Emily Richmond at The Atlantic reports on the exodus of teachers from Kansas.
“Frustrated and stymied by massive budget cuts that have trimmed salaries and classroom funding, Kansas teachers are “fleeing across the border” to neighboring states that offer better benefits and a friendlier climate for public education, NPR’s Sam Zeff reported.
To be sure, this is a tough time for the Sunflower State, where funding shortfalls forced a half-dozen districts to shorten their academic calendars, and teacher jobs are being advertised on billboards. But it’s hardly an outlier. Las Vegas, home to the nation’s fifth-largest school district, is undergoing a particularly brutal struggle to recruit, and keep, enough new teachers for the upcoming academic year. (After all, how many superintendents have been reduced to zipline stunts to draw attention to a hiring crisis, as was the case with the Las Vegas district’s Pat Skorkowsky?) And it doesn’t take much to find stories of teacher shortages in Arizona and Indiana, among many others….
“One solution: Residency programs that provide new teachers with intensive mentoring, coaching, and support for their first few years in the profession are gaining in popularity. But an underlying issue is that fewer people are opting to become teachers, and when they do, about half will quit within five years. Indeed, in last year’s Gallup poll, the percentage of people who said they didn’t want their children to become teachers jumped to 43 percent from 33 percent a decade earlier.”
The so-called reform movement has succeeded in making teaching an undesirable profession. Not only are teachers quitting, unable to live on meager salaries, but the number of people who want to be teachers has sharply declined. This fits the agenda of the reformers, who want to replace teachers with computers, encourage the retirement of costly experienced teachers, and turn teaching into a low-wage, high-turnover job rather than a profession.

I hope Senators Murphy, Warren, and the rest of the Democrat no-nothing’s who voted to keep federal standardized testing mandates in place last week read this blog and start to grasp how their policies are hurting public education.
LikeLike
They are also hurting the Democratic Party, most of whose leaders are, on educational issues, as bad as or worse than the Republicans.
LikeLike
I am a teacher with 25 years of experience. I encouraged my 3 kids to avoid teaching, and now they have successful careers in other fields. But I also have 2 grandchildren that are at the beginning of their educational journeys. Who will their teachers be? Amateur TFA instructors? Will they have to endure overcrowded factory style schools, or business modeled charters? How much of their time will be spent in front of a screen instead of in active, hands-on learning? It may not be a good time to be a teacher, but it is a worse time to be a student.
LikeLike
Your last sentence:
TAGO!
😎
LikeLike
yep. That’s why I left teaching. So I can be fully present to my children as we navigate public schooling in the “new normal.”
Just talking with a friend this morning whose children attend year round school and he said he finally told the school to stop hounding him about sending his children to school during the breaks. He says his children need breaks from school and time to learn and play and experience other things and just because his son, whose comprehension is above grade level, doesn’t read as fast as the school benchmark would have him read, doesn’t mean he is sending them on the breaks. I was proud of him and agreed whole-heartedly.
Wrap-around services are good, but if they rob the child of play time and experiencing other things just so they are on “green” on the data wall and everyone’s VAM is in place is NOT GOOD for the child.
LikeLike
“One solution: Residency programs that provide new teachers with intensive mentoring, coaching, and support for their first few years in the profession are gaining in popularity.”
Oh baloney. The problem is that no one wants to go into teaching – and those already in want out – because of the abuse teachers face. No amount of “mentoring” is going to fix that. The solution is to stop abusing teachers.
LikeLike
The big problem continues to be with unsupervised, unaccountable administrators who bully and target teachers for removal.
LikeLike
Teacher abuse will only stop when teachers stop being a bunch of sheep and just doing what they are told.
https://davidrtayloreducation.wordpress.com/2015/04/06/when-does-the-teacher-abuse-stop/
LikeLike
I wish there was a way to like all three of the above comments – Rheeformers are getting exactly what they wanted when they began their long war on public education and teachers. How can Americans continue to call our country the “Greatest Nation on Earth” when nearly half the population polled doesn’t want to see their children go up to be teachers?
What a sad demise of an honorable profession.
LikeLike
This is the perfect Hegelian Dialectic. THEY create the crisis in order to move their agenda forward by giving us the solution too. THEY create such a hostile environment for teachers which creates teacher shortage and then THEY rush in with the solution…..TEACH FOR AMERICA.
LikeLike
Yes that is exactly it. Just like the mechanic who tampers with your car so it breaks and you come right on back to him for the solution and of course his predetermined pay day.
LikeLike
Or H1bs.
LikeLike
Here’s a four-year old article about Caprice Young’s role in the de-professionalization of teaching:
http://www.schoolsmatter.info/2011/10/when-capricious-young-says-no.html
Robert Skeels starts by giving a detailed background on Ms. Young’s lucrative participation in various realms of the “corporate reform” world, but then focuses on her new role in “Encorps”, a company that takes de-professionalization to the next level. Whereas before it was “no experience required to teach”… now, it’s… “you’re now required to have no teaching experience.”
EXCERPT:
———————————————————————————————-
Given how busy Young has been, and how wealthy she has gotten over the years, one would think she would take a break. Yet it turns out her insatiable lust for money and power never ceases, nor does her hatred of educators and organized labor.
A reader sent me an email about her latest venture, and their analysis says so much about Young and the corporate school privatization putsch’s designs on deprofessionalizing teaching altogether.
———————————————————-
Robert,
I looked up Caprice’s new job…. “CEO” of a newly-formed company… “EnCorps”.
I’m trying to piece this together, but it appears that the charters in L.A. and San Francisco are hard up for Math and Science teachers, but the bosses don’t want to have to deal with fullly-credentialed teachers, and their accompanying demands for a decent wage, decent benefits, decent job conditions, etc.
They want desperate, compliant, cheap labor that can teach those hard-to-place subjects of Math and Science.
Enter… EnCorps… a sort of Teach for America for career-changers with Math and Science backgrounds in the private sector, and who are desperate for any kind of work.
The FAQ’s page seems strikingly familiar to TFA… i.e. the questions being asked of candidates, are almost identical to the TFA application. Here it is:
http://www.EnCorpsteachers.org/FAQ
What’s bothersome is that having a teaching credential… not just in California, but anywhere in the country… ELIMINATES YOU FROM EVEN BEING CONSIDERED TO BE AN EnCorps FELLOW ???!!
WTF???!!!
It’s like an organization is out to recruit people to staff hospitals that are desperate for qualified doctors and nurses, but they then say that anyone with an M.D., or a B.S/M.S in nursing is then disqualified from being recruited into that same organization.
Check this out: (bold highlighting is mine, NAME REDACTED)
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Eligibility
How do I know if I am eligible for EnCorps?
EnCorps Educators come to us from a diverse range of backgrounds. In order to meet basic eligibility requirements, a candidate must meet the following criteria:
· Must be a science, technology, engineering, or math (STEM) professional
· Fully eligible to work in the United States
· Able to pass a background check
· Have a Bachelor’s degree with a GPA of 2.50 or higher
· Not be in possession of a teaching credential (in California or any other state with a reciprocal agreement)
– – – – – – – – – – – – – –
A little farther down, it has the following FAQ’s:
– – – – – – – – – – – – – –
If I already have a teaching credential, can I apply?
No. Our program is designed to assist math and science professionals in their transition to teaching careers. If you are already a credentialed teacher, you are Not eligible to apply.
If I am credentialed in another state, can I apply?
No. California has reciprocal credential agreements with nearly all other states.
– – – – – – – – – – – – – –
And that’s a bad thing? I mean there are thousands of fully-credentialed MATH/SCIENCE teachers without a job right now in California.
I’m at a total loss to come up with a good, defensible reason why an organization whose “mission” —to use their own words—is “focused on closing the achievement gap by recruiting math and science professionals” to teach “in high-need schools in low-income communities as our mission dictates” would then turn away those “professionals” most qualified and able to do so.
When you read on, however, you start to get an idea as to why. The goal of EnCorps'”Boot Camp” training program is to produce teachers who are “CEO’s of their classrooms”.
Ay carumba! as Bart Simpson would say.
There’s the market-based model at work.
However, if you’re a parent in a low-income community—or any community, for that matter—do you want your kids to be taught by:
1) fully-credentialed Math/Science teachers with possibly years/decades of actual teaching experience;
OR
2) totally inexperienced, uncredentialed people just out of a dubious, short “Boot Camp” that trained them into being “CEO’s of their classrooms”?
I don’t know about you, Robert, but that’s not a close call. Any fully-informed parent would be irate that their principal procured their Math/Science teachers from EnCorps instead of hiring the countless experienced, fully-credentialed teachers who are out there available to work at that parent’s school.
Sincerely,
NAME REDACTED
———————————————————-
“CEO’s of their classrooms” indeed.
No experience required? No, it’s required that you have no experience. We wouldn’t want the bevy of fully qualified experienced professionals applying for their old jobs back now would we? After all, these days all it takes is five weeks to become a master at anything. Right?
The board of the vile EnCorps, Inc. features the usual suspects, including charlatan Ted Mitchell of NewSchools Venture Fund. None of EnCorps board members or staff are strangers to the profitable school privatization faction. They are all about educating poor kids on the cheap.
Celebrated education professor and author Dr. Diane Ravitch once said:
“The Obama administration is using its unprecedented billions to advance a strategy of deregulation and deprofessionalization.”
————————————————————-
One more thing, Ted Mitchell (mentioned near the end of this 2011 article) was later named “Assistant Secretary of Education” under Duncan.
LikeLike
Jack: good info.
If you can, would you give the link for the specific page where you found the “CEO’s of their classrooms” phrase?
Thank you.
😎
LikeLike
I just checked it. They’ve since scrubbed that from the page… along with the parts about no credential being required, nay demanded of potential employees.
Robert’s article likely brought them some embarassment.
LikeLike
Also, thanks for calling attention to the Teacher shortage/crisis in Las Vegas and that hare-brained “superhero” teacher recruiting campaign, which includes the anti-union superintendent zip-lining through downtown Vegas like Superman. (SEE BELOW)
What’s happening there is the eventual game plan for teachers
in all fifty states.
This is what ed reform has wrought…
the de-professionalization of teaching…
and the downgrading of the caliber of
the teaching force.
Check out this quote
(from the link BELOW):
http://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2015/05/06/402887228/las-vegas-betting-on-new-teachers-but-coming-up-short
—————————————-
—————————————-
“‘I feel like I’m being challenged, which is a definite change,” says first-year teacher Jessica Adams. She used to work as a cocktail server at the Planet Hollywood casino and resort on the Vegas strip. Unfulfilled with that career, she joined a fast-track teacher training program to get into the classroom.
Server Jessica is now Ms. Adams, the fourth-grade teacher.
“I really enjoy being with the kids and making a difference instead of serving tables,” she says with a chuckle.
The 26-year-old, who has a college degree in hospitality management, now works the floor in a temporary classroom trailer at Robert Forbuss Elementary, an overcrowded school in southwest Las Vegas.
———————————–
————————————
Now, Jessica… if you’re out there reading this, I don’t mean to denigrate low-level service work such as cocktail waitressing, or degrees in “hospitality management”, but as kids these days say, “WTF!” (What the f-word!)
Are Bill Gates kids at Lakeside being taught by cocktail waitresses with a couple weeks “training”, and in converted trailers? Obama’s kids? Rahm Emanuel’s? Michelle Rhee’s? Campbell Brown’s?
The enrollment at ed departments are dropping like an elevator ride at a Disney park… and current teachers are fleeing teaching like… like… like… I can’t think of a metaphor …
So what do they have to do in places where this crisis is being felt earliest—and there’s no union, or an extremely weak union (i.e. right-to-work-FOR-LESS states)?
Again, let’s take a trip to Sin City, U.S.A. and find out
about the teacher shortage there:
http://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2015/05/06/402887228/las-vegas-betting-on-new-teachers-but-coming-up-short
“Las Vegas: Betting On New Teachers But Coming Up Short”
The title of the NPR piece is wrong; those in charge in Clark County and Las Vegas are most certainly NOT “betting on” teachers. “Betting” implies you’re putting money on the table on the square marked “teachers”. They’re doing nothing of the kind. They’re only betting on… or hoping… that they can continue “cheaping out” on what they have to pay teachers. They believe that they do this, in part, by coming up with ridiculous gimmicks to get teachers to work in lousy conditions and for lousy pay.
Back to NPR:
———————————–
————————————
Many veteran educators here say the shortage is undermining morale and student learning.
“It shouldn’t necessarily all be put on the veteran teachers to help the new teachers,” says fifth-grade teacher Rob Rosenblatt. The shortage and overcrowding issues, he says, mean more work and more stress for teachers.
The district increasingly relies on long-term substitutes and online classes to help plug the holes. And there is a critical shortage of qualified substitutes.
Sarah Sunnasy teaches fifth grade at Bertha Ronzone Elementary School. She has back trouble but says she almost never calls in sick.
SCARY GRAPH ILLUSTRATING SHORTAGE
“I’ve come to school on days where I cried trying to get out of bed,” Sunnasy says. “Because I know if I try to call in a sub, there is not going to be anybody there. And I’m not gonna put that pressure on the people that I work with to split my class or cover my class.”
Last school year in the district about 500 teachers quit without giving any reason. One of Rosenblatt’s colleagues resigned a few weeks into the new school year. Rosenblatt says he and a colleague have had to pick up all the slack — lessons, report cards, grading and tests.
“Basically it was the two of us teaching not just our two classes but a third class on top of it. I even told my kids, ‘I’m neglecting you guys.’ ”
He apologized to his regular class but told them he had to step in because the class next door “just wasn’t getting the education they deserved.”
———————————–
————————————
Things there are so godawful that to solve the problem,
those in charge even come up with this idiotic
“superhero” teacher recruiting campaign where
Las Vegas’ (i.e. Clark County’s) anti-union school
superintendent Pat Skorkowsky went zip-lining through
downtown Las Vegas like a superhero to drum
up publicity, and where all human resource dept.
workers now wear superhero capes.
I’m not kidding… watch this video of this blithering idiot soaring through the air:
Hey, Pat Skorkowsky… why don’t you just pay educators a decent, (union-negotiated?) salary, with decent benefits, job conditions, etc.? This is a profession, not a low-level service job like cocktail waitressing!!! No… the rich Red States’ folks don’t want their taxes raised, and corporate reformers want to destroy teaching as a profession.
The Ed Week article BELOW has Staci Vesneske, the district’s chief human resources officer, implicitly dismissing the notion of raising teachers’ salaries will be part of the efforts to address the teacher shortage: (There’s more details about the “superhero” campaign)
http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/District_Dossier/2015/04/are_you_a_certified_teacher_cl.html
———————————–
————————————
ED WEEK: “One challenge in attracting candidates is wages. The starting salary for teachers there is just under $35,000, less than the national average and lower than other similarly sized urban districts. (The 2012-13 national average teacher starting salary was $36,141.)
“But that number may appear deceptively low, Vesneske said, because district employees do not pay for Social Security withholdings—the district covers those costs—and there are other financial perks that may make the salary worthwhile, she said.
“The need for teachers is more crucial in the elementary grades, but the district is looking for candidates in high-need areas such as math, science and special education, Vesneske said. Of the 2,600 teacher candidates the district is seeking, at least 1,000 will be elementary teachers, she said.
” ‘We are still looking for quality,’ she said.”
———————————–
————————————
… but we don’t want to have to pay anything for it….
she should have added.
LikeLike
Oh, and here’s that ziplining Vegas’ Superintendent Skorkowsky’s personal blog:
http://www.ccsd.net/district/pat-personally/
First, here’s Skorkowsky’s post putting out a bogus “survey” to the district employees and the community where he’s soliciting input on how to address the teacher shortage crisis:
http://www.ccsd.net/district/pat-personally/2015/apr/21/ccsd-seeks-your-input
You notice how, among the multiple choices included as “solutions”, you don’t see things such as
“Increasing Teacher Salaries & Benefits”
or
“Lowering Class Size”.
Instead you get only the following: (with no choice of “OTHER” and a blank to write in any other alternatives)
———————————–
————————————
Superintendent Skorkowsky:
“This year, the survey will ask questions pertaining to the following categories:
— Parental Involvement and Support
— Learning Attitudes
— School Safety
— Bullying and Victimization
— Physical Environment and Resources
— Respect for Diversity
— Perceptions of School Performance
— Perceptions of the District
“Currently, we get feedback through a variety of methods: public meetings, community events, PTA and PTO events, and student advisory groups as well as the feedback our Board of Trustee members get directly from their constituents.
“We want to make sure we get input from as many people as possible. We will report the data to the trustees and the community. We care about everyone in our school district and the survey is a way to get a snapshot of how we are doing, measure our progress over time and consider potential improvement for the future.”
——————————————-
This is a guy following his corporate masters’ marching orders, which include… “pay teachers nothing”… and “keep class size and student-teacher ratios sky high.”
Any suggestions otherwise are met with a curt, “Nope! Ain’t doin’ that! NEXT!”
What’s really galling is Skorkowsky’s phony and patronizing post about how valued teachers and other district employees are:
http://www.ccsd.net/district/pat-personally/2015/may/5/no-one-does-more-than-our-teachers
———————————–
————————————
Superintendent Skorkowsky:
“When you hear any legislator, business or community member or any economic expert speak about the future of our city, the consensus is that everything is tied to supporting education. We have worked hard to develop a focus of supporting public education in our community. It’s no secret that successful students lead to a successful community – and our teachers have a great deal of impact in that area.
“If anyone can handle that pressure, it’s our teachers. In true hero fashion, our teachers are also friends, nurses, counselors and advocates. During Teacher Appreciation Week, it’s important that we honor the hard work our teachers do for our 320,000 students.
“I personally know the job of being a teacher is not easy. It has become increasingly difficult and they carry a lot of responsibility and constantly deal with new challenges and changes.
“Still, despite the daily pressures they face, teachers provide a stable, safe and engaging environment for our students. Our teachers challenge our students, work with them individually to help them meet their potential and orchestrate entire classrooms with different levels of achievement without leaving anyone behind or letting anyone move forward alone.
“I personally am grateful for every one of our 18,000 plus teachers. I am comforted knowing that we have great leaders in our classrooms who support each other and who go beyond the classroom to help our students.
“Teacher Appreciation Week is a great reminder to thank our teachers. There are ways that we can support our teachers all year long. I encourage our parents and community members to ask what they can help provide or ask to volunteer in the classroom or in the school.
“More importantly, don’t be afraid to get more involved in your child’s education. Call or email their teacher and ask what you can do to help keep your child on track. After all, what makes our teachers amazing is that their interest is the same as our parents’ – to make sure our children succeed and to ensure a prosperous future for our community.”
———————————–
————————————
What a bunch of hollow, empty nonsense.
Pat, if, as you say, teachers are so crucial, and that regarding the future of Vegas, “everything is tied to education”, then why don’t you show your and the community’s “appreciation” by paying your teachers a livable wage relative to the costs of living in Vegas?
Why don’t you lower the sky high class sizes so that classes are manageable, so those sky high class sizes aren’t driving that annual mass exodus of these teachers that you and the community supposedly value so much?
Again, you notice no mention of low salaries or high class sizes/student-teacher-ratios among the reasons one should show sympathy and appreciations for teachers, or how raising salaries or lowering class sizes/student-teacher-ratios might be parts of the solution… again, it’s all straight out of the corporate reform playbook.
I’ll finish with two comments from the EdWeek article on the Vegas’ teacher shortage quoted above:
First here’s a comment from the Ed Week article of Vegas’ teacher shortage crisis—written by one “Sir Johnny”, that pretty much nails it:
http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/District_Dossier/2015/04/are_you_a_certified_teacher_cl.html
(Go to the COMMENTS section)
———————————–
————————————
————————————————
9:19 PM on April 10, 2015
Sir Johnny:
“$35,000 / year doesn’t cut it anymore. Trying purchasing a house for that amount of money as a single person.
“You want me to fork out $85K for a bachelor’s degree (what Pitt or Penn State now cost) and you can only pay $35K? …
“Nope, not going to happen. Doesn’t matter if you are paying both sides of Social Security or not. Pay needs to be around $60K/year to make it worthwhile.”
————————————————
———————————–
————————————
Another comment from “eppie”, a licensed veteran teacher in Nevada, says that it’s not all about money:
———————————–
————————————
————————
7:18 AM on April 11, 2015
eppie:
“As a licensed Nevada teacher for both elementary and middle school (including math and science), I will not go back in the class room until Common Core, the SBAC testing, and the student data tracking, storing and sharing, is removed from our state. The article failed to mention the reason many NV teachers retired early is because of Common Core.”
LikeLike
RECENT UPDATE on Las Vegas’ teacher shortage.
http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/District_Dossier/2015/07/nevadas_clark_county_is_hoping_1.html
According to this Ed Week article, as of last week, Vegas (Clark County) schools have over 1,000 teaching positions to fill in the next month-and-a-half early September) Again, this is due mostly to all the teachers leaving over poor salary and high class size (among other poor job conditions) during the middle or end of the 2014-2015 school year.
Apparently, the superhero campaign was an expensive bust. The superintendent was ziplining in vain:
In a move of desperation, the Nevada legislature is allocating a chintzy $10 million dollars whereby new or retired (but not current) teachers will get a one-time-only bonus of $5,000 if they sign by August 15th. Again, as for the teachers returning from last year… they get nothing.
Also, one-time bonuses are a way to cheap out on paying teachers, or other employees in general. The base salary, or salary schedule is not increased. When UTLA was fighting for a raise this last year, LAUSD kept offering multiple one-time bonuses that would not go on the salary schedule, and UTLA rightly turned them down. Eventually, UTLA teachers received a double-digit increase (10%)
Furthermore, it’s a slap in the face to those teachers who didn’t bail during the middle of last year, or at the end of last year. They’re sticking it out under trying conditions, returning to their classes in September, and they get nothing. Instead of rewarding current teachers, district officials use some lame ticking clock, used car salesman offer for people yet to be hired…
“Don’t miss out on this special limited time offer!
Sign on to teach by August 15, and you’ll get a check for $5000!”
Would hospitals need to stoop to this to get doctors and nurses? Would police departments do this to hire police officers.
LikeLike
“Would hospitals need to stoop to this to get doctors and nurses”? “Would police departments do this to hire police officers”? No because both are treated and respected as professionals whereas teachers are not.
LikeLike
Police? Not so much any more, sadly. Everything they do is questioned and videoed. Our turn is coming very, very soon and in some cases the videos have begun. The questioning (condemning) is ongoing.
Here in North Carolina the teacher shortage will only continue to grow as our screwy legislature and governor continue to bow down to big business and cut, cut, cut.
LikeLike
You can add New Mexico to the long list of states where Teachers are bailing out. Teachers who can retire are doing so early. Teachers who can are moving to other states where they can be treated more professionally. The Colleges of Education in New Mexico have seen a dramatic drop in enrollment because of the unprofessional way current Teachers are being treated. Current High School Teachers are encouraging their Students not to enter the Teaching profession. High School Students in New Mexico are clearly stating that the Governor and the Public Education Department are stealing their education with all the standardized testing being force upon them.
During the last four and half years under leadership Governor Martinez and Secretary of Education Skandera (a person mentored by Jeb Bush) Teachers have been bullied by the use of standardized testing and a Teacher evaluation that is totally unfair and useless when it comes to ensuring that Students are receiving a proper education. Neither Martinez or Skandera have any real experience in education. It is clear that Skandera is on board with privatization of public education. Martinez is making sure she does not upset Jeb Bush and many, many other Republicans so that she has a chance for a political position in Washington DC at the end of her term of office as Governor.
LikeLike
The trouble is, no state is immune to this garbage. The filth is nationwide.
LikeLike
Interesting that they show the Independence, MO billboard—that district was part of the notorious KCMO district just a decade ago. So it is rather a new district, and mostly non-minority (I think, at least compared to KCMO it is).
When I moved to Kansas City in 2000, people told me to stay away from KCMO (which of course made me flock right to it because I’m like that). But I taught in Independence my first year and it was mostly white children from trailer parks.
Friends I have in KCMO just moved out to Kansas because the charter they attended does not have a high school. So Independence seems to have an odd window of not being part of KCMO, but also not being part of Kansas reforms (although I thought Missouri reforms were just as bad. . .right???)
Pretty soon, there will be no “surrounding states” to run to. We’ll have to all start teaching in the Carribean or something—-hey, that doesn’t sound half bad!
LikeLike
woops—Caribbean. (doubled the wrong letters)
LikeLike
One of my own kids wants to teach, but we are discouraging that route. It makes no sense to invest tens of thousands of dollars into a teaching degree when the profession will be replaced with TFA volunteers or a career last only a few years.
LikeLike
I tried to talk my grandnephew’s wife out of the profession. She abandoned going into pediatric nursing in favor of teaching and will get her master’s degree in three years or so, and I think she is making a huge mistake. Even in Oregon, notorious for being nearly impossible to get a teaching job, is bottoming out of applicants for teaching positions, which is good for somebody like me getting up in years and trying to get my license and return because I am not retraining for something else at my age of 60. People new to the field are still starry-eyed and naive and think abuse can’t happen to them. They don’t realize that it is literally a crapshoot who you get as a boss.
LikeLike
A very huge mistake. She should have become a nurse work for a year and returned for a Masters to become a CRNA. I am currently doing something similar (Anesthesiologist Assistant). The starting salary in Florida (which is known for low pay) is no less than $130,000 for new graduates and as high as $180,000 for those with a few years experience. Mind you this is without any overtime at all 6 weeks paid vacation and 401 K match with profit sharing and full medical insurance paid.
LikeLike
I always used to warn the starry eyed newbies who thought they were getting into something that really wasn’t as it appeared. After about year three most of them would tell me “now I know what you were talking about when you tried to warn us all those years ago”. I actually had it good in the classroom. I was given autonomy because my test scores were always good and I really got along with administration. However, I was unhappy personally because I was always broke. I simply got tired of making peanuts and working so hard only to get the proverbial slap in the face when it was time to be compensated for my hard work and dedication.
LikeLike
Don’t allow your child to do it. It will only cost more when he or she ends up leaving the profession and having to return to school for another degree because as we all know education degrees translate to basically nil outside of the classroom. I was fortunate enough to have my loans wiped out via the teacher loan forgiveness program. Thank God I taught in a Title One school and taught math which allowed me to wipe out $15,000 of debt. The funny thing is I owed $15,300.
LikeLike
Medicine may be better for now. But the concern is the same “accountability” methods applied to teaching will be transferred to medical fields. There is just too much money in medicine to hide from hedge fund managers. And medicine is heavily intertwined with government, just like teaching.
A ProPublica report discussed in our Ohio news ranked surgeons. The similarities to teacher rank and yank were eerie. Most interesting was the response of those doctors ranked lowed. Very much the same arguments teachers make about flawed data and methodologies. In the past, doctors could wield power by threatening to leave or limit care. But they may find that tactic ineffective against Reformers who have their concierge doctors and could care less. It is all about money to Reformers and if a few more middle class start dying, that is within their acceptable margin of error.
Good luck in non-teaching. Changing careers at my age again just isn’t feasible. I thought I was in an invincible career originally. One director told me I was so capable, I’d never be fired or laid off. But it doesn’t matter how good you are in our Walmart economy or what skills you possess. H1bs destroyed that field. So out of the pan into the fire, only to watch the same corporate titans tear down teaching. At some point, Americans are going to have to realize we are all racing to the bottom. It will just take some a little longer to get there.
LikeLike
Mommas don’t let your babies grow up to be teachers
Don’t let ’em get pinkeye and drive them old cars
Make ’em be doctors and lawyers and such
Someone help me out!!!
Apologies to Willie!
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Texas Education.
LikeLike
Or, perhaps you’re one of those students who desires a challenge,
or even a good addition to your résumé for Grad school.
Platforms: Android, Blackberry, i – Phone, i – Pad, Windows Phone.
What you give away doesn’t have to be costly, but it must be valuable.
LikeLike