The following email was sent to me by a Washington, D.C. insider who has been part of the Beltway scene for many years:
“Turnover at ED may be at a record high.
“One former ED staffer told me this week, “Morale at the Department is very, very low. Arne has made so many enemies among teachers and administrators and Chiefs and Congress that it has become painful [for a Dept. staff person] to be on the line supporting his policies to our (ED) constituencies in the field. The Administration has only two years, and everyone knows that if they wait until the last year, finding another job will be more difficult because of the rush, so they consider themselves ahead of the game if they bail now.” I asked about new appointments, and she said, “There should be no shortage because having a Department job with a good title for less than two years is a pretty good gig: you add the title to your resume while knowing that you won’t have to put up with the bureaucratic B.S. for very long.” And, she added: “Since Obama isn’t going to get his nominees confirmed, appointees can, instead, take a Department ‘advisory’ job, make the same pay, and avoid having to go through hearings by a hostile Senate.”
My confidant added:
“At the same time Ted Mitchell was nominated (November 2013), Obama/Duncan nominated Ericka Miller, chief administrator at Ed Trust, to be Asst Sec for Higher Ed.
“Mitchell got confirmed last spring but Miller did not.
“I heard that the higher ed community told Senators that they weren’t happy with Miller. Her higher ed experience is limited to a few semesters teaching English at tiny Mills College in Oakland. (When you were at OERI, Ericka was Nebraska Sen. Bob Kerrey’s LA for ed.)
“News about Miller’s nomination a year ago:
http://www.careercollegecentral.com/news/obama-nominate-education-trust-official-key-higher-education-post
“So she has been cooling her heels at Ed Trust, I gather, waiting for the Senate to act. Oddly, friends on the Hill say that Arne et al have done virtually nothing to work the Senate HELP committee to confirm her (unlike their extensive work on behalf of Ted). Now they’ve given up. No way, if the Senate Dems wouldn’t confirm her, that the GOP Senate will.
“Rumor has it that Miller, like King, will now go to ED in January as an unconfirmed Sr. Advisor to Arne (in her case on higher ed.). I haven’t seen any formal announcement … just internal Dept correspondence. Will she then be doing the work of a confirmed Asst Sec?! Who knows? This Administration is good at finding ways to bypass Congress…often understandably.
“In the last 2 yrs of the Obama Administration one will see policy (all Depts, not just at ED) overseen by “Advisors.” In Miller’s case for Higher Ed; in King’s case Shelton’s portfolio I guess.
“What is the Ed Trust-like Higher Ed approach? Ratings of Ed schools based on the achievement scores of students of teacher graduates of the school? That seems to be Arne’s philosophy; whether Miller subscribes to it I don’t know. But Ed Trust was an NCLB advocate … and one can see some similarities in the “reform” belief/approach, i.e., teach/assess/rank instructors.
“Arne’s not going away…Obama loves him. Now most of his top staff will all be technical “Advisors.” As one DC-based wag put it this week, “Don’t expect much action from ED in the next 2 years.”
And these are the people that are determining the direction of public education. SMH.
For us AI folks, SMH = ???
Diane, have I told you lately that I love you? Who else would be so forthright and giving with information that helps the everyday person understand inside the Beltway life that has been destroying our children’s public school education? Thank you!
Let’s see…King, Duncan, Cheney, Rumsfeld, McNamara, and the list goes on. Poor Bob Gates and Leon Penetta having to deal with some of these characters.
It’s so much easier to destroy than to build, and that’s what these despicable people will be doing for the next two years: further undermining public education, while smugly patting themselves on the back for their “progressivism.”
I agree with you post completely, Deborah! I love Diane and follow her daily. She totally rocks!
“your.” The stress when you post a comment with a typo and don’t know how to edit….
They’re is not edite function hear!
Don’t worry though we all wish there were.
I just sing to myself, let it go, let it go..
The New Mexico Public Education Department (PED) is also totally demoralized. The loss of PED employees since Secretary of Education Designee Skandera took over is totally amazing. Duncan and Skandera are two peas in a pod. If someone challenges Skandera you can count on them being gone a short time later. Employees who want to keep their jobs just keep their heads down and say nothing. They know they will outlast Skandera. The dark cloud of low moral covers the whole State of New Mexico and it is all because of Skandera and Martinez (aka Governor).
I know that was a typo, but “low moral” is pretty close to correct, no?
“Don’t expect much action from ED in the next 2 years.”
Hot Diggity Dawg! Is that a guarantee of nothing coming out from them? If so Yeea Hah!
Maybe they could rescind some of the idiocies that they implemented so as to lighten their load even more.
Come on Dwayne, put your heart into it! Ye-ee Haw! Hot diggedy dawg!
Their morale’s low? Have they any clue how low morale is for the recipients (students, teachers, administrators, parents) of their policies?
The above comments about low morale reminded me of how one of the fundamental SOPs of the self-proclaimed “education reform” movement is what W. Edwards Deming called “management by fear.”
Among its corollaries: the practice of “firing your way to excellence.” To which I add: they think they can “frighten their way to excellence.”
Any doubt why I often use the term “edubully” to describe prominent enforcers of the “new civil rights movement of our time”?
And of course, when things go wrong—e.g., John Deasy, iPads & MISIS, anyone?—you blame it on everyone else, especially your “underlings,” in that classic mismanagement tradition of “kiss up kick down.”
¿? Ah, it’s part of “Bootlickocracy.” ¿?
Link: http://www.softpanorama.org/Skeptics/IT_skeptic/bootlickocracy.shtml
Part of the definition:
[start quote]
The absurd of the world of office cubicles in a large corporation is well known and well depicted in such works as Peter Principle, Dilbert cartoons, etc. A very interesting combination of Cronyism, Nepotism and Incompetence, can be found in corporate IT Departments.
One persistent and defining feature of such an environment is dominant use of “kiss up, kick down” principle by middle level managers. We will call such an environment a bootlickocracy.
The prevalence of bootlickocracy in large IT organizations can be viewed as a side effect of dominance of aggressive but incompetent managers who are colloquially called “empty suits.” More often they are authoritarians and very often Double High Authoritarians).
No substance and not much style. Just sharp claws and elbows. As such bootlickocracy is the product of the rise of a caste of professional “office politicians”, which incorrectly are called “generic managers”. Their defining feature is that they lack the technical skills and experience of those professionals they supervise, but that does not mean that they lack political abilities or IQ. As for politicians everything is politics the IT became a battle field of various cliques who fight for power and influence.
[end quote]
Now, doesn’t everyone feel all warm and tingly inside knowing that the self-styled “education reformers” are brimming with such folks?
😡
I feel all warm inside, but it was burrito day in the staff lunchroom here at school, and I think the gorge is rising…
Turn the building into a museum for failed draconian policies. Like this- The Stasi Museum is a research and memorial centre concerning the political system of the former East Germany. Wikipedia
Thanks for this, but not feeling warm and tingly because I have seen this “bootlickocracy” in action in public education, universities, schools, and in the deliberations of more than NGO with multiple “partners, and in more than one foundation.
“I have seen this “bootlickocracy” in action in public education,…
You’re right, it is not a new phenomenon. Bootlickers have always been around depending on the presence administrators who thrive on the attention of sycophants. Combine the two beasts with the current management by fiat style and we end up with the current DOE.
Abolish the US Department of Fraud in Education.
I stand by my earlier assessment that Arne Duncan is the most myopic and destructive cabinet member since Robert McNamara.
McNamara lived long enough to issue a tearful apology for his mind-numbingly stupid and disastrous policies. Here’s a question for the oracle: how slow a learner is Dunkin’ Duncan?
When, as will inevitably come to pass, people look back in horror on the sheer waste in money and in kids’ lives of the centralized standardization-and-testing era, when they coldly and critically appraise the devastation wrought in the era of numerology-driven decision making and impersonalized software for personalizing education, will Dunklehead hold out? Will he be the cranky old creepy guy, like Cheney, who stands by his lunacy to beyond its bitter end?
Duncan is too arrogant to ever admit he was in error. None of his “jobs” have ever been based on what he can do, but rather who he knows. Despite this, he proceeds as if he is truly the fully anointed savior of public education.
I fear he lacks self-reflection (like Cheney). Duncan will “hit rock bottom in his ignorance and continue to dig…”
So slow that in the winter molasses can run away from him.
So slow that he’s been raped by a sloth.
So slow that a 57 Chevy without an engine beats him everytime.
Are you having fun, Dwayne? 🙂
Does a wild bear shit in the woods?
“It won’t get better in the next two years”. Don’t know about that
but
my view: with the Republican majority taking over Congress it won’t get better then either.
I know it’s a little thing, really, in the grand scheme of things. But Diane you made my day. Thanks for sharing this.
It’s affirming to know that not only are there people who work around and alongside Duncan who can’t stand him, but that there are people on his team willing to leak information out of (I’m guessing) frustration with an untenable situation.
So he has no RttT funding, and very little institutional support in his bureaucracy. Maybe it’s finally time for a “game changer” of our own. One that really is “for the kids.”
I am a long time reader of this blog but have never commented. I am working to lead my NJ town to Opt Out. This morning there was a segment on the Michael Smerconish show on XM/Sirius channel 124 (POTUS channel) about Jeb Bush’s potential run for President in 2016. Smerconish pointed out that one of Jeb Bush’s differentiating characteristics is his support for Common Core and charter schools. Smerconish then hosted a guest from Center for Education Reform who spewed the typical nonsense about ‘choice’ and how wonderful charters are (citing ‘evidence’ of a 4th grade difference between charters and public schools in reading scores – don’t know where, or what year, or what happened to every other grade??!!).
At the time, I was driving to the mall screaming at the radio. I pulled in, found the call-in number and waited patiently. He took my call and I tried hard to sound competent, summoning all I have learned from reading this blog (but devoid of any data at my fingertips – ugh)! My first point was that he should have Diane Ravitch on his show!
So Diane, if you are reading, please contact the Michael Smerconish show on XM (he also does a CNN show on Saturdays) and suggest a segment on what education will mean in the next election! Would love to have your expertise shared with Michael’s audience!
And thanks for all you do! Even those not commenting are learning and mobilizing!!
Flea girl
Center for Education Reform is a rightwing advocacy group for choice (its founder came from the Heritage Foundation). It cheers whenever public schools close.
For me, there is only one state of the Department of Education, and it’s sad and corrupt:
A sign on a pirate flag in W. Yarmouth that is appropriate for Arne’s Office at DOE:
“The Beatings Will Continue Until Moral Improves”.