In several GOP-controlled states, the governor and legislators want to eliminate tenure for professors. Tenure protects professors from political interference in their work. Why do Republicans want to do away with it? The reason is obvious: Many Republicans think colleges and universities are dominated by leftists who indoctrinate their students. Apparently, those left wing professors aren’t doing a very good job of converting their students when you consider that Donald Trump is a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania; Ted Cruz went to Princeton College and Harvard Law School; Ron DeSantis went to Yale College and Harvard Law School; and Josh Hawley went to Stanford and Yale Law School. But the attacks on higher education resonate with their base, many of whom have not enjoyed the same educational privileges.
Monica Potts of Fivethirtyeight writes about the issue here:
The GOP’s education culture wars have a new target: college professors.
Texas lawmakers are considering a bill that originally set out to completely eliminate tenure at public colleges and universities. In Ohio, lawmakers are weighing legislation that would mandate tenure reviews for professors. This year, at least three more states — North Dakota, Louisiana and Iowa — considered similar measures, although those proposals stalled.
This new wave of bills targets a long-standing and common standard of job protection for college and university professors, meant to ensure freedom of thought among academics and insulate them from political attacks. The bills that are emerging this year are part of a broader trend among conservative legislatures attacking perceived liberal teachings in high schools and public universities: Last year, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signed a law that would require professors at public universities in the state to undergo a tenure review process every five years, saying that tenure promotes “intellectual orthodoxy.” Other Republican state leaders like Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick have since taken up the mantle, arguing that higher-level education is a place of liberal indoctrination and a source of “societal division.”
But the debate is about more than whether professors get to keep their jobs for life: It’s yet another sign that state-level Republicans are doubling down on appealing to their base. The partisan divide between those who go to college and those who do not is one of the firmest divides in American politics today, and it has reinforced diverging attitudes about the value of higher education itself and the role it plays in American life. Republican voters are increasingly suspicious of colleges and universities, and attacks on tenure are just the latest way the party is stoking those concerns.
Patrick’s attacks, which began last year, have been similarly focused on cultural issues, such as the teaching of critical race theory in college courses by “Marxist UT professors.” (Critical race theory, which became a hot-button topic in 2021, is an academic legal framework that asserts racism is systemic and embedded in many American institutions.) Professors, Patrick argued, have to be accountable to university leaders. University of Texas leaders and faculty pushed back against Patrick’s efforts and defended tenure as necessary for recruiting top teaching talent and retaining students. After that, the law was amended to eliminate tenure for new professors only. The Ohio legislation would regulate hiring and firing public university professors, as well as establish an annual evaluation process. The review process would include student evaluations, which ask about whether professors create an environment “free of political, racial, gender, and religious bias.”
Opponents of measures like the ones proposed in Texas and Ohio — and the law passed in Florida last year — are concerned that eliminating tenure will make educators vulnerable to politically motivated firings. The law in Florida would require the state Board of Governors (a body where 14 of the 17 members are appointed by the governor) to establish a five-year review process for professors. According to the Tampa Bay Times, Florida’s public colleges and universities already have an annual review process. While supporters have said its goal is to eliminate professors who are no longer meeting standards, most critics think — and DeSantis’s comments seem to suggest — that the motivations for removing a professor could be more political. Then-Florida House Speaker Chris Sprowls told the Tampa Bay Times that the bill would prevent “indoctrination.”
Please open the link to finish the article.
Those who want to eliminate tenure haven’t considered that tenure also protects a “less liberal” professor who expresses his/her views on campus . . .
The wealthy in the White patriarchy understand they have one play that enables the continuance of Republican rule.
That play is votes from the right wing religious. Right wing White churches have historical/current links to discrimination based on sex and race. Tapping into that bigotry increases votes for the GOP especially in the central and southern states..
Universities can be central to the plan of the wealthy. When Koch influenced universities with his funding, he recognized the ability that it gave him to select faculty and administrators. Without tenure, the door to hiring by the plutocrats, is wide open. The right wing religious were selected for the courts and they will be selected in university hiring. The strategy explains the connected push to build up religion via conservative colleges like Hillsdale and to shift Catholic colleges further to the right.
Fewer than 1/2 of college grads (46%) say religion is very important in their lives. Nearly 6 in 10 (58%) of those with no more than a high school education say the same.
Forty-six percent of Biden’s votes were from the non-religious.
The hiring of Ilya Shapiro by Georgetown was a significant harbinger.
Even though the right often claims to be on the side of individual rights, they are always on the side of power and wealth. The right wing always favors Goliath over David. As a result, they move to step on the rights of unions, protesters, women, people of color, LGBT individuals and tenure. They tend to support authority and status quo over change.
YUP!
This is where the canary in the coal mine goes the way of the Carolina Parakeet, which is extinct for those not getting the reference. While the national media falls all over itself covering Trump’s lunacy, Hunter Biden’s laptop, and any stupid comment made by MAGA Republicans, state legislatures in Republican states, which are currently the majority of states, are quickly dismantling many highly regard public universities. ALEC and other entities have been chopping away at the concept of public schooling at all levels in these states for decades and will soon realize their ambition should the press continue to allow this behavior in the dark while highlighting a lone voice from Mom’s for Liberty while ignoring the perspective of the majority of parents. The University of North Carolina, long considered a beacon for our dynamic public university system, will soon lose tenured professors should the super majority in the state get its way. Republicans obviously believe one thing, dumb the citizenry down and the party can do anything it wants. We may soon see if Republicans are correct.
Why?
Answer: The rePUG-ni-CONS have nothing else to offer that’s positive.
Remember…started with Reagan, that dolt.
The Pugs offer the religious right the fake morality of being anti-abortion. Almost half of Catholic bishops prefer Fox for news. (Religion News)
This is interesting. We learn about history so hopefully we keep “the good stuff” and throw away the bad. Not sure this “representative democracy” is working to make our lives better. I just don’t get it. I recall this though…”We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.” Maybe these people should study more or even read. As Buffalo Springfield sang, “For what it’s worth” read below.
Opinion From a Former Judge
I am a student of law whose age is 85. My first year of college was 68 years ago. One class I took was political science. A half-page of my textbook essentially outlined a few steps to overturn a democracy:
1) Divide the nation philosophically.
2) Foment racial strife.
3) Cause distrust of police authority.
4)Swarm the nation’s borders indiscriminately and unconstitutionally
5) Engender the military strength to weaken it.
6) Overburden citizens with more unfair taxation.
7) Encourage civil rioting and discourage accountability for a l l crime.
8) Control all balloting.
9) Control all media.
What was printed in 1954 as a possible diabolic nightmare has become an emerging reality. I hope that Americans will unite enough to pen a good finish -God willing.
.
KEITH M. ALBER CALIFORNIA
From Snopes: Alber said he wrote the letter in October 2021 and sent it to The Epoch Times newspaper. (The letter in the photo that circulated on social media was believed to have come from that print publication.) The Epoch Times has a history of promoting far-right political rhetoric and conspiracy theories.
#4 sounds like a right wing talking point.
4)Swarm the nation’s borders indiscriminately and unconstitutionally
Thanks for keeping me on my toes and the insight.
Here’s the information on Alber’s comment from Snopes to clarify. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/opinion-former-judge-1954 As Albers, I see parallels to what is happening currently.
My imperfect understanding of Greek Democracy is that Athenian Democracy ended from similar efforts about 2400 years ago. It took another 2000 years before a Western country would try it again.
Hence, the “Great American Experiment,” eh? Thank you for your insight.
Here’s the link to the original source, with some variation this list of approaches is directly from Soviet Reflexive Control approach to Information Warfare. https://bigthink.com/the-present/yuri-bezmenov/
Exactly! The proverbial frog in the pot. Here’s what comes to mind. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuBe93FMiJc
Alber didn’t foresee the religious right’s role. Conservative Catholics and evangelical protestants provided a check on the power of each other until they bonded together to elect Republicans, around the time of Scalia’s appointment. At that time, the current threat to democracy was born. Almost half of Catholic bishops prefer Fox for news.
Firing professors? Just another step in their playbook
These GOP radicals play the long game – very long game. They think they are contributing to “mankind” and preserving some moral order so decades to make change is a blip in history.
Universities and professors? Step 1b.
It’s all the same – just like they overturned Roe and go against what latest poll shows 74% of Americans support? (Abortion legal with some limitations).
Step 1. Raise and INDOCTINATE KIDS in a bubble.
1a. Raise controversy at the localist of levels that affect everyone – school boards
1b. GOP governors appoint ultra-right puppet University Presidents and State University & Education Boards who fire professors. erase any student who is “different,” and control curriculum
Step 2. Control State legislatures and Governors. A supermajority passes any law they want with a veto override locked in)
2a. Gerrymandering
2b. Voter oppression: picture id., literacy tests…
2c. PASS ANY STATE LAW ON ANYTHING THEY WANT
2d. Legislate impossibility to pass a Constitutional ballot to override a law*
Step 3. Control the lower courts and politicization of judges. When those laws are contested, the lower court judges side with the gop and state boys.
Step 4. Control the Supreme Court. All appeals land there and their Pavlovian response is ‘GOP law? Upheld!)
End of Story. Kids can’t think. State Constitutions are locked up. Precedents set with no appeals, and gerrymandering perpetuates the oppression.
*A Missouri state rep admitted publicly that if they didn’t pass law making a Constitutional Amendment vote to 4/7 (instead of simple majority) they’d never be able to keep their no (none, zero) abortion law because they know a majority supports abortion with limits.
The dangerously, dumb-or dumber, fascist MAGA RINOs march on, goose-stepping, with AR-15s in hand, ready to mow down children WOKE and libtards, whoever gets in their sites first and doesn’t shoot back.
Their slogan: shoot the trash in their schools, their church’s, their temples, at drag shows, attending music concerts, in theaters watching films that include gay characters, out shopping, et al.
If you can’t tell who the liberals are, shoot everyone you can.
Those fascist loving RINOs are being manipulated by Traitor Trump, ALEC, the Federalist Society and no telling how many other lunatic fringe outfits and billionaires out there exercising their 1st Amendment freedom to lie.
Diane, you could probably eliminate some words in the title and have it still be true: Republicans Want to Eliminate College.