A reader in Tennessee comments on the steady advance of privatization in that state, starting with Memphis, then moving to other urban areas. And when the Legislature passes a voucher bill, the stage will be set to decimate public education and leave it as a remnant of what was once known as the portal to opportunity in America. Thanks to Governor Haslam, his compatriots in the Legislature, and Kevin Huffman, one of TFA’s finest products. Doing it “for the kids,” no doubt. Shameful. Shameful.
The reader writes:
“Memphis and actually the entire state of Tennessee is “all in” as it pertains to turning over our schools to private interests for profit. Memphis schools are being systematically dismantled. They are now run by a lawyer. Everyone with any sense in central administration has already abandoned ship. Non-profits and charter groups are basically being asked “which schools do you want”. Our bargained contract is being trampled in the process. Gates Foundation partner organizations are asking principals “who do you want to get rid of? We will help you.” Principals are being given the green light to surplus (lay off) anyone they want, regardless of their performance.
“Nashville, Knoxville and Chattanooga are next. They started with Memphis because that was the district with the highest poverty. They bet on the fact that the state and citizens of Memphis would basically give the schools to whoever was willing to take them. In steps the Gates Foundation and with that single agreement the demise of public education in our community was sealed. That bet will pay off to the tune of 1.4 billion education dollars per year in our county alone.
“Within 5 years TEA and all the locals will be relegated to cursory “remember whens” as the major population centers of the state no longer are in the business of educating their own children. Charters, vouchers and non-profits will have no union affiliates. This will bankrupt the state level organization and open the floodgates for private equity and hedge funds to capitalize off of public tax dollars. All the while those making these decisions have their children in elite private schools that would never take on the ridiculous data-obsessed practices brought to us from Bill and Melinda Gates. No, Mr. Gates, data does not hold the answers to the world’s problems.
“I was termed an “Irreplaceable” teacher based on my personal teaching performance last year. What a joke! We are all replaceable. An iPad or virtual classroom should do the trick. I hoped to spend my life’s work teaching children. Instead, halfway through a career, I am marketing myself to other industries and embarking on a total career change. There is no room for career educators in this process. Especially ones who can not compromise their professional ethics to jump through the hoops of fire required. I hope the career path I choose for the future pays well. I am going to need the extra money to pay for private schools. I would not wish this chaos on anyone’s children. I will not accept it for mine.”
It is a sad day.

Should we have a map of the US showing the destruction of public education and the order it is happening from state to state?
LikeLike
Get me the data and my students will create the map that shows it.
LikeLike
(They’re doing data visualizations now.)
LikeLike
On a Road that leads to NOWHERE!
LikeLike
These issues are analogous to what is going on in medicine. I think this is a systemic problem that is rampant in our systems. Educators and medical providers and parents sharing a vision for children, whose health and education are pivotal to their future success.
LikeLike
We should have a revolution.
LikeLike
Starting with? A new political organization? The Teachers Party? The Public Schools Party? The Public Employees Party?
LikeLike
A labor party like exists in almost every other country in the world. (Except we should learn from their experience and have a labor party which has no connection to the !%.)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Labour_Parties
LikeLike
As someone on the ground here in TN I’d like to say they’re wrong. Unfortunately I think they’re closer to the truth then most would like to admit. Fortunately there are a few trying to fight the good fight. I urge you to check out Standing Together for Strong Community Schools (ST4SCS). A grassroots parent advocacy group doing what they can.
LikeLike
In typical bipartisan fashion, Arne Duncan is coming to the University of TN Knoxville on Apr 3 to perform his dog & pony show with Kevin Huffman to tout the “success” of TN’s Race to the Top. Edu-reform/privatization is bipartisanship DC insiders claim is critical for government to work. For whom does this education bipartisanship work? We know who- the Duncans and Huffmans are simply the tools of Gates & Murdoch and the financial industry.
http://www.utk.edu/events/index.php?com=detail&eID=53040
LikeLike
And of the Broad Foundation:
“Who is Eli Broad and why does he want to destroy public education?” (Details Duncan’s connection with the Broad Foundation.)
http://www.defendpubliceducation.net
LikeLike
YOU HIT THE NAIL ON THE HEAD!
The Race to the Top is a Dog and Pony $$$$ Show.
Nothing Else….Let us see who can fire the most TESTERS!!
Duncan is full of gar-bage..
He has not a clue..
He needs to be on the first vehicle on the road that goes nowhere.
LikeLike
Soon all charter school teachers will form a union and fight for rights, pay, conditions, etc. Companies will close and govt. will take over education.
LikeLike
Think about this. Huffman is Rhee’s former husband. Huffman has custody of their children. Rhee gave up custody of her children. What kind of woman does this? There are only a few general reasons. Wants to party hearty, needs more drugs and drugs are more important than their children, cannot afford them and “MY CAREER IS MOST IMPORTANT.” Which one do you think it is? Not a hard answer.
Now does what is going on in Tennessee make sense. Two pees in a pod. No mistake in spelling.
LikeLike
When I hear the “R” name, I get a knot in my stomach.
The “R: is so clueless…
Same as a snail trying to hit a 3 pointer.
LikeLike
Rhee has a home in Nashville and allegedly lives there part time and in CA part time with husband Kevin Johnson. I don’t know about the custody arrangement. Their daughters attend Harpeth Hall, a private all girls school in the heart of Belle Meade that has everything Huffman & Rhee deny public school children.
LikeLike
No offense but I don’t think Rhee’s personal life is at issue or will knowledge of it resolve these issues. But such discussions distract from the real problems.
LikeLike
UNIONIZE the charters!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LikeLike
“They are now run by a lawyer”??? SCARY
LikeLike
Yes, a lawyer is the acting interim Superintendent, Joe. His name is Dorsey Hopson. Before coming to Memphis, he was general counsel for the Atlanta Public School system (during the same time as the cheating scandal).
http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/02/justice/georgia-cheating-scandal/index.html
LikeLike