Remember all the hype about the amazing District of Columbia schools, about how they had improved more than any other urban district thanks to the reforms launched by Michelle Rhee and nurtured by her successor Kaya Henderson? Test scores rising, graduation rates soaring.
The hype seems to be unraveling.
An audit in January reported that fully 1/3 of graduating students had not met minimum standards to graduate.
Now, G.F. Brandenburg says that the scandals continue.
He writes:
“Not in my wildest dreams could I make this stuff up about how completely incompetent and criminal is the leadership of DC Public Schools. But these incidents are all reported in today’s Washington Post.
“1. The flagship DC high school for the performing arts, Duke Ellington, was found to have fraudulently given about 30% of its highly-coveted student slots to kids whose families neither lived in DC nor paid out-of-state tuition. Those fraudulent slots of course meant that hundreds of talented DC students were rejected. (Part of the reason for Ellington leaders getting away with this is the overlapping public and private leadership of the school, allowing them to report much less detail to any central authority. Similar to the situation in charter schools here and elsewhere.)
“2. Somebody has fraudulently erased the records of unexcused first-semester absences for a bunch of students at Roosevelt SHS so they would be eligible to graduate. These students had been absent so much that they had received Fs. However, their records now indicate that they had ZERO absences in the first quarter. Teachers reported the erasures but are afraid of reprisals.”
He goes on to describe the seniors at Roosevelt HS, where only 29% are on track to graduate. He points out that 38% of the class dropped out.
D.C. used to be the reformers’ favorite district, after New Orleans. Not so much now.

When I decided to buy my first car, my father gave me a sage piece of advice. “Never ask a seller about the condition of his car; you’ll just make an honest man lie.”
A bit like Gates asking Walton if Charters are a good deal.
LikeLike
And GATES is NOT an HONEST person, and neither is Zuckerberg or any of those who claim to be reformers of education. THEY ARE DEFORMERS and PLAY FOR PAY and an endless stream no less. These deformers are ensuring that their kids are in charge by damaging others.
The deformers ALREADY LIE from the GET-GO. Plus their WARES are DEFECTIVE.
LikeLike
Duke Ellington High School is currently operated as a joint partnership between D.C. Public Schools, the Kennedy Center, and George Washington University. Relationships among these partners are described here http://www.ellingtonschool.org/about/partners/.
My impression is that the D.C. Public Schools have given away control of policy and accountability to its high profile partners.
This is a talent-oriented pre-professional magnet school, with an audition required for admission. A majority of students who attend the school are African American or Latinix.
I am not surprised that there would be slots offered to favored parents who have talented students, even if not in the district. Even so, 30% of enrollments from out-of-district students, all getting a free ride, does more than just limit possible enrollments for students within the district. It also suggests that arts programs in other high schools may be compromised by the failure of the district to charge tuition for out-of-district students.
The Ellington High School has a non-profit fund. The 990 for the Ellington Fund (2016) shows assets of about $20 million with distributions for school programs, scholarships, and career launches of about $1 million.
In high schools for the arts with selective admissions there is usually some tension between the “artistic director(s)” of the school and the principal, who is in charge of academic performance. This school, like many others devoted to the arts, is dominated by the performing arts. The school, founded in 1974, thrives in part on the achievements and high profile reputations of some of its graduates.
LikeLike
“Latinix.” So, Duane, are we now dropping all feminine and masculine endings to Spanish gender words? (If it gets extended to all words that carry a gender ending or article, Spanish is in real trouble, especially since words spelled exactly the same way can carry opposite gender articles and have totally unrelated meanings.) Do we now have chiquix instead of chico and chica? How about hermanix instead of hermano and hermana? Are we now going to have niñixes instead of niños or hijixes instead of hijos or hijas? Have they taken on el and ella yet? Perhaps we could/should extend it to English. What do we use instead of he/she? Hix, shix, Xe? Hx for his or her? I don’t mean to be flippant, but I don’t think this idea has been well thought out.
LikeLike
Don’t expect the greedy Deformers to admit they are frauds, liars, and crooks (Trump clones). Expect them to ignore the scandal as if it doesn’t exist while they continue to push and repeat the latest invented, cherry-picked lies about how great private sector charter schools are.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What scandal?
LikeLike
That is exactly what “they” would say. “What scandal?” And then they would shift the topic and ignore you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The flagship DC high school for the performing arts, Duke Ellington, was found to have fraudulently given about 30% of its highly-coveted student slots to kids whose families neither lived in DC nor paid out-of-state tuition.”
Sounds like some money exchanged hands, eh?
I’d check the pockets and bank account of the person responsible for admissions.
LikeLike
The real question is whether the district will now go back and collect the monies owed them by those who fraudulently enrolled their children in said district.
Two bits says nothing is ever done in that regard.
LikeLike
The scandals just don’t stop coming in the DC public school system. The last chancellor was forced to resign, after manipulating the lottery system, to get his child into a top school. see
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/dc-politics/dc-public-schools-leader-to-resign-after-skirting-school-assignment-rules/2018/02/20/9b372230-1662-11e8-92c9-376b4fe57ff7_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.b78fb400c578
The congress needs to appoint a commission, and take over the WashDC public school system.
LikeLike
What would Congress do with the DC schools?
LikeLike
The publicly-operated schools in our nation’s capital are a disgrace. (I live in Virginia, just across the Potomac). Scandal after scandal, has rocked the school system. WashDC (public) schools have one of the lowest participation rates in the nation.
The “status quo” is unacceptable. Something has to be done, to turn the school system around. Maybe a congressional commission and/or takeover would be the answer. I don’t know if that is the best answer, but doing nothing, and just letting the corruption fester is not the way to go.
MIchelle Rhee is long gone. There is plenty of blame to go around for every one involved in the mess.
LikeLike
Michelle Rhee was succeeded by her deputy Kaya Henderson. The same reformers have been in charge for 11 years.
LikeLike
Charles, The U.S. Congress created the mess in DC through legislation and GW Bush signed it.
“On May 31, 2007, the bill was presented to the President and President Bush signed H.R. 2080 into law on June 1, 2007. After the standard Congressional review period expired on June 12, 2007, the Mayor’s office had direct control of the Superintendent and the school budget. On June 12, Mayor Fenty appointed Michelle Rhee the new Chancellor, replacing Superintendent Clifford B. Janey.”
A return to a 100-percent democratically elected school board held accountable by an education code and rational legislation is what should happen — not letting Congress run the schools. Congress can’t even run the country … thanks to the Alt-Right’s Party of “NO”.
LikeLike
AMEN, Lloyd. BINGO.
LikeLike
posted at Oped:
https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/More-Scandals-in-D-C-Scho-in-General_News-Education_Education-Funding_Educational-Crisis_For-profit-Education-180513-234.html
With this commen: t Click here https://dianeravitch.net/?s=CHARTER+FRAUD for the links to the posts on Charter School fraud across the 15,880 school systems, posted on her site, by Former Ass’ Sec’y of Education, Dr Diane Ravitch.
Or go to my series here at OPED,
and click onthe series that tell the story of the war on public education.https://www.opednews.com/Series/15-880-Districts-in-50-Sta-by-Susan-Lee-Schwartz-140921-34.html?f=15-880-Districts-in-50-Sta-by-Susan-Lee-Schwartz-140921-34.html
or on legislative shenanigans
http://www.opednews.com/Series/legislature-and-governorsL-by-Susan-Lee-Schwartz-150217-816.html
or the privatization of public edcuation
http://www.opednews.com/Series/PRIVITIZATION-by-Susan-Lee-Schwartz-150925-546.html
LikeLike
That silence you hear is Jay Mathews, winner so-called reforms’ Useful Media Idiot Award, trying to slink away and hide.
LikeLike
When corporations tell you how to think and act, democracy is thrown away. No one who is a researcher is surprised. they wonder why it has taken so long for the truth to be revealed. The goal of capitalism and racism is to ensure that there is always an underclass. Goal achieved by government policies and complicity by the powers to be in cities and states
.
Marketing by mass media who love the feel good stories and the hype. Pretend educators become media darlings, Oprah chooses the winners and losers
By dismissing the concerns of parents, destroying communities providing no alternatives for a solid education allows the powers to be to ensure that children don’t learn. All deliberate and the laugh is once again on the public.
LikeLike