The NY BATS. Are not happy about President Obama’s selection of John King as Secretary of Education. Say this for King. His arrogant indifference to parents set off the largest testing opt out in history. Maybe he can do the same for the nation.
BATS write:
“WE GOOFED BUT TRUST US TO FIX IT: Now headed for Senate confirmation hearings, Obama’s Acting Education Secretary John King admits in a new video that standardized testing has been harmful and wasteful, yet will continue federal tinkering to find a better balance between subjecting kids to non-stop testing hell and collecting data to improve instruction.
Reading stiffly from cue cards, King continues his “apology tour” after alienating teachers with corporate reform policies straight out of ALEC’s basement. Yet the Secretary continues to pretend outraged teacher and parent groups do not see right through to the heart of the problem – the corporate revolving door and the influence of money in politics.
Obama had always mailed in his education policy, straight from the boardrooms of Center for American Progress, the Gates Foundation and social engineers like Joanna Weiss. The policies were also favored by Wall Street and billionaires like the Waltons and Broads, yet were met with whimpers by the heads of the large teacher unions.
This untested market-based approach to changing schools exploded in opt-outs and gave Republicans an issue with great traction. Now Obama is backpedaling, but only in rhetoric as his actions only cement his commitment to upending classrooms through continuous, invasive measuring. His promises to help underperforming schools remain broken, as support for addressing actual learning obstacles flows instead into the hands of testing contractors and armies of consultants.
In essence, Obama is saying to America “yes we goofed” but let’s have a “fresh start”, beginning with the nomination of King, a darling of privatizers and dark money PACs that rain campaign cash onto your state legislators. This is not only tone-deaf and a thumb in the eye, it’s doubling down on corporate reform and federal centralization.
As a short-lived teacher and charter network director, King lacked the experience the education community was looking for, so his PR handlers instead launched an all-points media blitz based on his personal narrative, which credited NYC public schools for changing the trajectory of his life. Strange then, that he would pick a career in charter schools, which require pro-active completion of lottery applications, thereby leaving behind the most needy children whose parents are not as involved.
Today, the hope of students, parents and teachers across the political spectrum is that local control of schools can be restored by downsizing almost everything the megalithic USDOE does, abandoning NCLB’s federally mandated test requirements and concentrating on supporting the research-based recommendations of actual educators instead of mandating ham-handed “fixes” after meeting with lobbyists.
In short, Obama’s record on education is widely considered even “worse than Bush”, but the way forward now is no longer manufacturing fake crises and endlessly patching up failed (and unconstitutional) federal testing policies, it’s folding up shop and giving tax dollars back to districts so teachers can teach.”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?utm_content=&utm_medium=email&utm

In my opinion this president’s education,policies have been the worst. Worse than Bush’s because he was supposed to,be a”great” man with understanding of what this country needs. I feel that we have been duped and we don’t really,know,who he is politically.
LikeLike
If we read Frederick Hess’ article at the “K-12 tab”, of the Philosophy Roundtable website, where he summons the villainthropists to alter
university, schools of education, in a manner that just happens to benefit Wall Street and Silicon Valley, at the expense of taxpayers and the families of the 99%, Obama’s plan is very clear.
I agree he hid the plan, behind democratic rhetoric, as I assume his advisors, like Axelrod did.
LikeLike
He is a republican, and republicans pull his strings. He was brought in on a trojan horse, so the majority poor would elect him. How we all were elated to have our first black president, let alone a black democrat. THAT was painstakingly planned, for who better to screw the minorities? We never even saw it coming. Shame on us.
LikeLike
All this is great reason to try some kind of unified action. I’m proposing a mass letter-writing campaign expressing our concerns about John King.
Yes, I know there are plenty of nay-sayers out there who believe there’s nothing we can do to alter the course we’re on. But for those of you who still cling to a shred of hope, join me in this Call to Action. I for one, can’t just sit by and be content with commenting on this most excellent blog site. I know I am reading and responding to mostly like-minded people. But out “there” in the “real world” the media picks and chooses what they cover and how. Our democracy is at stake. But one thing we still have is our unified voice.
Let’s speak out together.
One or two voices are clearly drops in an enormous ocean, but joined together, maybe we can cause a stir. (butterfly wings, anyone?)
I propose we share our thoughts with the Chair of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Rep. Chaffetz (Utah-R) and some of the other members of the Committee that spoke out at the February 2nd hearing. You may know others you think we should write. To be most effective, we should be writing mostly the same people and during the same time frame.
At the risk of opening myself up to all sorts of feedback, I’m sharing my fledgling blog address where I’ve written more details for my proposal. I’m open to suggestions (kindly worded) on what exactly our first action letter should say. Please help move the conversation forward in a positive way.
I believe passionately that we must act together to take back control of both the narrative and our democracy.
If you’re interested: http://fromwhereiteach.blogspot.com
LikeLike
Just composed a sample letter to send to Congresspeople involved in the DoE hearing on February 2nd.
The basic message is: “Question John King’s appointment as the Secretary of Education.”
Would love others to copy or compose your own letter, and send them out over the next week.
We can’t let this go without response.
Together, maybe we’ll be heard.
http://fromwhereiteach.blogspot.com
LikeLike
As we all saw in the Congressional hearing tape, the terms right and wrong, are nebulous concepts to King, which explains giving Ohio, proven to have the most corrupt and underperforming charter schools, $71,000,000 to expand them, Then, the check’s put on hold b/c the data received from Ohio had been manipulated, leading to the resignation of the husband of Kasich’s campaign manager. Now, according to Plunderbund, King gets another stack of data from Ohio, that adds, in a footnote, that the on-line charter schools have been omitted from calculation.
Only a dishonorable man sets up a situation where people feel comfortable, repetitively committing wrong-doing, if not crimes.
LikeLike
To, me the Ohio situation revealed that the USDOE is just rubber-stamping those charter grants.
All of that information is publicly available. Apparently they don’t verify any of it before shipping out 71 million dollars.
It really puts paid to the idea that they are expanding “high performing” charter schools. They have no earthly idea what they’re expanding. How would they know they’re “high performing” anyway? They haven’t even opened the charter schools in Youngstown to replace the public schools. They’re “high performing” before they open? Why can’t public schools claim the same thing?
LikeLike
A better use for the $71,000,000-
Spend it on the replacement for the inadequate, decades old, Brent Spence Bridge, over the Ohio River, the only bridge funneling 3 interstate highways onto one bridge. The traffic congestion drags down productivity.
LikeLike
‘Let’s look forward…not back’
LikeLike
Those who do not want to look at the past are doomed to repeat it.
LikeLike
Huh? Forward? Really? Duh, just what the deformers want.
LikeLike
“Nothing to see here… Move along now…”
LikeLike
A good piece by David Denby of the New Yorker, a corporate media outlet that drops little nuggets like this every now and then:
http://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/stop-humiliating-teachers
LikeLike
Here’s still more DC lawmakers promoting charters in Ohio.
http://www.realcleareducation.com/articles/2016/02/15/education_leaders_lies_could_hurt_kids__in_ohio_and_across_america_1262.html
When’s the last time any of these people dropped into a public school? They’re aware that 93% of the kids in this state attend public schools, right? Did the public know we were hiring people who would spend 100% of their time and energy promoting charters and vouchers?
I know public schools aren’t fashionable in DC circles, but when they parachute into a state one would think they could carve out 10 minutes to at least pretend they’re interested.
LikeLike
The photo, in the linked article, shows Sen. Portman. Ohioans have a good opportunity to get rid of him in Nov.
LikeLike
BATS piece very good. Yes, Obama has been a big disappointment re education. Handing it off to Arnie who was clueless was not a good move. Here in Buffalo King is pretty widely distrusted. As commissioner of ed here in NYS his solution to “fix” the “failing schools” (determined by tests now deemed inappropriate for judging teacher performance) was to threaten them with “receivership” by an outside entity (fairies?). He clearly had no clue, and certainly no patience, with a district troubled by crushing poverty, gangs, drugs, as many as 40 languages spoken in several buildings. His standard response was: more rigor, higher standards, more data. The new commissioner, Elia, seems to be cut of the same cloth. How do these people get into education?!
LikeLike
$$$$$, Robert, $$$$$. People hired & protected by ALEC-bought legislators (DINOs–ahem–included). Simply connect all the dots & follow the money–the answers are apparent.
How to stop this?
Bernie 2016, because it all starts at the top, w/a non-ALEC bought president. (And elect your people to Congress, as well–Russ Feingold, et.al.)
LikeLike
Words that I never thought I would say:
Worse than Bush.
LikeLike
And where is Bernie? Not a word on K-12 education! In 10 years there won’t need to be free public school college tuition cuz there won’t be anyone prepared to go to college.
Not one word on ENDING federal money to charter schools.
Not one word on ENDING high stakes testing.
” ” ” ” ” teacher evaluation tied to testing.
” ” ” ” ” Common Core testing.
” ” ” ” ” Bill Gates $$$$$ into funding common core, curriculum, and all
” ” ” ” ” John King’s nomination and INSTEAD soliciting the guidance of Diane Ravitch and Linda Darling Hammond.
I thought/was told, the BATs were talking to Bernie and or his advisors.
LikeLike
You may be referring to Bernie Sanders’ education advisor Phil Fiermonte who wrote to Arthur Goldstein last August: http://badassteachers.blogspot.com/2015/08/bernie-sanders-explains-puzzling.html
There are also multiple statements on the record made by Bernie indicating he wants to “do away with” bubble tests and opposes the “high stakes nature” of tests.
He is behind the Innovative Assessment Demonstration Authority in the ESSA law to replace standardized testing with alternatives in a 7-state pilot.
Bernie has also said he opposes “privately run” charter schools.
Bernie did vote in March 2015 against Sen. Vitter’s Sen. Amendment 515, allowing states to opt out of Common Core.
LikeLike
There has not been one word – on any of the Democratic debates about K-12 education. That’s what I mean – about – not one word.
I am working hard for Bernie’s campaign, because of his honest, heartfelt, commitment to building a better, happier life for all and to reducing global warming. He truly understands.
I feel that he has not had the time in his life to understand the horrific changes that have happened in the past 15 years to public education. It’s been pretty crazy! Just understanding the whole Bill Gates/commom core testing thing is a puzzle to uncover!
I think he needs help to understand what has happened and what has to happen to fix it. He needs advice from the experts. There’s no way we can all understand it all.
LikeLike
My opinion- Bernie knows but, doesn’t want to criticize Pres. Obama. Hillary has already tried to create a wedge between those voters who support Obama and the candidate of the progressives. Bernie needs both groups to win.
LikeLike
Did anyone notice that Randi PRAISED the King appointement?
LikeLike
Was that before or after she spoke at the TFA reunion?
LikeLike
http://b-loedscene.blogspot.com/2016/02/what-vikings-gangsters-and-outlaw.html?showComment=1455489603178#c4196802111068565457
LikeLike
OUCH. I’ve been horrified by the stance on pro-testing and a need for initiating charters for so many long years now.
LikeLike
Wow, Really grim take on public schools from a former Obama Administration official:
“Public support for public education is declining, and it’s really at risk,” he explains. “I think if you look around the country you see first of all 3-million kids in charters, almost 2-million home schools, and 5-million in private schools. That’s 10-million kids who are not in the traditional public school system. And you have something like 28 states now that are doing some kind of a voucher and you have something like 30 states that are still funding education at pre-recession levels, pre-2008 levels. I think there’s frustration with the education system and taxpayers are saying they’ve had enough. Only about 20% of taxpayers have kids in the public school system.”
I think we have our answer for why politicians have abandoned public schools.
Public school kids simply don’t have enough political clout to merit support.
LikeLike
Hi Diane Thank u for always supporting bats:) I am one of 10 NY Admin I have never seen this statement to vote on as representative of our group. We usually vote on press releases Can u tell me where it came from? Thank u for your help:)
Jamy A. Brice-Hyde M.Ed. Sent from my iPhone
>
LikeLike
Jamy, it appeared as a comment on this blog.
LikeLike