Ever since the state of Louisiana began its voucher program, allowing students to attend religious schools with public funds, the program has gone from one embarrassment to another. The school that won the most vouchers was a small rural church school; it was thrown out if the program for financial errors. Some schools taught creationism. The state court ruled that the state could not fund vouchers by taking money from funding dedicated to public schools.
And now this. Danielle Dreillinger reports in the Néw Orleans Times-Picayune that 1/3 of the state’s voucher students attend low-performing schools.
“One third of Louisiana’s voucher students are enrolled at private schools doing such a poor job of educating them that the schools have been barred from taking new voucher students, according to Education Department data. The schools include four in Jefferson Parish, eight in New Orleans and six in Baton Rouge.
“The Louisiana Scholarship Program lets children from low-income families attend participating private schools at taxpayer expense if they have been at C-, D- or F-graded public schools or are entering kindergarten. Now in its third year, the program has been threatened by local and federal lawsuits, but total enrollment continues growing, from 6,775 in 2013-14 to 7,362 students this year.”

“Enrollment growing” up to under 8,000 is problematic since over 300,000 students are eligible.
LikeLike
Diane, you frequently say poverty is a reason for poor performance. I believe you. It is ridiculous, then, to expect that low-income students will necessarily do better by attending voucher schools. If you think they should do better just because they change schools, then you are contradicting yourself on poverty.
By the way, I object to my tax money being spent to teach faith in evolution. What can I do about that?
LikeLike
The alleged justification for vouchers is to get kids out of “failing schools”. If vouchers can’t do that (which they can’t – you’re right, poverty is the problem), then there is no reason for their existence.
Evolution is settled science.
LikeLike
Evolution isn’t something one would have “faith” in.
LikeLike
Monte – The point is not that Diane believes low-income students will do better in private schools. The point is that the LDE’s justification for vouchers is that all students can do better in private schools (or charters). Test scores used as a measure of student learning (bogus as it is) disprove their justification.
LikeLike
Thanks, Bill. Iâll get a Doodle out later. Book looks great. Thanks for such a thoughtful selection. Jan Resseger http://janresseger.wordpress.com/ “That all citizens will be given an equal start through a sound education is one of the most basic, promised rights of our democracy. Our chronic refusal as a nation to guarantee that right for all children…. is rooted in a kind of moral blindness, or at least a failure of moral imagination…. It is a failure which threatens our future as a nation of citizens called to a common purpose… tied to one another by a common bond.” âSenator Paul Wellstone, March 31, 2000
LikeLike
This is exactly what is happening in CO with Jefferson County school’s new school board voting in a Hillsdale College’s curriculum in an academy which violates the Supreme Court’s Constitution, the CO State’s Statues on religion in in school, and Jefferson County’s policies. Keep up your great work. We need help. Koch Brothers are said to funnel in 4 million dollars the next elections again, up from $400,000. We have only 2 seats now held by friends of the schools which will be swept away by the people who don’t vote, plus, the conservatives who are giddy with control now. Needless to say, the public schools are losing operation funds while their new charters have opened up in well to do neighborhoods. (I taught 34 yrs.)When they cut sports, art, and music in the Middle-Jr Highs, the gangs moved into the neighborhoods.) I spent $7,000 of my own money the last several yrs which I taught. Now as I sit in or live stream each board meeting I shudder at the life the teachers are living. Our school board meetings are a sham as kids step up to speak about their needs and they are rudely treated. I know it all started in a national secret conservative meeting of the rich Republicans as a plan to control elections. It will create a conservative population who are submissive to “the man”. Never quit advocating for schools. Some days you are all we educators have. Mary Patee 303-424-1240 marypatee@comcast.net
LikeLike
How is it legal for federal dollars to be spent this way when we have separation of church and state? Why are states permitted to give preferential treatment to vouchers and charters when the results have been so poor and the amount of fraud is staggering? There is a serious disconnect in our culture when democratic institutions take a back seat to some private group that can swallow up funds, get lackluster results while the rules allow them to starve public education. Where are the laws that protect children whose families want them to get a free public education in the United States?
LikeLike
Small church school rips off taxpayer’s money to teach Creationism. Sounds like a church run by pharisees.
LikeLike
It never ceases to amaze me at the Oligarchy’s ability to get people to vote for something that is bad for them by using some other idea like guns, or faith, or “Choice”.
I wonder if we have reached a tipping point where people who are driven into poverty or at least out of the middle class by the Koch’s and Walton’s now give the 1% what they want and vote against unions because they only see the tax issue.
We need more unions, not less to combat inequality. There is a close relationship between unionization and income inequality.
http://m.dailykos.com/story/2014/05/26/1301209/-The-tight-link-between-unions-the-middle-class-and-inequality-in-two-charts
It is pretty easy to see the effects of not being unionized on educators when you look at the adjunct professor issue.
http://america.aljazeera.com/opinions/2015/2/unions-can-fix-the-crisis-facing-adjunct-professors.html
LikeLike