Dana Milbank, a regular writer for the Washington Post, writes that the Jews who serve Trump have covered themselves in shame. While rabbis and Jewish organizations have unequivocally condemned the Nazi-KKK rally in Charlottesville, Trump says that there were “many fine people” marching with the Nazis.
This was a time when his Jewish relatives and cabinet members should have disagreed. Even James Murdoch, heir to the FOX News empire, called Trump out. His wife Kathryn regularly tweets anti-Trump messages.
But not Kushner, Cohn, or Mnuchin.
Most Jews have learned from history that when any minority is singled out for oppression, Jews are next. Except when they are first.
Don’t ask for whom the bell tolls. It tolls for you.
Milbank writes:
“What Gary Cohn, Steven Mnuchin and Jared Kushner did this week — or, rather, what they didn’t do — is a shanda.
“They’ll know what that means, but, for the uninitiated, shanda is Yiddish for shame, disgrace. The three men, the most prominent Jews in President Trump’s administration, could have spoken out to say that those who march with neo-Nazis are not “very fine people,” as their boss claims. Mnuchin, the treasury secretary, and Cohn, the chief economic adviser, were actually standing with Trump when he said it. They said nothing.
“All three let it be known through anonymous friends and colleagues that they are disturbed and distressed by what Trump said — Kushner even got out word that he and his wife, Ivanka Trump, had counseled Trump otherwise — but none is speaking publicly about an outrage that makes millions of Americans feel as though they are living a nightmare.
“We have seen such a character before in Jewish history: the shtadlan. The shtadlan , or “court Jew,” existed to please the king, to placate the king, to loan money to the king. He would dress like other members of the court, and he would beg the king for leniency toward the Jews, but, ultimately, his loyalty was to the king….
“Certainly, Cohn, Mnuchin and Kushner have a particular obligation as Jews, because the violent white supremacists in Charlottesville were targeting Jews with their swastikas and chants of “Jews will not replace us” and “Sieg Heil.” One of their leaders told “Vice News Tonight” it was objectionable that Trump would “give his daughter to a Jew.” A few stood outside a synagogue brandishing rifles, forcing Sabbath worshipers to slip out a back door.
“But Jews, because of our recent history, know what results from silence in the face of any type of bigotry. Before Trump dabbled in anti-Semitism, he made scapegoats of immigrants, African Americans, Latinos and, especially, Muslims. Two years ago, when I described the many actions that made candidate Trump a bigot and a racist, I noted that he hadn’t yet gone after Jews. That followed soon: the tweeted image of a Star of David atop paper money, and the speech and ads linking Jews to a secret “global power structure.”
“This racist demagoguery now comes from the president of the United States. In tweets Thursday, Trump proclaimed his sadness at the removal of “our beautiful” Confederate statues, and he revived the bogus claim that, a century ago, Gen. John J. Pershing dipped bullets in pig blood before shooting Muslim prisoners.
“Why is it so hard to condemn such filth? David Shulkin did. Trump’s Veterans Affairs secretary, who is Jewish (and an Obama administration holdover), said what needed to be said: “I do feel like as an American and as a member of the Cabinet, that I can speak for my own personal opinions on this, and I am outraged by the behavior that I have seen with the Nazis and the white supremacists.”
“Shulkin said he will continue to speak. “Staying silent on these issues is not acceptable,” he said.
“Veterans Affairs Secretary David Shulkin on Aug. 16 said “it is a dishonor to our country’s veterans to allow the Nazis and the white supremacists to go unchallenged.” (The Washington Post)
“Amen.
“Even the rabbi who oversaw Ivanka Trump’s conversion, Haskel Lookstein, joined in a statement saying he was “deeply troubled by the moral equivalency and equivocation President Trump has offered.”
“Amen.
“Even Sheldon Adelson’s Republican Jewish Coalition called for “greater moral clarity” from Trump, saying “there are no good Nazis.”
“Amen.
“As I write this, my 13-year-old has come into my office and said the neo-Nazis at the Charlottesville synagogue make her reluctant to return to Hebrew school. She also asks if our family will be a target because people know I’m Jewish.
“This is what Trump has done to America. And this is what Cohn, Mnuchin and Kushner allow with their shameful silence.
“Do they prize their appointments so much? Well then, don’t quit. Speak out. Let him fire you. But don’t play the court Jew.”

This happens so often. They sell their soul for $$$$$.
LikeLike
Some sell their souls for $$$$
Others, never.
LikeLike
They are the ‘kapos’ of Trump’s bigotry.
It is suggested by the world of finance that Cohn wants to be appointed chief of the FED…and that is why he is hanging in…but his creds with the Jewish community are finished…same goes for Mnuchin who already is hated for his role in Indy Mac/One West and bringing down the entire economy in 2008. Greed knows no bounds.
LikeLike
Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, 54, married his 36-year-old fiancée Louise Linton in front of a stunning list of Washington insiders and Wall Street elite.
Its his 3rd marriage, her second. Who says money can’t buy happiness?
LikeLike
This does happen often, if you are speaking of politicians generally. But members of all faiths sell their souls for money not just the atheists.
LikeLike
What? Atheists “sell their souls”? Surely you are not that uniformed about the great people of history who are and were atheists.
LikeLike
DA,
Do atheists think they have souls, for sale or not? Thank you.
Loved your professional talks for Newark reading specialists in the 90s.
LikeLike
Here’s the results on this question from Debate.org.
56-percent said yes that atheists think they have souls, and does it matter?
“There is no yes or no answer really, some do, some may not.
“I believe your soul is simply who you are. As an atheist I believe we will never know what happens after death until we truly are there. But every person is different in his or her own way.”
http://www.debate.org/opinions/do-atheists-believe-they-have-a-soul
My take on that question: One does not have to belong to a religion to have a soul or believe they have a soul. If you don’t think you have a soul but you do, then who cares.
Religion does not own the copyright on souls.
For instance, long before Christianity and Islam, “In the Republic, Plato introduces a new understanding of the human soul. The soul now has three parts: “reason” (λογιστικὸν) “spirit” (θυμοειδές), and “appetite (ἐπιθυμητικόν).” All parts of the soul have desires, but desire in appetitive and spirited parts is not a matter of belief about what is good and what is bad.”
Anyone interested might want to read what the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy says about Ancient Theories of Soul.
“The Homeric poems, with which most ancient writers can safely be assumed to be intimately familiar, use the word ‘soul’ in two distinguishable, probably related, ways. The soul is, on the one hand, something that a human being risks in battle and loses in death. On the other hand, it is what at the time of death departs from the person’s limbs and travels to the underworld, where it has a more or less pitiful afterlife as a shade or image of the deceased person.” …
“Several significant developments occurred in the ways Greeks thought and spoke about the soul in the sixth and fifth centuries. The questions about the soul that are formulated and discussed in the writings of Plato and Aristotle to some extent arise from, and need to be interpreted against the background of, these sixth and fifth century developments.”
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ancient-soul/#1
I know at least one person (him being a person is also questionable) that doesn’t have a soul or doesn’t care. He made a deal with the devil decades ago, and his name is Donald Trump.
The Greeks were discussing the soul more than 600 years before the birth of Jesus Christ and more than 900 years before Emperor Constantine made Christianity legal throughout the Roman Empire and more than a 1,000 years before Muhammad was born in Mecca.
LikeLike
Thank you Lloyd for your scholarly reply. I am quite certain, though in the end it is all speculation, that Tommy Jefferson, Richard Dawkins, and you and I have souls. I base that in part on our “reason, spirit, and appetite” which you have defined historically/philosophically.
Reiterate, the chutzpah of unreasoned and unreasonable religious ideologues and dogmatists in thinking they have spoken in person to some heavenly voice that they choose to guide them.
Hearing voices in the opinion of science, is called schizophrenia.
LikeLike
What if the voice you hear, is your own inner voice?
LikeLike
That would be your conscience,Lloyd…and we atheists have strong consciences that keep us on the right path. Can’t say as much for religious ideologues.
LikeLike
My take is that atheists can’t ask a God they don’t believe in to forgive their sins so it is best to avoid armed robbery, theft, fraud, cheating on your mate, and lies, etc.
But most if not all organized religions offer an out for their sinners. All you have to do is ask God for forgiveness repeatedly on a daily or weekly basis, and to Christians, Christ forgives you every time.
As an infant, I was baptized Catholic and then started out in a Catholic school where we could be forgiven every week for our sins and then repeat those sins and add more and still be forgiven on a weekly basis. After all, to Catholics and probably all Christians, Jesus Christ died for their sins and is still suffering every time one of his follower’s sins and they sin a lot, because they think they are going to be forgiven, again, and again, and again.
For instance, my father had an affair with my Godmother while my Godmother’s husband had endless affairs and mistresses he picked up in bars, but all those sins were forgiven every week. My dad also kept his cheating from my mother who probably knew but was in denial.
Want to be a sinner and be forgiven, join a religion that offers regular forgiveness. Is that a form of religious insurance if you donate weekly on Sundays after you confess all your weekly sins?
LikeLike
An equally good editorial in the Times
LikeLike
Where is Bloomberg in all of this?
Too many prominent Jews have sold themselves to the devil. . . . not at all because they are Jewish but because they are plutocrats and only interested in money and power. They are not the only ones. Many from every faith and ethnicity has done the same because it’s not about the color of your skin. The only color, as MLK predicted, is green and it’s the color to be concerned about because it s the color of money.
Shame on anyone who does not speak out against Trump and should be doing so! In fact, more than shame! A curse upon them and their houses, to cite an old Shakespearean quote.
LikeLike
That is the least of the issues . If it were only the Jews on Wall Street it would be a much smaller problem. The Arab Israeli conflict has created a rt wing mainly Orthodox Jewish community where Liberal Jews once were overwhelmingly dominate. They are still dominant but that rt wing community is vocal. Not good for American Jews or the future of Israel in the long run .
A re-post
http://www.thedailybeast.com/why-trumps-jewish-backers-love-the-alt-right
LikeLike
The right wing Orthodox faction will increasingly dominate American Jewish discourse due to their high birth rates and low levels of assimilation. Most Jews in this country identify as “just Jewish” and synagogue affiliation is declining.
LikeLike
Following right along with this strain…it appears throughout history, and is a truism today, that odious intrenched religious ideologues of all faiths are the problem…not just the Jewish extreme Right.
See the inquisition, the auto de fe, the Crusades, the Muslims, on and on. Do not paint just one religion with this tainted brush…it is the reason many fair minded and intelligent people choose to be atheists.
LikeLike
Ellen Lubic
As you know Ellen no argument from me on any of your points. One of my favorite Jefferson quotes
“your sect by it’s sufferings has furnished a remarkable proof of the universal spirit of religious intolerance, inherent in every sect, disclaimed by all while feeble, and practised by all when in power. Our laws have applied the only antidote to this vice, protecting our religious, as they do our civil rights by putting all on an equal footing, but more remains to be done…”
He may have gotten slavery wrong but he sure got religion right.
LikeLike
The color of money also caused Trump to harm another people: American Indians, who are so often left out of these conversations. After taking office, Trump immediately approved the Dakota Access Pipeline, against the rights and health and self-determination of the Standing Rock Sioux tribe in North Dakota. Oil leaking into their river is not a matter of if, but a matter of when.
LikeLike
Mnuchin went so far as to defend Trump:
from a retweet by Ted Lieu
“Third, as someone who is Jewish, I believe I understand the long history of violence and hatred against the Jews (and other minorities) and circumstances that give rise to these sentiments and actions. While I find it hard to believe that I should have to defend myself on this, or the president, I feel compelled to let you know that the president in no way, shape or form believes that neo-Nazi and other hate groups who endorse violence are equivalent to groups that demonstrate in peaceful and lawful ways.”
LikeLike
Some months ago a writer in the Forward referred to Jared Kusher as the Trump administration’s “court Jew.” I thought that was a devastating critique, and perhaps unnecessarily harsh. It looks as if it wasn’t. I think everyone who works for Trump needs to have a real soul-searching session with himself/herself. On a purely pragmatic level, working for 45 may not be a great career move. Ethically, it is a “disaster,” as somebody likes to say.
LikeLike
I would prefer the term “kapo,” who were the overseers in the concentration camps. They were prisoners who were given special privileges to keep the others in line. Jewish kapos were often more brutal than the camp guards. Thinking they were saving themselves, they were invariably killed when their usefulness lagged. Many were killed by fellow prisoners.
LikeLike
Sorry Ellen, I missed your comment above.
LikeLike
No problem, Greg…we are usually on the same page.
LikeLike
The Kapos were also eventually murdered by the Nazis; their collaboration merely postponed the inevitable. Those who were killed by inmates after the liberation of the camps were those who hadn’t yet been murdered by their jailer bosses.
Perhaps something for Kushner, Cohn, Mnuchin, et.al. to consider.
LikeLike
Add Stephen Miller to the mix. There is an article in a Jewish paper (I forget which one–we receive three & JUF News, as well) about how Miller divided his synagogue.
And–remember when DT said what a good girl Ivanka is–he listens to her, because “she always pushes me to do the right thing?” Yeah? Where is she now? Even her not Jewish stepmother issued a statement (before her dad). &–sorry to be judgemental–but I cringed when I saw a clip of her husband placing his hand on her behind (Orthodox men do not touch women, & certainly not that body part!). Not to mention her many tight &/or short dresses & skirts. NOT Orthodox.
Nevertheless, worst of all is the couple’s deafening…silence.
LikeLike
For some weeks now, the Kushners have avoided the heat by going on vacation…which is costing we taxpayers a fortune to guard them as they ski, swim, and surf, dine sumptuously, and lead their privileged lives.
LikeLike
Ellen,
It must be exhausting to stay on vacation for months at a time, avoiding the media, especially when you have been asked to settle the Middle East conflicts.
LikeLike
Just pray you get to pay for his jail cell, for a long long time.
LikeLike
Stephen Miller can’t be Jewish. He is not even human. He’s an assemblage of body parts, missing a heart.
LikeLike
And, as the comedian said, Miller physically resembles a Minion cartoon character.
LikeLike
Frankly, Miller gives me the creeps almost as much as Trump himself.
LikeLike
How long before Fake President Trump fires Veterans Affairs Secretary David Shulkin?
LikeLike
Here’s part of what I think is the right way to respond to the orange supremacist’s hateful Charlottesville intransigence from my favorite fellow Jew, Jon Stewart:
(caution: appropriately foul language)
http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/news/jon-stewart-talks-charlottesville-trump-at-chappelle-show-w498454.
LikeLike
And if you want the full bootleg transcript:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=dxY1DayUcIs
LikeLike
It’s funny because “everyone likes a good Shitler joke.”
LikeLike
LCT: I love Jon Stewart.
I notice that Trump wondered why Jon changed his name.
Why did Trump change his, which was Drumpf.
LikeLike
Someone should inform The Donald that his grandfather changed his name to seem more American before leaving Germany. Oh yeah, that’s right, his ancestors didn’t get here on the Mayflower, and German immigrants like his grandfather had to try hard to fit in because they were — drumroll please –immigrants! Donald needs to build a wall across the Atlantic and make Germany pay for it.
LikeLike
Diane…were you to meet Left Coast Teacher, you would love him too. He is a terrific person and a stellar teacher.
LikeLike
40,000 anti fascists in Boston yesterday . To 24 Nazis/ shit heads is more powerful than art . Most of the few arrests occurred when police attempted to clear a road to get the scum out . I wonder how polite they were when they did it. From my few experience with occupy I found that us Lefties are more than willing to follow police instructions until things get closed down for no apparent reason and force is used. At which point most disperse but there are always a few who do not mind spending the night in jail .
LikeLike