In response to two recent studies of Ohio charter schools, Governor John Kasich said that he would recommend stronger oversight of the state’s charters. This is noteworthy because charter operators have generously funded the campaigns of the governors and Republican legislators.
Critics of Ohio’s charter sector are skeptical. They note (off the record, of course) that the wealthiest charter operators have already made their campaign contributions for this election cycle. We will see if Governor Kasich proves them wrong.
The Columbus Dispatch wrote:
Gov. John Kasich pledged yesterday to crack down on shady Ohio charter-school operators in his upcoming budget proposal.
In a year-end speech to the Ohio Chamber of Commerce, the governor also threw out broad hints of possible tax changes, called for greater regulation on fracking wellheads and defended religious involvement in a new state-funded program with public schools.
“We are going to fix the lack of regulation on charter schools,” he said. “There is no excuse for people coming in here and taking advantage of anything. So we will be putting some tough rules into our budget.”
Two studies released this month blasted state laws and regulations that allow poor-performing Ohio charter schools to flourish and management companies to profit off the tax-funded privately operated schools. The studies showed that charter-school students receive fewer days of learning than youngsters at traditional public schools. Both reports were commissioned by the Thomas B. Fordham Foundation, a pro-charter-school organization urging more accountability of charter schools.
Richard A. Ross, state schools superintendent, said court actions and “persuasiveness” have failed to fix problems with some charter-school operators.
The changes will seek to exert more state control over charter-school sponsors — “operationally, financially and educationally” — to ensure high-quality educations for charter students, Ross said.

Don’t believe it for a second. It will be like the Moreland Commission–once they get close to the truth, it will be shut down.
LikeLike
Let’s hope that his inevitable Blue Ribbon Commission, headed by some generals and captains of industry of course, can also address the occasional reports that those who lie down with dogs get fleas.
LikeLike
Odd, because the Columbus Dispatch changed that story after they put it up.
Here’s what they wrote in the first version:
“He said the state will no longer tolerate out-of-state organizers coming into Ohio just to make money and take advantage of children.”
And here’s what the story says now:
“There is no excuse for people coming in here and taking advantage of anything. So we will be putting some tough rules into our budget.”
Did Kasich say out of state organizers were coming into Ohio just to make money and take advantage of children, or not?
Obviously if he said what they wrote (originally) it’s a much stronger statement.
LikeLike
As you know, Kasich says a lot of things his handlers, including the pro-Kasich Dispatch have to scurry to clean up. Calling a police officer an “idiot” or the “blue tongued cows” comes to mind. It is why the northeast media pulled a video interview of the governor slouching and scowling during the elections.
LikeLike
Does John Kasich believe they are in it “just to make money and take advantage of children”?
I love the “out of state operators” nonsense, too. The two biggest offenders are not just Ohio companies, they’re big Kasich donors!
Surely he knows White Hat is an Ohio company? He has to list their business address when he files campaign finance forms 🙂
LikeLike
Ohio has had two straight years of job creation below the national average. The jobs we are getting are part time and low wage. The unemployment rate is low because people are leaving the workforce. Young people are leaving the state in droves. Ohio has been predominantly run by these “free market” Republicans since it became a state, save for a short Democrat burst in the 80’s. It is in slow decline under the far right GOP regimes.
LikeLike
Agree. Republicans aren’t fiscal conservatives. They just want to direct the lion’s share of money from transactions, into the pockets of their friends.
Ohioans usually vote Republican because they think they are more like the 1%, than the “others”. It, obviously, takes more than a 26% decline in net worth, in a 6-year period, to convince them otherwise.
LikeLike
You just described Nevada perfectly Linda. The big hoopla over Tesla coming here so we the taxpayers can build their battery plant and the highway between it and the rail road depot was said to be their way of saving our economy. The so called high paying jobs will only net around $10.00 per hour. I would like to give our governor a job like that. Furthermore, it seems that Tesla may well be bankrupt before all of this is completed. Progress is only for them.
LikeLike
Senior Teacher,
It would take courage and contrition for Joe Six-pack to acknowledge he is among the downtrodden.
He thought that working hard and doing the right things, would keep his family in the middle class. It enabled him to feel superior. To offset the reality of his declining financial condition, the mid-western and southern mega churches prop up his ego, offering a message that Joe’s better than those poor people, because he’s a patriot and he doesn’t support abortion. It’s a low bar for self-worth but, he’s got to cling to something. Otherwise, he has to accept that he is no different than the people in the underclass, who he scorned. He’s among the fifty-two per cent of Americans, who have no savings for retirement and few prospects for a pension or inherited wealth.
Instead of Joe demanding that his government put working Americans first, he envies his neighbors who are clinging to middle class wages and tries to get them in his same boat.
LikeLike
The proposal from the charter groups for the new law that regulates charter groups includes a proposal for increased funding for charters.
I’m not clear why we’re increasing charter funding. Again.
Will there be an increase in public school funding? Or do they take yet another hit?
Wouldn’t it be great if public schools an advocate among the huge group of people we’re paying in state government?
LikeLike
I hope Ohio lawmakers actually do the job we’re paying them to do and write the law themselves.
I don’t think it bodes well when they only hear from groups that promote charters.
“Join Fordham as we welcome Bellwether Education Partners’ Andy Smarick to Columbus as he unveils his new report The Road to Redemption: Ten Policy Recommendations for Ohio’s Charter School Sector. Andy has dug deep into Ohio’s charter school law with an eye toward authorizer best-practices, good governance models, and quality outcomes for students.
After a short presentation by Smarick, hear reactions from a panel discussion of Ohio-based charter school experts that includes President and CEO of the Ohio Alliance for Public Charter Schools Dr. Darlene Chambers, Senate Education Chair Peggy Lehner, House Education Vice Chair Andy Brenner, and the United Schools Network’s Chief Learning Officer John Dues. A question and answer session will follow the panel. ”
I’ll be watching whether the people who work for the State of Ohio put any of their own work into this law, and whether they meet with anyone outside “the charter sector”. The charter groups are lobbying for more money to charters.
If they change the charter funding formula,, will anyone who works for the state analyze how funding changes will impact public schools?
I really have to insist Ohio lawmakers start considering the effects of charter laws on public schools in this state. It’s part of the job they accepted and we’re paying them to do it. I’m simply asking them to do their jobs. Public schools have to be considered in these discussions.
LikeLike
Michigan lawmakers say they are reforming their charter sector too. They made a big splashy announcement and then tabled it until next session 🙂
“Bold! Brave!” Well, maybe later. If they get around to it.
If I were betting I’d bet Pennsylvania is next and then Florida.
LikeLike
see also Jeff Bryant’s comprehensive piece this week in the Education Opportunity Network newsletter, here on Our Future Blog:
http://bit.ly/1wWJNfa
Education Newsmaker of the Year: charter school scandals.
In 2014, charter schools, which had always been marketed for a legendary ability to deliver promising new innovations for education, became known primarily for their ability to concoct innovative new scams.
From Local Stories To National Scandal
LikeLike
I think there’s a split between the local coverage of charter schools and the national coverage.
National media are located in NY and DC so they cover THOSE “charter sectors” as if every state is the same, but of course they’re not all the same.
The in-state coverage in Ohio, Michigan, Florida and Pennsylvania is much more comprehensive, investigatory and negative than the national coverage
There wouldn’t be any “charter reform” in Ohio and Michigan without the Akron Beacon Journal and the Detroit Free Press series, respectively, Local media.
It’s funny to me because OH, MI, FL and PA comprise a HUGE swathe of the country, yet all we hear about are NYC and DC charters- the “high performing” chains (KIPP, Success Academy). It’s this profound disconnect between reality in these states and the “national debate”.
LikeLike
With all that has and is happening I trust these politicians as far as I can throw a pregnant elephant.
LikeLike
I agree with you, Gordon! Ha..Ha..Ha…You made me laugh! As a stressed out teacher trying to get my kiddos ready for the February PARCC assessment in snowy, icy Ohio, I thank you for making me laugh!!!
LikeLike
Chiara: for the benefit of the grit impaired non-strivers that come from their glass houses of self-proclaimed “education reform” to this blog in order to throw stones of smears, sneers and jeers—
Interested parties can find the Most EduExcellent Announcement* referenced by you at the following link:
http://edexcellence.net/events/andy-smarick-in-columbus-ten-policy-recommendations-for-ohio’s-charter-school-sector
*Strangely, after being posted four days ago, not one comment. Rheeally!*
You provided the second and third paragraphs. The first:
[start quote]
Ohio’s charter schools have been under constant fire. Just last week, CREDO at Stanford University released a report on the academic performance of Ohio charter students that found them lagging their peers in traditional public schools. It’s time that we look under the hood and figure out what’s working and what needs to be fixed in the charter school sector.
[end quote]
I know that Fordham is especially enamored of Big people with Big titles and Big clout and Big expertise to help Handy Andy “look under the hood” [notice that sly reference to being the sort of people like car mechanics that do honest-to-goodness work that truly helps people?], but I noticed something peculiar…
Amidst a President & CEO and a Chair and a Vice-Chair and Chief Learning Officer, they left out someone that actually knows something about Ohio charters, and hasn’t (to my knowledge) participated in causing the problems that are forcing these folks to dirty their hands by looking “under the hood.”
You.
😱
Not on the right emailing lists? Lack the requisite connections? Maybe you offended Bill’s sensibilities like that shrill and strident Layton woman—and don’t get me started on the owner of this blog. Maybe spoke out of turn at an eduproduct launch?
😡
Well, I have just one thing to say to you—
Most krazy props that they wouldn’t consider someone like you suitable for their attempt to fine tune the party line, er, rebrand their product offerings.
😃
And look at it from your POV. Imagine trying to keep your sanity in the midst of a bunch of diehard followers of David Coleman & CCSS that keep repeating one of his bedrock Marxist axioms:
“My favorite poem is the one that starts ‘Thirty days hath September’ because it actually tells you something.”
Sure, it’s informational text, but why take the chance of dying of boredom?
Again, congratulations on your non-invite from your local neighborhood KrazyTA.
😎
LikeLike