Senator Bernie Sanders published an opinion piece today assessing the path forward for the Democratic Party and the nation.
He writes:
“Millions of Americans registered a protest vote on Tuesday, expressing their fierce opposition to an economic and political system that puts wealthy and corporate interests over their own. I strongly supported Hillary Clinton, campaigned hard on her behalf, and believed she was the right choice on Election Day. But Donald J. Trump won the White House because his campaign rhetoric successfully tapped into a very real and justified anger, an anger that many traditional Democrats feel.
“I am saddened, but not surprised, by the outcome. It is no shock to me that millions of people who voted for Mr. Trump did so because they are sick and tired of the economic, political and media status quo.
“Working families watch as politicians get campaign financial support from billionaires and corporate interests — and then ignore the needs of ordinary Americans. Over the last 30 years, too many Americans were sold out by their corporate bosses. They work longer hours for lower wages as they see decent paying jobs go to China, Mexico or some other low-wage country. They are tired of having chief executives make 300 times what they do, while 52 percent of all new income goes to the top 1 percent. Many of their once beautiful rural towns have depopulated, their downtown stores are shuttered, and their kids are leaving home because there are no jobs — all while corporations suck the wealth out of their communities and stuff them into offshore accounts.
“Working Americans can’t afford decent, quality child care for their children. They can’t send their kids to college, and they have nothing in the bank as they head into retirement. In many parts of the country they can’t find affordable housing, and they find the cost of health insurance much too high. Too many families exist in despair as drugs, alcohol and suicide cut life short for a growing number of people.
“President-elect Trump is right: The American people want change. But what kind of change will he be offering them? Will he have the courage to stand up to the most powerful people in this country who are responsible for the economic pain that so many working families feel, or will he turn the anger of the majority against minorities, immigrants, the poor and the helpless?
“Will he have the courage to stand up to Wall Street, work to break up the “too big to fail” financial institutions and demand that big banks invest in small businesses and create jobs in rural America and inner cities? Or, will he appoint another Wall Street banker to run the Treasury Department and continue business as usual? Will he, as he promised during the campaign, really take on the pharmaceutical industry and lower the price of prescription drugs?
“I am deeply distressed to hear stories of Americans being intimidated and harassed in the wake of Mr. Trump’s victory, and I hear the cries of families who are living in fear of being torn apart. We have come too far as a country in combating discrimination. We are not going back. Rest assured, there is no compromise on racism, bigotry, xenophobia and sexism. We will fight it in all its forms, whenever and wherever it re-emerges.
“I will keep an open mind to see what ideas Mr. Trump offers and when and how we can work together. Having lost the nationwide popular vote, however, he would do well to heed the views of progressives. If the president-elect is serious about pursuing policies that improve the lives of working families, I’m going to present some very real opportunities for him to earn my support.
“Let’s rebuild our crumbling infrastructure and create millions of well-paying jobs. Let’s raise the minimum wage to a living wage, help students afford to go to college, provide paid family and medical leave and expand Social Security. Let’s reform an economic system that enables billionaires like Mr. Trump not to pay a nickel in federal income taxes. And most important, let’s end the ability of wealthy campaign contributors to buy elections.
“In the coming days, I will also provide a series of reforms to reinvigorate the Democratic Party. I believe strongly that the party must break loose from its corporate establishment ties and, once again, become a grass-roots party of working people, the elderly and the poor. We must open the doors of the party to welcome in the idealism and energy of young people and all Americans who are fighting for economic, social, racial and environmental justice. We must have the courage to take on the greed and power of Wall Street, the drug companies, the insurance companies and the fossil fuel industry.
“When my presidential campaign came to an end, I pledged to my supporters that the political revolution would continue. And now, more than ever, that must happen. We are the wealthiest nation in the history of the world. When we stand together and don’t let demagogues divide us up by race, gender or national origin, there is nothing we cannot accomplish. We must go forward, not backward.”

Bernie needs to get real. Many of these voters have been voting against their self interest for decades. Remember Reagan Democrats? The reward the hard hats earned was romhave their unions (and their paycheck) weakened.
We are in this mess because Democrats have not attacked the basic oremises the GOP and conservatives operate on. Small government is good? Then why are all the former slave states which have been consistently conservative for 150’years without interruption at the bottom in most measures that are good, and at the top in things that are bad?
They have lower per capita income, lower family income, less education, less economic opportunity, than the liberal states. Why hasn’t this been a campaign issue?
The Democrats never had a coordinated campaign to make the GOP pay for obstructing the government. It’s a little late, but we need to get to it.
Steve O’Dongohue
33 years in the classroom in Oakland, CA
LikeLike
Steve
Easy, the man with the guts to call himself a Socialist is under no illusions about the Democrats,Trump or the Republicans
“Voting against their own interests for years”. Indeed
“The Democrats never had a coordinated campaign to make the GOP pay for obstructing the government”
The Democrats never had a coordinated plan to attack the rot at the heart of both parties corporate money. . Something that Trump played on very well as he proved Lincoln wrong.
But he was able to do that because since 92 the Democrats were all too guilty themselves of “fooling all of the People all of the time”
Time to clean house
LikeLike
To Steve O’Donoghue:
Are you seriously a teacher for 33 years?
I would guess that you vote for your self-interest.
Since you do not agree with Senator Bernie Sanders’ statement that people have voted against their interest, would you, as a teacher and a voter, please elaborate to all readers your explanation and your critical analysis that which President Candidate among all of four is the most QUALIFIED candidate?
Hopefully, from your view of point, readers will give you more inputs for you to see clearly whether Bernie’s statement is CORRECT or not.
IMHO, it is simply that in political games, there are empty promises in the UNREALISTIC platform from an inexperience candidate. All gullible people, who blindly trust, believe or want to show their frustration, will vote against their interest.
I appreciate your precious time to enhance my understanding in this particular RESULT in the Presidential election of 2016. Back2basic
LikeLike
May…I agree with much that Steve, the long time California teacher states.
Dems for decades have played the same game as Repubs. In this election, many of us felt these two parties were actually one party with the offering of candidates for Prez. and the giant money grabs.
Almost all our legislators have put their own purses ahead of their constituents. Just see their allowing only themselves to do INSIDER TRADING. The go into Congress with small assets and come out millionaires, then immediately become lobbyists. Those who many of us considered the best, like Dashle and Gebhardt, fooled even our sophisticated wonks as they dipped their greedy hands into the corporate money vats.
Our system is out of whack and does not allow for a popular vote for Prez so we get the worst of Repubs like Baby Bush and now Terrible Trump. We must kill the Electoral College which is a vestigal organ of the slavery era when only the male white landowner elites ran the country…as is now happening again with Citizens United overlords.
And Dems do not follow the Reagan 11th Commandment and support each other…rather they have too much chaos as we saw with the DNC in this election. Just follow the Wikileaks revelations as to how the DNC failed us…and Bernie. Disgraceful. I would like to see a former Senator, not a working Senator, head the DNC and I suggest Russ Feingold who knows how to work across the aisle and not to keep poking sticks in the eyes of both Dem and Repub opponents.
As to my state, Gov. Jerry Brown, a Dem, has betrayed us continually with his support of charter schools, and his promise to adhere to Prop 30 as temporary, and then to foist more terrible public policy on us with Prop 55 which funds only about half for schools, and too much of that taxation funding going to charters (who paid for much of the phone sound bites. Voters are so naive.
This from another California educator of almost 50 years.
Ellen Lubic
LikeLike
that is ‘phony; sound bites…hate this self correction algorithm.
LikeLike
Dearest Ellen Lubic:
First of all, I really appreciate your agreement with most of my thoughtful comments as you stated.
I really respect your expression and information that you contribute to cultivate me in this website.
I acknowledge the frustration of all conscientious educators. However, it is shocking to learn that there is no unity in thought and in action to pull the POSSIBILITY of “can work out” situation or even that it would remain THE CHANCE in which educators can persuade or can take a peaceful/ mutual understanding action in order to rectify from bad to better situation in or for PUBLIC EDUCATION! Sigh!
In the past two months before the election, all educators should unite and reinforce THE IMPORTANCE of the difference between “ELECTORAL” and “POPULAR” in the outcome of presidential election in order to inform the voter.
It is not too late for this time being ONLY IF educators can waken the CONSCIENCE of MAN in all TRULY CONSCIENTIOUS republicans in GOP and in VOTERS.
Please note that the greedy corporate will drag all to die with them = In the war where water, land and air are polluted, nobody can survive without TERMINAL illness!!!
I hope that you understand my thought in the link with my explanation, as follows:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XP9cfQx2OZY
The Good, the Bad & the Ugly Finale
[The strategy in “The triangle” of 1) the academe with power (=Clint Eastwood character), 2) the greed corporate (the invisible character appears from nowhere to surprise the academe), 3) the poor, the calculated rebel, and the short term gain in greed (=the digger)]
In short, there are some of my favorite quotes with wisdom from the Poet Leonard Cohen who recently passed away:
1) “Reality is one of the possibilities I cannot afford to ignore.” (= IMHO, all con artists do not have the slightest human decency)
2)”Act the way you’d like to be and soon you’ll be the way you act.” (= You would know this better than me in your 50+ years working in education)
3) “Love is the only engine of survival.”
= this is the true testimony of my living here in Canada from the UN-YIELDING belief in humanity from Dr. Ravitch and all conscientious educators in this website.
(like you, senõr Swacker, Dr. Laura Chapman, Dr. Jean Haverhill, Dr. Christine Langhoff, Guru writer Lloyd Lofthouse, my sweet spirit sister Susan Lee Schwartz, philosopher KrazyTA, and many many other amazing educators, lawyers, writers, poets, political analysts who are among of millions readers with 30+ viewers in this website.)
Respectfully yours,
May
LikeLike
Sorry. it should be written: “30+ MILLIONS of viewers”
LikeLike
I firmly believe that Bernie would have defeated Trump. This is what Democrats wanted. Clinton was a weak candidate with incredible baggage and 4 positions on every issue.
Democrats need a “WOW” ticket next time
VEEP must be black or Latino. #1 must motivate white working class.
Even Joe Biden would have been FAR better than Clinton.
LikeLike
agreed
LikeLike
Clinton a weak candidate? She won the popular vote by a margin that is widening as the count continues. I’d say the election was close but the electoral college rules the day. I voted for Bernie and he lost in NJ, 37% to Hillary’s 63%, that’s not even close. If we were a sane country, Bernie would be president. Too many Americans keep voting against their own best interests (What’s the matter with Kansas, etc.).
LikeLike
Why do people vote against their self-interest? Why do people who need government services vote for politicians who promise to cut them?
LikeLike
I’m convinced it is a love//hate relationship with the government. The red states and rural Trump supporters are more dependent on the Federal government. It becomes a loss of dignity which builds anger towards the government as both benefactor and cause.
LikeLike
I disagree that Trump supporters voted against their self interest. He isn’t perfect, but he was the better choice of two bad options for the working class.
I knew Hillary would lose when she answered a debate question about jobs with the usual tired case for (temporary) infrastructure spending, which Trump agrees with, and investment in solar.
Over the months, Trump laid out several concrete plans for incentivizing companies to stay in America and hire workers in depressed areas like Detroit. She didn’t have any new ideas.
Also, the Democrats advocate for cuts to the military budget and farming. Whatever you think about either of those industries, they provide millions of jobs and benefits to towns that have been decimated by plant closures. I don’t know where the Democrats expect those workers to go.
Finally, the Wall Street crime and corruption needs to stop! I look at a company like Wells Fargo which opened up phony credit card accounts and collect fees from thousands of people, mostly poor. The CEO should be in jail, instead he was allowed to retire with a $128 million parachute. Clinton, like Obama, would have hired corrupt and weak prosecutors like Holder and Lynch, approved by the big banks. Wells Fargo is just one of thousands of companies screwing over the poor.
So, say what you like about Trumo supporters, some of whom voted for Obama twice, they absolutely did vote for their self interest.
LikeLike
dianeravitch
Could it be when the choices are not clear . People vote for people who do not represent their interests. The overwhelming majority of Trump voters were voting their economic interests .They don’t go to rallies hollering lock her up. They are not suffering in this economy. They stood to benefit from Trumps tax cutting republican economic policy.
The Religious vote, voted their interests as well,from gay bashing Mike Pence, to abortion ,to vouchers for religious schools,
That leaves us with that small swath of the electorate those Mid West workers who got hammered in this economy. Hammered by Democrats whose name was on the Trade agreements that sent their jobs overseas . Still pushing that policy right into the fall.
Try telling these people that the Democrats had their backs. Soon after securing the nomination Hillary didn’t even bother . She went after moderate Republicans instead. Became dismissive of the left in her own party. Till the convention threatened to blow up,
Then she pivoted to where she was forced to go. Even after the convention the focus was on getting Republicans because their candidate was abhorrent, get them to vote against their economic interests .
All those commercials touting out Neo Con Republicans to warn other Republicans that he was dangerous . All those ads that said what will your children hear. They were falling on deaf ears of Republicans who voted their wallets. and those voters in the industrial Midwest ; never mind what they will hear, what will they eat.
.
LikeLike
Joe
Thomas Frank tells you “Whats is the matter with Kansas” in “Listen Liberal ” Clintonism is what is wrong with Kansas . I have waited my entire adult life to see the American
people given a real choice . A choice between the left and the right . Instead they are always given the same choice . . I could have accepted a Bernie defeat by the right.
I don’t think that will happen. But it would have been a referendum on visions .
The American people in 2008 voted for “Hope and Change” . They threw the scoundrels out massively. Only to find out “Meet the new boss .Same as the old boss ”
“Just like yesterday Then I’ll get on my(their) knees and pray. We don’t get fooled again
Don’t get fooled again”
They are about to be fed to the lions
LikeLike
Edit button DIDN’T
LikeLike
The DNC had Michael Bloomberg give a speech at its convention. Black Ohioan, former state senator, Nina Turner, had her scheduled speaking time cancelled.
LikeLike
Linda…thanks for your comment…DNC was dreadful in leaving out Nina Turner. Hope Turner runs for Congress…or for head of the DNC.
LikeLike
Message from a Midwest lifetime Democrat. We are profoundly alienated and angry. A vote for Clinton tells Washington “don’t worry we are fine. Go back to sleep.”
LikeLike
Three separate polls showed Bernie beating Trump by a comfortable margin. Young people would have voted in great numbers for Bernie.
LikeLike
Stop making me sick . I should go to his book signing today in Manhattan., except there will probably be more people on line than Hillary had voters in the Mid West.
LikeLike
It looks like Democratic governor in NC which means many voters voted Trump for president and Democrat for governor proving in NC at least Clinton was less popular than her party.
LikeLike
“It looks like Democratic governor in NC which means many voters voted Trump for president and Democrat for governor proving in NC at least Clinton was less popular than her party.”
It looks like Democrat Deborah Ross got over 300,000 fewer votes than Hillary Clinton. She lost her Senate campaign to NC Senator Richard Burr by a greater margin than Hillary lost to Trump. Less than 46% of the NC voters wanted Deborah Ross. Over 48% wanted Hillary.
Proving in NC at least, Clinton was MORE popular than her party.
Proving that Bernie could have lost NC by margins GREATER than Hillary Clinton, just like Deborah Ross did.
Actually, it doesn’t prove anything. Despite the disaffected Bernie voters’ certainty that no sliming or negative ads by Republicans could have touched their unassailably perfect Bernie, that belief was never once put to the test. What the wikileaks proved — but what the disaffected Bernie supporters refuse to recognize — is that while talk about negatives about Bernie may have been mentioned by pro-Hillary staff, they were never put out there to slime him. Never.
The belief that the Republicans would have been much kinder to Bernie than the “evil” DNC who “stole” the election from Hillary is truly absurd. And dangerously misses how this election was tainted by the alt-right/FBI/Republican/wikileaks hijacking of the candidate’s message. It will happen again. And again. Until Democrats get a clue and try to stop it.
I just re-watched “All the Presidents Men” again last night with my Bernie-supporting kid (who was smarter than many elders in realizing that Clinton was a perfectly acceptable 2nd choice).
Boy did we let that slime machine go right back to work. Were there Democrats as myopic as the “all Hillary’s fault” Bernie fans back then who insisted it was all Muskie’s fault for being a cry baby? All McGovern’s fault for being the country’s biggest loser. If only….if only their perfect Democrat had been up against Nixon he would have remained flawless and easily won against those 2 losers who could do no right.
LikeLike
YES in spades…
LikeLike
I agree with Doug and Joel many comments north of this one.
LikeLike
“So what would have happened when Sanders hit a real opponent, someone who did not care about alienating the young college voters in his base? I have seen the opposition book assembled by Republicans for Sanders, and it was brutal. The Republicans would have torn him apart. . . .
Here are a few tastes of what was in store for Sanders, straight out of the Republican playbook: He thinks rape is A-OK. In 1972, when he was 31, Sanders wrote a fictitious essay in which he described a woman enjoying being raped by three men. . . .
Then there’s the fact that Sanders was on unemployment until his mid-30s, and that he stole electricity from a neighbor after failing to pay his bills, and that he co-sponsored a bill to ship Vermont’s nuclear waste to a poor Hispanic community in Texas, where it could be dumped. . . .
Worst of all, the Republicans also had video of Sanders at a 1985 rally thrown by the leftist Sandinista government in Nicaragua where half a million people chanted, “Here, there, everywhere/the Yankee will die,’’ while President Daniel Ortega condemned “state terrorism” by America. Sanders said, on camera, supporting the Sandinistas was “patriotic.” . . .
In other words, the belief that Sanders would have walked into the White House based on polls taken before anyone really attacked him is a delusion built on a scaffolding of political ignorance. . . .
Sanders supporters puffing up their chests as they arrogantly declare Trump would have definitely lost against their candidate deserve to be ignored.”
http://www.newsweek.com/myths-cost-democrats-presidential-election-521044
LikeLike
Great article. Why I voted for Bernie in the primaries. Show the Clinton Coalition the door. I’m still not convinced Ellison can carry forward the Bernie movement. Ellison needs to inspire and go after the non-deplorables who voted for Trump. So far, Ellison seems to be playing it safe rather than leading a charge.
LikeLike
Russ Feingold, a FORMER Senator, not a working Senator, who knows how to work with Repubs and Dems peacefully and productively, as with McCain Feingold Act, would be far the best choice to run the DNC.
LikeLike
Great op ed by Bernie. As always, from the heart and with intelligence.
LikeLike
We have arrived at the point I dreaded – the day Americans would rue the theft of the presidential nomination from Bernie Sanders.
LikeLike
Ridiculous. In a column out today, Newsweek reporter Kurt Eichenwald explodes two myths that Bernie supporters are still clinging to:
http://www.dailykos.com/stories/2016/11/14/1599177/-Kurt-Eichenwald-explodes-two-myths-some-Liberals-cling-to
LikeLike
Eichenwald is nuts. Sanders would have easily defeated Trump.
The sad thing for Clinton backers to understand is the progressive wing of the party considers “Clintonism” not worth getting out of bed to fight for.
LikeLike
If you click through to the actual Kurt Eichenwald column, you’ll get undeniable statistics from a real-live journalist that prove that the Bernie folks were in a snit over nothing.
LikeLike
I love Bernie. He belongs in Norway.
LikeLike
We in Canada find Bernie very mainstream. His politics are perfectly normal in any Western democracy except the USA.
Then again every democracy has some form of Medicare for all except the USA where for some reason it is a problem. Our Canadian Conservatives know if they let out a peep against Medicare they would become unelectable. It is that popular.
No “exchanges” no signing up. You are a citizen it is free.
LikeLike
How are the winters in Norway and do the accept American asylum seekers.
LikeLike
The Democrats shot themselves in the foot. Bernie would have mopped the floor with Trump. Now they lost, WE lost, Democracy lost.
With George W. the nation, the planet will NEVER be the same.
Trump will, if he does what he says he will finish the job the George W. began.
I am glad I am at the age I am and probably will not endure the worst of what the future brings but my grandchildren and even my children? I fear the worst on MANY fronts.
LikeLike
“Bernie would have mopped the floor with Trump”.
We are in for a world of trouble if that is the only lesson learned from what happened. That the hijacking of this election by the alt right/FBI/so-called “fair and balanced” media is unimportant. Bernie would have remained popular and beloved because he was already smeared so much by the DNC that the Republicans and alt-right’s attacks would have been brushed off like nothing. Some Democrats just KNOW this. It’s all Hillary’s fault.
We don’t know if Bernie would have mopped the floor with Trump. We don’t know if after being slimed by the alt right as a terrorist sympathizer and money hungry fraud who will take away all private property, Bernie would have lost not just the electoral vote but the popular vote as well.
Maybe Bernie would have won. And maybe he would have lost big. The people who KNOW Bernie would have “mopped the floor” sound as deluded as many Trump supporters. Their certainty of facts that are far from proven is ruining this country. We no longer discuss how policies do and don’t work. We repeat our certainties and beliefs that we just “know” are true.
LikeLike
Read this if you think so.
http://www.newsweek.com/myths-cost-democrats-presidential-election-521044
LikeLike
As much as I appreciate the dedication of Bernie Sanders to a dwindling middle.class, I fear that he and Trump miss the mark. Automation is producing a remarkable portion of the problem. Ross Perots giant sucking sound is now produced by giant engines. A road project near where I live rarely employs more than twenty workers. Often there are just 4 or 5 on the job.
What economic model produces a middlelclass in an automated production environment? The consumer model does not work without consumers.
LikeLike
If we cut work hours, increase the minimum wage and redistribute income away from the 1% we can mitigated the problem. A shift to an infrastructure program, healthcare, education childcare and we have the making of a reorganization of the Midwest. Naturally the children will continue to move to California for IT or the east coast for financial services.
LikeLike
There is a bone headed belief in the DNC eminating from the Clinton led DLC that in a nutshell believes that progressives cannot defeat Republicans but only “centrists” can win. This may make sense to someone with a southern or Arkansas perspective, these are not winning states for Democrats anyway.
The Democrat world is northeast + Florida + Midwest + west coast + a growing sunbelt west region.
LikeLike
Go Bernie!
LikeLike