Big business has been trying to get rid of unions since the first union was created. Corporations don’t want workers to have collective power. They prefer a workplace where they make all the decisions and don’t have to listen to workers’ voices. The share of unionized workers in the private sector is near an all-time low, but that may change. Recently there have been inklings of a rebirth of unionism. We see it in the growing number of Starbucks and Amazon workers who have voted to unionize. But their numbers remain small. Happily, public opinion is trending in favor of unions.
Someone recently asked me why there was so much hostility to teachers’ unions, and I answered, “Because they are the largest unions.” Teachers’ unions are blamed for whatever critics don’t like in schools, even though they fight for adequate school funding and decent working conditions. Those who have wanted to crush all unions focus their wrath on the NEA and the AFT, while overlooking the police union and the firefighters unions.
My view: if you want to reduce poverty and build a robust middle-class, support unions.
The Economic Policy Institute reports:
It’s been nearly 60 years since approval for unions in the U.S. has been this high.
More than 70% of Americans now approve of labor unions. Those are the findings of a Gallup poll released this morning, and they shouldn’t be surprising.
Why? U.S. workers see unions as critical to fixing our nation’s broken workplace—where most workers have little power or agency at work.
The pandemic revealed much about work in this country. We saw countless examples of workers performing essential jobs—such as health care and food service. They were forced to work without appropriate health and safety gear and certainly without pay commensurate with the critical nature of the work they were doing.
Those conditions, however, pre-dated the pandemic. The pandemic merely exposed these decades old anti-worker dynamics. Clearly, as the new poll and recent data on strikes and union organizing shows, workers today are rejecting these dynamics and awakening to the benefits of unions.
Nonunion workers are forced to take their jobs—accept their employer’s terms as is—or leave them. Unions enable workers to have a voice in those terms and set them through collective bargaining.
We know the powerful impact unions have on workers’ lives, and broader effects on communities and on our democracy.
Here’s a run-down based on the Economic Policy Institute’s extensive research on unions:
- Unionized workers (workers covered by a union contract) earn on average 10.2% more in wages than nonunionized peers (workers in the same industry and occupation with similar education and experience).
- Unions don’t just help union workers—they help all of us. When union density is high, nonunion workers benefit, because unions effectively set broader standards—including higher wages.
- Union workers are more likely to be covered by employer-provided health insurance. More than 9 in 10 workers covered by a union contract (95%) have access to employer-sponsored health benefits, compared with just 69% of nonunion workers.
- Union workers have greater access to paid vacation days. 90% of workers covered by a union contract received paid holidays off compared to 78% of nonunion workers.
- Union workers also have greater access to paid sick days. 9 in 10 workers covered by a union contract (92%) have access to paid sick days, compared with 77% of nonunion workers.
The 17 U.S. states with the highest union densities:
- Have state minimum wages that are on average 19% higher than the national average and 40% higher than those in low-union-density states.
- Have median annual incomes $6,000 higher than the national average.
- Have higher-than-average unemployment insurance recipiency rates (that is, a higher share of those who are unemployed actually receive unemployment insurance).
Equity and Equality
- Black and Hispanic workers get a larger boost from unionization. Black workers represented by a union are paid 13.1% more than their nonunionized peers. Hispanic workers represented by unions are paid 18.8% more than their nonunionized peers.
- Unions help raise women’s pay. Hourly wages for women represented by a union are 4.7% higher on average than for nonunionized women with comparable characteristics.
- Research shows that deunionization accounts for a sizable share of the growth in inequality between typical (median) workers and workers at the high end of the wage distribution in recent decades—on the order of 13–20% for women and 33–37% for men.
Democracy
- Significantly fewer restrictive voting laws have been passed in the 17 highest-union-density states than in the middle 17 states (including D.C.) and the 17 lowest-union-density states.
- Over 70% of low-union-density states passed at least one voter suppression law between 2011 and 2019.
The growing approval of unions is playing out on the ground with more workers seeking to exercise their collective bargaining rights.
Data from the National Labor Relations Board recently analyzed by Bloomberg Law show the exponential increase in election petitions being filed. While the Gallup poll states that most nonunion workers do not respond that they want to join a union, clearly workers are petitioning for union election at elevated rates.
And workers have increasingly felt empowered to fight for what they want.
We were already seeing signs of workers being willing to strike to demand better wages and working conditions. Data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics showed an upsurge in major strike activity in 2018 and 2019, marking a 35-year high.
We are experiencing a labor enlightenment of sorts in this country, one in which workers are fed up with an economy and workplace that does not work for them. With approval for unions at the highest since 1965, there is a growing realization that unions can potentially make both work better for all.
And here’s my view, Diane: if you want to reduce poverty and build a robust middle-class, support unions.
Bob, agreed. Unions built our middle class.
Repeating your wise words, there, Diane.
Our current low union membership was 10.3% in 2021. Our low union membership also reflects the crushing impact from neoliberal economic policies in which workers interests are not a priority. Many red states have enacted “right to work” laws where workers can be fired at will. The teachers unions and the AFL-CIO are still standing, but weaker in “right to work” states. This bar graph from Forbes 2021 has the US at 10.1% union membership. Compared to many other western nations, our union membership is among the lowest. Biden is the first President in modern times that has expressed support for union membership. ttps://www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccarthy/2021/03/30/how-us-trade-union-membership-compares-infographic/?sh=4541999b66ac
Here’s an excellent analysis on labor, the economy and unions by NYU professor, Scott Galloway. https://www.profgalloway.com/labor-day/
It is about damned time. Unions have succumbed to much, in part because they have slacked their unionization efforts, but only in part. The decline was part of a decades long, coordinated attack on unions and worker’s rights and it is about damned time people woke up to the fact that this is a class war and they won.
The UFT ( NYC Teacher Union) negotiated a program whereby teacher aides, mostly women of color received released time to attend college as a pathway to becoming a certified teacher, thousands have benefited, unions are the pathway to the middle class
Of course the corporatists, libertarians and assorted right wing stooges will claim that if you are doing your job, you will have no need of a union. Another bogus gem claims that nowadays unions are no longer needed and you can always have a one on one tete-a-tete with your boss and problem solved. Total nonsense, unions are needed just as much as ever, there is strength in numbers. Unions improve work place conditions and ultimately benefit the students as well as the faculty.
“HAPPY DAYS” — that’s what the latter half of the 1950’s in America are called in the history books because when union membership grew to 25% of the workforce back then, not only did employees in unionized businesses enjoy good pay, plus good inexpensive high-quality health plans and secure fixed-benefit retirement plans, but even employees in non-union businesses enjoyed the same because those businesses had to provide all that in order to attract and retain good employees and in order to try to avoid becoming unionized.
Unions raised the tide of income equality for everyone, just like they had ended child labor and gave Americans weekends off from work. I was able to work my way through college more than 60 years ago with an unskilled union job that paid back then almost as much as today’s workers get in non-union minimum-wage jobs today. Sad.
But then came the decades-long onslaught of corporate-owned media propaganda to spread the fiction that union wages and benefits were driving jobs to foreign nations — when the actual truth was that corporations were shifting jobs to foreign nations in order to maximize their own profits…and American workers have never had a fair chance since then, suffering with stagnant wages. lousy “benefits”, and either no retirement plan or a 401(k) plan that benefits Wall Street and banks more than workers.
When I was a preschool child, my family lived in poverty. My mother worked in a laundry. My dad mucked out stalls at Santa Anita and went into the San Gabriel Mountains after his work day at the race track, to fill 50 pound bags with oak leaves to sell to nurseries. We were barely surviving and never ate out.
Then a close family friend found my dad a union job in construction, and my family left poverty behind and managed to buy their first house.
The most important job a union can do is not only negotiate fair pay and reasonable work hours plus benefits like health care and retirement when we are old, but to fight employer abuse of employees in the workplace.
As a union member and public school teacher for thirty years (1975 – 2005) the benefit of teacher labor unions went way beyond pay, protecting teacher from employer abuse, but also always included fights to reduce class size, and so much more that focused on what students needed to learn.
Reblogged this on What's Gneiss for Education.
Union busting is disgusting.