Don’t believe it when Paul Ryan or a.m. itch McConnell or Trump says that the GOP tax plan cuts taxes for the middle class. That’s a lame joke. It is a tax plan to cut taxes for billionaires.
The tax plan is payback to the richest Americans, whose campaign contributions keep the Agra day Old Party happy.
“The House Republicans’ tax reform plan has arrived. And as it turns out, the people it aims to please aren’t the infamous 1 percent, the upper class, or even millionaires.
“Instead, they’re multi-multi-millionaires and billionaires — the top 0.1 percent or even the top 0.01 percent.
“This rarified group has poured gobs of money into Republican campaigns in recent years. And they expect a return on their investment.
“First up is a cut in the federal tax rate that corporations pay on their profits — from 35 percent to 20 percent. Republicans have dutifully argued this cut will help ordinary workers by encouraging companies to expand and create jobs, but this is nonsense. The tax savings would largely go to dividends and other payouts to stock owners. And since wealth ownership in this country is even more unequal than income, the benefits of this cut overwhelmingly go to the richest of the rich.
“Second is the elimination of the estate tax. This cut is transparently meant only for the richest of the rich. As it is, the tax doesn’t even kick in until an inheritance is worth at least $5.49 million ($10.98 million for a married couple), and then the 40 percent rate only applies to the money above that threshold. So no one needs this tax to go away except the top tiny fraction of the 1 percent. The GOP would soften the blow to revenue by delaying its complete elimination for six years, and just increasing the threshold in the meantime. But the end result is the same.
“Third is a change in the federal tax for what’s called “pass through” businesses. Instead of sending profits to shareholders, these companies pass their profits through as income to their owners, so the money currently gets hit by the regular individual income tax instead of the corporate profits tax. Now, the House GOP intends to leave the top 39.6 percent individual income tax rate in place for people making $1 million and above. So the Republicans want to at least minimize the imbalance between that and the new 20 percent corporate tax rate by cutting the pass-through rate to 25 percent.
“This is where it gets a little wonky.
“There’s actually a huge amount of inequality among pass-through businesses, so only a tiny fraction pay the top income tax rate as it is. (And even fewer will pay it under the GOP’s changes to the individual income brackets and rates.) So the whole idea that this is a tax break for small businesses is nonsense.
“But on top of that, defining who counts as a “pass through” business is tricky, and it’s entirely possible that rich individual filers could rejigger their tax paperwork to claim to be a pass through business. To avoid that, the GOP has inserted some pretty complex rules, which rather hilariously undercut the claim that they’re “simplifying” the tax code. But those rules will also likely guarantee that people who actually work full time in the small business they own will still pay the normal income tax rates — only passive investors, who are disproportionately wealthy, will see the full benefits of the lower 25 percent rate. (Along with, say, real estate moguls like a certain sitting U.S. president.)”
When you look at the details, it is even worse.
All the cuts that will hurt ordinary people—students, teachers, families, small businesses— and the services they rely on are being made to finance tax cuts for the richest people in the nation.

The GOP’s Tax Cut Bonanza Is a Major Attack on Medicare @alternet
…According to the Congressional Budget Office, the GOP tax bill will instantly trigger $400 billion in automatic cuts to Medicare in the next 10 years, including $25 billion in the first year after enactment alone.
These cuts are the result of a law known as Statutory PAYGO. That law requires an automatic cut in spending when Congress increases the deficit. The tax bill is, in Donald Trump’s words, “a big, beautiful Christmas present”—for Trump’s family and other billionaires. If the Republicans are successful in passing a tax bill that increases the deficit by $1.5 trillion, as they intend, the provisions of PAYGO will be activated.
To be clear: If the tax bill passes the Senate and is signed into law by Trump, nothing more needs to be done to cut Medicare. If the House and Senate do nothing, the cuts take effect immediately after the end of the congressional session and get bigger every passing year. A vote for this tax bill is a vote to cut Medicare….
Statutory PAYGO is a law that never should have been passed. It makes it much easier for Congress to force cuts to vital programs like Medicare by passing unrelated bills which then need to be offset….
The tax bill is one enormous attack on our health. It takes away the ability of those with large health care costs to deduct those costs from their taxes. It repeals the part of the Affordable Care Act that seeks to make health insurance affordable. The consequence of that is $185 billion less in health insurance subsidies and $179 billion in Medicaid cuts. All so Republicans can shower huge tax giveaways on their wealthy donors.
https://www.alternet.org/activism/vote-gop-tax-bill-vote-cut-medicare#.WhQ979lfU6g.gmail
LikeLike
There was a 10/30 WaPo column called “This Tax Reform thing won’t be as easy as Republicans think” by Catherine Rampell. She addresses Statutory PAYGO. Not only would the bills now being floated set an immediate $28B cut to Medicare in motion, it would do other things like wiping out farm subsidies. This automatic sequester can be overridden– as it was by the Bush tax cuts– BUT: a bill to override it requires 60 votes– i.e., a handful of Dem Party votes. No more rush-rush quickie tax reform bill…
LikeLike
It’s not just that the top 1 percent get half of the money freed up by this tax plan in 2018. It’s the the top 10th of the 1 percent gets almost a third! And those portions expand by 2027.
This is another reason that Republicans are in office. Rob those who have little to give to those who have much more than they know what to do with.
LikeLike
The Donor Class.
LikeLike
That’s right. We work ourselves silly to donate to both those with the most money and those with the least. Who thought this was a good plan?
LikeLike
Ivanka Trump touts GOP tax cuts with data borrowed from the Obama administration..WaPo
We had puzzled over a comment by Ivanka Trump until our puzzler was sore. Speaking on behalf of her father’s tax plan, Trump said it would provide relief, in the form of tax credits and deductions, to families struggling to pay for child care. Then she said something that stopped us in our tracks. She added that“We spend less than any country in the developed world on children between the ages of zero and 5. It’s just a fact.” We wondered where this fact came from and how it made the case for a cut in taxes.
It took a little digging but it turned out she had borrowed this factoid from a report issued by President Barack Obama’s Council of Economic Advisers. The report – which made the case for expanding access to high-quality pre-kindergarten programs – cited 2011 data from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development that showed the United States ranked 33 out of 36 with respect to total investment in early-childhood education relative to country wealth. (The OECD notes that it does not capture state and local data, so to some extent the U.S. figure is too low.) In any case, the proposed tax cuts wouldn’t boost the United States’ rank – and even could increase taxes on 40 percent of families with children. For her mental gymnastics, we awarded Ivanka Trump One Pinocchio.
LikeLike
I understood right off how “a.m. itch” applies to Trump but it took me a while to figure out how it applies to McConAll.
LikeLike
Heh heh McConnell also causes me an itch in my a.m…
LikeLike
“itch McConnell”
Sounds about right considering he’s an itch on the backside of the body politic.
LikeLike
I want to know what has happened to the rage . Indivisible is too busy calling for Franken to resign, to call for demonstrations on Wall and Broad . But what did you expect from democratic staffers. The Business Roundtable has been pushing this cut, on the airwaves for months and the oligarchy could careless about their personal rate when all their income is in capital gains and dividends. I mean really a demonstration in Huntington LI NY 35 miles from Manhattan and one in the Village .
This is a dagger aimed at turning the clock back a hundred years and we are sleeping through it . The effect of the removal of deduct ability of SALT will make the calls for draconian wage cut backs for municipal workers and anyone doing contract work for those municipalities massive. The deficits will increase the calls for cuts in Social Security and Medicare and every other pubic service or good . . A race to the bottom . Kiss what is left of Teachers unions goodbye . Construction Unions goodbye . Graduate students goodbye (they love the stupid.) Make it more difficult for college students with the loss of a deduction and a credit. . …… …….
But of course the Democrats will never commit to completely reversing this because they are in bed with the same corporatocracy and the Plutocrat CEOs.
Time to vomit again.
LikeLike
Sing it, sister. There is an air of complacency and inevitability about tax reform that is literally sickening to watch play out. Maybe it’s because “math hard,” I don’t know. But these bills are worse than anything else we’ve seen from this White House or this Congress. And just I don’t feel the outrage.
LikeLike
Yup.
LikeLike
I think we are too busy being outraged by the sexual harassment sideshow. It just would not be politically correct to worry about how we all are going to be raped if the tax bill passes. I don’t mean to dismiss the seriousness of the sexual harassment charges, but I have a feeling that we are being very successfully being manipulated.
LikeLike
speduktr
Pretty much .
LikeLike
Wondering if Dem legislators are sitting back & waiting for this to play out… Say Reps have to cut deals in Senate to make this happen, raising projected debt even higher… Regardless even as is, triggers immediate huge cut in Medicare, wipes out next yr’s farm subsidies… So they’d have to get 60 votes to override the sequester, bye bye quickie end-of-yr win for Reps/ donors (& maybe failure)… Meanwhile all Dems can do anyway is quietly ensure not a single defection…
But if you’re referring to lack of outrage of the ave Dem voter, I suspect a large proportion aren’t even aware of enforced program cuts triggered by projected debt. Media assist would be welcome! Curse the timing of the ratings-attractive sexual-assault catharsis!!
LikeLike
This ain’t Kansas Bethree .
This is NY . In a NY minute, you should be able to put 10,000 on the street between students, labor and Civil rights groups. .Without visible protest this is sailing through . Amazing how quickly occupy changed the narrative to income inequality in 2011. Just in time for Obama to Jump on board and run to Osawatomie Kansas as the reincarnation of Teddy Roosevelt, A born again populist, at least till the election was over.
As for the Democrats who says they want to prevent the corporate tax break . 9 of them just voted with Republicans to gut Dodd Frank . So much for the filibuster . If they needed 12 rest assured they would be there. It is a dog and pony show. The American people pay the price.
LikeLike
Rolling Stone: Taibbi: New Tax Plan Contains Even More Bad News for Student Borrowers!
The headline in the New York Times seemed sympathetic: “The House Just Voted To Bankrupt Graduate Students”.
The piece by Erin Rousseau, a graduate student at M.I.T., detailed an insidious little virus buried in the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, just passed by Republicans in the House. The law would repeal section 117(d)(5) of the tax code, which exempts graduate students’ tuition waiver from taxation.
In the case of M.I.T. grad students like Rousseau – who work as teachers or lab assistants – the new law would tax over $50,000 of tuition they don’t actually pay. It would increase such students’ taxable income from the area of $33,000 to over $80,000. In most cases, that would add about $10,000 to their annual tax burden.
http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/taibbi-new-tax-plan-contains-more-bad-news-for-student-borrowers-w512423?utm_source=email
LikeLike
“Shocks the conscience” is the legal term for t.
LikeLike
Good lord! & the anti-ed rwnj rabble just eating it up no doubt. Do the .01% beneficiaries of this bill have sufficient brainiacs in the family to carry forward the US STEM brain trust? You know, close the skills gap (etc) Gates et al talking points for CCSS, draconian accountability policy etc? Oops! Looks like conservative policies are getting a little too transparent– your slip is showing Reps 😉
LikeLike
What kills me is the people who say they are sick of NYS getting a tax break by not paying taxes on their local and state taxes (a tax on a tax).
The reality is that even with that “tax break” the residents of NYS pay more in income taxes than they receive back from the Federal Government so we are really supporting those states who are doing the loudest complaining.
I figure that if this tax plan goes through my taxes will go up between 2 to 3,000 dollars on top of the $6000+ I already pay. So much for supporting the middle class.
LikeLike
Ditto flo56, we are going to be hit hard by this if it gets through (I’m in NJ)– plus a few more thou on our hi prop taxes even if 10k cap is passed. A real kick in the teeth, hubby needs to retire next yr (already overdue), this forces downsizing sooner than we’re ready, cuts ability to fix up to get best sale price, sure to impact home-sale prices downward– a lot of repercussions for us. And yet we are one of the biggest donor states to the conservative states voting this in. These so-called constitutionalists should read the history on why this double-taxing has never been done in all the yrs of taxing. Highly divisive, bad for the way a union of states needs to operate.
LikeLike
Good grief. The ‘tax break’ for the wealthy and now this garbage. It never ends. This was posted on an email from the White House.
…………..
GOP includes money for Trump’s border wall in Senate spending bill
By Stephen Dinan – The Washington Times – Tuesday, November 21, 2017
Senate Republicans included $1.6 billion for the first installment of President Trump’s border wall in the new homeland security spending bill they released Tuesday, keeping the president’s marquee immigration promise on track.
While avoiding the term “wall,” the Senate bill calls for $1.6 billion in funding for “physical barriers” and border roads — matching Mr. Trump’s original request for money to build or repair fencing along 74 more miles of the U.S.-Mexico line.
The homeland security measure is one of a series of spending bills the GOP released Tuesday as they geared up for an end-of-year battle over 2018 funding.
“This legislation will help enhance border security, provide relief from natural disasters, and help adapt to evolving threats against our country,” said Sen. John Boozman, Arkansas Republican and chairman of the subcommittee that oversees homeland security money…
Link: https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/nov/21/gop-includes-money-trumps-border-wall-senate-bill/?utm_campaign=shareaholic&utm_medium=email_this&utm_source=email
LikeLike
I’m hoping that people become aware of the damage this ‘tax reform’ will do, and act on it to call or email their Senators. This bill is a tragedy waiting to happen. Why is it responsible government to cut essential services so that the wealthy can get bigger tax breaks? Makes no sense to me.
…………………
States Warn of Budget Crunch Under Republican Tax Plan
Some state officials say the $1.5 trillion tax cut moving through Congress would raise taxes on residents and force tough decisions at the local level …
“Most states are not in a position to lower taxes in response to the federal tax increase due to tepid revenue growth and ongoing spending pressures,” analysts at Fitch said.
In Oregon, which has one of the highest state income tax rates in the country, roughly 30 percent of taxpayers would see their federal tax bills increase by an average of $573 with a full repeal of the state and local tax deduction, according to Oregon’s legislative revenue office.
Source: http://us.pressfrom.com/news/us/-101688-states-warn-of-budget-crunch-under-republican-tax-plan/
LikeLike
Quote from article: “We should focus on bringing down costs and offering consumers more options through more vibrant market competition. In the meantime, we can offer Americans tax relief through repeal of Obamacare’s misguided and unproductive individual mandate. [Washington Examiner, 11/15/17]”
……….
Right. We can start finding out exactly what each insurance company is covering and how much they charge for every disease possible. Then we need to predict which of those diseases we will get and then determine which insurance company offers the best rate. This is ‘market competition’.
It is essential that you only get the diseases or illnesses that are totally covered by your insurance company. If you get something outside that range, you’ll be screwed.
Also, don’t have any pre-existing conditions. Getting a rash when you are a teenager most likely will disqualify you for cancer treatment when you are in your 50’s. So, don’t ever get anything requiring medical attention when you are young.
………………………….
4 Ways Right-Wing Media Are Shilling for Tax Reform (and Why They’re Wrong) @alternet
Right-wing media have been relying on debunked myths and partisan spin in order to defend the Republican tax overhaul efforts, which have passed in the House of Representatives and advanced in the Senate. Conservative media figures are pushing falsehoods about the corporate tax rate and the impact the proposals would have on the wealthiest Americans while downplaying the negative impacts of repealing the Affordable Care Act’s individual mandate….
http://www.alternet.org/media/4-ways-right-wing-media-are-shilling-tax-reform-and-why-theyre-wrong#.WhbP4QkVztE.gmail
LikeLike
Well, in case you haven’t seen it: the new tax bill also proposes taxes on higher education related expenses, such as
Graduate student tuition wavers will be taxable.
Tuition discounts of the children of university employees will be taxable.
Interest on student loans will not be tax deductable.
This is the flier the TN state Campus Workers’ Union distributed on this.
LikeLike
This plan would continue the general post-war trend of shifting America’s tax burden from the wealthy onto everybody else.
LikeLike