The New York Daily News reports that pro-charter advocacy groups spent $3.6 million on attack ads against Mayor Bill de Blasio’s decision to deny 3 charter applications to Eva Moskowitz’s Success Academy charter chain (while approving 5 of her other applications). They spent these millions while claiming that they could not afford to pay the city rent for use of public space. Current state legislation says the charters “shall pay rent,” not “may pay rent.” De Blasio was acting on behalf of the 94% of students in overcrowded classrooms and overcrowded schools, while Eva’s schools are handsomely funded. She and her supporters believe that the high test scores the students obtain gives them the right to push handicapped children out of their classrooms and schools. Of course, the high test scores are obtained by excluding children with disabilities, taking half as many English language learners, and getting rid of kids with low scores before the testing begins.
The de Blasio administration was completely unprepared for this barrage of attack ads. The mayor never called a press conference to refute the wild charges against his administration. He appeared on “Morning Joe,” where the talk show hosts battered him with hostile questions. There was no advertising campaign to explain that no one was being “evicted” from the two schools that had not yet opened, or that the one school that was denied the right to expand inside a public school building would have required the eviction of children who are severely disabled.
This note came from Leonie Haimson of Class Size Matters:
Charter school lobby spent $3.6m in 3 wks on TV attack ads/claims charters can’t afford rent http://shar.es/RBFWo
This group is funded by the Walton Foundation; Marc Sternberg at DOE made sure Eva got all these co-locations just days before he left for the Walton Foundation. Watch out other cities and states; this is what you face once you open the floodgates to charters. They will attack for every dollar and inch of space in your schools.

And here’s what the NYTimes reported on today: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/20/nyregion/familiar-consultants-hired-by-the-mayors-pre-k-drive.html?emc=edit_tnt_20140319&nlid=26825267&tntemail0=y
Here’s the question the Times needs to answer: why are they harping on $236,000 of PRIVATE funds being used to “promote” pre-kindergarten— a bona fide need for children that clearly promotes learning— while missing the story that for-profit charter proponents are spending $3,600,000— FIFTEEN TIMES AS MUCH— to promote the use of space funded by taxpayers to subsidize their schools???
LikeLike
This is happening on Delaware. The TFA in my school goes to many events sponsored by TFA and completely paid for. I was denied going to IRA this year for lack of funds , even thought I had $750.00 from my local racing organization, and testing concerns. We need to make noise about this stuff. I am writing my Legislators today.
LikeLike
Morning Joe battered him with hostile questions?? I am sure the conservatives are happy to sit back and watch the Mayor get it from all sides. Honestly, MSNBC seems like just another FOX news to me and that is why I rarely watch these stations.
It’s too bad no one is giving Mayor de Blasio a chance.
LikeLike
Joe Scarborough is a conservative.
LikeLike
Years ago, Joe Scarborough was a conservative Republican Congressman.
LikeLike
Thanks for the clarification- for some reason I thought MSNBC was all liberal.
LikeLike
Even if MSNBC WERE “all liberal” that means nothing on this issue. Barack Obama is liberal and what’s he done on this? We know all too well. The problem is that many liberals, particularly those who have to stand in competitive races, have decided they need the money these foundations can supply, they have been up to now been able to sell this crap as “concern for economically deprived students,” a “civil rights issue” but that’s becoming harder and harder. They’re no longer able to have it both ways. Now their is grass roots opposition from parents and teachers who’ve seen that this bright shiny “reform” harms rather than helps their kids.
In my charitable moments I can point to Citizens United and politicians’ need for cash as an excuse. But really, it’s gotten too obvious and too cynical for that. The emperor wears no clothes. Question is will Democrats wake up in time to see it.
Pat Quinn is facing a tough re-election campaign in Illinois from anti-union gazillionaire thug Bruce Rauner, sort of a Scott Walker on steroids. This should not even be close but Quinn’s trimming of sails makes his re-election questionable. Think an energized parent-teacher alliance in Chicago could help him? Maybe, but he’s viewed as a pension thief by teachers and Deservedly so and won’t have that weapon.
The importance of this blog is that it’s helping to force the issue and making it impossible to ignore. Democrats and liberals who think corporate school “reform”is a path to free campaign funds are killing the party and it’s time they were made to realize it.
LikeLike
SC,
You’re right, in my town, the liberals aren’t exactly anti-subsidized private schools. In my town, many liberal enter charter lotteries and are gleeful when their child wins a spot.
LikeLike
Success Academy gets its high test scores by drilling kids relentlessly, using long days, less vacation time, even weekend time for test prep. In the weeks leading up to state testing, classes and activities that do not relate to testing are cancelled. At bottom, the fault is not with the charters that do this, but the system that rates them using test scores.
LikeLike
I agree, Annette, that the system is wrong. But the charters who turn kids into “little test-taking machines” are also wrong.
It is not cheating, it is child abuse.
LikeLike
yes, it is child abuse. The children become robots in the service of — the charter leaders? the charter movement? high stakes testing? future charter school students? but these children’s childhoods and love of learning are being sacrificed.
LikeLike
It’s all about rampant profiteering. CC and all the rest of the alphabet soup testing titles are merely the front for a business plan. The corporate greed heads want all that cash to take a direct u-turn from public institutions and head into their private coffers. Charters and vouchers are the repository of our public funds for these venture capitalists. It’s our obligation to speak out on this at every public forum.
Meanwhile many tech companies (e.g. Microsoft) who are involved in and/or looking to make inroads towards the education-industrial complex are avoiding paying their taxes (which should be going to public services (like schools, infrastructure etc.) by using tax havens abroad. So when Gates and all the others speak about their grand social generosity be sure to bring this up and ask them if they care so much about public welfare why is it they are avoiding paying their taxes with the shiftiest of maneuvers.
===========================================
The largest U.S.-based companies added $206 billion to their stockpiles of offshore profits last year, parking earnings in low-tax countries until Congress gives them a reason not to.
The multinational companies have accumulated $1.95 trillion outside the U.S., up 11.8 percent from a year earlier, according to securities filings from 307 corporations reviewed by Bloomberg News. Three U.S.-based companies — Microsoft Corp. (MSFT), Apple Inc. and International Business Machines Corp. — added $37.5 billion, or 18.2 percent of the total increase.
….
Lawmakers in the U.S., the U.K., France and Italy have scrutinized companies such as Microsoft, Hewlett-Packard Co., Apple, Google Inc. (GOOG) and Amazon.com Inc.
…..
In three years, Microsoft’s profits held offshore have more than doubled and Apple’s have more than quadrupled. Google’s cache has more than doubled in the past three years, to $38.9 billion from $17.5 billion.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-03-12/cash-abroad-rises-206-billion-as-apple-to-ibm-avoid-tax.html
LikeLike
“So when Gates and all the others speak about their grand social generosity be sure to bring this up and ask them if they care so much about public welfare why is it they are avoiding paying their taxes with the shiftiest of maneuvers.”
Exactly.
LikeLike
Because I pay my taxes. The money our household earns is all listed on W2s. There is very little we can do to avoid paying according to the scheduled rates. We can’t hide it abroad or call it “investment income” in order to cut the percentage owed by half. So, we pay it. And meanwhile those who have much greater flexibility with their taxes (hey, corporations are people too!) get to erode the public domain. So, I pay for private schooling too. However, if there is ever a significant threat to “American interests” at home or abroad you can bet your Chromebook that my son will be expected to fight and die for his corporation – ehem – country.
LikeLike
You are so right. This is all about the money and wall street. The rich get richer and step over the children laughing all the way to the bank
LikeLike
Not for nothing, but I’m thinking about all the amazing things my public school district could do with $3.6 million. And, for what it’s worth, if I were a major donor to charter schools, and I discovered that my money was being used for advertising and a smear campaign, I’d pull the purse strings closed so quickly they wouldn’t know their fingers had been amputated. But, alas….
LikeLike
Eva’s daily TV ads are killing DeBlasio, brilliant propaganda lying about the situation, tear-jerking smarmy shots of dark-skinned parents and kids being abused by an uncaring new mayor for no reason—shifting public opinion against him. Why is the Mayor silent? Why was he caught flat-footed given that Eva and her millions are a known commodity in NYC? This is a fiasco for DeB and he seems incapable of fighting back, after a stunning win in the election. Who can explain it? Leonie Haimson and Mark Naison should take the mayor to the woodshed and shake some fighting grit into him.
LikeLike
Richard Cohen seems to think differently- Maybe someone should enlighten him.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/richard-cohen-illogical-hostility-toward-charter-schools/2014/03/17/b3f1ae4e-adf2-11e3-a49e-76adc9210f19_story.html
LikeLike
A radio ad that played in Albany about the failure to approve the three charter applications urged listeners to protest this act that hurt the kids by communicating with the Governor, Senate Republicans, and Assembly Speaker Silver. After that, unbelievably, the ad ended with the words “we need to keep politics out of education.” I wonder who the genius was who wrote the script for that ad. Richard Ognibene
_____
LikeLike
Can someone offer a link to the NYS legislature’s rule that charter schools shall pay rent for use of district school space?
LikeLike
Might be useful:
http://www.milliondollarlist.org/data
LikeLike
Here’s a better one with the ed reform most popular:
http://www.milliondollarlist.org/donors
LikeLike
I hope DeBlasio has someone coaching him. He needs to be drilled on his talking points. How did he survive the campaign? He must have faced tough questions. All of his talking points have been provided on this blog!
LikeLike
Child abuse via ccss and high stakes testing are both well and alive in this “so-called” country of the “free and the brave”. We are being duped, duped, duped by our politicians and the big money they serve, because of campaign contributions. TAWDRY!
LikeLike