Nancy E. Bailey was there at the beginning, when Florida first embarked on a voucher program for students with disabilities. Now that program is recognized as the Official Camel’s Nose Under the Tent, the entry program that in many other states is followed by vouchers for foster children, vouchers for military children, vouchers for low-income children, then vouchers for everyone. Florida has not been able to build out vouchers because voters turned them down in a 2012 referendum, and the state courts rejected Jeb Bush’s effort to pass a voucher program because it was contrary to the state constitution.
Bailey discovered that the person who pushed the program through was uncredentialed. She expressed great concern for children with disabilities, but she had no experience or training.
She writes:
This is… about eliminating real options parents have with students who have disabilities. Starving public schools where teachers must abide by IDEA mandates, but are incapable of enforcing them due to inadequate funding, is unethical and cruel.
With McKay vouchers, parents flee to schools with no proof of success. How many parents are conned into believing such schools will provide the positive changes their child deserves and that they so desperately seek? Without oversight and rules no one knows—until it’s too late.
Bear in mind that Florida is Betsy DeVos’s model state for charters of every variety, vouchers, tax credits, online schools, and every imaginable way to break down public schools.

This is an equity issue that should be addressed by filing lawsuits. If states can abrogate their responsibility to abide by IDEA requirements, many states would be inclined to off load classified students into unregulated schools with uncertified staff members in order to save money. Why should they be allowed to circumvent IDEA? Parents should have to be informed if their child is no longer covered by IDEA laws If charters receive public money, they should have to abide by the same laws that the public schools do.
LikeLike
Crossposted at OEN,
https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/How-Florida-Developed-Its-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Children_Diane-Ravitch_Disabilities_Education-Vouchers-170529-396.html#comment660469
with comments that have links back to this blog
LikeLike
You end up feeling sorry for kids in Florida’s public schools, I swear. They do nothing else down there but promote charters and vouchers.
When’s the last time you read about some FL politician doing something for the public schools in that state?
I saw a map the other day of the percentage of kids in charters and vouchers and they are absolutely dwarfed by the number of kids in public schools, but you’d never know it listening to these people.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is getting harder and harder to find ANY politician doing something postive to promote public schools…
LikeLike
That is because many (not all) politicians have abandoned public schools, at least for their own children. In the USA, and the UK, more politicians send their own children to private (fee-paying) schools, than the general public (per-capita).
see
https://www.theguardian.com/education/2016/feb/16/politicians-send-children-private-schools-cameron
That is why I have supported, for a long time, a “slumlord” law, that would force politicians to send their own children to a government-run public school. Politicians would then be forced to ensure that schools had adequate funding, and adequate class size, etc.
LikeLiked by 1 person