Florida has a voucher for program for students with disabilities, called McKay scholarships. A story in Florida’s “Sun-Sentinel” revealed that a sizable number of these students with vouchers attend schools that do not have any full-time teachers with special education training or certification.
Dan Sweeney of the “Sun-Sentinel” writes:
“Learning disabled students can get up to $19,829 of taxpayer money each year to attend private school if they choose – but there is no state accountability to ensure the kids’ needs are being met.
“The law that created the vouchers does not require private schools to have anyone on staff with any sort of certification in dealing with children with learning disabilities. Nor are there public controls in place to check whether the schools are helping them.
“In Palm Beach County, 1,232 children receive $8.5 million in state voucher money. How much they get depends on on the severity of their disabilities, with amounts ranging from $4,125 to $19,829.
“There are 59 private schools in the county that accept the vouchers – and at least 28 of them don’t have full-time special education teachers.
“If someone wants to pay for a school that has no standards out of their own pocket, they’re free to do that. This is America,” said Kathleen Oropeza, co-founder of Fund Education Now, an organization that advocates for public education in the state of Florida. “But when you’re taking public dollars and you’re putting them into these private schools that are not regulated and have no obligation to meet the same standards that we impose on our public schools, that’s when the public should become concerned.”
And Sweeney adds:
“The voucher law only requires that private school teachers pass a background check and have a bachelor’s degree and three years of teaching experience or “special skills, knowledge, or expertise that qualifies them to provide instruction in subjects taught.”
“There is no limit on how many students can receive the McKay scholarship – it is solely based on need.
“To qualify, kids need to be on an Individual Education Plan, which sets educational goals for a child and allows for specialized instruction.
“But “once the family leaves the district on a McKay scholarship to a private school, the [plan] is no longer valid. Private schools are not required to follow the [plan] created by district personnel,” said Cheryl Etters, a spokeswoman for the Florida Department of Education.
“And nobody from the state or district checks to see if the children’s’ needs are being met.”
This is not the first time that a reporter has called attention to the bsence of oversight or regulation of the McKay scholarship program.
In 2011, reporter Gus Garcia-Roberts wrote a blistering exposé of the program, which he called “a cottage industry of fraud and chaos,” sending millions of public dollars to voucher schools that lacked curriculum or qualified staff. Garcia-Roberts won the Sigma Delta Chi award for public service journalism for the story. But the McKay program continues to be unregulated, unsupervised, and one in which public funds follow students to schools un equipped to meet their needs.

I guess we should not be surprised. This is just another attempt at excluding some students from receiving a quality education and being able to go out in the world and getting a quality job so they can live a quality life. Rick Scott and his Republican controlled Legislature make up their own rules so as to achieve their own agenda.
LikeLike
Why aren’t the parents filing lawsuits?
LikeLike
Many parents don’t have firsthand knowledge of how the legal system works or can’t find an attorney willing to work on contingent or for a share of whatever damages may be won,
Some are illegal aliens or have a criminal record and aren’t allowed in the school at all.
Others have had legal problems in the past and they are reluctant to engage in the legal system that they fear because they are trying to stay clean and sober and on parole.
Still others had bad experiences in school themselves, often with their own disabilities unrecognized and so they believe that there is no point in fighting.
In our middle class/upper middle class schools parents often show up at IEP meetings with an attorney or an advocate and most often in groups that have a good grasp of how the system works through self-education and research.
Poor parents are lucky if there is a translator available when needed or a meeting can be scheduled at a time when they are able to come and don’t have to be at work or have someone to babysit young children and babies.
Many minimum wage employers dock pay, cut hours, and threaten firing their employees if they miss work for their children’s school-related issues, especially if there are frequent emergencies, such as heath crises (like chronic asthma) or behavior troubles. I see this all the time.
It’s not so easy to file lawsuits when you work for minimum wage, don’t own a car, there are no lawyers located within walking or public transportation distance that will take your case, you live paycheck to paycheck and are often broke for days or weeks at a time, and the school district has an army of intimidating people talking at you using jargon that sounds like a foreign language (and may very well be) and waving huge stacks of papers at you telling you to sign everywhere.
I’ve worked as a parent advisor and advocate in the past and plan to continue that work after I retire. They need so much support and help and get next to nothing in many places, especially the poorer schools and districts. Charters are a whole other animal.
LikeLike
But, IDEA is a Federal law.
LikeLike
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Chris in Fla, please rehash this so it makes sense to me. What I get from the article is that mucho tax $ are being sent for IEP students to schools which have no capability of administering their IEP’s. I understand what you say– that these perhaps non-English-speaking/ poor parents of IEP students aren’t equipped to sue (where is the ambulance-chaser when you need him?)… where is the class action suit for taxpayers?
LikeLike
Thanks goodness they still have fire marshals in Florida, huh? If they privatize that service they’re really in trouble:
“Two hundred students were crammed into ever-changing school locations, including a dingy strip-mall space above a liquor store and down the hall from an Asian massage parlor. Eventually, fire marshals and sheriffs condemned the “campus” as unfit for habitation, pushing the student body into transience in church foyers and public parks.”
Lawmakers in Florida and national education expert Jeb Bush are really, really lucky the fire marshal caught it and it didn’t end a lot worse.
The McKay program was created by Bush. Why isn’t he ever asked about it when he appears nationally?
LikeLike
Remember that it’s legal here to murder black children in cold blood if you claim that you felt threatened by their existence. It’s happened several times already.
Florida has crazy falling from the sky.
LikeLike
Dr. Steve Perry
@DrStevePerry
Here is the actual CA Court decision which CLEARLY articulates why tenure discriminates against minority & poor kids
That made me laugh because “clearly” is a weasel word among lawyers. When someone writes CLEARLY before an assertion, you can be 99% sure there’s nothing “clear” about it, and that is true here as well! 🙂
You can tell your students that handy little tip for their “close reading” training. “CLEARLY” means “because I say so – loudly and confidently!” 🙂
LikeLike
Chiara: you nailed it.
One of the general criticisms of high-stakes standardized tests is that they reward superficial and facile thinking.
It also helps if you don’t read such decisions.
“All you need is ignorance and confidence and the success is sure.” [Mark Twain]
😎
LikeLike
It is also an unsubtle way of implying that anyone who doesn’t see it must be an idiot.
LikeLike
Ah, the glorious freedom of CHOICE! Lawmakers, reformers, former governors, and taxpayer overseers (!) constantly screech about the need for constant surveillance to ensure accountability in public schools because they are paid for with taxes. They won’t even allow for a short moratorium on the most punishing aspects of their crazy VAM, testing, and school grade schemes for fear that lack of accountability might creep in and take over again.
Magically, when that same taxpayer money is funneled to private or charter schools, the need for accountability vanishes into thin air. No laws requiring transparency or openness or public disclosure. No need to follow local, state, or federal statutes and laws because private ENTERPRISE. So we get storefront schools that are neighbors to whorehouses and liquor stores outfitted with cheap plastic lawn chairs where students receive no credit for their “learning” from videos and playing on a computer while the head of the school rakes in several million dollars from the state taxpayers.
When confronted with the obvious hypocrisy,mendacity, and outright grifting, the supporters deflect and blame parents for not being responsible customers of the educational shopping mall they have created. Funny how you are supposed to choose without the choice schools having to disclose budgets, teacher qualifications, curriculum, or records of performance. Those are all proprietary for their private brands and exempt from the Sunshine Laws public schools are subject to following.
And still the charter and voucher cheerleaders go on and on about how CHOICE is the civil right issue of our time.
Translated: School choice, vouchers, and charters are the civil right issue of our time: one of the last remaining legal grifts available for unscrupulous greed hawks who make big political contributions and expect high, unregulated returns for their money.
LikeLike
Chris in Florida: this is worthy of a separate blog posting.
An exemplar of “choice not voice” [as Chiara Duggan put it].
In baseball terms, a game-winning 4-bagger.
😎
LikeLike
THIS!
Great post, Chris.
LikeLike
How is this for civil rights—– The Public Interest Law Center of Florida needs to join with disabilities advocacy organizations and special education parents and file a Class Action Suit to ensure that schools that accept these vouchers are complying with federal laws and ensure that IDEA provisions are being properly implemented.
LikeLike
The privatization movement really means “you’re on your own.” In the end, if parents make the wrong choice of school with our taxpayer dollars, too bad. They really want government to have no responsibility in education. Every move the corporatizers make in this whole process is to that end. There is no ideal for public good with these people.
LikeLike
“They really want government to have no responsibility in education.”
Which is funny, given that they call themselves “the accountability movement”
All this does is make lawmakers and political leaders completely unaccountable for public education, which is probably why they’ve all grabbed onto it with both hands.
All they do is administer public funds and direct them to the contractor.
Theoretically, perhaps, we could get rid of lawmakers entirely and pay a solid accounting and audit firm to replace the Florida legislature. Anyone can make a payment to a contractor, no special skills required, which is all they’re doing.
LikeLike
(Reposting this from an earlier thread)
And in other Florida charter “school” scandal news:
Charter Schools USA Payroll Accounts Reportedly Frozen
http://miami.cbslocal.com/2014/06/13/charter-schools-usa-payroll-accounts-reportedly-frozen/
LikeLike
It’s been fun to watch the debate shift in Ohio. It started with “great schools!” and then when it turned out there were some good charters and some lousy charters (just like the public schools they replaced) it became “but parents choose the lousy charters!”.
I would say the Milton Freidman caucus within the ed reform political movement has not only won, but gotten everything they demanded.
Liberals got completely rolled. They lost on every one of their priorities: quality, equity, better funding, diversity, all of it, and they harmed existing solid or good public schools in the process.
LikeLike
“Liberals got rolled…”, in no small part, as a result of the rulings of conservative judges.
LikeLike
Liberals seem to enjoy getting rolled, Chiara, since they keep returning for more lies and abuse.
LikeLike
Liberals are being rolled by the president they elected and his henchman Arne Duncan. It starts at the top, folks. Btw, I voted for the man twice and feel deceived and betrayed.
LikeLike
In reality, this means these kids may be warehoused and neglected so a corporation may profit off them as they languish the way the old federal sanitariums (that existed before President Reagan closed them down and let the mentally ill go free to mostly become homeless) dealt with people who were deemed mentally ill.
So, we will now put these children in straight jackets, and lock them in padded, soundproof cells in addition to dope them until they are numb and almost brain dead. Maybe lobotomizes will make a come back. Corporations that make diapers can clean up too.
The GOP really knows how to deal with challenges like these—by making them vanish from public scrutiny.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on jsheelmusic and commented:
Being a Floridian, this does not surprise me. Florida is one of the lowest ranked states in regard to funding per student and teacher pay. I worked in the schools and know that education in that state is little more than a factory system that pretty much punishes those that go against the system, students and teachers alike.
LikeLike
I looked into the McKay. The private school options in my county were minimal. Most used the Bob Jones curriculam. Not exactly what I had in mind for my child with High functioning Autism. Since we had the lowest matrix funding it only covered part of the tuition. Those that get the higher funding can use it toward speech language or OT. Otherwise it is pay out of pocket. Decided against using it.
LikeLike
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx hoo-boy I’m going to get fallout from this comment. When I was a kid, Florida was where you went when you were in trouble with the law. I had not one but two neighbors in my tiny upstate rural nbhd of NYS (I mean w/n 1/2-mi of each other) who successfully escaped U. Sam by running to Fla.
Flash forward 50 yrs to NJ, I had a close friend who did the same after he had to testify against his partner in a gov-ed scam. The point being: both his kids, upon arrival in FL, were immediately advanced by a full grade; the elder was so smart they needed to put him in an IB school for tennis pro’s, then a fledgling community-college-cum-h.s. program; his sr hs yr was equivalent to a completed freshman yr at Flo-Atl-U.
BTW.. that elder kid had both gifted courses in NJ elem & an IEP [for adhd] in NJ middle school…
Why does it not surprise me that FL now shuffles its IEP LD kids to charters which haven’t the personnel to implement an IEP?
LikeLike