Jessica Calefati wrote a blistering series about Michael Milken’s K12 Inc. virtual charter school in California (called California Virtual Academy or CAVA) a few weeks ago. The series caused enough of a stir to persuade State Superintendent Tom Torklakson to order a state audit of CAVA.
Calefati reported that less than half the students at CAVA graduate, and none is qualified to attend a California public university.
The virtual charter industry is noted for high profits and poor performance. Student attrition is high, test scores and graduation rates are low. But profits are excellent, because the “school” receives full state tuition but has none of the expenses of a brick and mortar school. No grounds, no transportation, no custodian, no food services, no library, no support staff, no athletics. And classes that range from 40-more than 100 in number. As Calefati reported in the original series, students may get credit for attendance if they are online only one minute a day. The latest CREDO study found that for every 180 days enrolled in a virtual charter, students lose 180 days of instruction in math and 72 in reading. This is a lose-lose.
It is heartening to see state officials taking action to curb the fraud that runs rampant through its charter industry, unsupervised, unregulated, and unchecked.
Calefati writes:
In a rare move, California’s top education official has enlisted the state’s highest-ranking accountant to conduct a sweeping audit of California Virtual Academies, a profitable but low-performing network of online charter schools that enrolls about 15,000 students across the state.
The audit is the first that Superintendent for Public Instruction Tom Torlakson has asked the state controller’s Office to conduct since he took office in 2011. The request comes two months after this newspaper published an investigative series on K12 Inc., the publicly traded Virginia firm that operates the schools and reaps tens of millions of dollars annually in state funding.
In a statement Thursday, Torlakson said he has a duty to ensure that public money isn’t being squandered and sought the probe into the California Virtual Academies because of “serious questions raised about a number of their practices.” He said the audit would examine the relationship between the schools and the company and the “validity” of attendance, enrollment, dropout and graduation rates reported by the academies to the state.
This isn’t the first time the company has come under fire in recent weeks.
Torlakson’s request follows lawmakers’ calls last month for the state auditor to examine for-profit charter schools operations and Assemblywoman Susan Bonilla’s introduction earlier this month of legislation that would prohibit online charters from hiring for-profit companies like K12 for management or instructional services. The company is also being probed by Attorney General Kamala Harris, who launched an investigation of online charter schools last fall.
If Controller Betty Yee finds evidence of gross financial mismanagement, illegal or improper use of public money, a disregard for sound educational practices or repeated failure to improve student test scores the state Board of Education, may — based on a recommendation from Torlakson — vote to revoke the schools’ charters.

Congrats to Sup. Torlakson for stepping up when those in many other states have not had the courage to do so in the face of corporate money and pressure to allow charters free rein.
LikeLike
Torlakson, and his wife who is also running for office, seem to have decided teaching was not high pay enough, so both are now intent on having well paying jobs on the public dole.
Torlakson, whom many of us put ourselves on the line to get him elected, has been a shadow in the charter school battle, and he is non responsive to his constituents. If it had not been Marshell Tuck, a real 100% Wall Street greed merchant (funded by Eli Broad and his group) who ran against him, I would never have sent him money and written articles in his support. Never again…even if he finally seems to be doing something to support public education.
Hope Betty Yee steps up and runs for his seat in Sacramento, and John Chang runs for as public ed supporting Governor.
LikeLike
addendum…and let’s hear it for our AG, Kamala Harris, who is prosecuting Milken. She is a winner…and she will win by a large margin in her run for the US Senate.
LikeLike
Revoke, yes. But we also want our money back!
LikeLike
Our Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District in southern Ca contracted with Fuel Ed in February 2016.
Fuel Ed is the reb-randed name of CAVA the virtual academy.
Palos Verdes is a high ranking district, and despite myself and others protesting the PV District signed a contract anyway.
What is very disturbing is the way this company is funded.
They are making huge profits from low performing districts and schools, and
then K-12,Inc provides low level classes to high achieving districts for almost no cost.
Parents are left in the dark and believe what they are told.
What is the advantage for a high achieving district to sign with this disgusting company?
That’s what I’d like to know.
And who’s pocketing the money for low level classes? The shareholders.
See this article on the re-branding:
http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2014/04/02/27rebrand_ep.h33.html
LikeLike
Take it one step further and Packard and most of the original team have another spinoff as well. Pansophic Learning pillaging school districts internationally.
LikeLike
It’s about time. They should indict the people who run the schools when they find out they were siphoning money for the company with no services to students.
LikeLike
Shame on everyone for not watching this man and his activities closer. His time spent in prison for his shady dealings on Wall Street with junk bonds wasn’t enough? Allowing him to open up virtual charter schools was like inviting the fox into the henhouse…Milken is a crook!
LikeLike
Less than $35K a year, folks — that’s the going K12.com/FuelEd rate for teacher dignity and self-respect.
LikeLike