Amy Prime teaches second grade in Iowa. She writes strong opinion pieces and in this one, she lambastes the Des Moines Register (which publishes her articles) for its most recent editorial blasting the schools. In this case,the newspaper complained that Iowa schools did not have test scores as high as Maryland.
Have Iowa’s test scores “stagnated”? Whence came the belief that they must go up every year, like stock prices?
She writes:
“Even if our scores have “stagnated,” as the Register article asserts, then Iowa teachers should be praised for maintaining such high scores with that added challenge. I’d like to see a feature congratulating teachers for not allowing our kids to slip when we have been forced to deal with larger class sizes, decreased funding, more English-as-a-second-language students, less planning and prep time, the slashing of our music and arts programs, the demoralization of our profession in the media, increased interference from politicians and businessmen, and more.”
Amy challenges the editorial writers to talk to teachers, not to Stanford researchers or people from the governor’s office.

Teacher bashing, the latest sport in America.
LikeLike
Teacher bashing and only a few months after they gave their lives at Sandy Hook and two weeks after lay on top of their children during the tornadoes in Oklahoma. It is time for some respect.
LikeLike
Hi, Diane. I follow your blog closely and it is a big factor in my deliberation on to be a teacher or not.
I am writing you to inform you of a casual conversation I had with a recent graduate of Vanderbilt’s MBA program. After inquiring, he told me that he graduated from Vanderbilt’s “business education” school, and that he is using what he learned there to open up private aids to school districts for profit. He is also a TFA participant.
Given that Vanderbilt is home to the prestige Peabody education department, I find it horribly ironic that their MBA arm is promoting for-profit education reform. I just thought you should be aware.
LikeLike
Vanderbilt is to education what Dick Chaney is to world peace. they go where the money is… And RTTT was an exercise in bribery.
LikeLike
It saddens me that so many people hvae such low opinions of education. It seems that people just want to control things and have it their way. After all, every person thinks their own children are the top of the group, and if, for whatever reason, they’re not, well it must be the fault of the teacher or school system. It is sickening. People who do view teaching as a calling feel the most hurt from this kind of cruelty. But, it isn’t going to change. It makes the bashers feel too good and it makes them feel justified when things don’t “improve” even with the ridiculous cuts that are made, as those in Iowa. Sad.
LikeLike
Good for you, Amy. Teachers need to push back at every opportunity. Otherwise the know-nothings continue to think they actually have something to say about children and education. No need to be overly polite either. Good manners are wasted on these people.
LikeLike
Quote from the article and then a question as I am confused!!
I’d like to see a feature congratulating teachers for not allowing our kids to slip when we have been forced to deal with larger class sizes,
decreased funding,
more English-as-a-second-language students,
less planning and prep time, the slashing of our music and arts programs,
the demoralization of our profession in the media,
increased interference from politicians and businessmen, and more.”
The NC teachers have had this scenario forever and a day.
They test everyone and always have
Someone told me that5 Iowa only tested a certain group but now you are testing all ..Is that correct?
LikeLike
Glad Amy spoke up… And to some extent, I give the Register credit for publishing her op-ed. For the most part, however, the Register has pumped our Republican governor’s attempt to parrot the usual ALEC nightmare.
LikeLike
Totally bought out paper. I agree though, at least they published the op-ed.
LikeLike
In the late 90s I worked in an upstate NY district where the local newspaper accurately reported in their headline that our test scores “stagnated”… what the headline didn’t say was that they “stagnated” at 97%… those “minimum competency” tests disappeared during NCLB because they presumably weren’t showing that the schools were failing… to quote David Byrne: “same as it ever was”
LikeLike
I’m thinking about changing the name of our local public school from “Lincoln” to “The S.T.E.M. Academy of Excellence”. I’m happy with the school, but we need better branding in this market-driven, celebrity-led environment.
That way, we’ll get some state and federal funding and more positive press.
LikeLike
Great idea, Chiara!!
LikeLike
I remember a professor I had in Educational Psychology (one of my first courses in my teacher training) saying “Teaching is a poor man’s profession.” I didn’t like hearing that, but I got over it.
I imagine a lot of people bash teachers because they don’t want to empathize with anything but affluence. That’s why people vote for leadership that actually hurts them if they, the voters, are not wealthy–but they cast that vote so they can align (in their own minds) with wealth.
I think people want to bash teachers so as to make it clear that they are not teachers and therefore that they are not poor people. They have “teacherphobia,” or “poorfolksphobia.”
Maybe even Wendy Kopp and Michele Rhee, who ended up being teachers but wanted to continue to rub elbows with the wealthy and feel wealthy (and become wealthy) did not want to align with the perceived poor.
It’s like not sitting next to someone in middle school if you don’t want people to think you are like them.
It’s immature.
It’s silly.
There’s got to be a catchy name for this trend. “Common-o-phobia.” “Humana-phobia.” “Humanfrailtyphobia.” ??
LikeLike