What’s the gripe of those “white suburban moms” (and dads) who have turned out in large numbers to complain about Common Core and the increase in testing?
Here is a good analysis by a local Long Island reporter.
Jaime Franchi at LongIslandPress.com interviewed parents and leaders of the revolt and gives a full picture of the uprising.
The story begins:
“Uncomfortable. Impossible. My chest hurts,” says Vincent Pepe, 10, pointing to his t-shirt where he feels his heart rate accelerating. He won’t make eye contact. He doesn’t like talking about the state tests he took last year.
“There wasn’t enough time,” he says. “It makes you quit.”
His older brother Ryan, 13, looks up from under a pile of homework. Ryan has served as Vincent’s protector since he was born. But Ryan can’t protect him from everything.
Neither will be taking the state tests this year. And they’re not alone.
A battle is being waged in New York State with Long Island on the front lines. The warriors come armed with manila folders of research on topics such as Common Core, data-mining and a billion-dollar company named Pearson. They have bags under their eyes from long, weary nights in front of sometimes-incomprehensible homework. The battlegrounds are the classrooms, the kitchen table, and auditoriums packed with parents and teachers who are demanding a three-year moratorium on high-stakes testing, but will settle for the resignation of New York State (NYS) Commissioner of Education John B. King, Jr. and the head of Gov. Andrew Cuomo. They are an army formed on Facebook, with groups informed by a national movement but concentrated right here, mobilized and motivated by the stress of their children. Their vow is to defeat Common Core, the educational reform so extreme that kids are mutilating themselves in response to the psychological stress that experts are calling “Common Core Syndrome.”
State officials are intransigent. Despite the near-unanimous condemnation of the state’s high-stakes testing regime, the Regents and the Commissioner of Education have made clear that they have no intention of backing down. The kids will get the tests again and again, no matter how many fail.
Nearly 20,000 parents have signed petitions against the testing; that number will grow. The Long Island principals have led a statewide rebellion against the untested “education evaluation” tied to the high-stakes test.
The parents, teachers, and principals of Long Island understand what state officials do not.
Education policy cannot be rammed down everyone’s throats. Collaboration and respect are needed, not the power to compel compliance.

Diane, how I hope you read this. Colorado has 2 bills entering the senate today, against common core! We are working with senator on wording tonight. We are also hosting an on-air debate about cc next week. Can we be so bold to ask you to call and comment on this debate? (AM 560 KLZ in Denver). I know you are the busiest woman-but you are also THE expert. We want Common Core out of our state! Our newspapers won’t print anything against CCSandra Stotsky sent us an op-ed and the Denver Post refused to print it…but did post 5 proCC stories instead! Please consider helping our state and helping me and so many dedicated Colo parents in this fight. Thank You!! Cheri Kiesecker, Fort Collins
LikeLike
School is hard. welcome to the real world.
LikeLike
Why is this necessarily “common sense”? By your logic, if I plan to go out drinking on Friday, I should spend Thursday beating myself over the head with a hammer to prepare myself for the hangover I’m going to have on Saturday.
If the “real world” is as hard as you say, why not let kids be kids and enjoy themselves for a few years before entering it? And, while I don’t have any direct research to prove this, my guess would be that children who are allowed to enjoy their childhoods tend not to actually find the “real world” quite so hard.
LikeLike
Dienne: well said!
😎
LikeLike
Umm… so you probably don’t have children in school. You probably have no idea how much it has changed since you were there. No big deal. How about the fact that the Common Core has cost taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars per school district? Private companies (Pearson) have used our students as guinea pigs and schools as testing grounds for their products. They are pulling the strings of the Regents and we have to foot the bill.
LikeLike
School should be hard (in spots). It should not be inappropriate.
Educational policies should not ignore mountains of research on brain development and cognitive learning theories.
LikeLike
Perhaps you are checking in from another state. The outrage expressed in the article reflects ed doings in the only state which imposed common core testing & linked student scores to teacher eval’ns within 9 mos of adopting common core stds– too little time for most teachers & admins to read the stds, let alone adapt their curriculum, so tests were administered to students who had not even been taught to the stds on which they were based.
LikeLike
School is not HARD unless you expect a first grader to write a recursive formula for a geometric sequence..
INAPPROPRIATE…
Can a newborn baby WALK????? No…not until his muscles have developed properly…
I guess you do have one point….working on an assembly line (in this case …a testing line) for 14 hours a day and on the weekends…is HARD…Yep that would be hard because that would be so boring….
Gotta pass this test or that test or this test and all of you must know the exact same material..That is such a bunch of crock….anyone with a LITTLE Common Sense could see it…
Please change your name..
LikeLike
Thank you Jamie Franchi and thank you Diane for spreading our story!
LikeLike
Arne Duncan @arneduncan 3h
#OECDPISA lesson: The edu challenge in US is not just about poor kids in poor neighborhoods. It’s about many kids in many neighborhoods.
In other words, they want to take relatively strong public school systems and turn them into fragmented, partly-privatized, defunded weaker systems with vouchers and charters and all the other reform magic.
Can anyone point to a PUBLIC school system that reformers have actually improved? Is there an example of a strong system of EXISTING schools they have made better? Because I’m not seeing it in Ohio, and they’ve been at it a decade.
Weren’t we all sold on this with the promise they would improve public schools? Not set up a charter/voucher system of publicly-funded schools, but improve existing schools? Because that’s what the LI “moms” fear. That reformers will destroy their public schools. This isn’t hard to figure out. They want to RETAIN their public schools.
LikeLike
Long Islanders are fighting mad and we will not back down until the pendulum of education reform is redirected towards common sense, not common core.
LikeLike
Are you mad enough to start a serious legal action? Once a class action suit is filed the rest of the state can climb on board. I would guess Long Island has the resources and willpower to get the ball rolling.
Without legal action, the pendulum will not budge as long as the NY common core cartel remains in power.
LikeLike
Is part of this problem because NY didn’t jump into this until late in the game? As far as I can tell, Massachsetts got in at the beginning and even added additional standards and their school systems are doing very well on the tests. Maybe NY schools or perhaps it’s more specific to Long Island, but maybe we should have started phasing this in 3 years ago and done some professional development for our teaching staffs. I wonder if we would then be in a different situation? Perhaps our lack if planning and preparation for an entirely new protocol is the real problem….? Not the actual higher standards….?
LikeLike
Allison,
Mass did not start Common Core sooner.
Mass began a major Ed reform in 1993 that involved a massive increase in state funding, more equitable funding, pus higher standards and state testing and early childhood education.
LikeLike
NY and KY are the only states that were ahead of the curve on CCSS aligned assessments.
Pearson exams her in NY were designed for a 70% failure rate.
Factors that contributed to this include:
1) poorly written items
2) length of tests (9 hours over 6 days; 18 hours for IEP students)
3) insufficient time to complete tests
4) test taking fatigue
5) ridiculously high cut scores
6) norm referencing
7) no modifications for special ed or ESL students
8) no stakes for students (and they knew it)
Notice I did not include the CCSS standards on this list
So MA sharpen your pencils and join the fun!
LikeLike
Allison, I don’t think the standards ARE the problem. Higher standards are fine, a great idea, even. The problem is that at a VERY young age (4&5 year olds) they are making simple things like addition/subtraction very complicated. They are expected to compose sentences before they can read. They are all being expected to all learn the same way and at the same rate. 8 year olds are expected to read for 70 minutes at a time (how many 8 year olds can sit still for 70 minutes?) The teachers weren’t given sufficient time to develop curriculum. The teachers weren’t given the tests before they had to teach the kids how to pass them. The testing is a BIG problem, The kids are spending weeks prepping for days and days of testing that is being used to evaluate the TEACHERS worth. Those weeks & days are time that the kids are not being TAUGHT, they’re only being taught how to pass the test, and the pressure on these very young kids is depressing them, turning them off of school & learning bigtime. This generation will have the biggest dropout rate ever if this keeps up. The kids who are in kindergarten now will do better, but the older kids who last year were called good students and loved school and now are being called failures (as they struggle to grasp brand new concepts they have not been prepared for) will be the sacrificial lambs and THAT is unacceptable to us. In addition to this, parents are prevented from being a part of their kids’ education. Parents don’t understand how to help the kids with their homework and there is no one to teach the parents. The Common Core website has like 50 articles on how to help your kids understand CC and each one of them is like 120 pages long and reads like VHS instructions.
LikeLike
Karen, the difficulty doing the work is not due to the training it is due to the standards. They are not developmentally appropriate in total at the K-3 level. Their minds are not yet developed to process the concepts effectively at that age.
As to problems with common core, it opens the door wide to allow for political indoctrination. Especially at the K-5 grade levels where analysis of reading material concentrates on ONLY the presented material. Personal knowledge, bias of author, other opinions are prohibited from being included in the analysis of and one article. That is not even begun until grade 6, and even then it is less than 10% of 6-12 analysis standards.
These young k-5 minds, eager to absorb information, will take the material presented as fact. I do not trust most teachers to choose and present unbiased political material to be analyzed. In fact social media is already full of examples of politically biased curriculum.
LikeLike
Article not comprehensive.
Sen. Jack Martins (R) of Long Island is the only elected State Senator to demand the resignation of Chancellor King and in his correspondence with a constituent, shares the demand for a moratorium until 2017. Sen. Martins also has a bill to protect children’s data.
I am surprised that the Long Island reporter has no knowledge of this.
LikeLike
SIMPLE…SIMPLE..SIMPLE…
Life does not fit all the same way…
Ask the construction worker I had to pay yesterday..Just ask him…
The math he needs is not the same as a chemical engineer or a mathematical researcher or a etc etc etc etc etc..
All etc’s are all different..THANK THE LORD..
What a boring world this would be if we all looked the same…did the same…walked the same..wore the same…thought the same….talked the same….etc etc etc..
Those etc’s are DIVERSE and Schooling should be nothing short of expanding on the interests and abilities of each and every “etc”
Take you life back people…Do not allow the Giant $$$$$$ Testing Hierarchy to map the lives of your children…BE DIFFERENT and BE PROUD of your Differences……
LikeLike
All this sameness and equality of everything is Communism. How did that work out?
LikeLike