Governor Cuomo reached a compromise with teachers’ unions and legislators to protect teachers who received the lowest ratings on the Common Core tests. Such teachers will not be evaluated by the tests. Only 1% of the state’s teachers were rated ineffective. What this deal really means is that a meaningless and deeply flawed teacher evaluation system, cobbled together to get Race to the Top funding, is now rendered utterly meaningless.
Unfortunately for students, there is no relief from the many hours required for Common Core testing. Kids will continue to sit for three hours for each exam, plus dozens of hours of interim testing. Perhaps this is early preparation for the SAT or bar exams, starting in third grade.

The culture of testing continues in NYS
LikeLike
The culture of testing continues in NYS
LikeLike
So why just protect the “low performing” group. What about say, the average performing? And maybe the ones rated at the high end, now identified a “good” teachers are really bad?
This really is a cluster.
LikeLike
A cluster of what?
LikeLike
Duane, tsk, tsk, come now. of course you can complete the phrase.
LikeLike
I soo looove polite conversations!
LikeLike
See below!
LikeLike
It allows for “re-calculating” VAM scores for teachers rated ‘developing’ or ‘ineffective’. The recalculation formula enables only some teachers to completely escape use of student test scores.
This provision may get them in some trouble. Can Magee be this stupid? Or is it a set up because Cuomo is that stupid?
LikeLike
It also means continued hours of inappropriate common core instruction to special education students. They have their own plan of learning, called an IEP that is rendered utterly useless under CC.
LikeLike
Not to mention the extended time allowed to students under their IEPs or 504s; they’re potentially looking at 41/2 to 6 hours on these wasteful/inappropriate/useless (choose your own adjective) exams, multiplied by interims….oh, the shame of it all.
LikeLike
torturous? abusive? criminal? morally bankrupt?
LikeLike
It’s even worse than that. For students with IEPs, all PARCC testing will be done online, and must be completed in one session. So students extended time accommodations will not be allowed to leave to go to the bathroom unless accompanied by an adult. Also, if it’s a student’s lunch period, we have two choices: 1) Shadow the student through the lunch line and sit at the same lunch table with the student eating lunch, or 2) Bring the student’s lunch to him or her so they can munch and test!
We have four computer labs (about 120 computers) serving 1,200 + students. One of the labs is in the library. I’m sure the librarian would love to see students eating spaghetti and meatballs with a side of garlic bread in her lab. (snark).
PARCC testing is the new black: shackle children to computers and do not dare let them out of eyesight (with the exception of the bathroom stall) until the test is done.
Also, we have been reminded repeatedly that too many accommodations harm students with IEPs. The admins reminding us about this have never taught a day in their life.
I’d like to see the valid research on that. (In other words, something that has NOT been produced by the Bush/Obama DOE.)
LikeLike
This is probably an attempt to get an endorsement from NYSUT. Don’t be fooled by this tool for the corporate elite.
LikeLike
DING!
LikeLike
Nice strategy: Throw the unions a the unions and feed “what’s in it for me” appetite.Then, continue to ‘deform’ students.
LikeLike
Most of us have known for some time that the testing is all about MONEY and power!
LikeLike
“. . . is now rendered utterly meaningless.”
NO!
It was rendered “utterly meaningless” (IOW’s bullshit) from the very start and still continues to, as some of the posters have pointed out, cause great harm to the most innocent, the students, using them as less than pawns in a power struggle political chess match played by, take your pick of the following or combination of the following:
fools, asses, halfwits, dunces, dolts, ignoramuses, cretins, morons, imbeciles, simpletons; informaldopes, ninnies, nincompoops, chumps, dimwits, dumbos, dummies, dum-dums, loons, dorks, saps, jackasses, blockheads, jugheads, boneheads, knuckleheads, fatheads, buttheads, numbskulls, numbnuts, dumb-asses, doofuses, clods, dunderheads, ditzes, lummoxes, knuckle-draggers, [dipshits], dipsticks, thickheads, meatheads, meatballs, wooden-heads, airheads, pinheads, lamers, lamebrains, peabrains, birdbrains, mouth-breathers, scissorbills, jerks, ninglenerds, donkeys, nitwits, twits [& shits], boobs, twerps, hosers, schmucks, bozos, turkeys, chowderheads, dingbats, mooks; asshats, [asswhipes] (thanks google)
LikeLike
Ohhhh…soooo many to choose from! I like the way you people think. You’re starting to rub off on me ( much to the consternation of my superintendent and principal). For that, I thank you. Now, let me see….ninglenerds….
LikeLike
You guys are rubbing off on me too. My principal tried to play me and I nipped it in the bud. So he is tossing me out. Now they announced that teachers next year will have to stay until 4:30 for the same lousy extra money that we earned to stay until 3:50 this year. Am I the lucky winner?
LikeLike
I made that one up. It had nerd and I thought it wasn’t harsh enough so I added to it, the result, the word you picked.
LikeLike
NJ, ours tried the same, but ran into “length of school day” contract language. Any chance it’s in yours?
Duane, no wonder spellcheck tried to give me every other option. It is now my new go-to word. I like it!
LikeLike
Special ED in NY
Teachers in schools with an extended day sign Election to Work Agreements (EWA). These agreements circumvent the union contract. I don’t think they meet minimum wage thresholds.
LikeLike
Thank you. Always learning here. EWA is a new one for me. As for being a “winner”, um, congratulations? Been there. Can’t win for losing.
LikeLike
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx NJ teacher: “So now he is tossing me out.”?
meaning? you are getting canned?
LikeLike
How do you really feel, Duane ? Yup. You nailed i. As I wrote to describe the head of the AFT, who does not deserve to have a civil name: despicable.
LikeLike
This is utter bullshit. It triggers a re-calculation based on further bullshit. Thanks for nothing Magee.
LikeLike
Yes, NY teacher. It reminds me of the ever-changing and meaningless chocolate ration in Orwell’s 1984. It’s number nincompoopiness with ramifications for real people.
LikeLike
They don’t just move the goalposts. They remove the goalposts and put a soccer net in place.
LikeLike
I have a bad feeling about all of this. I thought the previous NYSUT leadership was often unresponsive. This group responds but makes deals with the devil, and worse, doesn’t seem to be including the kids in their negotiations. Many of us received “urgent” emails today to contact our legislators to support the “Governor’s Program Bill # 56”. I haven’t found the wording or this “Program Bill”, but fear it still leaves little kids sitting for ridiculous periods of time taking tests. It feels like we are selling out the kids to keep teachers from being evaluated by the tests. If so, then for heaven’s sake, for what purpose are the tests?
LikeLike
And this is supposed to make it okay that kids still have to take hours of tests that will not inform instruction? And this is supposed to make it okay that these tests can be used for high stakes decisions for students? And this is suppose to make teaching to the test that has and will continue to warp program and curriculum decisions okay? Am I missing something here?
LikeLike
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Or could this be a good thing? Sure sounds to me like Cuomo is backing off of VAM…
LikeLike
Only until he’s re-elected. Queen Eva and her hedge fund manager consorts likely gave Cuomo the okay to do this. They know they own him.
LikeLike
So this does’t solve anything, but it will add fuel to the crowd who believe that bad teachers can’t be fired. Ever hear of the Trojan horse?
LikeLike