Daphne Stanford left the following comment on the blog. Idaho, she says, doesn’t care about education. It doesn’t care about its own children.
Yes, there is a problem with education in Idaho; however, it’s not the fault of the teachers or the schools. The problem is much more complex than that. As a former high school English teacher who has also taught college-level composition, I can testify to the woeful state of education funding in Idaho: while I was teaching in Riggins, for example, the district had to pass an emergency bond levy for more school funding simply in order to keep the schools open. That’s ludicrous. I’ve also never heard of high schools actually charging students to take choir or art, for example, or to participate in team sports. It’s painfully obvious to me that part of the problem is not only that there is a lack of funding; there is also, sadly, a lack of belief or trust in education and educators–especially in rural Idaho. As one of the reddest states in the U.S., our state is especially prone to private corporations hijacking public education in the name of progress or technology. However, it’s not that simple. What is simple, however, is the formula that makes for good education: small class sizes, teachers who are adequately paid & supported, and a community that also supports and believes in education. If class sizes are bloated and overcrowded, if funding is non-existent, if teachers are overworked and underpaid–guess what? Education is going to suffer. It’s really not that complicated.

The problem Idaho faces is the same problem Utah faces – Mormon’s have lots of kids. So for each tax paying parent/couple you have twice as many kids. Also, don’t forget that each one of these kids is a tax deduction so the parents putting the most strain on the public school system are actually contributing the least. For states like Idaho and Utah to fund schools at a similar per pupil level as other states, they would have to be willing to tax themselves at a much higher rate.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The large families isn’t the whole problem–BUT, the Utah state legislature (and I’m assuming Idaho as well) use it as an excuse to underfund education. Utah used to be the top state in the nation in terms of how much of each worker’s GDP went to education taxes. Now, Utah is about 25th. Poll after poll has shown that taxpayers are willing to pay much more for education IF the money went directly to schools (not bureaucracy). But legislators won’t even touch raising taxes. It’s ridiculous.
LikeLike
Idaho’s Governor, State Board of Education and a sizable number of Legislators have set up public education in Idaho to fail. Working behind the scenes is the Albertson Foundation which has set a goal of increasing the number of students attending charter schools. The Foundation spends considerable time and resources “educating” legislators and communicating to the public that education is failing. We are fortunate to have a few individuals who are willing to stand up to the corporate statists. One is a teacher blogger who maintains Idaho’s Promise. https://idahospromise.org/
Another Idahoan who stepped up and consequently got stepped on is Dr. Russ Joki. Dr. Joki was literally the “last man standing” in a school funding lawsuit. As a result of the lawsuit, the Idaho Constitution was upheld and schools cannot charge fees for courses needed for graduation. Dr. Joki was accused of costing the West Ada school district money and targeted for recall. http://rjoki67.wix.com/electrussjokiwestada
LikeLiked by 1 person
Much of what junior high and high schools in Utah use to get by is through student fees, which are $110.00 at my high school, just to register. AND most classes, including math, computer tech, vocational subjects, and music, charge fees from $5.00-$100.00.
LikeLike
A very familiar them here in e state of Iowa
LikeLiked by 1 person
“I’ve also never heard of high schools actually charging students to take choir or art, for example, or to participate in team sports.”
This has become commonplace, also long lists of supplies that parents/caregivers must purchase. The lists are often available at places like Walmart, Staples, even Walgreens. Some of this cost-shifting happened with site-based management and a reduction of district-wide purchases where steep discounts could be and were negotiated.
Parents pay retail, and the back-to-school sales are devised to offer bargains on some items while other items cost more than they are during the off-season.
A long time ago the Dade County schools (greater Miami) purchased boxes of crayons in volume. These were shipped by rail car, offloaded to a central warehouse, and distributed to schools.
In “crayons to computers” recycling operations available in some communities, teachers and principals who have proofs of poverty rates among their students are permitted to pick up goodies for free, but with limits that have been calculated as a “best practice” especially for computers, lap-tops and furniture. Many of the free items are plastered with advertising. They were freebies at some other event and the surplus is redistributed with a modest tax break.
I tried to donate some Ammonite fossil specimens to our local crayons-to-computer store. The volunteer who had to inventory the fossils also volunteered that he did not believe in science. I told him I would find another place to donate them, and I did.
LikeLike
Shouldn’t many mid level management jobs in education be looked at? It seems to me that anyone not working directly with children or youth or a building administrator should have their value added assessed (not through scores, but through contact hours with students).
LikeLike
The comment below about being set up
to fail seems apt in lots of places.
I find myself wondering if state supes just don’t care because they will still be at the top of a school system statewide even I got goes all charter. So they have no incentive for caring (other than that aspect of them being trusted as stewards of state resources and efforts—oh yeah that). Seriously, most leadership seems to have swallowed the koolaid that reforms of test and punish and everything RttT brought. I do not get it at all except to say that they themselves must not believe in democratically run public schools. Why, I wonder? What do they know that we don’t?
LikeLike
Cx: even if it goes (not I got goes)
LikeLike