The Washington Post reports from a town in the Louisiana Delta.
VACHERIE, La. — At the new public charter school in this Mississippi River town, nearly all the students are African American. Parents seem unconcerned about that. They just hope their children will get a better education.
“I wanted my girls to soar higher,” said Alfreda Cooper, who is black and has two daughters at Greater Grace Charter Academy.
Three hours up the road, students at Delta Charter School in Concordia Parish are overwhelmingly white, even though the surrounding community is far more mixed.
As the charter school movement accelerates across the country, a critical question remains unanswered: whether the creation of charters is accelerating school segregation. Federal judges who oversee desegregation plans in Louisiana are wrestling with that issue at a time when President Trump wants to spend billions of dollars on charter schools, vouchers and other “school choice” initiatives.
In February, a judge found that Delta Charter had violated the terms of the parish’s court-ordered desegregation plan and asked the parties to submit proposals for how to move forward. The local school board in Concordia not only is seeking reimbursement of millions of dollars, but also wants the judge to require the charter school to cancel its enrollment and start over with the aim of creating a more diverse student body. That would include offering transportation to the school — something that could make it possible for more black students to attend.
The nation’s schools have become more segregated by race and class over the past two decades, according to federal data, and some research indicates that charter schools are more likely to be segregated than traditional public schools. Some charter advocates say they are more interested in creating good schools for marginalized children as quickly as possible — no matter the consequences for the racial makeup of enrollment.
Choice gives Southern whites the opportunity to restore racial segregation without saying so openly.
The great retreat from the goal of desegregation is underway, rolling back advances wherever they occurred, and charter operators are more than willing to lure students who are all black or all white. Charters are the new segregation academies.
As an aside, the article cites Urban Prep Academy as a charter in Chicago where 100% of students graduate and enroll in college. This is a myth that was exploded by Gary Rubinstein years ago. Urban Prep has high attrition and its students have lower test scores than students in Chicago’s public schools.

“As the charter school movement accelerates across the country, a critical question remains unanswered: whether the creation of charters is accelerating school segregation.”
What do you mean that question remains unanswered? It’s been answered resoundingly in the affirmative.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education.
LikeLike
There seems to be a convergence of realization about what is happening with Charters and segregation. In spite of, or maybe because of the serious complexity of this new study from Georgia, I am getting fewer five word insults than in my usual posts in St. Louis, where I am restricted to current affairs forum by the Post Dispatch—not allowed to comment on stories….200 views on this one—which helps dismantle the false history routinely offered about the takeover a decade ago on behalf of opening more charters. http://interact.stltoday.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=1219821 part of Nicholas J. Eastman’s table of contents….this is his doctoral thesis:
Stephen Ball’s Contributions to Critical Policy Analysis……………………………………………………119
St. Louis and the Spatio-Temporal Turn in Critical Policy Analysis ……………………………………131
4. FROM DESEGREGATION TO DISPOSSESSION……………………………………………………..161
The Deep Roots of Segregated Schooling in St. Louis……………………………………………………….165
Housing Segregation in St. Louis ……………………………………………………………………………………169
The Rise and Fall of Desegregation in St. Louis Public Schools …………………………………………184
SB 781 and the Neoliberalization of Education Policy ………………………………………………………193
Urban Neoliberalization and Accumulation by Dispossession…………………………………………….198
I asked Jeff Bryant to look it over, as well as Peter Downs….I hope you do, too, Diane.
I am going to fit links to your posts about Louisiana, and your New Republic article on DeVos into my thread.
LikeLike
Your statement: “Choice gives Southern whites the opportunity to restore racial segregation without saying so openly.” TRUE!
This is the mistake that so many have made.
It’s like: “Aloha Spirit” — words, which enslaved an entire population.
LikeLike
“So many” didn’t make a mistake. The intent of the big money has been achieved. Their goal is America under colonialism. It doesn’t get any plainer than Fryer’s prescription for two-tier education with the bottom tier “tested everyday”, profiting the tech industry and Wall Street. Fryer’s c.v. has huge amounts in grants from foundations, like Gates.
LikeLike
Racist Gov. Talmadge of Georgia first proposed privatization. His plan was to avoid school integration court rulings.
LikeLike
This is funny:
“Del Sesto Middle School staff and Providence school officials expected visitors to stop by and take a look at their work with personalized learning in real time but it was a huge surprise when THE Marc Zuckerberg and his wife Priscilla Chan walked in. (They were expecting representatives of the organization, not the head honchos!)
Zuckerberg was in his trademark jeans and a sweatshirt for the surprise visit. After their tour meeting students and visiting classrooms, the Facebook founder and his wife had a meeting with Governor Raimondo.”
Ed reformers peddle ed tech product constantly, but of course public schools will be the biggest buyers of these products because most kids attend public schools.
I was wondering when the ed tech industry would figure that out- that public schools are actually their biggest customers so it’s probably not wise to join with ed reformers to bash public schools.
Looks like Zuckerberg is a little smarter than the rest of them 🙂
I wonder if it makes a difference that his wife went to a public school. It’s apparently a rare thing these days among the higher classes 🙂
LikeLike
Gov. Raimondo, friend of hedge funds, destroyer of pensions.
LikeLike
The 74Million website has published a three part “case” for charter school survival in an era of choice. The author is a shill for 50Can in New York and several other states.
He correctly sees that charters were endorsed and supported by Democrats and Republicans. He also thinks that continued charter school growth depends on populating suburban districts. I think that his case is built on the belief segregation by race and class already present in suburban communities will and should provide the new fertile ground for scaling up. The “civil rights” argument for charters is not really needed.
The writer sees that NAACP is no longer buying the conventional civil rights and political argument for charters based on saving mostly black and brown children in low income neighborhoods and failing schools. He seems to think charter school expansion hinges on the same combination of race and social class, but marketed more aggressively in suburban districts.
This is a three-part promotion from the same folks who have always supported charters and choice.
https://www.the74million.org/article/bradford-the-politics-partisanship-of-americas-education-reform-debate-time-for-a-suburban-strategy
LikeLike
Here’s an piece ed reformers are promoting today. It’s from the Wall Street Journal.
I’ll summarize for you: “public schools suck and charter schools are awesome”
https://www.wsj.com/articles/los-angeles-charter-uprising-1495403794?utm_source=RC+Education+Today&utm_campaign=76ceb3cbe1-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2017_05_22&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_8a051b373b-76ceb3cbe1-85140157
This sort of blatantly political bashing of public schools and promotion of charter schools is all over ed reform. They ALL do it.
I don’t have any problem with ed reformers preferring charter and private schools over public schools. It’s an opinion. They really do have to stop flim-flamming people with this “agnostic” BS though. It simply isn’t true that they support public schools. They don’t.
LikeLike
The Gates-funded Hechinger Report can’t shower enough praise on charter schools. Suggested title for a new article, “Charter Schools Walk Next to God”.
LikeLike
You really have to read this stuff to believe it.
DeVos uses four examples in her speech. Two are private school students, who are “excelling”. Two are public school students who of course, failed because according to this publicly-funded propaganda she’s pushing, all public school students fail.
This is what passes for a work day at the US Department of Education. A speech devoted to trashing public schools and the students who attend public schools.
We’re all paying hundreds of public employees to run around the country bashing public schools. Can’t they find something productive to do?
https://www.ed.gov/news/speeches/prepared-remarks-us-secretary-education-betsy-devos-american-federation-childrens-national-policy-summit
LikeLike
Given more resources, groups like NPE could follow along countering the false narrative. It’s a shame we pay taxes for DeVos’ government to harm our communities. And, it’s a shame our politicians serve the ed oligarchs against us.
LikeLike