Jennifer Ramsey is a 17-year veteran teacher in Texas. She watched Donald Trump Jr. insult public schools and their teachers on national television, and she was outraged. She asks: What does he know about public education? We know he attended an elite and pricey boarding school (The Hill School in Pennsylvania), which costs $55,000 a year. But has he ever set foot in a public school?
Public education is a foundational institution in this great nation, promoting democracy by educating students to become active citizens. It is a truly American establishment. Unlike elite private schools, public schools do not pick and choose which Americans we teach. We teach students of all races, religions and economic levels. We teach brilliantly gifted students, as well as children with severe disabilities….
Does Donald Trump Jr. know that?
I will begin my 18th year teaching in a Texas public school. Unlike Donald Trump Jr., I know something about public education.
Public education is a foundational institution in this great nation, promoting democracy by educating students to become active citizens. It is a truly American establishment. Unlike elite private schools, public schools do not pick and choose which Americans we teach. We teach students of all races, religions and economic levels. We teach brilliantly gifted students, as well as children with severe disabilities.
As for Trump’s assertion that public schools are run for the benefit of teachers and administrators rather than for the students, again, I must ask: What does know about public education? Has he ever stepped foot in a public school?
Trump doesn’t know that in public schools, teachers spend hundreds of dollars out of their own pockets and hours beyond the workday preparing their classrooms to be fun and happy environments for the new group of American learners coming in. He doesn’t know that teachers help little ones learn the social skills they may be lacking at home, or how often teachers buy clothes for the little ones who are sent to school in clothes with holes and stains and too-small shoes.
Trump doesn’t know what it’s like to comfort a middle-school child whose mother beat him before he came to school, with his mouth still a bloody mess. Or what it’s like to try every single teacher strategy you know to reach the girl who is shut down, hates school and everyone in it — only to find out that her mother is selling her to grown men for drug money. He doesn’t know the heartbreak and real American life that teachers experience every day while interacting with their students.
Trump doesn’t know the love most teachers feel for their students. He doesn’t know our students are always “ours” — even years later. He doesn’t know how often teachers give their students lunch money, snacks, second chances, a shoulder to cry on and hugs. He doesn’t know the tears of pride and joy we cry when our students walk across the stage at graduation. He doesn’t know the anguish we feel when our students die.
The truth is that Trump and the public school bashers like him don’t know anything about public education. I am proud to be an American public school teacher, and I have heard enough of the un-American rhetoric that politicians and businessmen like him use to tear down a truly American establishment and condemn the millions of Americans working hard to care for the children of this nation.

Well said, but Trump isn’t listening!
LikeLike
One caveat: The candidate is Donald Trump; the son is Donald Trump Jr.
LikeLike
We need a HUGE chorus of public school SUPPORTERS shouting out every time Trump or the Corporate Deformers bash public schools or public school teachers.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I suggest informing both political parties of the problems teachers are facing. Neither side is listening to experts in education. Get them to listen to you. I think that the Dem VP candidate and Rep P candidates would listen. Note that I mention no names here. This column is getting too political.
LikeLike
It’s fashionable to bash public schools. He’s a quick study. ” Everyone knows” all public schools suck and 50% of public school employees are functionally illiterate. All the best people say so.
He’ll do great in politics if his father appoints him to some position he isn’t qualified for and didn’t earn.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Getting elected or appointed to a position you are not qualified for’ is the very definition of politics.
LikeLike
This cannot be ignored. Trump has emboldened David Duke and his allies.
Former Ku Klux Klan Grand Wizard David Duke announced his US Senate campaign Friday in Louisiana, promising to defend the rights of European Americans.
“Thousands of special interest groups stand up for African-Americans, Mexican Americans, Jewish Americans, etc.,” he said in a YouTube video. “The fact is that European Americans need at least one man in the United States, one man in Congress, who will defend their rights and heritage.”
Duke, a former Republican state representative and convicted felon, said his emphasis on the rights of European Americans is what distinguishes him.
“The New York Times admitted that my platform became the GOP mainstream and propelled Republican control of Congress,” he said. “I’m overjoyed to see Donald Trump and most Americans embrace most of the issues that I’ve championed for years. My slogan remains ‘America First.’
Source http://www.cnn.com/2016/07/22/politics/david-duke-senate-race/
Is David Duke saying Trump and his staff are all plagerists, and that the Republicans cheering him on at the convention are all finally on board with Duke’s agenda?
LikeLike
You make the points Laura, that have motivated me to vote for
Clinton/Kaine.
Yes, the dangerous bigots are now released from being closeted, and they are jumping on the Trump bandwagon even as far as running for office. Cannot imagine a more alarming situation.
We see this in Europe, particularly in France, where the Fascist daughter of a prime Fascist activist, is now up to 40% acceptance by their voters, and can possibly soon be the next in line to Hollande.
It is happening here. I hear this language promoted by Trump and David Duke spoken easily, every day, in my own So.. Calif. community. No one seems to take issue with that famous Fascistic statement, “America First”, that those of us who are older remember clearly meant keep America ‘White and Christian’…and get rid of the rest.
LikeLike
Thank you, Diane Ravitch, for your tireless support of public education and public school teachers!
LikeLike
Good for the Texas teacher and good for the Chicago public schools teachers who embarrassed Rauner with their protest:
“The emails released Thursday produced an instant firestorm, forcing the governor to immediately backpedal and put out a statement saying that he “regrets” the emails, that he “apologizes to CPS educators for making an unfair, untrue comment” and that it “was sent out of frustration at the pace of change in our public school system.”
What an insufferable, arrogant bunch of snobs. They have utter contempt for the people they’re supposed to be working for.
https://www.dnainfo.com/chicago/20160722/loop/rauner-regrets-calling-cps-principals-incompetent-teachers-illiterate
LikeLike
Donald Jr. was an appointed “attack dog” for the conservative agenda of the Republicans. Donald Jr. grew up in a billionaire bubble, and his comments merely reflect the ignorance of his upbringing. By the way, if Trump wants a strong America, he should immediately encourage his sons to sign up for the military. After all, only a Trump can make American great again.
Public education is a building block of a democratic society. Throughout my career I considered my service in public education to be an act of patriotism. We must have an informed electorate in order to maintain a democracy. Public schools and teachers, though battered and maligned, represent what is right about our country. The privateers have it all wrong. They don’t want what is best for us; they want what they think is best for them. $$$$
LikeLike
I have always thought that Presidents should actually be required by law* to have their children and/or grandchildren serve in the active duty military (preferably the army)
If a President is not willing to send his children or grandchildren into war, s/he has no business sending other people’s children or grandchildren.
Presidents’ daughters should not be exempt from serving on the front lines and if the children or grandchildren are too young while the President is in office, they should be required by law to serve when they reach the age of 18. If they refuse, the former President should be summarily imprisoned until such time as their children enroll.
My guess is that if that were done, Presidents would get us into far fewer wars — if any.
And ideally, the same law would apply to members of Congress.
*it might require an amendment, not least of all because no President would ever sign the bill and Congress would certainly not even create such a bill if it also affected them. It’s too bad that the founding fathers did not put such a requirement in at the start.
LikeLike
Tim Kaine has a son in the Marines. How many in the Trump family have ever worn their country’s uniform? Donald went to military school. Why didn’t he serve in Vietnam like others of his generation?
LikeLike
Donald went to military school because he gave a teacher a black eye and was a discipline problem his parents didn’t or couldn’t deal with.
LikeLike
Agree 100% with retired teacher and the Poet.
The combination of free universal education, and then after WW2, the GI Bill, plus the union movement, built American society into the greatest Middle Class the world has known….mostly all turned to dust since the uprising of the Free Market determined by the economists of the Austrian and Chicago Schools, and the Reagan Revolution.
LikeLike
Diane,
I didn’t serve in the military, and I’m of Trump’s generation. I’m proud not to have served in Vietnam. My WWII combat-veteran father was prepared to drive me to Canada, had I been determined to be I-A.
You had no skin in that fight. Where do you get off calling out anyone for not serving?
I’m so tired of arm-chair patriots making military service, let alone combat service, the criterion for ANYTHING outside of the military itself.
And let’s not forget that Iraq veteran, Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard, endorses Bernie Sanders, explicitly because she sees him as the ONLY candidate who has veterans’, servicemen’s and servicewomen’s safety and interests at heart. And he never served in the military either.
LikeLike
Poet, I think you’ve got the wrong solution to a serious problem. Rethink that one, please: it’s got more holes than it takes to fill the Albert Hall.
LikeLike
I’m pretty tired of these trust fund babies actually believing they are important or relevant. Too many pampered, privileged elites, and that includes all the Bush boys, Romney, and Trump Sr. If not for his cushioned, isolation, Trump Jr. would be serving fries or a cube rat like the rest of America.
LikeLike
All the Trump kids defer to dad as he holds the purse strings. Bill Maher said having the nanny speak at the RNC looked like a “hostage video.”
LikeLike
I’m sorry, but why does he think he is qualified to say ANYTHING about public schools or even the quality of my toilet? I mean seriously , who the Hell does he think he is? Did anybody give two %*$*& s what Chealsie Clinton or Ron Reagan thought or said? Remember Bubba Beer? Yeah, just because you are related to someone of power does not mean you are a sage or some beacon of wisdom.
LikeLike
Ron Reagan however did turn out to be a valuable and intelligent voice for the Left to Center, and to this day refutes his father’s policies.
LikeLike
Bob, just how IS the quality of your toilet? Inquiring minds want to know.
And yes, I do care a lot about what Ron Reagan says.
Chelsea spells her name “Chelsea.” And it was Billy Beer, if you mean Jimmy Carter’s brother’s “brand.”
Meanwhile, Trump, Jr. has the same right to speak as any citizen. You may disagree with his views, but the issue isn’t his qualifications beyond what the Constitution & Bill of Rights grants him and you. Cool documents, bro: check ’em out!
LikeLike
“I am proud to be an American public school teacher” – and we are proud to have you as one of our own. The children you speak of we all know and love and will always carry with us in our hearts.
LikeLike
As I have posted earlier, vote IN YOUR OWN BEST INTEREST. Vote 3rd Party. There IS MORE than the DEMS and REPS.
LikeLike
Yvonne, you’re casting pearls before the deaf and preaching to the blind. Or something. 🙂 Still, always glad to note the progressives in the room. Keep trying.
LikeLike
I have spent the last two days in a teacher workshop in Tennessee. The disconnect between Trump’s speech and reality could not be more drastic. All the teachers I met were intelligent, passionate promoters of their subject. They were not of one mind about technique or even what should be the focus of their classes. There was intelligent discussion among a varied group that included teachers involved in sports, community, church, and school. Disagreements were handled with diplomacy.
These are certainly not the teachers we have been hearing about from reformers. Where are these people? We all know the answer, and it becomes very simple with a little math. All professions have people in them who have chosen incorrectly. Usually, these people shop around until they find a job they feel like they are doing well. As was evidenced by the ages of the group I was in, teachers are doing this too. They have always done it, just like investors and nurses. Within this mobile group, the simple probability of being taught by someone searching for the right place for them is very high. If you are in school for 13 years, the probability of getting a teacher whose skills are not honed is very high, after all, a young kid may have contact with as many as five teachers each year, and that goes up as you get older.
All that research that shows how long it takes for a child to “recover” from a bad teacher is based on a fallacy. No one can make a blanket statement about a “bad teacher”. This is not too dissimilar from blanket statements about rival ethnic groups. You cannot identify who is good and bad. The probability that any student will be taught by a teachers who does not fit his or her needs is quite high. Students need to understand that not every teacher will do things their way. But, of course, they are young.
Students become adults who recall a few things about school, some of them fond memories and some of them very bad. Often the traumatic, the time someone shouted at them from the teacher’s desk or confronted them in the hall will stick long after the experience of learning about Newton and Galileo. School reformers know this. They are aware that suggesting that teachers are the problem will hook the general populace. So this is what we hear. Listen you public. You are really surrounded by people who are uneducated. But they are not to blame. Teachers are to blame. Remember how bad the teachers were? They are the problem, not you.
Since Bob Dole uttered a few critical sentences in the 1996 Republican Convention, political leaders on both sides have been trying to gain from his gambit. Now we hear Trump taking this to a new height. You are not to blame for your problems. Teachers are. Bad political deals with foreign nations are. Muslims are. Mexicans are.
These political uttering a find fertile ground precisely because they remind people of the places government has failed them. That one teacher who did not fit you. That policeman that was rude to you. But most public servants are good people. For every lazy fireman there are 500 risking their life. For every bad teacher there are 500 neglecting their own children for the good of yours.
The Dallas police chief is right. We are asking police and school to solve problems that are too intractable for them. This message is a harsher truth than the nuanced reality that explains this horrible summer. No one is going to the White House on this message except to take a tour.
LikeLike
Where did Chelsea Clinton go to school again? To whom is she married? But she sure knows about the plight of poor people. And those struggling young Obama girls? What DC and Chicago hellholes did they trudge to? My memory just isn’t what it once was.
Or is it that only GOP kids may not talk nonsense? The older I get (66 tomorrow), the more confused about the rules our oligarchs and their supporters have prescribed for us.
LikeLike