T.C. Weber, who blogs as Dad Gone Wild, writes about the latest problem in Nashville.
The pro-public school/anti-charter forces won a resounding victory at the elections recently. Their candidates won handily.
But then the new superintendent of schools stunned everyone by hiring as his chief of staff a woman who had been actively involved in the charter movement in Washington state and elsewhere. She scrubbed the charter stuff off her resume, but the Internet is forever, and she couldn’t hide her long history as a supporter of the very policies that Nashville voters had just decisively rejected.
Jana Carlisle was executive director of the Partnership for Learning, which advocated for charters in Washington State, even though voters had rejected them three times. The initiative was finally passed, by less than 1%, in 2012, after Bill Gates and his fellow billionaires poured nearly $20 million into their campaign, a sum that overwhelmed the League of Women Voters, PTAs, teachers’ unions, and the NAACP. Carlisle made a statement about implementation of the charter law soon after its passage. The statement (which I copied on my cellphone) has now been removed from the Internet. Here it is:
PFL: Testimony to state board on charter schools, accountability
On November 8, 2012, Jana Carlisle, executive director of the Partnership for Learning, testified at the State Board of Education’s meeting in Vancouver on public charter school implementation and the state’s new Accountability Index.
Her comments are as follows:
“Good Afternoon. My name is Dr. Jana Carlisle and I’m here representing the Washington Roundtable’s education foundation, the Partnership for Learning.
I’m here today to reinforce the importance of the State Board of Education’s role in providing guidance and oversight to local school boards wishing to become charter school authorizers, as well as to the smooth and quality functioning of the state’s public charter school application, approval, and annual review processes. The founding member organizations of the Washington Coalition for Public Charter Schools include the League of Education Voters, Stand for Children, Democrats for Education Reform, and the Partnership and Roundtable. Our groups are committed to supporting effective implementation of and leadership for public charter schools in Washington state. To do so, we are interested in collaborating with the State Board and its staff, the Commission, and a broad base of stakeholders that include parents, students, educators, and elected and agency leaders. As is the case with the SBE, our implementation conversations have already commenced. We are eager to work closely with you and the SBE staff during the coming months and years to ensure that the intent of the initiative – which includes giving priority to opening public charter schools that serve at-risk student populations or students from low-performing public schools – is realized.
Today you have also talked about what to include in the Accountability Index. The WRT and Partnership for Learning strongly believe that a performance-based accountability system is absolutely essential to ensure our state’s implementation of a 21st Century education system and to secure support for adequately funding basic education. We believe that Washington’s accountability system must include: 1) transparent and accessible district and school report cards that include scale scores and status updates on meeting the outcomes delineated below; 2) a statewide growth-based accountability index that establishes key school performance indicators, targets, and the line between success and failure; and 3) statewide capacity and authority for incenting and rewarding school innovation; for establishing timelines for progress to occur; and for supporting, intervening in, and taking over struggling schools.
We believe that a 21st Century statewide education system – and thus the index’s indicator – in Washington will result in the following:
1. Closing student achievement gaps among students in K-12 mathematics, English Language Arts, science, and social studies – based on actual performance and growth measures.
2. Increasing overall academic achievement for all student groups for K-12 mathematics, English Language Arts, science, and social studies – based on actual performance and growth measures.
3. Increasing the overall graduation rate of high school students – documented in terms of four- and five-year rates – and the college and career readiness graduation rate.
4. Reducing remedial rates in two-year colleges and in four-year universities.
5. Increasing four-year post-secondary participation within one year of students’ high school graduation.
6. Increasing two-year post-secondary participation within one year of students’ high school graduation.
7. Increasing two- and four-year post-secondary graduation rates.
8. Increasing participation rate in post-secondary STEM programs (this includes workforce training, industry certification, and/or credit bearing two- and four-year postsecondary coursework).”
© PARTNERSHIP FOR LEARNING | 520 PIKE STREET, SUITE 1212 SEATTLE, WA 98101
INFO@PARTNERSHIP4LEARNING.ORG | P: (206) 625.9655 | F: (206) 447.0502 | PRIVACY POLICY AND TERMS
You can also read about the work of the Partnership on the website of the rightwing PIE Network.
Look, if someone wants to work for the charter movement, that’s fine, that’s their right. But they shouldn’t apply to work in a district that rejects charters while scrubbing their resume to hide their sympathies. That’s not honest.

Corporate Rule is fundamentally opposed to Democratic Rule.
It does not play by the same rules — it never will …
LikeLike
Stealth infiltration of state and local school boards, and other governance structures, is enabled by big money contributors to “leadership” programs that groom people for corporate-style roles like this one, a clear case of voter nullification by appointment.
The charter industry seems to regard Nashville seems to be regarded as a trophy community for charter francises and foundations who are targetng large metro districts as “proof points” for the assumed benefits of pouring public subsidies into privately operated schools. Memphis is also in the cross hairs.
LikeLike
“Republican nominee Donald Trump’s presidential campaign has tapped Rob Goad, who has worked for Indiana GOP Rep. Luke Messer in Congress, to work on school choice issues in the real estate executive’s bid for the White House.
Goad is on leave from Messer’s office and for the past two weeks has been in New York City working for the Trump campaign as a policy adviser, according to sources. He’s the first adviser for Trump to focus specifically on education issues.”
Why do ed reformers insist on calling this “education issues” when it’s so obviously limited to charters and vouchers?
That is itself deceptive.
LikeLike
They should just call it corporate access to public money. That clarifies the relationship.
LikeLike
Was Jana Carlisle also a Senior Program Officer of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, in 2009?
LikeLike
retired teacher
August 31, 2016 at 11:02 am
They should just call it corporate access to public money. That clarifies the relationship.
Or, they could just call it what it is- charters and vouchers. I’m amused Donald Trump believes public schools suck. When is the last time he or any member of his family entered a public school? He couldn’t find a Michigan public school with a map.
LikeLike
When has the publicly funded, private sector, autocratic, secretive, often fraudulent and inferior, child abusing, corporate charter school industry ever been honest in their efforts to destroy community based, democratic, transparent, non-profit, traditional public educaiton, crush the teachers’ unions and destroy the teaching profession?
LikeLike
And, self-anointed reform, siphons off community money, eliminating the benefit of local spending velocity (local taxes dollars in the pockets of local employees and businesses), which threatens community survival.
LikeLike
Their new Superintendent is the former Superintendent of Prince Georges County Public schools in MD. PG Co is a suburb of Washington DC. PG Co and Balto City in MD have the highest rates of charter schools in MD and outside of DC. Coincidence? Connect the dots.
LikeLike
Ms Carlisle, and her attempts to infiltrate community based public education, is eerily reminiscent of the classic movie, “Invasion of the Body Snatchers”.
Service with a smile…as neighborhoods in the United States are slowly, but completely taken over. The destruction of not only democratic and representative government, but the chilling eradication of human norms and values. Alien pods were secretively and systematically supplanted into American towns and cities, would take on all characteristics of the chosen person, and emulate them completely…in every way, except for displaying the human capacities of love, compassion, understanding…in essence, the creation of a human-like race of robots.
The Invasion of the Body Snatchers was viewed by many as a call to arms…a state of emergency…during the alarming height of the Cold War.
In pushing the privatization agenda, Ms Carlisle is one of those pods…planted, grown, programmed, and paid for by an anti-American agenda…the agenda of Bill Gates.
LikeLike
IMO, your description is perfect for the Gates-funded Pahara Aspen Institute Fellows.
LikeLike