Tom Ultican taught high school math and physics in San Diego after a career in the high-tech industry.
He recently read Katherine Stewart’s outstanding book “The Good News Club: The Christian Right’s Stealth Assault on America’s Children.” He learned about the history of religion and the public schools and how difficult it was to make the public schools secular. Then he realized that his own community had become a target for evangelism.
This post combines his review of Stewart’s book with his observations about what is happening today.
He writes:
“Christian soldiers have been marching off to war and elementary school is the battle ground. Writer Katherine Stewart’s book, The Good News Club, The Christian Right’s Stealth Assault on America’s Children provides the disturbing evidence.
“The Good News Clubs are after school programs, sponsored by evangelical Christians, in elementary schools across America. Stewart begins her narrative by describing how the 2001 arrival of a Good News Club in Seattle’s Loyal Height’s Elementary School splintered the community and created enduring angst.
“Some parents reacted by removing their children from the school. Stewart quotes one dispirited parent as saying:
‘“Before, we were all Loyal Heights parents together,’ sighs Rockne. ‘Now we’re divided into groups and labels: you’re a Christian; you’re the wrong kind of Christian; you’re a Jew; you’re an atheist.’”
“The wrong kind of Christians include all New Age churches, United Methodists, Congregationalists, Catholics and Episcopalians. We Buddhists, Hindus, Jews and Muslims can just forget about it.
“The episode in Seattle conjures images of the nineteenth century religious riots in America.”
He brings the story to the present:
“For the past few decades, I have been seeing more and more athletes at every level pointing skyward when they hit a home-run or score a touchdown. As a kid, I saw BYU players joining in public prayer after games, but now I see public high school kids doing that. From Stewart, I learned that this did not just happen. It is a result of a well-funded campaign led by a group called the Fellowship of Christian Athletes (FCA).
“With funding from people like Truett Cathy, founder of Chick-Fil-A, and non-profits like the Bradley Foundation, FCA has infiltrated sports programs at all levels, marketing their version of “muscular Christianity” to impressionable young men and women. FCA leaders imbed themselves in teams and form sports “huddles.” Thus a peer pressure forms that indicates not precipitating in the prayers and the overt religious gestures means not being a team player. Stewart shared:
“In San Diego, California, a long-serving vice principal who wishes to remain anonymous observes that thirty years ago, prayer played a peripheral role in high school sports. Now, he says, there are FCA huddles at nearly every high school in the region.”
“Conclusion
“Katherine Stewart’s book is written in an enjoyable and fascinating fashion and her personal research is extraordinary. The account of witnessing the infamous Texas school book wars of 2010 or her telling of attending evangelical missionary conferences or her description of the misinformation being disseminated to teenagers in the now federally financed “abstinence-only” sex education programs are illuminating. All Americans concerned about – freedom of religion; Shielding children from unwanted religious indoctrination at school; and protecting public education – should read this book. Reading this book has been an eye-opening experience.
“U.S. Secretary of Education, Betsy DeVos is a devout member of an evangelical church, Mars Hill Bible Church. It is a widely held view within the evangelical movement that public education is a godless secular movement that provides an opening for Satan. That explains why so many evangelicals home school their children. It seems likely that our education secretary has an evangelically based anti-public education agenda. Arguing the relative merits of school policies misses the point.
“It is more likely that religious ideology is the point.”
How well I remember Ronald Reagan, at a press briefing, talking of what were called, in those days, the “freedom fighters” in Afghanistan.
“They’re good, God-fearing people, just like us,” he said.
He was talking, of course, about the Taliban.
I have long thought that the religious right in the US, which hates and fears folks of other nationalities and religions, is just like the folks whom they most hate. Indistinguishable.
Bingo
I thought I recalled that the contras of El Salvador were his freedom fighters. Or was it Nicaragua?
those too. Ronnie’s controllers had freedom fighters working overtime everywhere. And they were smuggling a lot of cocaine into the United States to pay for all that.
Just to correct an error… The Taliban didn’t exist when Reagan supported the mujahideen during our 1980’s proxy war against the Soviets in Afghanistan. The Taliban made their first moves 1994. One of the commanders Reagan praised actually died fighting the Taliban later on.
About 90,000 Afghans, including Mohammed Omar, were trained by Pakistan’s ISI during the 1980s. The renowned British Professor Carole Hillenbrand concluded that the Taliban have arisen from those US-Saudi-Pakistan-supported mujahideen: “The West helped the Taliban to fight the Soviet takeover of Afghanistan” –Wikipedia
And Omar became, of course, the supreme commander and spiritual leader of the Taliban in Afghanistan
Like I said, Reagan was not talking about the Taliban. The Taliban wasn’t formed until 1994. In fact, Abdul Haq, one of the mujahideen commanders hosted and praised by Reagan, later died trying to oust the Taliban.
There’s no “of course” about any of this. The proxy war we fought against the Soviets in Afghanistan in the 1980’s and the aftermath that continues to this day are incredibly complex and difficult to fathom. It’s indisputable, though, that when Reagan praised the mujahideen, he was not talking about the Taliban.
When I was a textbook editor, years ago, we had a health textbook refused for adoption in Texas because it contained the line “Humans and other mammals lactate.” The reference to lactation bothered them, of course, but what really sent them over the top was the suggestion that humans might be mammals. ROFLMAO!
When I was an anthropology major I always wondered what happened to neanderthals . Problem solved we found them.
lol But you are underestimating Neatherthals
I had a parent call my Vice Principal last year to tell her that Mr. Shepherd was doing Devil Worship in his classes.
My students were reading the opening scene of Macbeth.
Another time, I took a class through a guided meditation to clear their minds for a particularly lovely bit of learning. Same thing: Some fundy called the school to tell them that Mr. Shepherd was doing Satanic rituals in his classes.
One cannot make up stuff this insane. But such thinking is common enough below the Mason Dixon line, where every other building is, oddly enough, either a church or a strip club.
or a gun shop
Double Bingo .
Bob,
Thank goodness those students had you as their teacher. Hopefully, you exposed them to another way of being.
You are right about, “One cannot make up stuff this insane.”
Thank you, Yvonne!!!
Bob Shepherd: guided meditation, Macbeth, mammals and lactation…
Not to mention Devil Worship and Satanic Rituals…
“Truth is stranger than fiction, but it is because Fiction is obliged to stick to possibilities; Truth isn’t.”
Good thing you didn’t bring Mark Twain into the classroom!
😎
Twain sauntered into my classroom, in his white suite, almost weekly. I suspect that his cigar smoke is still lingering in that air. His words certainly are.
suit*
Mark Twain undoubtedly meant “known possibilities” because, by definition, if something is not a possibility, it is impossible.
Sherlock Holmes’ take is actually very close to the current scientific view “Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth.”
Cross posted at
https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/American-Style-Taliban-Inv-in-Life_Arts-American-Hypocrisy_American-Legislative-Exchange-Council_American-Legislative-Exchange-Council-Alec_American-Schools-171113-396.html#comment679139
“The Chosen”
Our people were chosen
By God, it is true
And now we’re imposin’
His edicts on you
So join us in preying
Or suffer His wrath
Cuz all we are saying
Is “Ours is the path”
I really like this one.
someDam for poet laureate
Join us in PREYING. Perfect.
Publicly-operated schools are required to provide facilities for all types of after-school and religiously-affiliated organizations. see
https://www.oyez.org/cases/2000/99-2036
I do not see this as a problem, if the clubs are given strict guidance, as to how they can recruit members, conduct their activities, etc.
Q It is a widely held view within the evangelical movement that public education is a godless secular movement that provides an opening for Satan. That explains why so many evangelicals home school their children. It seems likely that our education secretary has an evangelically based anti-public education agenda. END Q
I would be cautious about extrapolating the views of SOME evangelicals, and placing them on any individual, even the SecEd. True, some Christians choose to home-school their children (Approx 1.1 million USA children are home-schooled) Not all home-schoolers are evangelicals. And it is not fair, to blame a persons religious beliefs, on their support for school choice. Even some atheists, would like to have more choices for their children.
Q
…; but no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States END Q
US Constitution Art 6 Sec 3
All you people picking on the religious right. At least the American Taliban gets the parents permission before assaulting a minor child. Wait the Afghan Taliban does the same .
I have lived for years in Afghanistan. I do not get your comparison.
Good News Club is only one of several programs offered by the Child Evangelism Fellowship, Founded In 1937.
The website lists these “Partnerships”
1. Liberty Counsel “Though there are other good Christian law firms that can help us with Good News Club® legal cases, we encourage all chapters to use Liberty Counsel because it is important to have a national strategy in approaching these cases. Liberty Counsel is helping us nationwide and every case has the potential to set a precedent for several states– and even for the nation–. That is best achieved by using only one law firm” A link is provided to Liberty Council, recently defending a “young earth scientist” working for the tax-subsidized “ARK” edutainment venue in Kentucky.
Revival Movement Association “plays a huge role in equipping Child Evangelism Fellowship national missionaries around the world with CEF teaching materials and providing Gospel booklets to children. Revival Movement Association is an Interdenominational Evangelistic Mission that: Publishes and prints Gospel literature in over 95 Languages. This literature is supplied free of charge to many missions, churches, pastors and Christian workers in over 170 countries. Prints five tons of paper each day! Each year they print around 10 Million Gospels of John and many millions of Scripture booklets, Gospel tracts and sets of children’s Bible lessons.“ A link shows that this is a printing operation located in Ireland.
Crossway Child Evangelism Fellowship “uses both King James Version and English Standard Version (ESV) in our literature and ministry material for children. Crossway is the publisher of the ESV Bible. Crossway is a not-for-profit Christian ministry that exists to proclaim the Gospel through publishing in order to, by God’s grace: Assist individual Christians and the church in growing in knowledge and understanding of the Christian life; Bear witness to God’s truth, beauty and holiness, and to the Lordship of Christ in every area of life; Help bring men, women, and children to Christ as their Lord and Savior; Glorify our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ in every way.” A link for Crossway shows it is operates as a printer and international distributer of Bibles and other publications.
Protect My Ministry is “The endorsed background check provider for Child Evangelism Fellowship in the USA. Protect My Ministry offers quality, affordable background checks with superior customer service and ministry specialization.” The link to Protect My Ministry shows that it has “integrated partners” and bundled software deals for church management (online) and security checks (includes profiles on employees, volunteers, and children who are part of the church family). One is a software program for “managing people and their relationships between each other and the church.” It requires a profile on each person with “an infinite number of attributes” “easily grouped and reported.” You can add your own notes, tag these as badges, for family reports on events such as baptism or church attendance. Another version includes contributions, and descriptors for organizing people who have similar church interests.
Calvary University These operations are all linked to (formerly Calvary Bible College) Kansas City, Missouri opened in 1932. Calvary allows the Child Evangelism Fellowship to help offer a Children’s Ministry major. Students who enroll in and graduate from “CEF Children’s Ministries Institute” should be able “to transfer virtually all of their credits from the Institute to Calvary and use them toward meeting the requirements of this major.”
The Jesus Film Project. Child Evangelism Fellowship is working closely with The JESUS Film Project to find effective means of distributing The Story of Jesus for Children world wide. CEF is currently the number one partner in conducting follow up ministry around the world with The Story of Jesus for Children.” A link to The Jesus Film Project is provided.
Regular Baptist Press offers print and online curriculum materials for teaching ”the love and truth of Christ” beginning with children age 2 and 3 through elementary and secondary school, and adulthood. “Child Evangelism Fellowship confidently recommends Regular Baptist Press…to help churches achieve the goal of reaching children with the Gospel.”
There are more links and extensions of the “Good News Club.” This program is active in my home town and largely under the radar of the press. In contrast, our numerous and long-standing Catholic schools are thriving and have well-funded advertising campaigns.
Pakistan’s madrassas seem to make Pakistan ungovernable. Christianist madrassas could do the same here. Roll back vouchers; roll back charters. Go back to plain old public schools for everyone. And have them teach knowledge. Our effort to replace the knowledge curriculum with the skills curriculum has led to empty heads that ministers and other cynical charlatans happily fill with their “truth”.
@Ponderosa. You need to read the Supreme Court case : Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925). The government does not have “dibs” on children’s minds.
But the Pierce decision did not require the public to pay for religious schools
Agreed, and stipulated. The Pierce decision did NOT require the public/government to pay tuition costs at non-public schools.
The decision clearly forbids what Ponderosa is advocating, Q Go back to plain old public schools for everyone END Q
The SCOUTUS stated unanimously and unequivocally that the government cannot compel parents to send their children to public schools. (Applause)
Yes, parents have a right to send their children to religious schools at their own expense.
See https://www.oyez.org/cases/1900-1940/268us510
What you are proposing has been declared unconstitutional by a unanimous Supreme Court.
Ponderosa, this is the wisest statement I have read so far regarding the danger posed by a proliferation of religious schools. Thank you!