Calling John Oliver! The charter lobbyists have been criticizing Oliver for his expose of charter fraud last Sunday. Unfair, they say. Untrue, they say. Slanders charters, they say. Let’s see how they fit this story into their narrative.
Nicholas Trombetta, founder of the Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School, pleaded guilty to stealing $8 million from the school and diverting it for his personal use. Trombetta’s school was often featured on television as the nation’s first virtual charter. With an enrollment of 10,000 students from across the state, Trometta had receipts of $100 million a year. What to do with all that dough rolling in from taxpayers?
I have written about this scandal on several occasions, from the time Trombetta was charged in 2013. (See hereand here and here. Another cyber charter leader in Pennsylvania, June Brown, who ran the K-12 Agora Charter, was arrested and charged with stealing $6 million.
The Associated Press reports:
“PITTSBURGH (AP) — The founder and former CEO of an online public school that educates thousands of Pennsylvania students pleaded guilty Wednesday to federal tax fraud, acknowledging he siphoned more than $8 million from The Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School through for-profit and nonprofit companies he controlled.
“In entering his plea, Nicholas Trombetta, 61, who headed the school, acknowledged using the money to buy, among other things, a Bonita Springs, Florida, condominium for $933,000, pay $180,000 for houses for his mother and girlfriend in Ohio, and spend $990,000 more on groceries and other items.
“He manipulated companies he created and controlled to draw the money from the school, also spending it on a $300,000 plane, Assistant U.S. Attorney Stephen Kaufman said.
“Trombetta was making $127,000 to $144,000 annually at PA Cyber when he ran the illegal tax evasion scheme from 2006 to 2012. He faces up to five years in prison when he’s sentenced Dec. 20.
“By running the money through the companies or their straw owners, Trombetta avoided income taxes, though prosecutors haven’t said how much. Most of the siphoned money was squirreled away in Avanti Management Group, which functioned as Trombetta’s retirement savings account, Kaufman said.
“This case reflects the priority we’ve placed on protecting against fraud in education,” U.S. Attorney David Hickton said.
“The school, founded in Midland in 2000, had more than 11,000 students across the state when Trombetta was charged three years ago and still has more than 9,000. As a public institution, it’s funded by federal, state and local taxes. Districts across the state pay the school to educate any students who opt to enroll in PA Cyber instead of a bricks-and-mortar school.
“Trombetta almost didn’t plead guilty Wednesday when his attorney, Adam Hoffinger, began sparring with Kaufman, who had to describe the complicated conspiracy to the judge.
“Kaufman said Trombetta used Avanti, the National Network of Digital Schools and other companies in the scheme. The Network of Digital Schools markets a curriculum developed in conjunction with PA Cyber and sold it back to the school, while Avanti provided unspecified management services, the prosecutor said. Avanti had four owners who pretended to be equal 25 percent partners when, in reality, Trombetta owned 80 percent of the firm, Kaufman said.”

Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education and commented:
So educators in Atlanta are caught cheating on a test and get 20 years. This guy steals 8 million dollars and is going to get 5 years. There is something very wrong here. He should get at least 1 year more than the educators in Atlanta
LikeLike
It’s all about who is going to controll the money.Urban public schools are closing under the guise of low attendance. Urban & black kids are suffering from these Rip offs.
Gentrification is also taking black communities and schools.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Matthews' Blog.
LikeLike
You are making history by becoming one of the relatively few places where these frauds are documented with some potential for wider circulattion. When will the fraud stop? who will hold the authorizer of this fraud responsible? Who will hold the legislators responsible for the state chaerter laws responsible? SImilar issues in Ohio and likely elsewhere.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just a reminder: Staff at Detroit and Chicago Public schools have pulled the same kind of stunts, so this is not just something that happens at charter schools…
LikeLike
Perhaps fraud is more common in large school district, but they are more likely to find it as a mandatory independent auditor is required. I can’t speak to other districts. I couldn’t even get reimbursed for a toll on my way to a conference without a receipt.
LikeLike
Remind me when staff in Detroit and Chicago had unaudited use of $100 million. I can’t remember.
LikeLike
Why is the amount important???
LikeLike
The state auditor in PA has been trying to get lawmakers to regulate charters for years. Years.
Why isn’t this a state case? Why did it take a federal investigation to stop this when the state auditor has been saying it’s been going on for years?
“Pennsylvania Auditor General Eugene DePasquale issued a scathing report damning the state charter law Tuesday, and he blamed many of the School District of Philadelphia’s fiscal woes on state lawmakers who have not revised the nearly 20-year-old measure.
“Our charter school law is simply the worst charter school law in the United States,” said DePasquale at a news conference at the Philadelphia District’s headquarters.
Specifically, DePasquale said, the law fails to give districts the power to ensure that only high-performing charters that serve equitable populations of children are opening. And he lamented that districts waste too much time and too many resources fighting to close underperformers.
He blamed recent failed efforts in Harrisburg to reform the charter law on special interest lobbying.”
http://thenotebook.org/articles/2016/04/12/pa-charter-school-law-worst-in-u-s-state-auditor-general-says
LikeLike
Rudy, you must be thinking of Broad Supernintendo Barbara Byrd Bennett in Chicago, who defrauded the schools of Chicago in the SUPES kickback scheme.
“Assistant U.S. Attorney Megan Church charged Byrd-Bennett received ‘bribes and kickbacks’ of 10 percent on business she steered to SUPES and Synesi, including a $20.5 million no-bid contract for principal training Byrd-Bennett encouraged the Board of Education to endorse, which it did so unanimously.”
https://www.dnainfo.com/chicago/20151013/downtown/barbara-byrd-bennett-pleads-guilty-corruption-charges
She wasn’t “staff”. She was the boss, thanks to Eli Broad and Rahm Emanuel.
And before Chicago, she did the same in Detroit, in a $40 million textbook scheme.
She replaced the disasterous Jen Claude Bxrizard, another Broad super.
LikeLike
Since a “The Boss” is on the same payroll as anyone else, they are staff, one way or another… But yes, that was the one I had in mind. And something tells me that financial abuse in school districts is rampant… So to my point: These things happen, whether they are in public service or private business. It has little or nothing to do with the environment – but everything with the people involved. Bad people do bad things, no matter where they are.
LikeLike
Few, especially in the CTU, would argue there is corruption in the city. Byrd Bennett was a protegé of privatizer Eli Broad. The Broad seal of approval enabled her access to positions where she she was able to commit these frauds.
LikeLike
The amount is important! The amount is directly proportional to how many students and families are affected because of his financial shenanigans. Yes, all of these type of guys are bad, but you have to be a moron to not see how this level of fraud is worse than nepotism or misrepresentation or petty thefts. Think of it this way: A 100 million should have been spent on the hundreds of students with textbooks, facilities, technology, instruction, etc, instead of adding to the bulge of this guy’s wallet. We are not talking about how union members steal from other union members nor how district officials employ their nephews to cronyistic heights of stupidity nor the pocket-lining of someone on the board to complete some form of construction by hiring his own company. We ARE talking about one man stealing millions from what should go to children.
And, to be totally honest, this kind of thing happens at a much higher percentage at charters than it does at traditional public schools. It is not rocket science but it probably has to do with the type and amount of checks and balances that are built into the system. They simply do not have enough. Right now our charter laws basically send personal fraud invitations to all the Trombetta-types out there. And it sounds like Rudy cares more about protecting the status quo of charters than he does about improving them.
LikeLike
Why is the amount important? People are tired of seeing white collar criminals get slaps on the wrists. Charter scams remind me of Bernie Madoff. The scale of theft is important to everyday people, whether white collar thieves and their friends and supporters like it or not.
LikeLike
$8mm worth? I think we might have read about that in the uniformly anti-pubsch mainstream media…
LikeLike
Rudy, considering Chiara’s contribution that it took many yrs to bring this PA online-school charter fraud to light– whereas Barbara Byrd-Bennett was exposed w/in just a couple of yrs– holds the answer. Sure, publics are susceptible to fraud. But they are held to transparency & regular audits, so we find out & expose them sooner. Charters, like this PA online school, despite feeding at the public trough like public schools, can hide from transparency & audits, behind the corporate veil, for much longer; it takes a fed investigation to out them, & by then the taxpayers’ money is long gone.
LikeLike
Then change the rules! The situation described in the original posting need to be addressed.
LikeLike
Rudy, your post at 4:47pm: i completely agree: “these things happen, whether they are in public service or private business… Bad people do bad things, no matter where they are.”
You are so right!! That’s why we have laws. People will do whatever bad stuff allowed; most will hold off rather than risk breaking the law.
So: school districts run by local boards of ed are under the magnifying glass of the local taxpayers. School districts run by the state are at a remove & can get away w/illegal acts for a while. But they’re subject by law to transparency/ audits; the state law will catch up w/them eventually.
But charter schools are different: though supported by taxpayers, their finances are auditable only as far as their state charter allows. Most states’ charter laws place these schools outside common fed & state procurement laws as applied to local school districts. The very laws which encourage charter schools to innovate, i.e., not be subject to fed/state ‘red tape’ also allow them to sidestep financial audits et al laws relating to conflict of interest– thus creating a welcome-mat for fraud. That’s why it takes years of fraud before stuff smells so bad that the fed steps in to investigate.
This is why you can’t make the argument that pubsch also commits fraud. The playing ground is not equal.
LikeLike
Beth,
I agree. The continuing charter scandals reflect the fact that charter schools are typically unsupervised, unregulated, and unaccountable. That is very different from a public school where the budget is discussed at open public meetings. Criminal acts occur in public schools, but not on the scale we see almost daily in charters. Most states lack the staff to oversee charters. They collect the money and they are on their own, some have even sued to block audits. In Ohio, a charter operator went to court and argued that everything purchased with public funds belong entirely to his corporation. The law didn’t say it didn’t, so the court agreed with him. Everything purchased with public funds belongs to the corporation, not the public.
LikeLike
Pennsylvania’s Governor Wolf has intruduced plans to expose charter schools to more oversight and accountability. The Ed Reform crowd, worried that the “game may be up,” responds with predictable defensiveness:
“We are cautiously optimistic, but the charter community has been burned before, and our honest initial impression is that this may be another effort to undermine school choice in Pennsylvania, regardless of the statements in the press release regarding improving quality and accountability,” said Robert Fayfich, executive director of the Pennsylvania Coalition of Public Charter Schools. “We are anxious to work with [Pennsylvania Department of Education] on this initiative if we are invited to do so, but time will tell the real purpose and value of this new charter office.”
When, I would like to know, has the charter community ever been “burned” before? This is an industry lobbying group. Hopefully, the Dept of Ed has the good sense to keep them at arms’ length!
LikeLike
Rudy: I reject your entire comparative construct here. The thieving charter schools and the lawless heads of the public school districts mentioned above are on the same side. They are both part of the same effort to destroy America’s public school system and replace it with privatized corporate schools run by appointed boards of directors for the benefit of hedge funds and institutional shareholders.
The assault consists (broadly) of two elements:
(1) introduction of charter schools (which much remain relatively unregulated in order to hide where the money truly goes (not to educating students): and
(2) the degradation and destruction of public schools — by:
bleeding them of funding; loading them up with top-down ed reform requirements (common core, and massive high stakes testing run by private companies who cynically manipulate the passing rates and refuse to disclose test questions, research, or scoring models); teacher performance requirements that cause teachers to be fired, students to be flunked, and schools to be closed or privatized, based on those phony test scores, and school administration infiltration by corporatized administrators trained by the Broad Academy and others.
This is like being under assault and, when someone complains that the army is shooting at you, someone points out — well, but the navy is shooting at you too! The bad administrators at the top of the public school systems who are being caught are part of the same corporatization / privatization push as the bad charter school operators. Just a different branch of the same noxious weed. In MOST of these cases, these people are put into positions where they can steal from taxpayers through mayoral or state-wide appointment (turn around districts, districts that mayors have “taken over”, etc). Occasionally, bad things happen in districts that are run by elected schools boards as well — but not the cases cited above.
So while it is true that graft and corruption are caught earlier in public school systems, etc. — it begs the real issue. ALL of these bad actors have their genesis in the poisonous, ruinous corporate ed reform movement.
LikeLike
Many of the charters are shutdown because of financial reasons, because that is easier to spot than shoddy education practices.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Shoddy education practices…” How do you recognize those? Would you call a teacher who is reading his newspaper while the class is asleep guilty of “shoddy education practices?”
Would you call a teacher who manages to show 12 movies in a quarter without a single plan in mind guilty of “shoddy educational practices?”
As before, I see the blame placed squarely in the shoulders of “outsiders.” What kind of self-testing, examination, whatever you want to call it, exists among teachers, ensuring a constant quality control of their “product?”
I hear from home-schoolers, and when I ask the reason as to what made them decide to home-school their children, the quality of teachers is one of the first things that come up, next to environment. And this is from people who were teachers, even one who was once director of Special Education in a school district!
These are honest people. They are not religiously inclined as far as education is concerned. But they DO worry about where the public schools are headed – and have been for decades now!
How DO teachers police themselves?
The evaluator system is not working. After all, the teacher I evaluate today will do the same for me next year.
You can’t use student performance – unless the same teachers have bad results year after year. “Bad groups I understand – but those will draw a line through their entire “career.”
So, dead serious: How do teachers police themselves?
LikeLike
Rudy said: “Would you call a teacher who is reading his newspaper while the class is asleep guilty of “shoddy education practices?””
Oh my gawd!!!!!! What total clap trap. Teachers reading newspapers is so false, so bogus that it’s an insult to one’s intelligence. There is no way that a teacher can sit back and do nothing. A teacher has to be on his/her toes at all times or the class will revert to chaos in a heart beat. Teachers do show educational films/videos but this has to be done sparingly because there is so much material to cover and so much test prep that is imposed on teachers. Rudy, you are a troll.
LikeLike
For the last twenty years, I have been employed by public education. Twenty years ago I moved to this country, and have spent time in each and every class room in the district where I work. During these 20 years, I have seen some great teachers – but I have also seen people who should not be allowed in a class room – and yet, there they are.
The majority of the people I work with every day have had kids in these schools, and as parents, they too have been frustrated beyond belief.
My own kids finished high school in this country, and have their own stories of praise and shock.
Slander is defined as, “to make a false spoken statement that causes people to have a bad opinion of someone.” Eyewitness, however, is a totally different thing. “a person who sees something happen and is able to describe it…”
When I tell you about what I see, on daily basis, I am an eyewitness. When I talk about a teacher who was transferred from school to school, because no one wanted to go through the painful experience of firing the teacher. One principal finally did have the courage – but that was after having worked long enough to retire with a full pension.
When a Social Studies teacher uses the class time to show one video after an other (Not sparingly, as is mentioned elsewhere, but instead of teaching) one has to wonder.
These are exceptions, I KNOW that. But they are allowed to continue, year after year.
Someone wrote that the amount of financial abuse WAS important, and referred to loss for students. Stealing my time (which is what someone does who is hired to perform x task, for x pay) is much more important than money. Money can be replaced, time cannot. Those teachers who fail to do their job stole time from each and every student in these districts. Not only present time, but future time as well.
When teachers fail to prepare their students by failing to teach, they have an impact on their future, as well.
It is experiences like that which are responsible, partially, for charter schools and home schooling. One of our schools WAS run by a education-for-profit company for 15 years. At the end, the outcome was no better after those fifteen years than any f our other schools.
I fully realize that students’ success is not solely caused by bad teaching. As a parent, I have responsibilities for good outcomes as far as education is concerned. And I see how a number of our parents do not live up to their responsibilities as their kids travel through our district.
I believe in education. I have been educated both here and where I came from. I am still learning (After all, in my profession change moves so fast and often). I hold my crew accountable when they fail to do their job correctly. The same should happen in a clear, obvious and impartial way. Unions, seniority – interesting concepts. But when it comes to “doing what is best for education,” both unions and seniority can be immovable objects.
LikeLike
Rudy,
I would like to thank you in advance for ceasing and desisting your slander of my profession. Thank you kindly.
LikeLike
Rudy – first of all, your slam does a disservice in the context of “all public schools”. Certainly doesn’t happen in mine, does it happen in your local district & if not where? 2nd, how oh how does the occasional teacher asleep at the wheel (for surely there must be a few) compare to diverting eight million hard-earned tax dollars to condo, houses, groceries, & airplane??
LikeLike
Wow – what does a Muslim cleric have to do with all of this??
LikeLike
You wrote:
“bethree5
Rudy – first of all, your slam does a disservice in the context of “all public schools”. Certainly doesn’t happen in mine, does it happen in your local district & if not where? 2nd, how oh how does the occasional teacher asleep at the wheel (for surely there must be a few) compare to diverting eight million hard-earned tax dollars to condo, houses, groceries, & airplane??
I did not slam “all public schools…” but as someone responded, it does not only happen where I live and work.
And you don’t think there are charter schools out there which do a great job educating the kids under their care? I am not FOR charter schools. I am for ANY opportunity where a child gets the best possible education, be it home-schooled, public or private, charter.
And those who fail in their assumed responsibility should be held accountable – union, no union,charter, private AND public.
LikeLike
Totally agree with your above post, Rudy. My teaching experience has been only with private schools– long ago, full time for an expensive academy near Syracuse, recently for 15 yrs visiting central-NJ preK’s as a ‘special’. The privates I’ve seen work closely w/sub-par teachers for a year or two then fire them if they still don’t measure up. The preK’s have to do a good job mentoring teachers. They can’t pay much & have to develop people who start w/ few qualifications. And clients will walk quickly, w/ plenty of schools to choose from in our area.
Publics w/ or w/o union teachers are similar to what I experienced in a decade of corporate work. The buck stops w/supervisors & dept heads. If the district keeps on somebody’s inept relative for decades & fires others willy-nilly, good candidates begin to look elsewhere & the pool of qualified applicants shrinks. Obviously the difference is the client can’t easily ‘walk’. To balance that, schools must be managed very locally w/community holding the district’s feet to the fire. Dividing up the community with charters and vouchers makes that impossible.
LikeLike
Rudy,
The examples you give about a bad teacher never teaching are meaningless. There is a means to fire those teachers.
What you seem to be upset about is that there are bad principals who are way too lazy or because the teacher is their friend don’t want to do anything to document his poor performance. Fortunately, there are far fewer bad public school principals (why aren’t you calling for their firing?) than there are very bad charter school principals can hire anyone who will do their bidding and everyone is afraid to report bad behavior because their job is at stake.
Here is the difference: in a public school, if a teacher was doing something even worse than sleeping – like purposely targeting a child of a different race because they didn’t like her lack of academic achievement — any teacher or student who witnessed it could report it without fear of retaliation or losing her job. The union protects the teachers who report bad behavior so it can be reported and stopped.
But in charter schools, everyone is afraid because their jobs are on the line. So bad behavior goes unchecked for years. How is it caught? Maybe an assistant teacher after she tries to report something wrong and her job is threatened actually has the nerve to secretly tape the behavior she has been reporting for months but ignored because that kind of behavior is rewarded if it gets unwanted kids out the door.
And maybe that charter school assistant teacher has the connections to give the video to a NY Times reporter and the reporter isn’t afraid that if she reports it she will lose her job and the behavior that has gone on unchecked for years and years is (maybe going to stop). Or maybe not, since of course, the next teacher who witnesses it will be newly afraid of losing her job.
If oversight depends on terrified teachers whose jobs are at stake having the ability to secretly record bad behavior, then those schools will be far more likely to abuse kids. Which is why most of the long term, always ignored, sexual scandals happened in private schools (a tiny percentage of all schools) instead of public schools. Because it public schools, people aren’t nearly as terrified of rocking the boat when they witness bad behavior.
LikeLike
Means for firing those teachers are blocked, time and again, by union actions.
Most of the sexual scandals over the past few years have taken place at public schools. Check the news.
Bad principals should also be fired – but we were talking about teachers.
We do not accept bad performance in a corporate setting. Why should we accept that in a school setting?
I’m part of the non-bargaining group. Even there, it is ridiculously difficult. We have a probationary period for new hires – but have to travel the same arduous way as if it had been a twenty year employee.
Bad teachers are just as present in public schools as in any other educational environment. Why are you and others on this list so blind to that fact??
Charter schools and private schools can deal with that a lot more efficient and don’t bother me with the “thousands” of teachers being fired for imaginary reasons – that is bad under any circumstance in any work environment. That, too, is the the topic.
LikeLike
If most of the sexual scandals took place at public schools, it is because most students and teachers are in public schools. Duh. But private schools have been beset by sexual scandals that were unreported for decades, but came out. No one said anything for a long time and many kids were molested. Elite schools, Catholic schools.
LikeLike
Oh Yeah, those awful unions protect teachers.
http://www.perdaily.com/2011/01/lausd-et-al-a-national-scandal-of-enormous-proportions-by-susan-lee-schwartz-part-1.html
http://www.perdaily.com/2014/03/lausd-and-utla-collude-to-end-collective-bargaining-and-civil-rights-for-teachers-part-2.html
http://www.perdaily.com/2015/07/lausd-blacklisting-teachers–how-they-do-it.html
http://www.perdaily.com/2015/01/were-you-terminated-or-forced-to-retire-from-lausd-based-on-fabricated-charges.html
In this teacher’s room, we KNOW THE FACTS, that over a hundred thousand teachers across this nation have been sent out the door with no access to civil rights in the workplace, because school systems save $40,000 to $60,000 In the PENSIONS every time they send a teacher packing. Paying pensions began to eat up the entire school budget especially after the GOP decided on austerity, and starved the states, so the first ones to be assaulted were TEACHERS.
Of course, now pensions are under siege in all areas, just like social security, and health services are under attack…nothing for the workers.
Don’t you have something better to do, then to push your nonsense in a PLACE WEHRE TEACHERS KNOW THE REALITY. Go find some social blog where you can rant to all those who thrive on lies. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8bihhjH3nI
LikeLike
Teachers don’t “police themselves”. In public schools, there are layers of oversight. In charter schools and private schools there are not.
That is why there are far more scandals per school in private and charter schools. It’s not even close. The worst abuses that plenty of people knew about but everyone was afraid to speak out have been in non-public schools.
In public schools, the problems could be reported without fear of losing your job. That’s why there have been almost no on-going scandals like we see in private and charter schools where the administration and many people were well aware of the scandal for many years but were scared to speak out.
You can’t point to public schools where everyone was terrified to speak out against an abusive teacher or a financial impropriety. Either it was unknown or it was revealed publicly.
Contrast that with so many sexual scandals at private schools where the parents who complained were said “take your kid out of the school”. No recourse.
Contrast that with teachers abusing children in charter schools where a principal could write a got to go list to a dozen higher ups and the only response is “don’t put that in writing”. Not, stop targeting kids for removal. When a child is targeted, a charter school teacher must surreptitiously videotape it and send to a reporter because that kind of behavior is valued by the charter school. So it will never stop unless somehow the press gets wind of it.
You think it is better to have the only oversight be maybe the charters will be caught out by the media because everyone else is afraid to talk, instead of let’s have union protections and due process so that people can complain of abuse.
That seems so off. Why are you trying to hard to protect bad schools? When there is already a means to get rid of bad teachers and none to get rid of bad schools except hope it becomes a media sensation so that the people who run the bad schools “may” have to stop.
LikeLike
I posted this at Oped News, http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/GUILTY-Online-Charter-Fou-in-Life_Arts-Charter-School-Failure_Charter-Schools_Expose_Guilty-160825-95.html#comment614838
with this comment whichh has embedded links at the post.
The corruption within the charter school INDUSTRY is endemic .
Until Oliver did his thing, except for Bill Moyers on PBS, this is a topic the mainstream media won’t touch. For a thorough and chilling review of ALEC’s plans to privatize education, see ALEC Exposed . ALEC loves charters and vouchers, hates unions, loves profits.
In Atlanta, local NBC channel 11 station did an expose of the secretive far-right group called the American Legislative Exchange Council, ALEC. Under the aegis of ALEC, Georgia legislators met in a posh resort with corporate lawyers to decide their priorities for the next session.
ALEC has model legislation, which legislators introduce into their states. It even has tax credit legislation , similar to the one that Governor Cuomo introduced in New York. It has already been adopted by several states to benefit private and religious schools.
But this is a nation wide conspiracy by the EDUCATIONAL INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX .. and the fraud follows it—see Ohio: Charter School Equipment Belongs to Private Manager, Not the Public | Diane Ravitch’s blog tells us.
Diane Ravich predicted the current disaster for public education years ago. How Not to Fix Our Public Schools and in her book Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America’s Public Schools
As a daily reader of the Diane Ravitch blog, I am watching as thestate legislatures , and like in Texas, appoint businessmen to oversee the schools.
LikeLike
So much fraud going on. So much. http://legalclips.nsba.org/?s=charter+schools
And for so long.
Thank you Diane, again and again, for all you do.
LikeLike
THANKS, Diane! Love this one. Charter schools exist because of the oligarchy.
Both the DEMS and GOP love charters, as does Obama and his unholy cabinet. This tells me something…PAYOLA.
LikeLike
The State and Federal authorities should audit ALL on-line charter schools. I’ll bet that more and more would be found to be in the same guilty boat as the Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School.
LikeLike
Just think of $100 million sloshing around every year! What can you do with it?
LikeLike
Liar loans and now virtual students for virtual schools. The evolution of large scale societal grift.
LikeLike
Is there somewhere to short charter schools? It’s a house of cards built on lies.
LikeLike
It’s not just the embezzlement and fraud of charter scams (I hereby refuse to call them schools), it’s the winked-at segregation. It’s the inequality in addition to the deregulation. And it’s Fetullah Gulen too. He needs to be extradited and his “donations” to charter scam loving foundations confiscated.
LikeLike
This is your taxpayer dollars – people ! Wake up ! You know that chunk of money they take off your paycheck and when you buy something and your property tax? It is your money going into the grubby greedy hands of these swindlers. Oh – you do not want regulation getting in the way of your ‘freedom’ ? Yeah – let them take all they want. Think about it – it needs to stop. Someone woke up and saw it did not work with prisons – let us do the same for our schools and stop the money grab.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Network Schools – Wayne Gersen and commented:
John Oliver featured PA in his segment with the stae’s AG calling it’s charter law the worst in the country… And this is one example of the consequences….
LikeLike
It is fashionable in these pages to prominently display charter school fraud and ignore all others. But fraud is in all sectors and aspects of life.
Here is some documentation on school (public and charter) fraud: It may be a partial list. It is from the US Department of Education website.
Source: http://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/oig/ireports.html
Calendar Year 2015
• Former CHARTER SCHOOL Director Sentenced to 42 Months for Embezzling Government Funds. Columbia, SC., August 26, 2015
• Five SCHOOL Bus Owners Indicted For Bid-Rigging And Fraud Conspiracies At Puerto Rico PUBLIC SCHOOL Bus Auction. San Juan, PR., May 21, 2015
Canton Couple Sent to Prison for $2.3 Million Student Loan Fraud. Canton, OH., March 11, 2015
• Former CHARTER SCHOOL Principal Sentenced in Connection with MCAS Cheating Scheme. Boston, MA., January 09, 2015
Calendar Year 2014
• Former Detroit PUBLIC SCHOOL Teacher Sentenced On Fraud And Money Laundering Charges. Detroit, MI., May 06, 2014
• Niles-Based Education Firms and Executives Indicted in Alleged $33 Million Fraud; Bribes Allegedly Paid to Four SCHOOL Officials. Chicago, IL., April 28, 2014
• Former Executive Director of Public CHARTER SCHOOL Sentenced to Nine Months in Prison For Stealing $29,000 in Funds. Washington, DC., April 24, 2014
• Georgia Woman Sentenced for Student Loan Fraud Scheme. Madison, WI., April 15, 2014
• Manhattan U.S. Attorney Announces Lawsuit And $2 Million Civil Settlement With Academic Advantage, And Civil And Criminal Charges Against Former Academic Advantage Employees, In Scheme To Defraud Federal Government Into Paying For Tutoring Services That Were Never Provided. New York, NY., April 15, 2014
• Former Beaumont ISD Employees Guilty of Stealing over $4 million. Beaumont, TX., April 14, 2014
• More Convictions in Relation to Progreso Bribery Case. Houston TX., April 09, 2014
• Provider Of Services For Special Needs PreSCHOOL Students Pleads Guilty In Manhattan Federal Court To Fraud Charge. New York, NY., March 07, 2014
• San Leandro Man Sentenced to 27 Months In Prison for Student Aid Fraud Scheme. Sacramento, CA., February 27, 2014
• Former President Of Galiano Career Academy Sentenced For Theft Of Federal Funds, Obstruction Of A Federal Audit, And Aggravated Identity Theft. Orlando, FL., February 25, 2014
• Four Montgomery Residents Sentenced for Conspiracy to Defraud the United States Department of Education. Montgomery , AL., February 24, 2014
• Three Defendants Plead Guilty In Federal Student Aid Fraud Scheme. Oakland, CA., February 18, 2014
• Two Sentenced to Prison for Student Loan Fraud Schemes. Sacramento, CA., February 06, 2014
• Former District of Columbia SCHOOLs Compliance Officer Pleads Guilty to Wire Fraud and Conflict-of-Interest Charges. Washington , DC., January 23, 2014
• Millcreek Township SCHOOL District Agrees to Pay Government $350,000 to Resolve Allegation of Improper Medicaid Reimbursement . Millcreek Township, PA., January 21, 2014
Calendar Year 2013
• Former Detroit PUBLIC SCHOOLs Accountant Sentenced On Fraud And Money Laundering Charges. Detroit, MI., December 18, 2013
• Former Greenville, MS SCHOOL District Superintendent Sentenced to 76 Months for Receiving Bribes. Oxford, MS., November 14, 2013
• Indictment Unsealed Charging Three Midwest City Women with Conspiracy to Defraud OKC SCHOOLs Tutoring Program. Oklahoma City, OK., August 26, 2013
• Texas-Based SCHOOL Chain to Pay Government $3.7 Million for Submitting False Claims for Federal Student Financial Aid. Dallas, TX., August 22, 2013
• Head of CHARTER SCHOOL Pleads Guilty To Fraud. Philadelphia, PA., August 13, 2013
• Manhattan U.S. Attorney Announces $1.7 Million Settlement With Testquest, $2.3 Million Judgment Against Former Testquest Manager, And Filing Of Criminal And Civil Charges Against PUBLIC SCHOOL Teacher In Connection With Scheme To Defraud Federal Government Into Paying For Tutoring Services That Were Never Provided. New York, NY., August 09, 2013
• Former Detroit PUBLIC SCHOOLs Accountant, Teacher Found Guilty Of Fraud And Money Laundering Charges. Detroit, MI., August 5, 2013
• Federal Judge in El Paso Sentences New York Businessman for Role in Scheme to Defraud the El Paso Independent SCHOOL District. El Paso, TX., July 31, 2013
• Former Pennsylvania CHARTER SCHOOL Operator Pleads Guilty To Federal Income Tax Fraud. Mount Pocono, PA., June 13, 2013
• Former Accounting Employee Pleads Guilty To Stealing More Than $75,000 From CHARTER SCHOOL. Washington, DC., June 10, 2013
• For-Profit SCHOOL in Texas to Pay United States up to $2.5 Million for Allegedly Submitting False Claims for Federal Student Financial Aid. Abilene, TX., May 31, 2013
• Former Pontiac SCHOOLs Associate Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer Sentenced to 12 Months in Federal Prison. Detroit, MI., April 17, 2013
• Two Former Executives of Athletic Equipment Company Admit Extensive Fraud on New Jersey SCHOOLs. Newark, N.J., April 02, 2013
• Former Pennsylvania CHARTER SCHOOL Operator Charged With Federal Income Tax Fraud. Mount Pocono, PA., March 26, 2013
• Investigation of Alleged Test Cheating at D.C. PUBLIC SCHOOLs PDF (2.77M)
Calendar Year 2012
• Beauty SCHOOL Owner And Son Sentenced In Manhattan Federal Court For Educational Grant Fraud. New York, NY., December 17, 2012
• Former River Rouge SCHOOL Official Convicted of Bribery. Southfirld. MI., November 15, 2012
• Former Pontiac SCHOOLs Executive Pleads Guilty to Defrauding a SCHOOL District Receiving Federal Funding. Boomfield. MI., October 09, 2012
• Former Ira Independent SCHOOL District Superintendent Sentenced to 14 Months in Federal Prison on Mail Fraud Conviction. Lubbock, TX., August 31, 2012
• Former Greenville PUBLIC SCHOOLs Superintendent Pleads Guilty. Oxford, MS., August 02, 2012
• MET SCHOOL Employee Pleads Guilty to Embezzling Federal Funds. Providence, R.I., July 30, 2012
• CHARTER SCHOOL Founder Charged In $6 Million Fraud Scheme. Philadelphia, PA., July 24, 2012
• CHARTER SCHOOL’s Former Board President and Former CEO are Sentenced for Fraud Scheme. Philadelphia, PA., July 13, 2012
• Former Assistant Superintendent of Polk County SCHOOL Board Sentenced for Bribery Conspiracy. Tampa, FL., April 26, 2012
• CHARTER SCHOOL’s Former Board President Admits to Fraud Scheme. Philadelphia, PA., April 03, 2012
• Former El Centro SCHOOL Superintendent Pleads Guilty To More Than $325,000 in Federal Grant Fraud. San Diego, CA., March 12, 2012
• Former Pontiac SCHOOLs Assistant Superintendent Indicted for Taking District Funds and Money Laundering. Bloomfield Hills, MI., March 06, 2012
• Former Detroit PUBLIC SCHOOLs Accountant, Teacher Indicted on Fraud and Money Laundering Charge. Detriot, MI., February 01, 2012
• Former CEO of CHARTER SCHOOL Pleads Guilty To Fraud. Philadelphia, PA., January 20, 2012
Calendar Year 2011
• Waterloo Man Pleads Guilty To Financial Aid Fraud. Waterloo, IA., December 22, 2011
• Former Charles County PUBLIC SCHOOL Employee Sentenced to Prison for Theft Scheme. Greenbelt, MD., Decemver 16, 2011
• Four Former Jefferson Parish PUBLIC SCHOOL Board Employees Sentenced For Embezzlement Scheme. New Orleans, LA., Decemver 7, 2011
• Butler County Woman Fraudulently Obtained SCHOOL Loans. Pittsburgh, PA., November 30, 2011
• Four Former Jefferson Parish PUBLIC SCHOOL Board Employees Plead Guilty in Scheme to Embezzle Education Program Funds. New Orleans, LA., August 24, 2011
• U.S. Files Complaint Against Education Management Corp. Alleging False Claims Act Violations. Washington, DC., August 08, 2011
• $1.6 Million Settlement Agreement Announced with Chi Institute for Alleged Failures to Comply with Federal Student Aid Requirements. Philadelphia, PA., July 22, 2011
• Former Jefferson Parish PUBLIC SCHOOL Board Employee Pleads Guilty To Conspiring To Embezzle Education Program Funds. New Orleans, LA., July 14, 2011
• Former Charles County PUBLIC SCHOOL Employee Pleads Guilty to Theft Scheme. Greenbelt, MD., June 07, 2011
• OIG Statement on Execution of Search Warrant in Stockton, California
• Two Former Executives of Athletic Equipment Company Charged With Extensive Fraud on New Jersey SCHOOLs. Newark NJ., May 11, 2011
• The Former Superintendent of Glendale, PA SCHOOL District Pleads Guilty to Federal Program Theft. Johnstown PA., May 09, 2011
• Board President and Chief Executive Officer of Philadelphia CHARTER SCHOOL Charged with Fraud. Philadelphia PA., April 14, 2011
Calendar Year 2010
• A Former Polk County SCHOOL Board Administrator and Executive Vice President of M.M. Parrish Construction Co. Indicted for Conspiracy to Commit Bribery and Robbery. Tampa, FL., December 10, 2010
• Former El Centro Elementary SCHOOL District Superintendent and Two Former San Diego State University Professors Indicted. San Diego, CA., 11/30/2010
• Former Clerk of Montgomery County SCHOOL Board Pleads Guilty . Roanoke VA., 10/04/2010
• Federal Officials Announce the Sentencing of a Former Member of the Wilkes-Barre Area SCHOOL District Board of Education. Harrisburg, PA., June 28, 2010
• Employee Sentenced to 5 Years in Federal Prison for Theft of Funds from Langston Hughes Academy CHARTER SCHOOL. New Orleans, LA., May 27, 2010
• Former VATTEROTT Director Sentenced For Financial AID Fraud KC SCHOOL Received $362,000 in Federal AID For Ineligible Students. Kansas City, MO., April 23, 2010
• Former Orleans Parish SCHOOL Board President Sentenced to 18 Months in Federal Prison. New Orleans, LA., March 11, 2010
• Former SCHOOL Board President’s Daughter Sentenced. New Orleans, LA., March 11, 2010
• Federal Grand Jury Returns Third Superseding Indictment Against Mose Jefferson and Renee Gill Pratt. New Orleans, LA., March 05, 2010
• Management Information Report-CHARTER SCHOOL Vulnerabilities. (Date Issued: 03/09/2010)
• CHARTER SCHOOL Employee Pleads Guilty to Theft of Over $600,000 from SCHOOL. New Orleans, LA., February 25, 2010
• Former Pittston Area SCHOOL Board Member Sentenced. Hughestown, PA., February 01, 2010
• Bill of Information Charging SCHOOL Employee With Theft of Funds from Langston Hughes Academy CHARTER SCHOOL. New Orleans, LA., January 29, 2010
Calendar Year 2009
• Former Board President Sentenced in CHARTER SCHOOL Fraud Case. Philadelphia, PA., December 15, 2009
• Vocational SCHOOL Employee Admits Making False Statements. Boston, MA., December 11, 2009
• Former CEO of CHARTER SCHOOL Sentenced to 37 Months on Fraud, Theft and Tax Charges. Philadelphia, PA., October 22, 2009
• Federal Officials Announce the Filling of a Criminal Iddictment Charging a Current Member of the Wilkes-Barre Area SCHOOL District Board of Education with Conspiracy. Harrisburg, PA, September 15, 2009
• Central Coast Woman Indicted in Scheme to Defraud U.S. by Submitting Application with Forged Signatures for $35 Million in Grants for After-SCHOOL Programs. Riverside, CA, September 3, 2009
• Former President Of Proprietary SCHOOL Sentenced to 18 Months in Prison. Philadelphia, PA, April 10, 2009
Calendar Year 2008
• Former President of Sports Equipment Company that Serviced SCHOOL Districts Nationwide Pleads Guilty to Fraud. Newark, NJ, December 22, 2008
• PSJA ISD Trustee Pleads Guilty in Bribery Scheme. McAllen, TX , November 03, 2008
• Two Former CHARTER SCHOOL Execs Plead Guilty to Embezzling SCHOOL Funds. Philadelphia, PA , October 22, 2008
• United States Reaches $1,750,000 Settlement with the District of Columbia to Resolve Allegations Regarding Fraudulent Misuse of Federal Grant Funds by the District of Columbia PUBLIC SCHOOLs Washington, DC, September 12, 2008
• El Paso Independent SCHOOL District Ttustee Indicted El Paso, TX, August 29, 2008
• Former Dallas Independent SCHOOL District (DISD) Executive and Houston Businessman Convicted in Federal Corruption Trial Dallas, TX, July 10, 2008
• Former Director of Internal Audit for the District of Columbia PUBLIC SCHOOLs sentenced to prison for theft of federal funds. Washington, DC, May 7, 2008
• Two Former Orleans Parish SCHOOL Board Employees Sentenced To Federal Prison. New Orleans, LA, February 20, 2008
Calendar Year 2007
• Former top District CHARTER SCHOOLs official sentenced to prison for embezzlement, kickbacks, and tax evasion. Washington, DC, November 29, 2007
• Pair Indicted in California CHARTER SCHOOL Investigation. San Bernardino, CA, September 4, 2007
• Former Top D.C. CHARTER SCHOOLs Official Pleads Guilty to Embezzlement and Tax Evasion. Washington, DC, August 9, 2007
• Former DISD Employee Sentenced To 12 Months In Federal Prison. Dallas, TX, August 9, 2007
• SCHOOL President Sentenced in Department of Education Loan Fraud Scheme. Miami, Fl, August 2, 2007
• Former Director of Admissions of Touro College, former Director of the Computer Center of Touro College, three students of Touro College, as well as three New York PUBLIC SCHOOL teachers indicted. New York, NY, July 16, 2007
• Federal Grand Jury Indicts Former Dallas Independent SCHOOL District (DISD) Executives on Conspiracy, Money Laundering, Bribery and Obstruction of Justice Charges. Dallas, TX, May 29, 2007
• Former Official with LAUSD Arrested in Fraud Scheme in which He Authorized Large Purchase of Book He Wrote. Los Angeles, CA, March 2, 2007
Calendar Year 2006
• Grand Jury Returns 47-Count Indictment Charging Layton Couple with Alleged Scheme to Defraud Davis SCHOOL District of More Than $4 Million. Salt Lake City, UT, November 22, 2006
• Former State SCHOOL Superintendent Linda Schrenko Sentenced to Eight Years in Federal Prison. Atlanta, GA, July 12, 2006
• Elementary SCHOOL Principal Convicted of Embezzlement. Baltimore, MD, June 15, 2006
• Schrenko Co-Defendant Botes Found Guilty By Jury After Schrenko Pleads Guilty, Temple Re-Arrested and Jailed. Atlanta, GA, May 24, 2006
• CHARTER SCHOOL Owners Sentenced for Defrauding SCHOOL to Pay for Lavish Lifestyle. Minneapolis, MN, May 24, 2006
• Another Former Orleans Parish SCHOOL Employee Pleads Guilty in Federal Courts. New Orleans, LA, May 17, 2006
• Former Philadelphia CHARTER SCHOOL Principal Charged With Fraud. Philadelphia, PA, March 21, 2006
Calendar Year 2005
• Former Deputy Under Secretary for Safe and Drug Free SCHOOLs With The Department of Education Pleads Guilty. Washington, DC, April 29, 2005
• Former Deputy State SCHOOL, Superintendent Pleads Guilty to Funneling State Money to Schrenko Campaign. Atlanta, GA, January 10, 2005
Calendar Year 2004
• Federal Grand Jury Indicts Eleven in Orleans Parish SCHOOLs Corruption Investigation.
• Former EL PASO SCHOOL Administrators Indicted. (PDF 75K) Texas, October 22, 2004
• Prepared Table CHARTER SCHOOL Officials Indicted. Houston, TX, July 1, 2004
• Harvey SCHOOLs chief gets jail term for fraud. Chicago, May 13, 2004
• Working group to review and investigate alleged criminal violations involving the New Orleans PUBLIC SCHOOLs (HOPS). New Orleans, April 19, 2004
• Harvey SCHOOL Board President Guilty Of Financial Aid Fraud. Chicago, March 11, 2004
• Convictions obtained in scheme to divert two Department of Education grants totaling S1.9 million meant for SCHOOL districts in South Dakota, which money was then used to buy expensive SUVs and other items. Washington, DC, February 3, 2004
• SCHOOL Administrator Guilty of Federal Grant Fraud. Madison, WI, January 14, 2004
Calendar Year 2003
• Former employee sentenced to 6 months in prison for her role in stealing from the Department of Education. Washington, DC, December 18, 2003
•
Calendar Year 2002
• Indictment for Stealing $163,000 from the Dept. of Education. Washington, DC, September 17, 2002
LikeLike
Raj,
Lack of oversight encourages fraud.
When those who are free to use public money without oversight handle millions of dollars, the frauds get very large.
I don’t know of any case where a public school principal was arrested and pled guilty to the theft of $8 million (Nicholas Trombetta) and June Brown ($6 million).
If you do, please let me know.
LikeLike
Once again, the amount of money should not matter. Building secretaries have stolen tens of thousands of dollars before it is discovered. Funds are misused in travel expenses etc. on a regular basis – in public schools.
LikeLike
And so we should give over schooling to charters which are opaque and lack regulation?
LikeLike
What makes you jump to that conclusion????
It’s the same when I point out that yes, there are bad teachers – people jump to the conclusion that I hate teachers.
I will gladly acknowledge that there are bad employees in our district who are not teachers.
I was a preacher for twenty years, and will gladly acknowledge there are bad preachers.
I spent eight years as a contract chaplain with the us Air Force, and gladly acknowledge there are bad chaplains.
But those are not the topic of conversation on this list, are they?
LikeLike
WHAT THE FU$# ARE YOU SAYING.
There is no comparison… talk about False qequivilancies.
LikeLike
Language, language!
The point is: fraud is just as easy in a public service. But few districts file complaints. For obvious reasons.
LikeLike
her principal, seeing no consequences set her up so that a student would sexually assault her.
Lawless America “Cold Interview” – YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bGMBKF2UMq4&feature=em-share_video_user
Here is language for you… you are either an ignoramus of enormous proportion to say what you do here, or a GOP troll who actually believes the BIG CON the party sells.
LikeLike
“Hundreds of thousands of teachers…” are financially cheated… Charter schools, in 2014, employed 72,000 teachers, as compared with 3.1 million public school teachers.
So I am trying my best to find those “hundreds of thousands” teachers who are cheated financially.
When I started work here, 59% of the teachers would retire within the next ten years. Two rounds of early retirements were offered (Not forced, but voluntary). Was there a financial motive? Of course there was. With 30 years of experience the average salary in our district was $65k. Fresh out of school teachers cost 34,440. So yes, from a financial point of view it makes sense.
None of these teachers were chased away to short them financially.
Still looking for those “hundreds of thousands of teachers…” it is obvious that this is not about the charter schools, either. Unless they have such a roll-over of teachers that they do not teach more than a day a week.
LikeLike
Rudy,
So teachers in their Rolls-Royces are making out like bandits?
Rudy, this is a site that exists to support teachers and public schools. Go to one of the right wing blogs where your contempt for teachers will be welcomed.
LikeLike
Rudy,
So teachers in their Rolls-Royces are making out like bandits?
Rudy, this is a site that exists to support teachers and public schools. Go to one of the right wing blogs where your contempt for teachers will be welcomed.
LikeLike
You keep talking about ‘teachers’ in such a negative way, but I grasp how poorly you understand what has occurred. It is not your fault… it is the norm in this nation with its almost SIXTEEN THOUSAND SEPARATE SCHOOL SYSTEMS.
SORRY your ability to discover the truth about the war on teachers. I put this up at Oped often and here, often enough… because this is the reality.
From LAUSD to New York City Public School and everything in between: A NATIONAL SCANDAL OF EPIC PROPORTIONS by Susan Lee Schwartz Part 1′ : http://www.perdaily.com/2011/01/lausd-et-al-a-national-scandal-of-enormous-proportions-by-susan-lee-schwartz-part-1.html
Today, Dan Geery, an editor at Oped News: http://www.opednews.com/author/author1198.html
and a man who ran for Utah Senate , felt compelled to add his comment: .
YOU can FIND his comment there, but here is a copy to help you to realize that ehe schools were emptied, over 2 decades of almost ALL the experienced TEACHER-PRACTIONERS.
Dan Geery writes:
“Everything I see here is 100% consistent with what I’ve seen and experienced. For the short, personal version see this URL” http://endteacherabuse.org/Geery.html
“I consider myself a canary in the cage–or was, anyway–given that I was speaking out in the mid to late eighties about what’s right for kids.”
“Here’s my political site, that I’ve left up http://www.voteutah.us
.
You can see what I consider SHOULD be the focus of what we humans are doing, namely putting kids first. To see what is being actually done makes me ill (for a bio regarding my teaching and some related items, go to “Biography” on the above site and look in the upper left for “Recommendations,” namely how other educators perceived me).
See, I can help you a little to ‘get it’ but I doubt that any thing like facts will get in the way of what is your worldview, etched in stone.
http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/The-Age-of-Post-Truth-Poli-in-Life_Arts-Democracy_Donald-Trump-Lies_Lies_Media-Lies-160824-370.html
LikeLike
Diane,
My list is just a tip of the iceberg.
You believe that consistent fraud by public school officials/educators over the years is small and should not be disclosed and simply forgotten. You are obsessed in putting down charter schools and are willing to forgive all transgressions of pubic schools educators, officials and elected representatives.
History tells us that every new fraud discovered will be bigger than the previous one.
But fraud is fraud. Fraud simply hurts children, their parents and finally the tax paying public.
Let me take this little farther with a single example. Remember there are many more documented facts similar to this one with monetary value or psychological value.
LAUSD is a public school district. You state that “Lack of oversight encourages fraud.” LAUSD has oversight by democratically elected board members, therefore it does not suffer from lack of oversight as per your understanding. But LAUSD has paid over $300 million and counting to the parents whose children were the victims of a few teachers.
Would you agree that there is something wrong with all sectors of education, whether public or charter?
LikeLike
Raj,
There is something wrong with people who steal from children, no matter where they work.
The opportunities for theft and fraud are larger in the charter industry because they are largely unsupervised. That’s the main difference between public schools and charter schools. Public schools are regulated, supervised, and audited. Charter schools are not. Some crooked people in public schools evade the supervision. The odds of corruption are far greater when there is no supervision.
Have you found a school system where a principal stole $8 million? That happened in Pennsylvania at a cyber charter pulling in $100 million a year with no supervision. Another cyber charter founder was found guilty of stealing $6 million. Where is the comparable case in public schools?
LikeLike
Thanks for posting, Raj.
Were you aware that a large percentage of the fraud that you have listed comes from charter schools? When we consider the number of charter schools (about 7%) compared to the number of traditional public schools (the rest), that’s an extremely hefty percentage of charter fraud out there. That’s pretty damning evidence. In addition, the closer one gets to our current date, it appears that the frequency of charter school scandals increases (or perhaps our knowledge of them does).
I know that you have only listed a small sample, but if it is simply representative of the larger set, it is quite telling that something needs to be done with the laws regarding charter schools (and with student loans).
LikeLike
TheMorrigan
Partially agreed, Charter schools have a greater share of fraud but not by much. My detailed analysis shows that.
I tend to look at the whole dataset not just cherry pick charters. If I add other (strange behavior of public school teachers/employees) the list becomes excessively large and defies comprehension. This stuff is available for anyone to see.
Diane still is unable to accept the fact that public schools also are involved in fraud and extremely poor behavior leading to large financial losses to the school districts. These financial and moral losses are staggering as compared to the fraud by the charters.
One needs to be more careful in judging others.
LikeLike
Raj,
If you can’t see that deregulation facilitates fraud, let me suggest you see the Academy Award winning documentary “Inside Job,” about the collapse of the global economy in 2008. It might open your eyes.
LikeLike
And there was absolutely no bias on the side of the makers of that documentary. It was as impartial as Fahrenheit 911.
Again, I am against people defrauding – no matter who the defrauder or the defrauded ones are. I am also against biased opinions. These have a habit of not being bothered by such irrelevant things as facts.
And, with all due respect, you are biased. Your opinion is yours, and you have every right to it. You have a career in education behind you, at different levels. I applaud you for that. That does not, however, mean that your opinions are always based on an overabundance of impartial facts.
It’s easy to point fingers – after the fact, with hindsight – and usually with bias. I have lived 1/3 of my life in this country, and have from the very beginning been surprised as to how quickly people believe the negative, without looking for facts themselves. In politics, in religion, in trade…
And when more facts become available (which then proves the original to be incorrect), few people are then willing to admit they were wrong.
Case in point: Ferguson shooting was PROVEN by all levels of law enforcement to be a justified shooting. But still people list it among the “innocently shot…”
On this list, you railed against the financial abuses in charter schools (and rightly so) but when I started with the FACT that public school is far from unblemished, I was ‘shouted down.’ Until a list is posted, which shows the facts.
There are bad teachers (and we have had that subject discussed earlier), and I am told I hate teachers. Someone else on this list also commented that yes, there are such things as bad teachers. I listed some examples based on 20 years of experience in a school district. But I have to stop “slandering…” Should I even mention those teachers (male and female) of sexual intimacy between teachers and students…
LikeLike
Rudy,
I did not shout you down. I am sorry you consider me biased. In every institution, public or private, there is the possibility of fraud. When there is no oversight or regulation, the opportunity for fraud grows larger. Charter schools by their nature are deregulated and unsupervised. Charter leaders handle millions of dollars with no one watching. That is not true in public schools. Are public schools perfect? Of course not.
And by the way, I reject your contention that “Inside Job,” which won the Academy Award, was biased. Where did you get that from? I thought it was careful, non-sensational, and well documented. Did you see it?
LikeLike
I am still waiting for you or Raj to give me an example of a public school where the principal stole $8 million, as Trombetta did.
LikeLike
Once again, the amount is not important. The fact that such theft is possible in both charter and public school is what matters. It is not a unique issue to charter schools.
LikeLike
Sorry, Rudy, there is a difference between stealing $8 million from the public and stealing $800. No public school official, no teacher, no principal ever has complete discretion over school funds. There are district, city and state auditors.
Compare that with charter operators like Nick Trombetta, who had control of $100 million a year.
LikeLike
no surprise that school districts are as vulnerable to fraud as the private sector or any other segment of government. Crimes in districts include collusion with outside vendors who provide kickbacks to employees, misuse of district-issued credit cards, embezzlement of district funds, and theft of district property.
“There is no national data on fraud in school districts. But, says Don Mullinax, a former inspector general in the Los Angeles Unified School District, “I think there is a lot more than administrators are aware of because they’re not looking for it, and if you’re not looking, you’re not going to find it until it hits you.” He now leads the government practice team of Forensic/Strategic Solutions, a forensic accounting firm that has worked with districts including Wake County and LAUSD. Most district leaders lack ways to uncover it, and when it is found, it’s not always reported, he says. “What’s scary is that a lot of administrators and principals figure that’s not their job,” Mullinax says. “They are hired to be educators, and they don’t have a background in financial management or accounting or auditing, so they don’t focus on fraud. They wouldn’t see it if it walks up and hits them in the face.”
https://www.districtadministration.com/article/fighting-fraud-schools-0
LikeLike
Come on, Rudy. Name a public school principal who stole $8 million like Trombetta. You are changing the subject.
LikeLike
I’m not changing the subject. I’m showing you that financial fraud exists in school districts, from a school administrators source.
And yet again, the AMOUNT DOES NOT MATTER. it is the ACT that matters.
LikeLike
Rudy,
The amount matters. But then I suppose you believe in giving equal punishment to the man who steals a loaf of bread and the man who steals $8 million. The same act!
LikeLike
We are not talking about stealing bread. You maintain that public schools are “safe” from predators (financial). I wholeheartedly disagree.
I believe that ripping off a public school of 1000s of $ is no different than a charter school.
Let me tell you about a public employee from Dixon, IL. she ripped off this little town to the amount of FIFTY THREE MILLION over twenty or so years. Audits and everything.
LikeLike
Rudy, the auditor must have been her husband. I never said that public schools have no crime. I said that lack of oversight encourages fraud. It is fairly simple logic.
LikeLike
Oh, by the way,
Your example of LAUSD is not an example of fraud or theft. Perhaps the settlement was too high or perhaps you are arguing that LAUSD shouldn’t have paid those families a settlement (that, instead, they should have fought them in civil court all the way to the end). Or perhaps you are arguing that that is money being wasted. Or perhaps you were talking about those teachers who committed felonies and not fraud. But whatever the case, there was no deception here on the part of the money being paid out to those families. I personally do not like the whole situation and I can’t honestly say someone benefits from anything that happened in these cases, but the $300 million is not an example of lacking democratic oversight nor is it an example of fraud.
LikeLike
Hey Raj and Morrigan and anyone who does not realize what is actually happening
Serously. Deception? Hmmm, It is astonishing to hear those, like Raj, who are really ‘uninformed’ ( truly ignorant, i.e clueless– have no information about the tens of thousands of teaches who were sent packing on fabricated charges…. a subject that has been documented and chronicled for a DECADE HERE.
http://www.perdaily.com/2015/01/were-you-terminated-or-forced-to-retire-from-lausd-based-on-fabricated-charges.html
and http://www.perdaily.com/2014/03/lausd-continues-to-target-teachers.html
http://www.perdaily.com/2014/02/
and http://www.perdaily.com/2014/07/former-ctc-attorney-kathleen-carroll-lays-out-unholy-alliance-between-union-and-public-education-pri.html
I have covered the LAUSD swamp in my series here.
http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/FINALLY-TARGETED-TEACHERS-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Agenda_America_Corporate_Corruption-150708-830.html#comment553842
Then there is the FACT, that collective bargaining is the onLY way for a teacher to defend civil rights and thus the UNIONS do not protect teachers, but have aided the breaking got tenure.
http://www.perdaily.com/2014/03/lausd-and-utla-collude-to-end-collective-bargaining-and-civil-rights-for-teachers-part-2.html
Going to court is out of the question in most cases.
Here is a site that will give you an insight to the war on teachers,
http://endteacherabuse.org and help everyone to know WHY THE KATHLEEN CARROLL, THE VERGARA AND THE RAFE EXQUITH CASES ARE SO IMPORTANT!
GOING TO COURT, FOR A TEACHER>>>takes years!
The school systems with their CADRES of attorneys DELAY– so that a teacher –even one who wins (like this one did): http://blog.ebosswatch.com/2013/05/one-womans-legal-fight-against-workplace-bullying/
They end up spending years… AND ALL THEIR SAVINGS… EVEN IF ONE CAN GET AN ATTORNEY!
Most attorneys won’t even touch a teacher’s civil complain, for a variety reasons, often that they have ties to the system itself.
Meanwhile teachers face this… which Portelos is still fighting IN COURT, TODAY.
FOLLOW HIM ON FACEBOOK
http://www.endteacherabuse.org/Portelos.html
http://protectportelos.org/does-workplace-bullying-continues-my-33-hrs-behind-bars/
http://protectportelos.org/the-david-pakter-saga-an-all-too-familiar-of-a-story/
David Pkter won, spend half a million to do it, and years of his life in his sixties.
He won but the media only tells about the bad teachers, not this astonishing, talented man who was the NYC mayor’s pick for the top award. David brought in a plant, and the principal charge him with insubordination…out he went… into the rubber room, cause the y GOT HIM. http://nycrubberroomreporter.blogspot.com/2009/03/gotcha-squad-and-new-york-city-rubber.html
So, when I listen to the arguments I realize how hard it will be to get teachers to stand up and say TEACHER’S CIVIL RIGHTS MATTER
LikeLike
Diane Ravitch,
You may have a long wait for me to come up with the public school principal who cheated exactly $8 million dollars. You and I know it is a mathematical impossibility to find such an instance. It is not the point.
But take a look at the prison sentences that were given to the charter school principals/operators/folk and then compare them to the prison sentences given to public school administrators/principals and or elected officials. In my judgement a duly appointed judge has looked at a lot more information than available to me or you and passed the judgement which in this land of ours is the final say. Prison sentences are the best metric we have on fraud.
You will notice, first of all that prison sentences are not proportional to the monetary value of the fraud. As I said before, a fraud is a fraud. If you are willing to listen and dig deep into each instance of fraud I listed from a reliable source you will be able to see the virtue of my analysis.
One who does not use his/her analytical ability to the fullest extent to judge others is lost in his/her own quagmire and shouldn’t sit in judgement of others.
The operation of charter schools is supervised by the school district that authorized it in most cases or some other authority designated by a duly elected peoples representatives. I believe in many cases they are not managed well or managed at all, as evidenced by the poor performance of on line charters.
You must remember that charter schools operate under a death penalty clause which the public schools do not have. Charters can be closed, but public schools cannot be shutdown. You have claimed before that a public school was killed by budget cuts or a charter schools. Public school was shutdown but never killed and the reasons are many.
Finally, you rail against Success Academy, What about all the failing public schools, the bottom 5% or 10% or more. Do you think that these “Failure Academies (forgive me for my interpretation)” should continue without any external input from the citizenry via their democratically elected state legislators because the local elected school board has failed in their task?
Remember there are over 13,000 public school districts in the USA and many are managed well, but many are pawns of the teachers union, a perfect example being LAUSD. The teachers and administrators have reached a entitlement mentality. Remember you get what you deserve, but are entitled to nothing other than air.
Change is painful, but is a necessary evil. Status quo is what got us to this unmanageable state.
LikeLike
Raj,
You are full of it, whatever it is.
Where did you get the zany idea that public schools can’t be closed? Rahm Emanuel closed 50 in one day. Did you not know that? Dozens of public schools were closed in nuclear and replaced by charters that are free to choose the students they want and kick out the ones they don’t.
Name a public school official who stole $8 million. Or $5 million.
There are grifters in every field, but in public schools, they get audited.
Why are you so angry at public schools? Did you attend one? Was a teacher mean to you?
LikeLike
Let’s just keep it simple and focus on fraud, since strange behavior is not indicative of single sets of people nor groups nor life in general (who doubts that?), and while slightly related, it has nothing to do with fraud nor anything else to do with this article. Let’s keep focus, eh?
And, while I haven’t read everything you or Diane have written, I have never gotten the impression that she refuses “to accept the fact that public schools also are involved in fraud and extremely poor behavior leading to large financial losses to the school districts.” That’s a huge leap to say that. Her own posts on this page implicitly argue against that position. There’s no invincible ignorance here.
You probably should take your own message to heart: “One needs to be more careful in judging others.”
LikeLike
Diane,
Yes, I attended one of the greatest public school in the world, the University of California at Berkeley.
Yes every one knows public schools are closed sometimes, because student population is reduced in that area and a new school is opened where the student population has increased. The public school closings are mostly related to demographics not performance. Sometimes the infra structure is so old and bad it is cheaper to demolish the old school building and build a new one in its place. On rare occasions attempts were made to close a public school for lack of performance and it has been an utter disaster.
The records show that over the past 20 years about 30,000 public schools were closed but the total number of public schools that are open remained around 98,000 to 99,000. Those schools were not closed because their performance was in the bottom 5 or 10% but because the population changed.
One can argue and may win the argument if he/she says because 6% of the kids now attend charter schools, 6% of the public schools are now closed. Even this is a fallacy, because public school system has continued as if nothing has changed. They educate 6% less kids, but still maintain the same infra structure, because the number of public schools have not changed to suit.
Only private industry knows how to downsize and survive. Public schools have never learned or will never learn this valuable lesson. They have the entitlement concept.
Finally for all those concerned in this blog, I do not hate public schools or charter schools or private schools or religious schools. On the other hand I do not like on-line charters but still do not hate them..
Diane, I advise you to look into the closure of 50 schools by Ram Emanuel in Chicago and you may discover some other valid reasons.
LikeLike
Raj,
From your comments, I think it is fair to say that you are contemptuous of public schools. It must be painful for you to read this blog. I feel your pain, but not much.
LikeLike
There you go! In the district where I work, we have closed six buildings in the past 19 years. This amounts to about 20% of our total.
We have, in the same time, lost 25% of our student population.
Under our current superintendent we closed two of those buildings. We have lost close to 20% of our budget due to state cutbacks. But we have not laid off any staff.
If we would have chosen closure based on performance, other buildings would have been picked.
Where I live, three schools have been closed for the same reason: loss of student population. Here, too, performance was not a criterion.
I realize that represents just two out of the 399 districts in the state, but I feel safe to say that this is pretty representative for our state.
Of course, anyone with eyes and common sense could have seen the major reason for closing schools: demographics. 12 years ago, you could have foreseen what school population would be like in 2016.
LikeLike
Susan Lee Schwartz
You said “Hey Raj and Morrigan and anyone who does not realize what is actually happening. Seriously. Deception? Hmmm, It is astonishing to hear those, like Raj, who are really ‘uninformed’ ( truly ignorant, i.e clueless– have no information about the tens of thousands of teaches who were sent packing on fabricated charges”
You accuse me as being clueless, uninformed, truly ignorant. Do you have anything substantial to add to the conversation? Can you really think straight?
Let us see LAUSD lost about 15% of students to outside charters in the last 15 years. Today’s media reports that the total staffing is the highest in recent years. Should it not be less by 15%? Please tell me what is the meaning of this? Is it just a lie by the media or just an aberration?
LAUSD finger tip facts show that number of teachers in 2015-16 was 26,827. Where are the tens of thousands of teachers sent packing on fabricated charges that you are talking about? Is it just an imagination? Flight of fancy? Please enlighten me.
And finally stop citing blogs which are full of misinformation, innuendo and straight out lies very similar to your baseless statement.
LikeLike
Raj,
Try to hold your contempt for teachers and public schools in check. It is really unattractive. We know you are far superior to the rest of us, but don’t show off so much.
LikeLike
After looking through all those posts in this thread, Susan Lee Schwartz, I cannot for the life of me identify why I got lumped together with Raj. I clearly know that charters engage in fiscal no-nos more than TPS do. And I know deep down that charters need more oversight and should be limited. So I am not exactly on the same side of the fence as Raj. In fact, despite your post and my uniformed opinion, I find that I agree with Ravitch more than I disagree with her.
LikeLike
Exactly, Christine! Rudy knows nothing.
LikeLike
In response to Rudy, who misses the main point here, Whom are we more likely to catch an punish, the fraudsters in the public schools or the ones in the charter schools? The answer is obvious, the charter section is rarely ever punished even when they are caught.
LikeLike
Obviously you have not read through the list posted earlier. You might find it enlightening.
LikeLike
I see a list that has huge numbers of charter schools and a very small number of public schools. You also threw in lots of privately run schools and programs that aren’t public schools. A beauty school? What is the point? That privatized schools of all kinds will often be corrrupt if the oversight is missing. We already know that from charters and their lack of oversight.
As a public school parent, I have all sorts of recourses if I feel as if there is corruption going on. So do the teachers in the school.
Charter schools are like private schools. They can do what they want because charters demanded that they be able to be free from all the pesky regulations that protect students and teachers and other administrators that witness corruption.
That is a feature of charters, not a bug. People will be corrupt anywhere, but only charters are free from that pesky oversight that allows corruption to be seen.
It shouldn’t depend on a frightened assistant teacher secretly videotaping the bad behavior of a “model” charter school teacher after having her job threatened when she mentioned it to her superiors at a charter to get it to stop. If she had been a public school teacher, she could have complained up the line without fear for her job.
LikeLike
Need an edit function catch and punish:
LikeLike
Rudy is a preacher? A chaplain?
And I thought God never made mistakes.
LikeLike
And so the anonymity once again allows hateful speech.
If nothing else, I at least have the courage to use my own name in posting.
If all else fails, derogatory remarks are your answer??
LikeLike
The point though made time and time again keeps getting lost. Charter schools depend on public taxes for survival. Public expenditures must be transparent: line-by-line budgets, income and expenditures, subject to regular audit. That is how we minimize fraud (yes the amount of dollars wasted by fraud matters to taxpayers). Charters, like any vendor proposing to do govt work, must be financially vetted before being allowed to operate: that is how we minimize delay and disruption of govt projects caused by vendors going belly-up in the middle of a project. Why is this even debated? Charter law needs an overhaul in most states.
LikeLike
The reason Raj is so determined to claim that ANY fraud, no matter how small, is all the same shows the very problem with charter schools.
The reason the public school frauds are for so little money is because oversight works! It is not that there are no people willing to enrich themselves if they can get away with it in both kinds of schools. It is that public school employees get caught before they can steal very much.
Charter school operators get away with it for years. And then maybe someone notices that millions of dollars is missing!
That’s why Raj has proven what he didn’t intend to prove. That oversight prevents this from becoming the big frauds that happen in charter schools. And if charter schools were true public schools set up as “choice” schools under the same DOE that runs public schools, that fraud would have been caught before millions and millions of dollars disappeared. It would have been caught after the guilty party stole a few thousand, like at public schools.
Thanks so much, Raj, for supporting the end of privatized public education. You proved how much better the oversight is if the charters are not subject to oversight that public schools are.
LikeLike
Diane, you are so ‘kind’ to answer Raj and Rudy, who have nothing but that voice in their head to offer a view of reality. Having just posted this, I think it is apropos.
http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/The-Age-of-Post-Truth-Poli-in-Life_Arts-Democracy_Donald-Trump-Lies_Lies_Media-Lies-160824-370.html
LikeLike
At least this is a post on education and not politics-LOL!
LikeLike