This article was written by An Garagiola-Bernier and published in the Washington Post.
She had a difficult life, growing up in a low-income home, dropping out of high school to help pay expenses, then suffering a debilitating disease that made it impossible to work and required multiple surgeries. She relied on charity to get by, but eventually enrolled in a community college. She made it to Hamline University, where she has a scholarship awarded by the John Kent Cooke Foundation. But she could not have made it to where she is today without the help of multiple federal assistance programs for low-income students like her. Those programs are now jeopardized by the proposed budget cuts.
She writes:
President Trump and Education Secretary Betsy DeVos never had to worry about the cost of a college education for themselves or their children. They never had to skip meals because they couldn’t afford to buy food. They never feared becoming homeless because they couldn’t afford a place to live.
Unfortunately, I — like millions of other low-income people — have had these worries. Not because we are lazy, ignored our school work or are not very bright. We simply didn’t have the good fortune of Trump and DeVos to be born into wealthy families. Many of us have had other bad breaks as well.
In my own case, I dropped out of high school to work at a low-wage job to help my mother pay mounting bills. Later, I was stricken with a disease called Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome that made it impossible for me to work for seven years and required me to undergo 12 surgeries, leaving me and my husband struggling to get by with our three children. I turned to a charity to pay my enormous medical bills. Disabled, with little education, my employment opportunities were dismal.
Fortunately, I found my way to community college and then transferred to Hamline University in St. Paul, Minn., where I am now a student. My life was transformed when I received a Jack Kent Cooke Foundation Undergraduate Transfer Scholarship that provides me with up to $40,000 a year for my education at Hamline. But most low-income students aren’t as lucky.
I resumed my education after many years out of school because, like the vast majority of low-income students, I want to make something of myself, get a good job and leave poverty behind. I am told the best way to do this is to get an education beyond high school.
But instead of helping us to further our educations, President Trump recently proposed his “America First” budget that calls for a 13 percent cut in the Education Department budget, amounting to $9 billion.
In higher education, Trump has proposed taking $3.9 billion in surplus funds from Pell Grants for low-income students to use for other parts of government; $200 million in cuts to other programs that help low-income students pay for and succeed in college; cuts to the Federal Work-Study program that pays students to hold part-time jobs; and elimination of the Supplemental Education Opportunity Grants for low-income students.
Two particularly effective programs that prepare low-income students for college and help them graduate would be hit hard — one called GEAR-UP (the acronym stands for Gaining Early Awareness and Readiness for Undergraduate Programs) would be eliminated, and a group of programs called TRIO would be cut. TRIO got its name from three initiatives that date to the 1960s.
How can Trump “make America great again” by denying access to higher education to those students who are low-income?
How is he “putting America first” if he closes the doors of opportunity to those who were not born rich like him?

I had an opportunity to listen to Senator Lindsey Graham talk about how he lifted himself up and became the Senator from SC he is today. He said both his parents died before he began college.
But he failed to say his social security benefits (based on the death of his parents), at that time, continued through age 21 and that full-time tuition at a flagship state college in SC was roughly $287.00 per semester and $596.00 per semester, if you lived in a dorm (no food plan). This included University provide healthcare.
Back then it was easy to self-fund college on social security benefits and summer and part-time jobs. I know I did it, too. I earned $20.00- 30.00 per day waiting tables during the breakfast shift at Howard Johnson. My University even held my check for several weeks at that time. (My father was killed in Vietnam so I also had $330.00 per month VA but they paid really late during the semester). My husband also self-funded working a work study job and obtaining student loans. He left college as a chemical engineer with a $55.00 per month student loan.
He could not have done it today. Nor could I. Nor could my husband. It amazes me the disconnect of our politicians with the plight of our young people today. Comparing his experience of “lifting himself up by his bootstraps” with what our kids face today is ludicrous.
LikeLike
Disconnect implies that they do not know or care . It is far more sinister.
LikeLike
“The Lindsey Graham Story”
If I can do it, anyone can
I ate out of a garbage can
Now I spew it every day
Tons of garbage thrown your way
LikeLike
Without S.S. and a public university, Paul Ryan wouldn’t be sitting where he is, either. The fraud of political hypocrisy destroys people and jeopardizes the future of their nation.
LikeLike
Thank you for sharing that story, Sandra. Very compelling and true.
LikeLike
The myth of the “self made man” has to go the way of the dodo bird. NOBODY can do / does it alone.
LikeLike
I know I am just repeating things you already know Diane, but they do not have a grasp of the big picture. Getting people into colleges and higher education is how you build a middle class and break the cycle of poverty. This is what makes America strong. Plus dead dinosaurs are not recyclable, when they are gone, they are gone! So taking money out of education and channeling it into the fossil fuel industry, for example, is the opposite of making us strong. It is just getting it all now, as fast and as much as possible, to hell with future generations! Another note, if I might, people like me need information we can use to educate ourselves, information you provide in your blogs. Now I am no professional, but I fact checked you as much as I knew how when I first followed you, even knowing your qualifications. They do not always mean what you would hope they mean! In your case, if my opinion is worth anything, you bore out magnificently. Sometimes I wish my email was not clogged up with so many offerings, but I read them all, and learn something every time. Mostly they point me in directions of investigation I would not have thought of on my own, so I thank you, your blogs absolutely do make a difference, even to the not so educated reader which I represent! I have a blog which is very mundane and poorly written, but I am practicing and learning! So thank you!
LikeLike
They understand the big picture. The Koch’s, Gates, and Walton heirs want to eliminate common goods.
The Bill Gates family lives in the state with the most regressive tax system in the nation. In the state of Washington, the poor pay a rate up to 7 times the rate the rich pay. Walmart’s headquarters are in the 2nd poorest state in the nation.
The goal is colonialism, characterized by two-tier structures, quality for the richest 0.1% and servitude for the rest. Gates said he read Pickety’s unassailable economic conclusions, which describe the future of concentrated wealth. (Sx Walton heirs have income equivalent to 40% of Americans combined and their share is growing.)
Gates neither refuted the evidence nor changed his direction. He is content with its outcome.
His kids, living the societal consequences, may not be.
LikeLike
Gates’ kids will be set for life. Already are.
If things get too bad here in the US they can always move to one of the island resorts that Gates undoubtedly already owns.
Or they can just live on the mammoth Gates family yacht.
There was a time in the past when the wealthy needed the rest of us to work in their factories and buy their stuff, but those days are long gone.
They simply don’t need us any more.
They can now do and say whatever they please.
They don’t care because they don’t HAVE to care.
LikeLike
Gates should be made a man without a country.
LikeLike
How about without an earth. Let’s send him to Mars or beyond.
LikeLike
Thank you for all you said, John.
Even worse than pouring billions into the fossil fuel industry is pouring billions more into the military. We have the greatest military in the world, and I am glad for their protection.
But the war we must win is the war of ideas by being a model of democracy, justice, opportunity, and decency.
If we slam shut the doors of opportunity to those not born with a silver spoon in their mouths, we are no model. And all the military in the world can’t protect us if we rot from within.
LikeLike
Other industrialized nations offer free or low cost college tuition supplemented by the state. Here we exploit our young people so they start out the beginning of their adult lives under water with student loans which, if not paid, will result if garnishment of their Social Security.
LikeLike
Trump’s budget works hand-in-glove with Gates’ most recent trespass into higher education- the Frontier Set program.
Organizations like the Association of Public and Land Grant Universities and American Association of State Colleges and, two state systems of higher education, as well as 31 colleges signed onto the program’s goal- to “create new institutional delivery systems”. We should have no doubt that the new “systems” will enrich the tech industry and Wall Street, at the expense of the middle class and poor.
The colonialism Gates imposed on K-12 is now being imposed on the system that Americans created and built as a quality alternative to the elite colleges with legacy admissions and unaffordable tuitions.
LikeLike
The public college/university system in the US is the envy of the world.
It’s no accident that so many foreigners choose to get degrees here and that most of them do so at the public colleges and universities.
The parasites on Wall Street WILL destroy the host (in this case the public university system) if they are allowed to do, just as they destroyed the lives of millions of home owners with their reckless and fraudulent practices.
These people suck the host dry until it is an empty shell and then move on to another host and repeat the process.
LikeLike
Linda,
Whatever Gates does in education turns to dross for students and teachers, to gold for the tech industry.
LikeLike
Yes.
LikeLike
Just for the curious, here is a link to the intended capture of public higher education by the Gates Foundation that Linda mentioned. I think that none of the people who have signed on to this venture understand that Trump has just made on-line learning a wild west for data gathering by Internet service providers. The whole discussion of privacy in this fact sheet and related materials is invalid. Trump and Congress eliminated the privacy law of the Obama administration on April 3, 2017.
https://www.google.com/#q=Gates+Foundation+Frontier+set
LikeLike
AND evidently Betsy DeVos is making it more difficult for students and paying off their student debt. Penny wise, pound foolish the Trump administration.
LikeLike
trump wants to: Make America GRATE by pretending that he is great.
LikeLike
How can Trump do this; how can the GOP’s leadership do this?
Easy, because they think that if you didn’t make it like they did, then you are a loser and deserve to suffer. It doesn’t matter that they were born into wealth because the psychopaths and malignant narcissists among them don’t even consider how they got where they are. They have convinced themselves they did it all on their own.
To them, winners don’t need help from the government because that help to losers who shouldn’t have such breaks costs wealthy taxpayers money they don’t want to share with anyone.
LikeLike