I have received a copy of this story from about 15 different people, all of whom live in Louisiana. The story tells about emails showing that John White, the commissioner of education in Louisiana, hatched a strategy to mislead the media and divert attention from the botched voucher program. After a local newspaper revealed that some of the schools accepting vouchers were little denominational schools that have neither facilities nor teachers, the commissioner had to find a way to change the story from his incompetence to something else.
I guess people send me the story thinking that I will be shocked by the idea of manipulating the media. But living in New York City, I can’t be shocked because we have a Department of Education that has done this sort of thing for the past ten years. They know how to play the press. They put out a blizzard of press releases boasting of their progress, their new programs, their slogans, their latest gimmick. If something goes wrong, they put out another blizzard of self-congratulatory releases. They “muddy the narrative,” as John White put it in one of his emails that were released. They change the conversation. The press falls for it.
This is old news to those of us who live in New York City. John White learned his tricks from the best.
UPDATE:
The Louisiana press is onto the game, thanks to the released emails. The Shreveport Times writes:
Now, we’re looking at legislators who were duped, an education superintendent who’s making it up as he goes along, and a governor who’s traveling the country nonstop running for vice president.
In all of this, we’re wondering — who is really concerned about our children?

Bloomberg is sending his minions all over the country and he is advising mayors on how to destroy teachers. Their concerns are their own reputations and egos, not children, teaching and learning. One would think their disingenuous and destructive ways would eventually catch up with them. Apparently money and power controls the message, which is why I am thankful for Diane and this blog. Please don’t leave us!
LikeLike
Bloomberg acts like a Teapartier on one hand with his sending money and minions (I think the original term was carpetbaggers) down South and a socialist on the other with his demands that Americans drink smaller sodas and lose weight. Neither is any of his business. He has a pretty messed up city of his own to work on. And what is he doing running the schools anyway? I’ll bet he doesn’t have a teaching certificate.
Bloomberg really needs to butt out of southern politics. A mad teacher is a mad teacher whereever she lives and you really don’t want to encounter a mad teacher with a computer nowadays because we are smart and high verbal and our younger ones, especially, have great technology skills while the mature ones have guts. If we unite we can stand against any politician because we gave them the education they are now using to do bad.
LikeLike
Can I just add one thing…I think I am a mature one and I am working on my technology skills. I also think Diane is doing pretty well for a smart lady in her 70’s with this blog.
Another common denominator with the Bloomberg minions is it seems many of them are former TFA’ers (The Rheeject, White – Louisiana, Sternberg – NYC). They taught for 2-3 years and then became experts at education, all subjects, all grades, all abilities/disabilities, everything. TFA likes to boast that their members move on to “leadership” positions.
So isn’t the underlying message that if one stays in teaching, perfecting the craft and dedicating your life to children and learning, therefore, that is not as noble and courageous as slumming for a few years and then moving on to be a “leader”.
The only qualities the above TFA dropouts have in common is the ability to demean teachers, lie to the public, juke the stats, manipulate
parents/students and promote themselves. Some are also good at raising money….the Bernie Madoffs of school reform.
Why is TFA so proud?
LikeLike
Yes, & yes, twinkie1cat! Just look at the NEA resolution to support the Chicago Teachers’ Union! Yes, WE can!!!
LikeLike
Linda your are absolutely correct on all accounts!
LikeLike
I agree, most educators who have been around for awhile at past being shocked. It is often I think a way to validate what the person who sent it perceives, so the blog is a source of hope and support for many of us. I still get a feeling of overwhelming frustration and anger at the fact so many God-fearing, Family -Focused, Traditional -values , so called Patriotic Conservative (with a capitol C) politicians and elected officials are willing to lie, cheat, steal, manipulate, swindle and misinform to get what they want, money and power. The teachers and parents in Jefferson Parish, New Orleans and so many others are in an all out war, Pearson has control of our educational media and test scores and the morale of the teachers going into a new school year is lower than our rainfall right now, and that is pretty bad. We can’t talk about it as a team or a school since that is “complaining”. The out-pouring of community concern? Many with great scoring schools think none of this applies to them and vouchers isn’t an issue and quite a few believe teachers are lazy and doing a terrible job anyway so we get what we deserve! Schools with fair scores are trying to find some normalcy to cling to for August when our students arrive, knowing other schools have it so much worse. Those at schools with great scores almost suffer from survivor guilt and keep to themselves.
Our kids arrive in our classrooms in a month, we got our new value added scores at the end of the year which revived the feelings of anger and confusion since no one can tell us what they really mean. Those who were informed their teaching actually had a negative impact on their students want know how to improve or what to change but no one knows. Who are the Highly Effective teachers? Many teachers want to see what one looks like even though we know the system is bogus since they are the new standard for teaching here in Louisiana apparently. Of course next year they could be rated ineffective. We also know that if we find out who they are, we will probably be more depressed.
No one really talks about it as a profession, it is all done in whispers since everyone fears getting in trouble. Any sort of discussion about concerns or fears or political issues is seen as complaining or being negative. The preferred attitude is one of Polly Anna- “Well, even though we may all lose our jobs, are looked upon like lazy and incompetent losers by our community and government that’s okay! We’re gonna have a great year and work together to make this the best year ever!” If someone points our the Emperor has no clothes they become on of the outcast and shunned, doomed to be ignored in staff meetings since they only offer honest perspectives and realistic solutions. These aren’t “Happy, Positive” contributions!
There is great belief in prayer and that God rewards the righteous. For years if a teacher gets in trouble for telling the truth or trying to offer realistic ideas or perspectives and doesn’t use God or the Bible as the main source of reference or is not one of the ones with all the Biblical quotes on posters, crosses, or WWJD stuff in their room they are attacked. Everyone goes to church together or at least is vocal that they go to church, is related to everyone else or went to school together and they all come back and work WITH teachers who taught them. How can change occur is everyone’s relationships are so convoluted and entangled? Disagree at school and you are going to hear about it at home. Of course, school staff who get into legal trouble get prayed for if they are saved and then once God forgives them, everyone else does. We are still fighting for science and have issues with desegregation going back to the 70’s!
Jindal, White and the state political actors and BESE all either use this mess to get their way or play on the knowledge that little opposition is voiced and those who are outsiders or different will be silenced and shunned or fired. Like the Borg on Star Trek say, ” Resistance is Futile “….I hope not! Just forwarding posts and articles and links from here is like being in a secret society. The information is so valuable but posting here makes you vulnerable to a witch hunt.
LikeLike
What they will probably mean is the same old same old. Teachers that the principal likes and who kiss administrative butts will get good evaluations and the ones he doesn’t like won’t. Only now they will have to fake more documentation. Not hard especially given the example of the far reaching Atlanta cheating scandal. By the way, that one was going on for a long time before it was discovered—-early 90s at least. Administrators, principals, lead teachers, department chairs,and coordinators. See what happens when you base evaluations on test scores?
LikeLike
Bingo! Twinkie1cat,
That is exactly what will happen. Suck ups, sychophants, brown-nosers are all set….just keep praising the powers and your evaluations will be just fine.
Also, how are they evaluating teachers whose subject area is not tested? Are we only going to persecute math, reading and writing teachers?
Since the CCSS says all are responsible for literacy, then aren’t all responsible for the scores? This will only pit teachers against each other and build resentment.
As stated above by confused (god bless you…that is an extremely unhealthy work environment) it will become, or it probably already is,
a survival of the fittest atmosphere. Enter quietly, stay in your room, nod along at all meetings, back to your room, leave out the back door, keep your mouth shut, don’t make any waves……repeat the next day.
LikeLike
Linda,unhealthy work environment is an understatement. In Atlanta if you were not black, local, a member of AKA, Delta or the Q-dogs (who saved a principal with sexual harrassment history from a rape indictment) and went to an Atlanta University Center school, and preferably to Atlanta Public Schools yourself, and /or went to the right church you had a huge strike against you from inception. A white APE who got systemwide Teacher of they Year also got a lot of harrassment. She was real good and her mama was an APE with the system also.
In Ascension Parish Louisiana, being a Katrina survivor was a strike against you in 2006-07. In East Baton Rouge Parish being older or perceived as disabled was one, as well as being white. They also tried to sabotage me by requiring an immediate IEP meeting—like 3 days notice (you are supposed to have 15) with a difficult parent who had gotten in a fight with the previous teacher and had refused to cooperate with the program. I just invited the father in and handled it in my usual professional and parent friendly fashion. (I already had the daddy on my side and was working on the mama. Special ed parents can be very sensitive and sometimes a bit mental.) The lead would not give me a computer code (Thank God for the autistic teacher who lent me hers.) so I could write the IEP! The administration was pissed!
In Paulding County Georgia at one high school the principal only hired female teachers who looked like they could still be in high school. I was transferred in. He was not happy with a fat 55 year old even though the skinny redhead was already burned out after one year in the classroom. Some of the buttlickers and apple polishers were horrible, abusive, incompetent teachers. But if they had the ear of the principal they could do no wrong.
Then there was the semi-illiterate, intensely racist, first cousin of an associate superintendent. I got her IEPS so I knew she couldn’t read. (This was when they were written by hand on NCR paper.) She was absolutely unfirable even when she got caught hitting a student by the Vision teacher. She took that out on me too, because I was white and he was black, a very cute Vietnam veteran, although also gay. (She didn’t know that.) She finally got pulled from SID/PID. Still did not get fired, however.
I think this is why so many teachers quit after 2-5 years, poor work atmosphere and lack of support. Mentoring programs are crucial. I think I made it for a long time because I was older, tough, and especially because nobody wanted my kids but me. They purposely gave me the only all Profoundly Intellectually Disabled class in the system and that was fine for me. I loved it and I loved them.
That is one thing that really concerns me about the charters. How are these young teachers going to get mentoring and professional development hours required for re-certification? Have they even thought about that?
LikeLike
Twinkie..I should be crying but I am laughing so hard. I will have to print this out and save it for a really bad day. I think we are the same age group and weight class. Not sure if you are up on northeast news or NYC, but Bloomberg wants to ban large sized sodas to cut down on obesity and he is destroying teachers and their union. He must really have it out for chubby teachers. We could parade around city hall with sodas and books. I have dual certification, reg. Ed and sped, so I could identify with your stories. They will always need you if you don’t lose your mind first. We could write a book…..Teacher
Confidential….the trials and tribulations of teaching in a test crazed nation.
LikeLike
I always love it when teachers say they don’t want to strike because then people would demonize them.
LikeLike
I would not have wanted to strike because my kids would be with a sub who would not know how to handle them and might hurt them. Southerners tend not to strike, but in Atlanta they could call up a flash mob complete with media within 24 hours even before cell phones and social media! Remember this was the home of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.! I did not trust everyone with my babies. Our special ed. bus drivers did a 3 day sick-out however, which forced the Atlanta system to buy buses and quit contracting real fast. The special ed drivers were system employees making up to $13 per hour and benefits while the regular education drivers were contracted and making $8, part time and no benefits. And they had to deal with packs of rowdy children with no monitor. Whole fleet of busses down at the barn in a couple of months! A lot of new employees too.
LikeLike
twinkie1cat, you sound like my kind of person! I am a retired special ed. teacher who also fought back when the occasion called for it. In retirement, I continue to be deeply involved in special ed. advocacy. &–I can tell you the great power of a union local–when our ignorant sp.ed. director tried to pull the “total inclusion” crap on our district in the late ’80’s, the union president & I got together & filed a grievance
on the premise that it was a contract violation, as per a change in teacher job description. We put together a 200 page document (w/the cooperation of district teachers) citing as to how children were not getting their needs met. The grievance went all the way to the school board, & the students won! (Because of union involvement–never would’ve happened, otherwise–fear of retribution
by teachers w/o union support.) Again, yes WE can!!!
LikeLike
Strikes are illegal in Florida.
LikeLike
Strikes used to be illegal all over the world–still are in many places–but that doesn’t necessarily stop them. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strike_action
LikeLike
If strikes are outlawed then
only outlaws will have rights.
LikeLike
Yeah,I guess yall’s media water stays brown and swishy up north. But it was pretty remarkable here, especially considering the story originally came from a small paper, the Monroe News/Star in a very small city in a part of Louisiana near the Arkansas border, an area that is notoriously conservative and so supportive of Bobby Jindal that the legislature redrew voting district lines to dilute the vote of more moderate south Louisiana. It was some nice, solid investigative reporting.
LikeLike
Was there any fallout for White or will Jindal just cover for him?
LikeLike
No there has not been any fallout because White is a handpicked lackey doing Jindal’s bidding. If things get worse it won’t be Jindal who goes down, however, until, of course the Recall works. But White might eventually get fired and then replaced with someone else just as bad. Jindal is not showing any signs of having learned his lesson as yet. However, the Louisiana GOP is trying to intimidate the Recall organizers, a great sign that they are worried.
LikeLike
So Diane, do you have any advice for preventing the bad guys from muddying the narrative since you have experience in that area?
LikeLike
Diane,
Please read this lame response by Eva Moskowitz – “We cherish public education”…is she for real?
To this Ny Times article:
An Upstairs-Downstairs Divide at a Public School Building in East Harlem
Please readers check out all the comments.
Oh Diane….please, please, pretty please, make this into a new post.
LikeLike
Linda, et. al.–send all your info. to Parents Across America. It’s a VERY powerful organization, w/new affiliates springing up daily. In fact, everyone join, &/or start your own chapter.
LikeLike
Great minds! I did last week and I just got an email about an upcoming meeting this summer. I think our state is recently been added. Thank!
LikeLike
Linda and Twinki1Cat,
With you two responding on here and Diane starting us all off I now find I am rushing home to see what information -the real kind- is here and words of advice and empathy. The links are amazing and I forward everything-to HOME emails, never school..Ha! I have to work on the staying out of trouble, I wear shin guards to staff meetings since my peers kick me when they see me raise my hand.
LikeLike
This isn’t really funny, but I read in a blog that the staff meetings were so bad that one teacher, who was being treated for cancer, scheduled her chemo treatments for those days to get out of the meetings. She looked forward to the treatment as it meant she didn’t have to sit through another mindless meeting with droning administrators.
You can also set up bingo cards secretly. You fill in your district acronyms frequently used during the meeting (SRBI, IEP, CCSS,etc). You mark them as the meeting proceeds and the BS is flying. When you win you call out quietly Bull____ Bingo! The meetings fly by!
LikeLike
So far I’ve seen no fallout. As long as the media covers the story with their perspective and the governor and HIS elected BESE members keep patting him on the back instead of kicking him in the behind, there probably won’t be. But, it’s another day in Louisiana. One never quite knows what will next surface and will survive in the hot sweltering sun.
LikeLike
Great follow up on Jindal’s scheme by Steve Benen at The Maddow Blog:
http://maddowblog.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/07/05/12577970-muddying-up-the-narrative-on-vouchers#comments
LikeLike
This editorial is worth it for the picture alone: http://www.nola.com/opinions/index.ssf/2012/07/louisianas_school_vouchers_nee.html
LikeLike
Too funny…you made me laugh. Even the owl looks confused….WTF?
LikeLike
Diane,
Did you read this? Finally something somewhat critical of Bloomberg.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/gail-robinson/nycs-school-closing-gambi_b_1644758.html
LikeLike