John Marzulli of the New York Daily News reports that the ex-project manager of the South Bronx Classical Charter School is suing the school for $1 million for firing her for reporting financial and academic wrong-doing.
She allegedly told supervisors that the school was billing the city for special education students who were not enrolled and that some exams were plagiarized.
She also complained that children were punished by withholding food from them.
Leonie Haimson of Class Size Matters reports that the school was awarded an A by the city on its latest report card:
She writes:
South Bronx Classical Charter allegedly defrauded public funds by charging DOE for special ed kids no longer attending, cheated on the state tests and withheld food from kids as punishment; yet got an A on NYC progress reports.
The school claims to develop “citizens of impeccable character.”
Lester Long, the ED and principal, who was allegedly informed of the fraud and shrugged his shoulders, is a former investment banker according to Wikipedia.
The charter school was allowed to expand into the middle grades and to replicate and open a second school, S. Bronx Classical Charter II by SED and the Regents, despite the fact that it was reported in 2012 that between 20 and 40 percent of students originally enrolled in the school left before they were tested, and no new students replaced them.
Moreover, in its site visit dated June 2012, the DOE charter office noted that the “school should continue its efforts to reach compliance with the amended 2010 NYS charter law requirements related to the enrollment and retention of at -risk student populations… …its enrollment of students with IEPs is below CSD 12 averages with a special education population of 5.4 % compared to CSD 12’s average of 18.3 %, as is the school’s population of ELLs (7.7% compared to 19% in the district.)”
The visitors also mentioned the high level of turnover of teachers and excessive reliance on inexperienced TFAers.
In another case reported in the DN in 2012, the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights was investigating the suspension of Christian Charriez, 6, a special-needs student, who was suspended four times – the last time his parents told that he had to receive a psychiatric diagnosis.
“Principal Lester Long said the school invited Christian back to school and contacted his mother multiple times, but a letter from the family’s lawyer shows the school was contacted multiple times without response.”

If it proven that food was withheld somebody should go to jail.
LikeLike
Oh, I hope this teacher wins big.
LikeLike
Me, too, Linda! Ditto for Christian’s parents.These cases could open Pandora’s Box on these rotten, conniving charter school operators.
LikeLike
Linda Johnson: me too.
Note when you go to their website, they boldly proclaim on their home page “Developing Liberated Scholars and Citizens of Impeccable Character” — but shouldn’t the school administrators model that behavior themselves? Or at least not punish a staff member for living up to their own professed standards?
Link: http://www.southbronxclassical.org
I guess I forgot that an old dead Frenchman anticipated this so very long ago: “Hypocrisy is the homage vice pays to virtue.” [Francois de la Rouchefoucauld]
But not to worry. This whistleblower’s plight will be borne heroically by leading charterites/privatizers everywhere:
“We all have strength enough to endure the misfortunes of others.” [Francois de la Rouchefoucauld]
🙂
LikeLike
Now they are at the whims of the court system. Is it as corrupt as ours is in California in which since 1988 the Superior Court Judges have been illegally paid up to $44,000/year extra by the counties which is against the California State Constitution as shown in the Sturgis Case. As a result of my friend, Richard Fine, who explained to us many years ago how to approach this, was put into solitary confinement in the County Jail at 70 years old. Mr. Fine used to be a Federal Prosecutor, world educated, former counsel general of Norway when we met him. After 18 months of Leslie Dutton at fulldisclosure.net exposed this and her organization paid for all the collect calls from the jail and Richard did his defense from his head as they would not let him have anything he was released. In the release papers, and they are all on fulldisclosure.net, the judge states “I put him in jail to scare every attorney in California away from this case.” The next thing the judge does is retire. Didn’t stop Richard Fine. My Hero. In fact, Richard Fine found that for three years no one in L.A. County won in Superior Court against L.A. County. Does that pass the smell test and the problems with illegally fired teachers goes through this mess. Just want to let you all know that this is what is really happening underneath it all. Go to fulldisclosure to see this and Belmont. You will see me with the bullhorn outside as they go into the $1.3 billion school and in other videos as I led the group which got it shut down until “Cowboy” Roy Romer came to help take the school construction bond money. We really hope that we do actually have a new board. We do not know. We will with the decision on the I-Pads and on closing all the special education centers for the moderate to highly disabled. This is a tragedy.
Diane and all others help us stop LAUSD from exposing these children to the ruination of their lives. They have already tried with their highest functioning students with only physical disabilities to “Mainstream them” and within one week they were back because of the treatment. I was just out there videoing a pshchologist on this. We are putting together a video to take to the board which will rip your heart out at what they are thinking of.
LikeLike
It is so depressing to read what is going on. The abuse of children… of parents… and yes of teachers. But then, it is Sunday evening and I always used to be cheery on Sunday evenings looking forward to seeing the students on Monday. Now… I am realizing the date at which I have to hand over a bunch of nonsensical data on which I will be evaluated and that date is approaching. Nothing to do with my teaching despite what the “experts” say and is an all-encompassing colossal waste of my time redirecting my lesson planning to nothing but data collection. It is Sunday and I am not cheery. When will the “Bill Gates” types be run out of “education” town so I can do my job – the one that I love???? When? And when will administrators return to being seasoned teachers with classroom experience which actually helps them be good leaders? Just thinking…
LikeLike
Can someone tell me the difference between charters and magnets? Don’t they both cherry pick their students and have low ELL-sped populations?
LikeLike
Bobby,
One is run by a private corporation, the other is part of the public school system, subject to the same laws and regulations.
LikeLike
How is it that these schools which are replacing PUBLIC SCHOOLS are allowed to to do these things? Charters want to replace public schools then they should have to comply with ALL the requirements of PUBLIC SCHOOLS. How do those who push this justify leaving so many behind?
LikeLike
Dianne,
Thanks for your reply. I have a hard time supporting any school that cherry picks their students. How is this different from rich suburban schools not educating poor children? I get that charter schools are not the answer but it is not right that there is such inequity in schools, regardless of what we call them. Here is a question I ask myself and I would like for you to answer. Would you or I or your predominately white middle class readers send their children to a school in the South Bronx or Harlem, assuming we agree that educating the whole child is paramount? Thanks again for your courage to have these discussion.
LikeLike
Magnets that are in urban areas educate poor children and they are not for profit. I honestly question the need for magnets.
LikeLike
This is a classic charter story. This stuff is happening all over the place. They are cash cows to CEOs and their friends and familymembers. I keep waiting for politicians too have the guts to put an end to this sham. I hope she wins and the charter is shut down.
LikeLike
This is a MAJOR CRUELTY and CRIME. How can people do this to students and their families? Oh….$$$$$. How sad that this country has been reduced to PROFITS at ALL cost. This mindset is totally SICK.
LikeLike