decided to figure out just how much you’d need to cut back on your booze and moving pictures to save enough to qualify for that tax.
http://thebaltimorepost.com/why-arent-you-paying-the-estate-tax-maybe-because-you-bought-311000-bottles-of-whisky
LikeLike