When people write Pennsyvania Governor Tom Corbett to complain about the devastating effects of his budget cuts on the children of Philadelphia, he responds by blaming the teachers’ union for not accepting even deeper cuts. A few days ago, a first-grader died; there was no school nurse on duty. Her position had been cut from five days a week to one day a week plus another occasional day. This was the second child to die in a school where Corbett’s budget cuts had eliminated the full-time nurse. Corbett blames the teachers.
Governor Corbett accepts no responsibilty. His response to critics betrays a guilty heart, or a man without one.
This teacher, Steven Singer, describes what happened when he wrote a letter to Governor Corbett.
“Wow! I am flabbergasted by PA Gov. Tom Corbett’s reaction to the second Philadelphia student dying at school without a nurse on duty! As many of you did, I wrote him a letter asking him to please increase funding so tragedies like this are not repeated. He must be getting some heat because this is the first time he’s ever actually answered any of my correspondences.
“His answer was basically: (1) how dare the Philadelphia Teachers Union intrude on the family’s suffering to make a political point and (2) if only the teachers union would take concessions and work for less money, the state would have enough to pay for nurses!
“The deaths of these two students are direct consequences of Corbett’s education policies! He slashed education funding by close to $1 billion every year for the last 3 years! This resulted in 20,000 teachers being laid off, class sizes skyrocketing, the elimination of art, music and extra curricular activities – and, yes, school nurses! If this is not the time to address the issue of his malfeasance, when is!? Once people have time to forget? He did nothing after the first student died. Hadn’t the time come yet to address that issue before the second one died!? Will there be time to address the issue before another child dies? Would rushing to judgement after three years be too uncouth!?
“And then he blames teachers for asking to be treated fairly! Sure if we all just accepted sweat shop conditions, think of the money the state could lavish on our schools – to Pearson and Common Core!
“We had very low voter turnout during the primary that put Democratic candidate Tom Wolf as Corbett’s November challenger for governor. If people don’t show up to kick this bum out of office, we will all deserve what we get! Correction: we’ll deserve it, but the kids who mostly aren’t old enough to vote, will continue to be the innocent victims of this poisonous political hack!
“Here is Corbett’s letter:
“Putting the safety and educational needs of our students first must continue to be our top priority. There is an appropriate time and place to call for education policy discussions. Right now, our thoughts should be with the child’s family, friends, school and community who have all been through an extremely traumatic situation.
I am deeply troubled that the union leadership of the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers – and by extension the American Federation of Teachers – would use the recent tragedy at Jackson Elementary as an opportunity to make a political statement. For more than a year, we all have asked the union leadership – who are disconnected from the great teachers in Philadelphia who are in the classroom every day – to come to the table and engage in meaningful negotiations to assist in the financial recovery of the Philadelphia School District.
The Commonwealth, the School District, the School Reform Commission and City Council are all working to contribute to the success of Philadelphia’s schools and students. I will continue to ask the union leadership to put the children of Philadelphia first and engage in a meaningful dialogue and a shared vision for the future of the children of Philadelphia.
Tom Corbett”

Wow! And we were beginning to think that Rahm was the biggest ______ in state or local government.
LikeLike
Oh, he still. If a similar situation were to happen in Chicago, and if he were to get similar letters, his response would be quite similar, except his would have some f-bombs in it.
LikeLike
Tom Corbett,
This is scary as shit. He has no remorse whatsoever. Teachers should acquiesce to Walmart wages to afford school nurses. I thought I could no longer be shocked. I was wrong.
LikeLike
Not, of course, that nurses would be hired even if teachers agreed to Wal-Mart wages….
LikeLike
What Pennsyvania Governor Tom Corbett is doing is not exclusive to his state. It’s also happening in California. For instance, in just one of the more than 1,000 public school districts in California, Chino Valley Unified School District has been in negotiations with the local teachers union for one-and-a-half years. The teachers were asking for a 1.65% cost of living increase for the 2013-14 year after having no increases starting as far back as 2007.
BUT CVUSD district refuses to negotiate for any pay increase to teachers even to keep up with the cost of living.
This district started the school year with a hefty $55 million beginning balance beyond the money coming from the state to fund the current school year. Besides the asked for meager cost of living increase in pay, the teachers union was also asking for lower class sizes, more assistance for special education students and collaborative committees to set up between the district and teachers to develop a plan for their neediest students (LCAP).
For more details, watch the video:
To demonstrate the district’s lack of collaboration with its teachers is how the district has developed the LCAP. Where they want to spend $26,000,000 on programs and not include the opinions of the very people who will work with our students.
And when the public schools fall short of administrative and political goals, who do they blame? They blame the teachers who weren’t allowed to be a real part of the decision making process.
Please help spread the word of this one public school district as an example of how the public schools are being sabotaged—not by teachers but by administrators and elected politicians.
LikeLike
It’s happening in my district as well. The new administration won’t pay teachers a decent wage. Many are leaving for better paying districts in the surrounding areas. They claimed they wanted to develop the LCAP with parent and teacher support–but they already had the money locked into what they wanted. Instead of paying teachers a living wage, they are spending millions on new district offices. Really, really sad.
LikeLike
And guess what happens when school nurses ask for a living wage and benefits commensurate with their training and responsibilities?
In the Bizglish of Tom Corbett: ‘It is outrageous that school nurses want to take funding that should go to classroom teachers and the arts and PE and other worthwhile activities and selfishly demand that they alone deserve $11@hour.’
The argument works, on a certain level, for every situation; you just change “school nurses” and the other specifics to something else.
Linda put it very well in a comment: “Grow a heart please.”
😎
LikeLike
To avoid misunderstanding: I did not put quote marks around the Tom Corbett remarks because I made that up—I used that as an illustration of how, from my POV, he thinks and might react to a similar situation.
I apologize if there was any confusion.
😎
LikeLike
Are you telling us that a Registered Nurse is ONLY making $11/hour? Why would any licensed RN work for $11/hour? Hospitals must be paying more than that. If $11/hour is true, how can Corbett think that is TOO much money? He’s disgusting.
LikeLike
Tom Corbett:
You are a person who has lost his soul.
This is not an opportunity to levy blame at others, but to stand up like a governor, accept responsibility, stand with the people of Philadelphia and not the reformists who contribute dirty money to you and your administration, and do right by the people of the state of Pennsylvania.
Shame on you and all that you have done to harm a great American city, state, and nation. The city of brotherly love has become the city of inhumane corruption under your watch.
Surely, you will be held accountable for your actions, by the millions of people who you have not only turned your back on, but on those that your policies harm.
The entire nation is watching.
LikeLike
To the Catholic Church and Archbishop of Philadelphia, Charles J Chaput:
Where is the Catholic Church when evils such as this plague your city?
It is wonderful that you conduct services during the high holidays, and guide followers along in their religious pursuits.
But it is time for the Catholic Church, the Church you represent, to get involved and call on those who commit atrocities to end their criminal actions.
Almost a century ago, the Church remained silent as tens of millions suffered the horrors of fascist regimes in Europe and Asia.
Will you stand up for the people, the masses, the ones that Christianity was founded on, or remain quiet and choose to look away?
I am most certain that your voice would be well received, on earth as it is in heaven.
To the leaders of the Jewish community, when will you get involved and speak out for the heinous crimes committed in the name of “reform”?
You have seen what inaction has done throughout history. Must we bear witness once again?
How many more horrors must we witness before the leaders of these two great faiths finally throw their support to those who bear the brunt of Corbett’s policies in Philadelphia, and also those throughout our nation?
Our great nation was founded as a haven for all those who seek dignity, self-respect, and freedom….based on natural rights and natural laws. Does our Statue of Liberty hold her torch proudly high for all Americans, or just for those who seek profit and power?
How will ALL of our religious leaders be judged when we are all held accountable for our actions?
LikeLike
The Catholic University of America took a million dollars from the Koch’s for an ethical entrepreneurship program.
Religious leaders?
LikeLike
Corbett’s strategy is divide and conquer:
“It is outrageous that school nurses want to take funding that should go to classroom teachers and the arts and PE and other worthwhile activities and selfishly demand that they alone deserve $11@hour.”
“For more than a year, we all have asked the union leadership – who are disconnected from the great teachers in Philadelphia who are in the classroom every day…”
To the nurses- classroom teachers are better than you.
To the teachers – give up pay so we can have nurses.
To the union membership – your union doesn’t represent you.
It’s why unions were created in the first place.
Funding of our public schools need not be a zero-sum game. Schools are under-resourced by choice.
LikeLike
This will be Corbett’s modus operandi until November. He is in deep political trouble and needs to stir up his anti-Philadelphia, anti-union, anti-public education base in the state. See this Daniel Denvir article from last year: Secret poll: Corbett should exploit Philly school crisis, attack teachers union for political gain http://tinyurl.com/nolqzb7
Also see this recent article to see how the Philadelphia School Partnership, the private organization which is overseeing the privatization of Philadelphia public schools is working with Corbett to attack Philadelphia public school.: How Philly’s most powerful ed reform group broke the law http://tinyurl.com/pn9uckb
LikeLike
Corbett is also dishonest, or doesn’t know, about what is actually happening in negotiations. The union has been at the table for almost a year, and only they have put anything on it: wage freeze and contribution to health insurance. The district has put nothing on the table. They have actually gone to the PA Supreme Court to have seniority and other rights abrogated so that they can impose work rules without negotiating.
Ken is right. This is all designed to appeal to Corbett’s base. He is working out of the Scott Walker playbook: use a manufactured budget crisis to take away the collective bargaining rights of union members.
LikeLike
Governor Corbett has shown all along that he only responds to his corporate cronies. He didn’t impose a tax on Marcellus Shale drilling, even while those companies made big profits. Why? Campaign donations. He hasn’t closed the loophole that allows corporations to claim they are headquartered in Delaware to avoid taxes.
We have the option to elect a new governor this year in Pennsylvania. I truly hope the people see what kind of person Corbettt is and fire him!
LikeLike
From my understanding, Philadelphia principals all took pay cuts too.
There is better treatment and staffing in prisons. Corbetts building them!!!
LikeLike
Yes, my principal told us that after having his salary and benefits cut, he now makes $23.000 less per year. It’s not just the teachers and nurses that are getting screwed here.
LikeLike
You’re so right, Tracey. Just the fat cats gain. The greed mongers.
LikeLike
This is mind-numbing and shocking. The venality and demagoguery of this political hack is almost criminal. A child dies in a school and every one has to remain silent, according to Corbett, because it might embarrass his misadministration? He has a kindred spirit in NJ with Christie who blames the teacher pensions for NJ’s economic woes and for lack of proper funding for cancer research. Corbett and so many of his political cohorts despise public education and especially teacher unions; they have total disrespect for public school teachers and I’m talking about real public schools not charter schools. Shame on him, he should pay a price for his nonfeasance and malfeasance but sadly he will just walk away from the mess he created and probably become a lobbyist for some corporate entity.
LikeLike
According to statistics reported by my union, the Pa.State Education Association, 40% of its teacher membership voted for Corbett in 2010. In the years since our membership has dwindled as a result of layoffs, demotions, and worsening job conditions. I am hopeful that this election year things will be different but I have my doubts. Corbett’s hard hearted anti-union message, contained in his letter, is very popular with ordinary folks in the community where I teach and around the state. Republicans have been quite effective in setting teachers up as the fall-guy for every economic woe faced by the poor and lower middle classes, while the 1% walk away scot free with all the economic gains of the past thirty years. If our leadership can’t convince even it’s membership that we need change, what hope is there of convincing the general public that good, strong public schools with adequate resources and dedicated, fairly compensated teachers is in their best interest?
LikeLike
If the 1% had gone after the schools, universities, VA, prisons, public roads, parks, public retirees, federal employees, all at the same time, the story might be different.
Church messaging, from the Catholic hierarchy to the evangelical mega churches, is a significant contributing factor in the public’s voting against its own interests.
Foster Freiss is a poster boy for the political, religious component.
LikeLike
When I got my auto-response from Corbett, my knee-jerk response to him was,
“How dare you, of all people, accuse the UNION of not putting the children of Philadelphia first?!?!?
How DARE you!?!?!??”
What complete and utter [donkey]. I won’t move back to PA while this twit is in office. I want better for my family.
LikeLike
Unreal I cannot believe how the politicians in our government are making teachers and our teacher’s unions the scapegoats for their FAILED polices and theft of moneies from our children and their educational rights. How many BILLIONS did THIS Governor give to the horseman of this state? I think it was the same amount that they took away from education if I remember reading it correctly. Yet teachers should take pay cuts…while politicians wine and dine like fat cats…because we all know us teachers are “rolling in dough” and “living the high life” …as I work with my own special needs child who is now a young adult…and my adult aging parents and my youngest son with dreams of being an Olympic hopeful (yeah there is another government helping hand – NOT!!). We too have families and pay taxes…and work hard…and have cost of living…oh and aren’t stupid…by cutting 20,000 teachers you saved a good amount of tax payer money…a nurse should have not been a problem! I hope the parents of BOTH children sue the government for removing the funding from education which caused these cuts and allowed the deaths…which is why he is pointing fingers…somewhere there is a brazen attorney looking to make a name for himself/ herself!!! There is a waste of money…find it!!!
LikeLike
I saw this coming. Blame the teachers for not giving up more. f
LikeLike
Blame the Unions ? The Unions protect our students and teachers Corbett has himself to blame Weak Leader . Get him out..
LikeLike
How pathetic. I hope that the good citizens of Pennsylvania vote this man out of office and that other governors around the country take notice.
LikeLike
Everyone who filled out a petition sent out on fb from the PFT/AFT ,got this form letter from The Governor. I got one, too. I replied back to the Governor that us parents are not over the death of the first child in Philly and that I would like to have a meeting with him. I did not get a reply thus far. He always said that no one reached out to him. Well I am and he has no excuse now. Maureen Fratantoni-Nebinger H&S President
LikeLike
Why is this the (admittedly awful) governor’s fault 3 years into one term? Philadelphia’s school district wasn’t paying a quarter billion $/yr to the bond industry in debt service when Corbett came into office because he just came into office. For most of the 10 year history of the SRC (including now again) it’s been run by Democrats; the state was run by Democrats 4 years ago… on top of multiple generations of of the city being run by that one party, with the mayor, 14 of 17 minimum City Counciltheives, the City Controller, the Sheriff, the DA & anyone else charged with assessing and collecting property (i.e. school) taxes for Philadelphia… all Democrats. All of the time.
Schools outside of Philadelphia in PA have nurses. There are 501 school districts in PA & this is the one where kids are dying. For 17 years & counting the city by itself, in exclusion to the rest of PA, a city completely run by Democrats, decided to stop collecting school taxes from all new construction & renovation anywhere for any reason. This includes on corporate HQs (Comcast’s $1.2 billion skyscraper is getting $10 million FROM THE CITY in negative “taxation”), luxury condos, etc – the most & most valuable real estate in all of PA. From the first year of Nutter the city instead of expanding the PILOT program to collect school taxes on the 11% of real estate owned by rich non-profits decided instead to END the program, not collecting a penny for the schools from rich behemoths like Penn. On top of this the city has an estimated 111,000 properties in arrears on assessed taxes, according to an Inquirer study 57,000 of them speculative investments. They are in arrears on average 6.5 years & in some cases haven’t paid a penny to the schools in 30 years, during which time the city has always been completely run by Democrats.
There’s a desperation to pin one-two generations of total corrupt abandonment of the PSD for real estate interests by city Democrats on a one-term governor because he’s a Republican. It makes no sense, it’s really been a craven deflection of responsibility (and therefore solution formulation) on the part of the PFT and “school advocates” who’re more loyal to a crooked Democratic Party than to their own union or schools or students or futures. I’ll add that the failure to collect taxes like a normal, sane community not fully committed to Reaganomics – which is what this nightmare has been – has caused a rolling bond market debt service that now amounts to $270 million/yr of funds transferred from the school budget to both corporate parties’ friends/owners on Wall St.
Meanwhile just across the street from the city – where Tom Corbett is also governor – elected school boards even in places where most people vote Republican raise property taxes on all construction [all property in fact!] most years, and as a result have interest-earning rainy day SURPLUSES, nurses in every school + unionized, non-laid-off teachers making twice the money for teaching classes half the size.
Self-described “liberals” did this to non-white unionized school district to fill their own pockets. And it’s all blamed on a party that virtually doesn’t exist in this city & a state government which has nothing whatever to do with assessing or collecting Philadelphia school taxes. If the PFT had any sense – which they don’t – they’d be running a full slate of candidates in 2015 in the November general elections to bump the crooked Dems out of office, default on the bond usury, create for the first time an elected school board with taxation powers like the surrounding (and often Republican) communities have. Instead they’re going to sick with the real estate and FIRE sector-owned filthy Dems all the down, until the last school goes charter, the last dues are collected from the last unionized teacher & the PFT staff cash their last checks out of the world’s least useful union dues.
LikeLike
He is a man with nothing and he knows all is lost. So now he is fighting to regain lost support from his own party. The People must come out to VOTE in record numbers.
LikeLike
What a cop out!
In Buffalo, at one point the nurses were cut to one or two days a week. Prior to money issues, many of the inner city schools had fully functioning clinics with not only nurses, but weekly visits by doctors. The children even were able to get their vaccinations.
With the reduction in nurses, there were similar issues, especially with the high rate of asthma found in the city’s children (see the Peace Bridge controversy). After negotiations between city and county, the Erie County Executive agreed to staff every school with a full time nurse. The trade off was that the city paid the nurses the same as a teacher’s salary, but the Erie County nurses are paid much less as county workers.
The Buffalo Public School System is not paid through property taxes. The City pays some, but NYS provides the bulk of funding. The budget is huge – hundreds of millions of dollars. Yet, the district is always crying poverty.
If PA valued education, they would find the funds. And not on the backs of the teachers. We are in crisis mode as governors would like to divert education monies to other places (or other pockets). Pennsylvania’s problems reflect the problems found in all states (in varying degrees).
If we can’t afford to fund public education, then where are our tax dollars going?
If we can’t provide full time nurses to deal with the health of children in our schools, then the state better take a closer look at their priorities.
Because our young should be number 1, not an after thought.
LikeLike
I don’t believe that either the unions nor the governor are responsible. Geez! There haven’t been full time nurses since I was in grade school more than 50 years ago nor have I ever known of a child to die at school since I’ve been teaching, now for more than 25 years. If a child, like an adult becomes ill, we call 911. We’ve called when children have fallen from the monkey bars and we called when I was stung by a bee on my tongue.
LikeLike
This isn’t surprising. In the culture we live in today, we teachers and/or unions are more often than not the scapegoat of society’s ills. I worry because at my school site we only have a nurse a half day twice a week, so if students become ill, they must go to the counseling office for “treatment.” I worry about one of my students who has a seizure disorder; if he has a seizure in class and if something happens, will I get blamed? My stepbrother and I often have heated arguments over education. He feels that standardized testing is the end-all, be-all of school and student success. He doesn’t believe that any student is not prepared for any grade level. When I tell him that my high school students are grade levels behind in reading, he says it’s my fault for not bringing them up to the appropriate reading level. Um, I can’t do that in the 8 months I have before state testing. A tangent, I know, but if every person who criticizes education taught for a month, then that person would see just exactly what we are faced with every day. We aren’t baby-sitters, and we certainly aren’t doctors and nurses, either.
LikeLike
Note to Governor Corbett: You are an awful governor and a disgusting excuse for a human being. I can only hope you lose your election and the following day drop dead. It would be exactly what you deserve. No turning the other cheek here!
LikeLike
YES! AGREED!
LikeLike
Mr. Corbett, I am just as disappointed that our leaders would use the damage done by an economy centered around “investors” who capitalize on and speculate with public funds as those funds are there’s to play with, and then push a plan to further choke the public instead of step up/own up and consider more modest sustainable growth models.. They will get what they truly deserve, which will be far worse if they joined the disingenuous FOX News-like parsing and mis-framing of arguments to protect culprits and further harm true supporters of society. Get your resume in with Pearson now.
LikeLike
He blames teachers when he cuts fundings in education. Ill blame him for joe paterno`s death.im voting him out
LikeLike
They all need to be fired without any extras 401 and the rest of it taken from them and put back into the cities they stole it from. We need to start over with bill down the street, Mary the cashier from the local supermarket make it a draft normal people from all walks of life. No more political lifers that do nothing but line their own pockets with the labor of others. There thieves plain and simple
LikeLike
As always it’s the haughty tone that does me in. How dare you teachers suggest that my cuts are hurting children, no it’s your greed.
LikeLike
Tom Corbett is a scumbag and a deeply deranged and immoral person.
LikeLike
The DEFORMERS = $$$$$$
LikeLike
Corbett is taking some heat on his Facebook page, but there are an equal number of Philadelphia and union haters posting too.
https://www.facebook.com/Gov.TomCorbett
LikeLike
Don’t be surprised. This is a man of disingenue who pulls the wool over the public’e eye with a contemptuous PR stunt.
LikeLike
I agree, Ken. Most politicians resort to these tactics.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on SD Educators United.
LikeLike
When will a lawyer take up the cases and sue Corbett and the state for the unnecessary deaths of these two children? Only when money and the risk of losing political office become involved will anything be done to stop this inhumane slaughter of the innocents.
LikeLike
I know some people still believe that “suing the bastards” is the way to get justice, but I’ve watched Chicago schools bureaucrats smile benignly for the past 15 or 20 years every time a desperate person, parent or teacher usually, gets up in front of the Board of Education and says “I’m GOING TO SUE YOU!!!”
The reason for the smiles is that all of them know that (a) the courts will almost always rule in favor of the Board and the government officials and (b) the person or people who bring the lawsuit (or lawsuits) will be paying for the lawyers on both sides of the case. Our taxes pay the lawyers for the governmental plaintiff, and we also have to pay for our own lawyers.
The Chicago Teachers Union learned these lessons in a way the hard way beginning as soon as CORE won in 2010. Lawsuit after lawsuit to protect teachers who were cut, to challenge this that and the other injustice. Etc. Etc. Etc.
Last summer, for example, the union paid for the lawyers to represent a bunch of special education parents whose children were in the schools that the Board had voted to close at the infamous May 22, 2013 meeting of the Chicago Board of Education. The largest school closings in US history.
We covered every day of those trails in substancenews.net. Almost word for word in many cases. Our side won every argument; made the Board’s witnesses look as clueless and evil as they were. And when the case was “over,” one of the federal judges devoted a lengthy opinion not only throwing out “our” case but attacking the plaintiffs for even having brought it.
If the law says that a government agency can do whatever it wants, you will not get “justice” by suing, but only by changing the law. It’s been true since this country was founded on laws (and a Constitution) that legalized slavery and has been true ever since. So please, don’t waste your dollars on litigation unless you want to make lawyers wealthier — or want to “make a statement” and have lots of money with which to do it.
The law belongs to those who own it. I could easily share a dozen Chicago examples, but will only if asked at Csubstance@aol.com. Otherwise, save your money for other approaches to justice.
LikeLike
It was the same lack of justice for the people that led to the colonies rebelling against the British Empire.
LikeLike
These are very wise words that everyone should consider. With very few exceptions, the only way to effect change that affects large numbers of people is through the political process. Courts protect individual rights. They rarely change the world.
LikeLike
Agreed. Not to mention that lawsuits are lengthy(can last years) and do not take care of the immediate problems that need attention. There is strength in numbers and the more people that step up and let those in power know how disgusted they are, the better.
LikeLike
Dear Governor,
This responce to this childs death shows what a cold heart you have. You have some nerve to blame the teachers union for this tragedy. Then you take no responsibility for the cuts to school funding that forced the schools to have no nurses. I am a republican and I am ashamed of what you have done. It is going to be my privilege to vote you out of office this November. .
LikeLike
Corbett is a MORON. He needs to be held responsible for spending school money on tax breaks for race horse owners and building prisons. Enough!! Will the parents sue? Will they sue Corbett?
LikeLike
Um. And Corbett’s letter WASN’T political. Come on, Gov. Do the right thing. And yes. He should be personally sued for his cars, his house, his annuities, retirement and down to his underwear!
LikeLike
Send more open letters to the newspapers. This must be front and center in the public’s consciousness until election day. Keep doing it. We are behind you in Pennsylvania!
LikeLike
Sent a second message to Governor Corbett requesting a meeting.
LikeLike
I believe Corbett may be related to Mitch Daniels and/or Mike Pence, esteemed(ha!) governors of Indiana and haters of public education and teacher’s unions, ( not necessarily in that order. Our union power has be hobbled by these bozos and other Republican legislators.
LikeLike