Mike Klonsky writes that Chicago’s Mayor Rahm Emanuel and Governor Bruce Rauner have brought the city and state to their knees with their austerity budgets.
“Mayor 1% finally made his long overdue payment to the teachers pension fund, but not without extracting his pound of flesh — 1,400 teachers being laid off and another $1B in borrowing, another windfall for his bankster patrons and another attack on the teachers union and teachers’ collective bargaining rights.
“Aside from the hardship the layoffs will bring to the teachers and their children and families, think about what the loss of so many union jobs means to the community and the continuing destruction of the city’s middle class.
“Think also about spiraling class sizes and program cuts in city schools and what that will mean, especially for the neediest of students who need personalization more than ever. It also makes another teachers strike that much more likely.
“By my figuring, 1,400 teacher jobs lost means minimally, about $84 million in yearly taxable income that won’t be spent in neighborhood groceries, auto dealers, hair salons and shoe stores. That translates to hundreds more lay-offs from local businesses, millions more in lost revenue for the city and state and the further pauperization of the community’s working class and small businesses owners.”
“Likewise for our sociopathic billionaire governor who will shut down the state government, with an even greater civic toll, rather than taxing his corporate and LaSalle St. cronies even one penny more on their speculative windfall profits.”

Both the city and the state should be charging transaction taxes for every trade at the Mercantile Exchange. That’s where, during the Occupy days, they hung signs in the windows bragging, “”WE ARE THE 1%”
Hey, if they can own it, they should be required to pay for it.
LikeLike
LikeLike
Why should they be required to pay any more than YOU? Simply because they are more capable, more ambitious, more focused….or, in a word, “better”? Sorry, but I’m not seeing it. Just because others have wealth and you don’t, from my perspective, that does NOT give you the right to coerce funds out of them.
You want to see something financed, then here’s a suggestion; *YOU* finance it…and quit expecting OTHERS to do the work for you!
Sound like a plan? [smile]
LikeLike
Ken Meyer,
Lot of readers here don’t like the fact that a few people soak up billions while others work even harder and can’t pay their rent. If your plan is that the rich thrive while working people sink into debt, then I don’t like your plan at all. Oh, it is so very hard to get a reservation in those restaurants where a bottle of sparkling water costs $10, and dinner is $200 per. Pity for the billionaires and garden=variety millionaires. I don’t think so.
LikeLike
Brokers charge transaction fees. They should be paying taxes on them. Many locations charge service taxes.
LikeLike
Don’t feed the trolls. Someone who claims that money makes you a better person is just being provocative.
LikeLike
“Someone who claims that money makes you a better person is just being
provocative.stupid”Fixed.
LikeLike
Thank you, Diane. I’m one of those people who can’t pay my rent. I added up my lifetime earnings as an educator over the past 40+ years at non-unionized schools and it turns out that I made HALF of what the government says the average worker with a high school diploma earns in their lifetime. I have three college degrees and my average annual salary is below minimum wage.
That occurred because I’m an Early Childhood Education specialist and since we do not have free programs for all birth – 5 year olds in this country, I went where the jobs were and taught primarily in private child care centers, where the pay is low and most teachers receive no benefits. Consequently, my Social Security is unlivable. My experience is not unusual. I fear this is the model that privatizers most relish and would love to emulate. Please do what you can to prevent that. Since I am now three months behind in my rent and can’t possibly pay it, I’m going to become homeless this month. There could be many more teachers like me out there.
LikeLike
Ken Meyer,
Go back to your tepid rabbit hut since there’s no one like you to share your apologetic, delusional thinking that makes you look like a silly talking orbit.
[grin]
LikeLike
ECE Teacher: I am serious when I ask this: is there somewhere that I can send you money to help you get current on your rent? No one should be homeless. I don’t have a lot, but I can help. Perhaps if others feel the same way, they could help also. My email is
threatenedoutwest@yahoo.com. PLEASE let me know.
LikeLike
Threatened Out West: You are so kind to offer to help me. Thank you ever so much. I am very afraid of homelessness, so I did just email you. Any donation could potentially help me to stay in my apartment and would be appreciated. Very gratefully, ECE Teacher
LikeLike
Don’t they get it? With the way they are rolling hardly anyone is going to want to become a teacher. Why bother when the hand that feeds you is also spanking you? Jerks! Government is taking the heart out of public education. Only a miracle worker can put the heart back in. Who will that miracle worker be?
LikeLike
Sure they get it. That’s one of the strategies in their business plan to privatize public education. If people want to teach, they’re supposed to go to the ever expanding numbers of non-unionized charters that are opening up.
As far as a “miracle worker”, Bernie Sanders is the only candidate that has come out against privatization. On June 26th, about 39 minutes in, he said he’s against privatizing education and NCLB/testing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKJ0yFKE3kY
LikeLiked by 1 person
The goal is to replace teachers with “coaches” – except for children of the 1%ers.
LikeLike
All the coaches I’ve known at CPS neighborhood schools are experienced master teachers. I think this is about replacing qualified veteran teachers with minimally trained, novice TFA types. Those who stay more than two years do tend to get sent up the ladder rather quickly to serve as models and leaders at charters though, despite the fact that they are still beginners. Maybe the intention is to infect neighborhood schools with the same misguided policies.
LikeLike
A shocking development is the NYC Pre-K for All initiative. They need over 1,000 Pre-K or EC teachers. Certification is desired and eventually required. Carmen Farina is sending out emails to DOE teachers and is rounding up applicants from the DOE portal. However, the schools are non-union and the pay is very low. This is coming from the DOE. What can we do about it? Additional b -2 certification is from 3 – 6 credits. This is expensive;about $1,500 – 7,000, depending of the school. Once certified for B – 2, you must re-take the CST (Pearson test – about $290). It has been recently re-written and is extremely difficult. Since most people (if not all) fail, you can use you previous CST test! But you are required to take the new test first. More money for Pearson. Universal Pre-K is a license for Pearson to print money. Albany should pay DOE rates to the teachers and pay the schools (YMCA’s, etc) who are participating in the program.
LikeLike
Look at the posts on blogs like this; after reading them, do you think very many RESPONSIBLE people would WANT to be like the whinny individuals that post here?
It’s not a question of “taking the heart out of public education”; rather, that the “heart” has become a diseased organ, composed of individual elements that are about as “professional” as carnival barkers.
LikeLike
You sound immature and crazy.
LikeLike
Nothing like a troll’s puerile posts to demonstrate the pot calling the kettle black.
LikeLike
It is clear you understand nothing about public education. It is a cornerstone of democracy; it is of, by and for the people.
LikeLike
This week’s troll, ladies and gentlemen! Have you noticed that they only post for a week at a time? I wonder how much they get paid to do it.
LikeLike
It is clear that Ken Meyer is somebody’s whipping boy/girl, sent out to attack public education and attempt to win support. Notice, there is no evidence offered, just the usual vitriol.
The teachers I’ve had and worked with in my lifetime are some of the finest, most caring people and deserve the respect that is not going to come from such a pesky flea.
By the way, “whinny” is something a horse does. Ironic, isn’t it, that Ken Meyer can’t spell “whiny’, since it’s all he seems capable of himself!
LikeLike
Ken,
In what ways has the “‘heart’ has become a diseased organ”? Please list what you consider the “symptoms” of that disease to be.
TIA,
Duane
LikeLike
“Only a miracle worker can put the heart back in. Who will that miracle worker be?”
NO!, What it’s going to take is each individual teacher to refuse to be part of the educational malpractices that are educational standards and standardized testing and any other harmful malpractice which they are told to do! Refuse!
LikeLike
I think that the most cuts will be to central office personnel and school support personnel and programs in the schools and almost 400 will be vacant positions that will not be filled. It’s too early to say what this is going to look like until the actual cuts are made.
LikeLike
I don’t think it’s very likely that central office will be seeing a lot of cuts, since they have been expanding under Rahm:
“CPS has actually increased spending on central office salaries since 2011, by $22 million. CPS has not only held the line against budget cuts to its central offices involved in standardized-testing (Department of Assessment), expanding school choice (Innovation and Incubation) and test-based management of schools (Accountability), but they’ve increased spending on staff by 11% since 2011.”
http://ajustchicago.org/2015/07/cps-broke-on-purpose/
We may not know yet where the cuts will be, but I don’t see cuts to “school support personnel,” “programs in the schools” and “vacant positions” as something that could be minor, since it could mean fewer supports and programs for at-risk kids (who need more not less), as well as not replacing retiring teachers and increasing class sizes.
LikeLike
This gets worse than Klonsky illustrates it.
http://chicago.suntimes.com/news/7/71/736432/1400-cps-layoffs-include-teachers-school-staff-central-office-personnel
Emanuel is asking everyone else for a whole ton of money before being willing to institute a relatively small property tax increase which isn’t even among the biggest ways he could bring in money to the system (most of them are riffs on the millionaire’s tax that he would need to be willing to bite the hand that feeds him to implement).
Either teachers give back a ton of money to pay for their engineered crisis and to put the system back on solid footing, and/or, the state gives a ton of money to bailout the system and/or centralizes pension debt which would be a backdoor bailout since it would saddle the state with CPS’s choices.
All so Emanuel is willing to increase revenue by a few hundred million which barely touches the debt owed to the banks because of their financial gimmickry that they’ve used to fill in the gaps while paying out huge to financial institutions.
LikeLike
This is all part of the plan to starve public schools and destroy them. His plan is going to harm those in the working class which, in turn, will impact the economy of the city. Millionaires can only own so many homes. His goal has always been to use schools to improve neighborhoodsl If he destroys the middle class, who will live in these neighborhoods? This is misguided leadership wearing blinders.
LikeLike
Isn’t Emanuel also using a bunch of taxpayer’s money to fund a stadium at a private college in the city?
LikeLike
Actually, Dr. Ravitch could block the trolls in consideration of her readers. This is by far the most informative forum on the internet, and nobody needs the distractions. Out of curiosity, I click on the link of anyone glibly defending choice or reform policies, and they always lead to some sort of dead end, in this case a blank Facebook page. Leave the forum to those who are willing to stand up and be counted.
LikeLike
No need to block the few pseudo trolls. I use pseudo because for the most part they post a couple of times at the most and don’t return. They certainly don’t appear to have the “passion” of a true troll, only the paroxysm of a paid puck of propaganda.
LikeLike
“Austerity” doesn’t work. Not in Greece. Not in Chicago.
Not for the 99%, at least. (It works fabulously for big banks and others at the top of the pyramid, of course) .
The evidence is very strong.
Austerity is nonetheless propped up by crackpot economic “theory” that depends on La La Land mathturbation and elementary math errors by incompetents like Rogoff and Rheinhart at Harvard.
LikeLike
“. . . mathturbation. . . ”
TAGrO!
LikeLike
The National Institute for Retirement Security has a state by state press release on the “Economic Impact of State and Local Pensions”, at its website. Illinois is included.
LikeLike
This is EXACTLY why people should delveDEEPLY into the facts BEFORE you vote.
Be careful what you pray for, you may get it.
Sadly the propaganda machine working full time fools too many people too much of the time.
The corporate media does NOT educate. It promotes corporate agenda – propaganda.
LikeLike