Ed Berger, an experienced educator who lives in Arizona, writes that the corrupt politics of the state are hurting children and public education. Berger has worked in education in Arizona since 1991, and during that time he has met many dedicated, hard-working teachers, doing their best to educate children with inadequate resources.
What have I experienced? Great things at all levels Pre-K-University! Dedicated teachers and administrators constantly working to improve our schools; dedicated human beings fighting for children and quality education. They are pitted against an economic system that has created pockets of poverty which damage children and their potential for learning, and political ideologues who want to destroy or profit financially from public education.
I am witnessing first-hand the calculated destruction of Arizona public schools and the professional educators who serve our children.
Arizona is a ‘right-to-work state.’ No worker’s rights means no organized opposition to the politicians who control the State. As with other public employees, educators have no power to confront and expose abuses and those who damage our schools and children.
Arizona is a ‘one-party-rules state.’ One powerful political party controls what happens to our children and our community schools. That party is closely aligned with the religious right. Those groups gets access to the education tax dollars citizens pay. With tax dollars, they inject religious bias into the curriculum in the schools they run. Politicians in Arizona have effectively broken down the barriers between church and state.
How do they do it? Too many make profits from the education tax dollars citizens pay for our children. They do this by privatizing schools, bypassing safeguards, and taking over or eliminating elected school boards that stand in their way. They exempt, stop, modify, or eliminate accountability. They stop full audits and the release of specific information about what these profit-driven schools do to, or for children. They maintain a chokehold on information.
Hundreds of millions of dollars have been diverted from public education–which enrolls 85% of the state’s children– to private bank accounts. The children are cheated.
Berger writes that:
In Arizona, under the cloud provided by the Legislature, hundreds of millions of dollars are not accounted for. As a result of legislation, well over 600 charter schools have been created since the mid-90s. There are over 450 of these partial schools active now. Whole industries including banks and finance systems, school management services, and curriculum businesses have risen to get a ‘free’ piece of the public education pie. Public tax dollars are being diverted into private ventures. All of these services come out of the tax dollars that citizens are led to believe educate children.
Services already provided by law in our public district schools are being duplicated at great cost to taxpayers. In Arizona, ‘schools- of-choice’ spend valuable resources on rent and purchases of buildings. This results in public funding used to buy, build, or lease space. It often pays the property mortgages for private corporations and crooked individuals who will end up owning the buildings. What a great deal for kids. Right?
Besides siphoning off teaching money for buildings, kids are not getting the comprehensive curriculum and services that our district schools must provide. Partial schools cheat children by not exposing them to at least 10 disciplines taught by certified and vetted professionals.
He adds:
Arizona is a state controlled by ALEC (Alliance Of Legislative Executive Councils). Much of the Alliance’s agenda comes from the teachings of the radical right-wing John Birch Society, the legacy the Koch Brothers continue to force on America. The Koch Brothers, ALEC, and the Arizona political machine advocate the destruction of public education in America, the end of workers’ rights and worker organizations, and the right to access public tax dollars for their own profit. They call it “privatizing.”
More often than not, legislators allow ALEC teams to write the legislation they will introduce and vote in. This process subverts the democratic process of representative government. It is in fact, corporation representation.
The public schools are starved of the resources they need to educate the children. The ALEC-controlled legislature is trying to destroy public education.
This is political corruption of the worst kind, the kind that hurts children and undermines the future of the state.

Search n replace Arizonia with Ohio. Kasich recently started a $10 million partnering initiative between schools and communities. The catch? The partnership must include a “faith based” organization. Since Kasich is the Lord’s chosen governor, you can bet we’ll see proselytizing from far-right “christians” against evilution, heathen teachers, and any question not approved by God – at least not approved by those who talk to God. Grab me a banjo and canoe, I’m headin’ into the backwoods of Ohio and salvation!
LikeLike
It’s a joke, too. 10 million spread over the state’s schools is peanuts. Kasich and the ed reform wrecking crew grabbed 1.5 million out of this districts funding, for example, and we’re not a big district.
It’s pure politics. He’s positioning himself as the “compassionate conservative” by pretending to do something for public school children.
It is 100% for the benefit of John Kasich’s career. I eagerly await the front page photographs with the kids arranged as props behind him.
It’s also a really consistent theme in ed reform. The money NEVER goes directly to public schools. They pass it thru one or another politically-connected org or foundation or lobbying group.
LikeLike
Kasich is trying to rebrand himself as a defender of poor, humane leader, fiscally saavy, blue collar champion. But he is as far right winged as they come. This balanced budget tour is a cover for a presidential hat in the ring and financed by dark money. But no serious economist thinks the BBA idea is a good one. Ohio voters, in all fairness, do not have much choice as the Democratic party has imploded. But I wish they would stop voting against their own interests. The Ohio economy just posted 24 consecutive months of job growth below the nation. Ohio schools are sinking fast under GOP rule. The Republicans are doing everything they can to destroy teachers and undermine education. We are set up to fail.
LikeLike
“, , , those who talk to God. . . ”
Like Georgie Porgie did during the time he occupied the White House???
LikeLike
It would be great to have a thorough study of all the costs that are a direct result of “ed reform”/RTTT/NCLB directives vs. non “ed reform” costs within the schools. I am guessing that if all the money used for “ed reform” were transferred over to real education – the non “ed reform” costs – our schools would be in much better shape today.
LikeLike
Having lived in AZ for over 70 years and taught for 25, I can confirm the accuracy of Berger’s description of the state. I am so glad to see someone link religious views with anti-public school views. Fortunately, many religious groups have risen in support of public education. But until an organized force confronts right-wing conservatism, it will keep encroaching on the public weal.
LikeLike
And as someone who grew up in Arizona, went through elementary, HS, and college there, I can also attest to the accuracy of the description. My friends and I used to discuss where things went so wrong. AZ was a great place to grow up in back in the 80s, but now pretty much all of us have left, disgusted with the extreme right-wingers who took over the state: the anti-public education crowd, the anti-environment crowd, anti-government crowd, etc. There is so much to see and do and love in AZ, but I will never move back there in this lifetime unless radical shifts are made and Arizona returns to a more normal state of mind, where hate and greed and “I got mine” are not the guiding principles for governing and living in the state.
LikeLike
Here in Des Moines , It isherwood Democrats that are leading with with the religious with the few Republicans following suit. We have Unions though. Hard because these Democrats are also Union. What does one do? how does one have a chance anywhere?
LikeLike
Excuse me. Had cat jump n keypad. Comment starts. . It is the Democrats
LikeLike
Arizona is a cautionary tale for other states where abuse and deception rule the land. I think the FBI should conduct an investigation, ASAP. i am sure there are several lawsuits that could be filed including civil rights violations.
As for the devout citizens of Arizona, I guess they never read the ten commandments, “Thou shalt not steal!”
LikeLike
“MathVale
December 13, 2014 at 11:37 am
Kasich is trying to rebrand himself as a defender of poor, humane leader, fiscally saavy, blue collar champion. But he is as far right winged as they come. This balanced budget tour is a cover for a presidential hat in the ring and financed by dark money.”
I love how state and federal government has us competing for grants funded with our own money. It’s become ridiculous. I’m fighting with Franklin County for a share of the money I just sent to the state? No I’m not. They’re not my “competition”. I want their public schools funded too.
I’d like to join with them and use our pooled tax money for ALL of our schools. Cut out the ed reform middleman 🙂
How much of that 10 million will make it into public schools once it’s passed thru 15 politically-conected ed reform orgs? 5 million? Maybe? Why can’t we have some of our state tax money back without paying John Kasich’s donors 15% off the top?
LikeLike
“When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross.”
― Sinclair Lewis
LikeLike
As someone who received an excellent education in the 40’s and early 50’s i can also attest to what was a thriving education system. Went east for college and spent most of my career in and around the public schools of MA, CT and NY. Returned to AZ and was appalled at what i saw and heard, especially given my east coast filters and experiences.
“educators have no power to confront and expose abuses and those who damage our schools and children.” So true. Outstanding teachers and principals are scared to even talk about what is going on in their schools for fear of losing their jobs . The good news is they love kids and teaching, as a general rule, At the AZ School Boards Association meeting, at which you spoke this week, i was very impressed at the number of board members who attended and the vast majority who nodded in agreement. If only that energy could be marshaled and enthusiasm sustained.on behalf of the teachers and the children.
Another observation seldom mentioned is the strong dislike of the Latino population.More than once I have heard the comment about funding the schools is a waste of money given the large Latino population. They don’t deserve it, no appreciation, another handout, they should be sent back, hold back the “other” students, etc. “Don;t give more money to the dirty Mexicans.” (All Latinos are considered undocumented despite the facts.) .What will happen in 2030 when, I believe, the Latino population will be the majority? But we can’t wait that long..
LikeLike
Barbara,
I had a similar experience, going to public schools in Houston, them east to college. What is happening now is the defunding of public education and the establishment of publicly funded private schools where the strivers can escape “the others”
LikeLike
One reason AZ is so open to charters, is the attitude that anything is better than a public school with all those Mexicans. Doesn’t matter one wit about quality, depth of experience for the child in these imperfect schools or who is making a lot of money. In all fairness, there a few good charter schools that serve the Latino population. Wouldn’t be surprised if they are not on someone’s hit list. After all this is the state that passed a law severely limiting bilingual education and tried eliminating Mexican-American studies in Tucson..
LikeLike
I completely agree with your observation of the dislike of the Latino population. I was scrolling comments waiting to read a reference to it!
Is it more of a fear than a dislike, though? A fear of Latino voices being heard. ALEC trembles at the undocumented having a shot at participating in democracy more than anything, because they embody the most corporately exploited economic working class vis-a-vis labor laws…not so much in purchasing power.
In AZ, there is arguably more of a foothold for the mushrooming of institutional racism and civil rights violations than in any other border state. True, this is happening everywhere but the rhetoric in AZ is unashamedly loud, uncensored, and absent of the need for repackaging.
LikeLike
And here in California, particularly coastal California, where we have a strong Democratic plurality, and our public schools are now over 52% Latino and only about 11% White, we have the largest numbr of charter schools in the nation, close to 2000. Many. if not most, of our Dem legislators are supporters of privatizing, starting with former LA mayor, Villaraigosa, and his cousin, Perez, who was Speaker of the State House. Even Henry Waxman told me his “liked charters”…..
I think that it is no longer a Dem vs. Rep. issue…they are both the same since our Dem Prez and his appointments (mostly from Goldman Sachs) are all pro big business and focused on Wall Street profits. We have often discussed here how many of the billionaires trying to take over public ed call themselves Dems, e.g. Eli Broad.
Our entire system is polluted.
Arizona however, is particularly odious. A teacher friend of color settled there upon retirement, and was offered a job as a prinicpal in a high school. He had spent 30 years in LAUSD, but his assessment of the attitudes, racial and religious, in Arizona, left him fleeing back to crowded LA.
LikeLike
I’m just concerned that our future leaders will come from this sort of system. We seem to be moving backwards – into the 1800’s instead of 2015.
LikeLike
See you today, Diane, in cR-AZy AZ. Very excited.
LikeLike
The voters of AZ are complicit. Either they are voting for these people, or they are not voting, handing their power over to those who do vote. Until the citizens of that state change their views or begin to engage, nothing will change.
LikeLike
And here we have Idaho, which just approved tiered teacher certification based on teacher evaluations and test scores, misguided by corporate interests and non-education political figures. Today they approved tiered teacher salaries, which is a merit pay scale rewarding leadership duties rather than best teaching practices, experience, and professional development/continuing education. This legislation hurts students by driving the best teachers out of Idaho.
LikeLike