Peter Greene watched the first full performance of Betsy DeVos playing the role of Secretary of Education and characterizes her “mom with an axe.”
The first thing he notices is the DeVos Look, which he calls “church lady smirk….like it amuses her to imagine that all those Lessers are just having fits that she is this amazing. It is the look for which ‘supercilious’ was coined, and it’s not a good look on anyone, let alone a starched white heiress. Her Trump-approved minder should really help her with that.”
She pushes the idea that while other people believe in institutions and buildings, she believes in children! Got that, you building-huggers? Anyone who disagrees with her is promoting adult concerns, while she on the other hand, cares for children, in her selfless way. If only everyone chooses, without any regulation or oversight, everything will turn out for the best. It worked for her.
It won’t do to fix the schools we have, because Obama tried, he failed, and there’s no point throwing money at them. Ah, says Peter, strange to hear from a woman who throws millions at the schools and causes she does like.
When she and Whitehurst get to the question and answer, he asks some normal questions like, how do you measure the success of your policy of full frontal choice, and she coyly responds that she is not “a numbers person.” As long as parents have many choices, and they are free to choose, things will go swimmingly. Whitehurst asks, but what if academic outcomes get worse under your plan, and she answers, things are so terrible now that they can’t get worse.
Now, questions from the audience. Won’t unfettered choice promote segregation? Answer, of course not. Question, what if parents make bad choices, doesn’t the government have a role to protect them? Answer, parents don’t make bad choices. The free market always works. If parents choose a school, it must be good.
“This is another DeVosian mystery– the implication that public schools are operated by a bunch of lying liars, but charter and private school operators are somehow more virtuous? Or is the belief here that the Free Market somehow forces people to be honest or else they’ll be deselected. Does she believe that people won’t choose you if you’re a big fat liar, because I’m pretty sure DeVos is serving at the pleasure of the living embodiment, the walking proof that lying can actually be a great way to succeed in the Free Market.”
Performance over, curtain falls.
Something tells me this line of thought–if that’s what it is–will be repeated again and again, with an occasional new anecdote about a student who was saved by a voucher or whose life was blighted by a terrible public school.
As the Warner Brothers cartoon series “Looney Tunes” used to say at the end, “That’s all there is, folks.” Was that Daffy Duck or Porky Pig or Bugs Bunny?

Betsy Devos is a Looney Tune. She should be in a padded room wearing a straightjacket. For good measure, her mouth should be sealed with Duck Tape. No, that’s not good enough. Her mouth should be sewed and glued shut.
LikeLike
As one tweet (BELOW) put it, under Devos, Parents’ Night or Back to School Night would go like this;
“Good evening, parents. I’m your child’s Third Grade independent contractor.”
LikeLike
When she says that she is about the children and not the buildings, please do not get me started on the huge amount of fraud surrounding school buildings and real estate that has been done in the name of reform and privitazation.
LikeLike
Of course, teachers dedicate their lives to the buildings, not the children. That’s her idea. Not mine
LikeLike
Reading Peter Greene makes me really glad I never started my own education blog. He sure is good.
It’s clear DeVos and Company are just retreads on bad ideas that have already been proven wrong. It reminds me of how our culture these days relies so heavily on redoing stuff that we already know -for example, classic movies that are remade and/or expanded endlessly. (For example, back in December I went with my son to see the newest Star Wars. It was in one of those fancy cinemas with the reclining lounge seats….I had to fight to stay awake.)
Besty DeVos, Darth Vader, Dick Cheney, the Sith Lords, James Watt on and on and on. Didn’t we see all these characters before back in the 1980s? Every time I watch Mike Pence I keep thinking….doesn’t he look like one of the “bad hombres” who hangs out with Darth Vader? Yup, just looked it up. He’s that guy, “Grand Moff Tarkin”. https://timedotcom.files.wordpress.com/2016/12/grand-moff-tarkin1.jpg?quality=85
Something new is going to happen. Something new has GOT to happen. And, when it does, all these tired, worn out political retreads are going to look as goofy as those hair metal bands who were popular back in the Reagan era.
LikeLike
As Alan Greenspan famously admitted in testimony to Congress after the CEO cheating of clients and shareholders which led to the Great Recession of 2008
“I’ve found a flaw”
I’ve found a flaw
In righteousness
Of market law
That “choice is best”
Cuz CEO’s
Will sometimes choose
What’s best for those
And rest will lose
…And it was Porky 🐷
LikeLike
Where would we all be without you. Of course it was Porky Pig.
LikeLike
My first thought was Porky Pig! But I wasn’t sure. Thanks for the help.
LikeLike
There’s a headline from Slate on Google News this morning that reads as follows: ” “Betsy DeVos ‘is not a numbers person.'”
LikeLike
Logical development of ideas is not her forte either. DeVos should come view some of the make believe classrooms where I have worked if she wishes to test my devotion to school buildings over school children.
LikeLiked by 1 person
As a current student moving closer and closer to becoming a teacher, everything I read that comes out of Betsy DeVos leaves me in fear for the education system. What leaves me baffled is the fact that I do not think she got to the position she is in now because of her mind. She claims to not be a numbers person, but charter schools rake in so much money; she gives money to what she wants to support and then looks at the schools and causes that are not given tons of money and points her finger at them saying that they are failing. Not to put down people who support her, but could we really be so quick to support someone who makes those decisions without considering the larger picture at hand? What makes a school virtuous is the combination of the system of that district and the people in it. I would love to hear her evidence that public schools are not as virtuous as charter schools.. I’m sure it would make a lot of intriguing points..
Her ideas fail to provide any sort of light on the improvement of the education system, and I am wondering about the future of her position as the next generation of teachers approaches.
LikeLike