Nearly two-thirds of the school districts in Texas filed a lawsuit against the state formula for funding public schools. A lower court judge ruled that the state’s funding formula was unconstitutional. Hopes were high that the lower court ruling would sustain that decision.
Unfortunately the state Supreme Court sustained the current methodology.
The legislature cut $5.4 Billion out of the schools’ budget in 2011. Many districts have never recovered from those draconian cuts.
“Houston lawyer Mark Trachtenberg, who represented 88 property-wealthy school districts in the case, said the ruling “represents a dark day for Texas school children, especially given the Legislature’s repeated failure to adequately fund our schools.”
“A recent study by the National Education Association found that Texas ranks 38th in the country in per-pupil public-education spending.”
Pastors for Texas Children issued the following statement:
“Pastors for Texas Children Executive Director Rev. Charles Foster Johnson on Today’s Supreme Court Decision
“The Texas Supreme Court’s ruled today that the Texas public school funding system technically meets “minimum constitutional requirements”—a ruling belied by the direct professional experience and expert witness of hundreds of thousands of Texas educators.
“The Court’s conclusion may be based on legal technicality, but the burden of this sophistry will be borne by our 5.3 million schoolchildren.
“We hover near the bottom nationally in monetary support for our schools. It is sinful for a society as rich as Texas—an economic “miracle,” as a recent governor put it—to make our schoolchildren eat the crumbs that fall from our state’s table of bounty.
Our Lord famously said, “To those whom much is given, much is required.” But, the Texas Supreme Court and the Texas State Legislature have perversely revised that moral dictum: “To those whom much is given, less is required.”
“Of particular moral offense is the arrogance shown by certain state leaders whose cynical tactics seek to divert our attention away from the grave injustice of inadequate school finance.
“Pastors for Texas Children will not fall for these ridiculous distractions.
80,000 new schoolchildren enter our public school system every year, in classes that are overfilled, with teachers that are underpaid, in schools that are underfunded. Over 60% of our Texas schoolchildren are poor. Our dedicated teachers work long hours at low pay to provide God’s gift of education for them while enduring demoralizing attacks from the very leaders constitutionally charged and Biblically sworn to support them. This is the moral outrage of our day.
“We recommit ourselves to holding our Governor, Lieutenant Governor, 31 State Senators and 150 State Representatives accountable for the “suitable provision of free public schools,” as our own Texas State Constitution mandates, as the American civil tradition establishes, and, most importantly, as the Biblical call to justice unambiguously announces.”

Do they use the sameformula that Florida uses, by chance?
LikeLike
The governor and legislature have been captured by the charter industry. Their decisions are not based on what is best for the young people of the state. Their decisions are based on what is best for them and their cronies. Unless the people change the leadership of the state, Texas will continue to starve public education to provide opportunities for charters and likely vouchers. http://www.commondreams.org/news/2015/03/04/newly-unveiled-texas-school-reform-proposals-step-right-wing-agenda-0
LikeLike
The courts are bought and paid for. No surprise.
LikeLike
The deeper problem that cries out for remedies…and justice, in and beyond Texas.
“By 2010-14, (after that “Great Recession” pf 2008-09 ) 14 million people lived in extremely poor neighborhoods—5 million more than before the downturn and more than twice as many as in 2000.”
“El Paso, TX continued to rank among the regions with the highest concentrated poverty rates in 2010-14 (Table 3). Like El Paso, some regions with greatest concentrations of poverty in 2010-14 were also among the poorest metro areas overall, including McAllen-Edinburg-Mission, Tex., where more than half (52 percent) of the poor population lived in extremely poor neighborhoods.“ (Table 3)
“More than half of all poor residents in the United States now live in high poverty or extremely poor neighborhoods.”
Source http://www.brookings.edu/research/reports2/2016/03/31-concentrated-poverty-recession-kneebone-holmes
“Texas children increasingly live in the state’s metropolitan areas, often in the suburban regions around major cities where population and poverty are both rising rapidly. These metro areas are driving the state’s childhood poverty: Houston and Dallas each have a child poverty rate of 37 percent, nearly 20 percentage points above the state average, while Austin’s rate is 29 percent and San Antonio’s is 24 percent.
Importantly, the report notes that these disparities were not caused by accident. They are largely due to the legacy of racial and ethnic segregation still felt in many Texas communities. “Prohibitions against homeownership, weaker protections against proximity of industrial hazards, and lack of public investments built a foundation for advantages and disadvantages of place that are still evident today,”
Source https://texashousers.net/2016/04/13/report-texas-childhood-poverty-largely-divided-by-place-and-race/
This is the national problem that the billionaires and friends claim to address by installing charter schools in low-income and highly segregated communities. This practice does nothing more than strengthen the segregation, while pretending that increments in test scores and no-nonsense discipline will launch the children and whole community on a path to succeed. This is a big lie, with compelling longitudinal evidence. See for example: Richard Rothstein, “For Public Schools, Segregation Then, Segregation Since: Education and the Unfinished March” 2013. http://www.epi.org/publication/unfinished-march-public-school-segregation/
LikeLike
Your last link should be sent to Obama and King. According to this research, the best chance for minority students to succeed is in an integrated public school. I know this works as I witnessed the success of many minority students during my career in a diverse public school.
LikeLike
It’s a sad day when our courts side against our children. As a teacher and a parents, this infuriates me and makes me question the whole system. How can I help in the next few years before my own child fall in a possible crack that are all too common?
LikeLike
One should always keep in mind that the Judiciary is a “legal system” and not a “justice system”. Legality trumps justice. In this scenario, the only thing that matters is the legality of something. Other than that, don’t bother.
LikeLike
Funny how Texas can casually kick around the idea of incinerating $60,000,000 + on a high school football field –
http://onlyagame.wbur.org/2016/05/14/allen-mckinney-texas-football-stadiums
– and get national attention, but when their legislature looks at really crippling the actual administration of education…..silence (except at places like Ms Ravitch’s all-together wonderful site)
LikeLike
The football stadium fiasco points to what the fiscal conservatives will say: “If the schools can afford to spend that kind of money on a football field then they don’t need any increase in funding, and if anything a decrease because obviously they have enough already.” (while at the same time be in the best seats of the new stadium cheering on their home-town team)
LikeLike
It just shows that the whole legal system, including the operation and selection of the supreme courts, needs to be overhauled.
Based on the support of Trump and Sanders, people will make the change soon.
LikeLike