This article appears on Breitbart.com, a conservative media outlet. Written by Dr. Susan Berry, a regular contributor to the website, it is critical of Jeb Bush’s support for the Common Core and details his relationships with other groups and funders.
With polls showing Republican support for Common Core plummeting, common sense would dictate that Bush call it a day with the nationalized standards, as has been done by other Republicans, such as Maine Gov. Paul LePage and U.S. Sen. David Vitter, who plans to run for governor of Louisiana next year.
However, as a review of Bush’s history with the education initiative demonstrates, his interest in pushing onto the entire nation the reforms he introduced while governor of Florida – and his methods for doing so – have led his critics to claim he is more about big government crony capitalism than concern for children’s education.
Bush is the founder of several organizations that all play into a reported strategy that involves not only motivating “the people” at large for changes in education, but also using state education officials to administratively make some of those changes happen without the scrutiny or approval of the public.
As the founder and chairman of the Foundation for Excellence in Education (FEE), a national group which states its ambitious mission is “to build an American education system that equips every child to achieve his or her God-given potential,” Bush tapped for CEO Patricia Levesque, his former deputy chief of staff for education, enterprise solutions for government, minority procurement, and business and professional regulation while he was governor.
Chiefs for Change is an affiliate of FEE and describes itself as a “bipartisan coalition of current and former state education chiefs who believe that American public education can be dramatically improved.” Current members of Chiefs for Change include Mark Murphy of Delaware, Tom Luna of Idaho, John White of Louisiana, Hanna Skandera of New Mexico, Janet Barresi of Oklahoma – who was defeated in the state’s primary election this year, Deborah Gist of Rhode Island, and Kevin Huffman of Tennessee, former education commissioner and ex-husband of controversial Washington, D.C., schools chancellor Michelle Rhee…..
As it happens, some of the Chiefs for Change are also members of the Partnership for the Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC), one of the two federally funded interstate consortia that are developing tests aligned with the Common Core standards.
“Cronyism and corruption come in all political stripes and colors,” wrote [Michelle] Malkin at Townhall. “As a conservative parent of public charter school-educated children, I am especially appalled by these pocket-lining GOP elites who are giving grassroots education reformers a bad name and cashing in on their betrayal of limited-government principles…..”
Additionally, Bush has joined with former president of the pro-Common Core Fordham Institute Chester Finn and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce in Conservatives for Higher Standards, a group that promotes the Common Core standards but whose supporters still call themselves “conservatives.” Among the organization’s supporters are Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN), soon-to-be head of the Senate committee that oversees education; former Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour (R); former U.S. Secretary of Education Bill Bennett; Iowa Gov. Terry Branstad (R); Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam (R); former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee (R); and New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez (R).
The Fordham Institute, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and Bush’s national organization have all been awarded grants by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, the primary private backer of the Common Core standards.
In 2013, Bush’s FEE itself received $3,500,000 from the Gates Foundation. Two million dollars of that was awarded to FEE “to support Common Core implementation,” and $1.5 million was “for general operating support….”
In addition to the Gates Foundation, FEE’s donor list includes names not unfamiliar to critics of the Common Core standards: the GE Foundation, the Helmsley Charitable Trust, News Corp, the Walton Family Foundation, Bloomberg Philanthropies, Carnegie Corporation, the Schwab Foundation, Microsoft, Exxon Mobil, Paul Singer Foundation, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, Intel, K12, Pearson, Scholastic, and Target.
Book publishers such as Pearson, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, K12, and Scholastic are all poised to reap billions off the sale of Common Core-aligned textbooks and instructional materials that school districts are forced to purchase if they want their students to succeed on the Common Core-aligned assessments. Similarly, technology companies will benefit from the online assessments and student data collection.

The only way some can make a living is by doing harm to others. Jeb is a good case study for those who want to learn about human weasels.
LikeLike
Jeb started it all. He is the one who pulls most of the strings when it comes to Education policy in the U.S. He was an abysmal Governor and used that platform to initiate the reforms in Florida that many States have now adopted. The A through F grades for schools wers started in Florida in the late 90’s. Virtual classes are now mandatory at the high school level in Florida and guess who operates them? Jeb is the worst scuzz bucket there is it does not get any worse than him. The voters couldn’t even stop his antics. When the citizens of Florida voted in favor of the class size amendment he simply fefused to fund it and it remains unfunded more than 10 years after it was approved by the voters. His great plan to address a teacher shortage in the mid 2000’s was not raise salaries which rank near the bottom in Florida; instead he decided to offer teachers a laptop for choosing a career in teaching. This guy is a serious piece of work! The funny thing is his self proclaimed nick name while he was in office was the “education” Governor. What a joke!
LikeLike
He is in favor of the Common Core to hasten the defeat of public education. At that point he and his cronies will really clean up.He has no vision and no real background in education. He only sees $$.
LikeLike
Jeb, Joel Klein, and other corporate types are thrilled to see the crash in test scores produced by Common Core. They believe–and they have said publicly–that it will persuade the public to abandon public schools and embrace charters and vouchers.
LikeLike
The word “conservative” has lost all meaning these days, but a true libertarian, if there is such a thing anymore, should fear the rise of the Corporate State as much as any true liberal does.
When it comes to bona fide one or the other, Jeb is neither fish nor fowl, but just plain fishy and foul.
LikeLike
There are no liberals or conservatives; there are simply “politicians”. The more you play into the Dem Repub mantra the more divided we become. The truth is they have all been bought and thus comprimised. These so called leaders simply hide behind behind the labels that get them the desired audiences and as a result votes, but in the end if you have sold your soul and values for the sake of money and power it simply does not matter whether you are a so called liberal or conservative. Today this is much more evident with the actions of Democrats when it pertains to Education and even Unions. These are two areas that Democrats were once considered “champions” of. The two party monopoly simply needs to come to an end because they have ultimately merged into one mega party with the differences between them becoming more unrecognizable by the each passing second.
LikeLike
Most people aren’t politicians — that may be the only thing that will save us in the long run. I know lots of people with genuine liberal values. I used to know — a long time ago — lots of people with genuine conservative values, and way back then they used to be strong supporters of public education, the environment, and all sorts of things that would get them plucked from the right wing today. So it makes all the difference whether we are using the labels to describe the values of people in general or whether we are using the labels to describe their supposed-to-be representatives who are demonstrably representing something entirely alien to the will of the people.
LikeLike
Jon Awbrey, I see the split within the Republican party as a fight between Main Street and Wall Street, between the locals who care about their town and the hedge funders who want to monetize everything. May the locals win.
LikeLike
So true. George Bailey v. Henry Potter. The main street Republicans by and large buy into the highly successful brand marketed by the GOP. Plenty in my social circle. The discussions always seem rooted in fear and a nostalgia for an America that never was. There is an insular quality to the main street GOP views. Often, even teachers and police support Republican causes that eliminate public jobs, destroy careers, and wipe out retirement. It is bizarre and tough to comprehend. The business Republicans (not small business) are driven purely by greed. Money is all and scorn for “others” is twisted into all kinds of pseudo-religious rationalizations and trickle-down theories.
LikeLike
Some conservatives view the Common Core testing as federal overreach. They see it as an encroachment of states’ rights.
LikeLike
As a very certain non-conservative, non-libertarian, and non-Republican, when I read about the growing split on the right over issues about national standards and the Common Core in particular, I do not see a sincere ideological debate about education, but rather a power struggle between non-progressives who either openly align themselves with Wall Street (e.g., Jeb Bush) because they know which side their bread is buttered on and are not ashamed of it, or a crumbling bunch of folks with (mostly) Tea Party ties who are falling over each other to show how authentic their “super conservative” credentials are, their anti-Obama credentials are, and thus how anti-national standards they are. But I think the latter group are far more full of it than the former. Jeb Bush has made his bed and is willing to lie in it. But all these others, particular the Republican governors who were on board the CCSS train, are jumping off because it’s the thing to do as they look towards 2016 and their next reelection campaign or move up the ladder, perhaps all the way to DC. When one of these folks says Jeb Bush cares more about Wall St. than he does about children, I have to bite my tongue not to laugh out loud. As if a single one of these frauds cares about most children, particularly poor kids, children of color, public school kids of any sort at all. When was the last major US politician from the GOP out there fighting for anything that was even vaguely child-centered? Or indicating the slightest understanding of what public education is about? Not that we’ve had much along those lines from major Democrats, of course. But they’re not the subject under discussion in this particular post.
So pardon me if I doubt the sincerity of members of the GOP coming out against the Common Core these days. It’s not grounded in any hatred on their part for Wall Street. They’re at least as much in bed with the corporate interests backing the Common Core as are those on the other side of the aisle who’ve backed it. This is pure politicking, grabbing hold of an anti-Obama issue that seems to have real traction, unlike the other failed attempts like birtherism, Fast-and-Furious, Bengazi, and even more absurd nonsense. It’s a Race to the Right, an effort to be Holier-than-Thou, with “Thou” being every other Republican with national ambitions. And given indications that a lot of non-Tea Party conservatives are looking to Jeb Bush to lead the GOP back to the White House, it can’t come as any shock to see the Common Core used by other Republicans as what they hope will be a litmus test for “authentic conservatism.” Frankly, I wish a plague on all their houses. I don’t know that there’s a single person in a governor’s mansion or Congress, with the notable exception of Bernie Sanders, whom I would trust as far as I can throw a drone.
LikeLike
I attended Anthony Cody’s author event today for “The Educator and the Oligarch” at the Laurel Book Store in Oakland, and in this post, I run into Bill Gates again. I’ve also been watching The Tudors. I’m finishing season 3 and I see a lot of similarities between Emperor Bill Gates and England’s King Henry 8, but Gates isn’t beading wives. He is beading teachers and children.
On the BART ride home, I read the first four chapters of Cody’s book, so I know what I’m talking about when I make the comparison between Gates and Henry.
LikeLike
Common Core and the emphasis on testing is really turning off those who have money to move to private, which was the point all along I suppose. We are steadily on the road to privatization. They first ruin the public system and then dismantle it. We are in the “wrecking” stage right now. What can I do? Should I keep my kids in the public when there are other options? No! My kids only get one chance for a good education, and I am not into test prep and babysitting, sorry folks. Do Obama’s kids go to public schools?
As a public school teacher myself, I try to minimize the disruption for Common Core in my own classes, but the kids are going to miss so much school this year due to testing. What can I do? There is nothing anyone can do. It all comes from on high. Many of us are just trying to keep teaching, somehow.
The last stage (coming soon) is when the parents of our “leafy suburban” school get their kids’ failing test grades on the new tests. How will they react? Even at our top school, maybe only 30-40% will pass. Will there just be more of a stampede to private schools? Will they let their kids be labeled idiots? It is going to be interesting. It is make or break time now. I am in one of the top 100 public high schools in the country, by the way. Seeing our excellent public school slowly die under testing, low morale, etc., tells me that it doesn’t look good for public schools. It’s sad. The upper middle class is starting to send their kids to private. It was the opposite 15 years ago. The whole “master plan” is working. The elites don’t want public anything anymore. Let’s face it.
LikeLike
“What can I do? There is nothing anyone can do. It all comes from on high. Many of us are just trying to keep teaching, somehow.”
John, John, John, John, John!!?!!?!! said in that teacher’s increasingly exasperating voice, that I’m sure you have used when a student of yours said “I can’t do this” (without hardly having tried to do ‘this’).
There’s a ton you can do. The question is: When will you decide to quit feeling so hopeless for yourself, get off your mental arse, and actually do something concrete to improve your students’ class experiences. If the crap “from on high” isn’t right don’t effin do it. Do what you know to be right. Make them make you not do the right thing, force the issue, draw it all out, publicize it. You might be surprised to find out the vast majority of students, teachers, parents and community is on your side (notice I didn’t say Admin because they are definitely a horse of a different kowtowing breed).
LikeLike
“The whole ‘master plan’ is working. The elites don’t want public anything anymore. Let’s face it.”
Never surrender! Once you give up, they win. And that’s what Bill Gates and his billionaire allies want. See if there is a parent Opt Out group in your district. Join them. If there isn’t one, possibly identify a parent who would Opt Out their child from testing and fight like a Navy Seal to keep them out of the testing funnel. That parent will be the leader who will recruit other parents to to join the resistance.
The actual number of elites is very small—probably two dozen or less at most. It is their money that’s buying support for their agenda. If that money stops, the support will melt away.
LikeLike
Having dealt with him in person as he tried to foist microsoft crap on my special forces team, and went over my head so my commander could tell him to jump with us minus a parachute, your instincts are correct Lloyd. He expects all to bow to his brilliance and can’t believe anyone would disagree with him. As a former profiler, I will say he has the same narcissistic personality traits we find in sociopaths. I do wish he had come with us for a small plane ride.
LikeLike
“I do wish he had come with us for a small plane ride.”
Are you Argentinian by chance?
LikeLike
My favorite part of this article: “In the Public Interest claimed…, though it’s important to remember the source is a labor advocacy group whose goal is to keep teachers in jobs and funding flowing to public schools.” Gosh, ultra-rightwing Breitbart forced to use a progressive source for research? Maybe that’s because progs do their h.w. & all over this topic long before TP woke up. Hmm, now our prog blog can find a good summary of our research in Breitbart! Knew this had to happen sooner or later. Old-timey ‘true conservatives’ were always hostile to crony capitalism in gov. Maybe that principle overrides knee-jerk anti-union sentiment in TP.
Comment thread at Breitbart: it’s entertaining wayching as the many factions right of center try to pummel each other into consensus. Can’t happen as too many are too dogmatic to compromise.
LikeLike
I’ve said it before, and I’ll day it again… The pushback against CCSS from conservatives is all political grandstanding. Would there be a pushback if Romney was elected? Of course not.
LikeLike
Conservatives don’t like the federal govt. to intrude on the states, but they know that this is just temporary. Once the Common Core destroys the public schools, then the Dept. of Education will disappear, and everyone will go private (or not). Everyone wins! They know that it is necessary to wreck the public schools first and convince the upper middle class parents that public schools are bad, etc. They don’t care what the inner cities think (obviously) and the rural schools will be destroyed as an afterthought. Save your money if you have kids.
LikeLike
Conservatives like the federal government when it enforces their goals and policies. Look at the some 200+ lobbying groups feeding on federal dollars like hogs at a trough. I agree, save your money. It will be interesting watching these main street Republicans who voted in school destroying politicians having to take out $40,000 student loans to get their kids through grade school..
LikeLike
You know what will happen? Its like we’ve gone backwards where people secretly taught slaves how to do addition and subtraction by using rocks, by teaching the alphabet and how to spell your name, only reading basics. If your “better” discovered you knew how, you were beaten or killed by example.
We will become a society where we have to secretly teach the young, so the oligarchs don’t know they are educated. Is this the future we’re headed for? Because, if its going to be a world where one can only get the kids an education by digging deep INTO EMPTY POCKETS to fund an elementary education, we’re all screwed.
The world of education is becoming a horror movie, only things you could never have imagined, conspiracies and plots to roll us back to a severe “have and have not” society where “they” existed to be served, and kept the remainders illiterate and in servitude – they aim to make each next generation ignorant, dumb, compliant, controlled, and lets not forget, grateful to serve.
Scary stuff, that.
Eventually, there will be a revolution, and no amount of “their” money will protect “them.”
LikeLike
Lets hope Jeb doesn’t make it to the White House; I might have to kill myself
LikeLike
If you haven’t killed yourself yet with Obama in office I doubt Jeb will push you over the edge. Obama has been abysmal in my estimation even worse than GW and he was atrocious.
LikeLike
Jeb Bush in the White House would be a nightmare of astronomical proportions. This simply cannot happen!!!
LikeLike
It could be worse.
The U.S. could end up with Jeb Bush and a Tea Party dominated Congress in both the Senate and the House.
If the voters don’t dump the GOP in one or both houses of Congress in 2016, the next election, I think we can kiss the public schools and the federal government goodbye.
The schools, prisons, police and military will all be privatized while abortion rights for women, the FDA and EPA and a few other federal watchdog agencies would be closed or gutted so they had no real power to act in the public interest.
LikeLike