The editors of the Catholic magazine Commonweal remind us that this new era is not normal.
We must not forget that.
Every day brings new outrages or misdeeds. Any of the stories flitting across our screens might have been enough to dominate the news for days or weeks during previous presidencies: continuing investigations into Russian interference in the election, shameless lies by the White House staff, unhinged statements to the press, saber-rattling tweets, unvetted cabinet nominees, Trump’s continued refusal to release his tax returns, and surreal exchanges with foreign heads of state. Surely one element of Trump’s strategy is to exhaust his critics and divert their attention, making it difficult for ordinary citizens to focus on what really matters or even keep track of what is actually happening.
Terms like “autocrat” and “authoritarian” are being used by thoughtful observers to describe Trump, and not without reason. His executive order banning entry of people from seven predominantly Muslim countries, among other draconian measures, is only the most prominent example. Reliable information on the inner workings of the Trump White House is hard to come by, but there are credible reports that the legal advice of Homeland Security officials was ignored during the executive order’s drafting, and that congressional staffers who had to sign nondisclosure agreements also were involved. When the new policies were abruptly put into effect, chaos ensued at airports around the country, drawing thousands of protesters who expressed solidarity with those stranded and afraid, and sparking criticism worldwide.
The fate of the order is now being fought out in the courts, but its motivation is clear: bigotry and fear-mongering, not empirical evidence. Rudolph Giuliani, a close Trump ally, admitted the president asked him how he could impose a “Muslim ban” legally. Tough vetting procedures established during the Obama presidency were already working; since 9/11, no one in this country has been killed by a terrorist from any of the seven countries on the order’s list. Trump is now attacking a Republican-appointed judge who suspended the ban, describing him as a “so-called judge” and decrying the ability of the courts to thwart his will. Dangerous terrorists could be pouring into the country, Trump warned, suggesting it would be the judge who has blood on his hands if the worst happened. Just weeks into his presidency, Trump is assaulting the independence of the judiciary and chafing against the separation of powers…..
The task ahead is clear: extreme vigilance and, wherever necessary, resistance. As the Russian-American dissident Masha Gessen has warned, in situations like the one now confronting the United States, “politics as the art of the possible is in fact utterly amoral.” The “corrupting touch” of autocracy will forever stain the reputations of those who are co-opted by Trumpism. Congressional Democrats must do nothing to enable this administration, and everything they can to minimize the damage that it causes. Trump is showing us exactly who he is, and the disturbing vision he has for the country. Don’t get distracted.

Proto-Fascist
This is a form of political behavior marked by obsessive preoccupation with community decline, humiliation, or victimhood and by compensatory cults of unity, energy and purity, in which a mass-based party of committed nationalist militants, working in uneasy but effective collaboration with traditional elites, abandons democratic liberties and pursues with redemptive violence and without ethical or legal restraints goals of internal cleansing and external expansion. [The Anatomy of Fascism]
Click to access Robert%20O.%20Paxton-The%20Anatomy%20of%20Fascism%20%20-Knopf%20(2004).pdf
LikeLike
Read “Submission” by Michel Houllebecq…
LikeLike
Diane: I’m glad to read this from the Catholic Commonweal. Unfortunately, the Catholic Church on the inside is not as unified as it seems. That Skype meeting between Bannon and many Catholic higher-ups in 2014 spoke a different tale; and there’s no reason to think Bannon has changed his mind.
But not-so-oddly, the differences WITHIN the Catholic Church only speak,to the internal differences that occur in any group order, large or small. Those difference are not built on a singular doctrine that everyone understands in exactly the same way, but on different people who understand the doctrine according to their own moment of understanding and who share SOME similar ideas with others, or who THINK their ideas are similar when they are either nuanced differently or are not the same at all.
Bannon and his group seem to think that everyone in every religion is lockstep–thus all Muslims (he thinks) are, in their hearts, out to murder Christians and take over Christianity in the name of Allah. He seems not to be able to imagine the development of an ecumenical spirit.
It’s bad thinking, regardless of one’s religious grounding, and we find it in EVERY religion, as well as we find a great(er?) assortment of ecumenical spirits.
LikeLike
“Unfortunately, the Catholic Church on the inside is not as unified as it seems.”
This is fortunate, not unfortunate. The Church is a living body which moves and breathes. There will always be rigid ideologues like Bannon who wish to pin Catholic support to his peculiar politics– alas (thankfully) finding only a few like-minded clerics in the Vatican (like Burke). Right now, Pope Francis is ascendant, & will be for his lifetime (hopefully decades!)– a visionary who champions the little-guy whether he finds himself in a democracy or a totalitarian dictatorship– and who respects other world religions insofar as they respect the rights of the common man.
LikeLike
bethree5 Of course you are right. It’s unfortunate for Bannon. But if you made a chart and listed all of the major religions (and minor, for that matter), including Christianity, you would find a similar spectrum of views in each one from left to right extremes, and calling the same doctrine their own. My point is that Bannon seems to identify the worst-case aspect of that spectrum, in his case for the Muslims, and broad-brushes them as all looking for WW III. He leaves no room for the development of an ecumenical spirit–and that’s ALWAYS a human possibility.
LikeLike
Yet I agree w/what you say: Bannon seeks [fruitlessly] Vatican support for his dark West vs East vision. He will find that the Catholic Church encompasses much broader vision than his own.
For example– anecdotally– my own Catholic upbringing was on the left-fringe, encouraged by Pope John XXIII: in my family we studied the Dutch Catachumen rather than Boston’s, & had many a spirited discussion at CCD w/our dyed-in-the-wool yet intellectual Irish-Catholic Msgr.
LikeLike
bethree5 Yes–I’m a late-comer to Catholicism. But I almost didn’t enter the Church after my year of preparation because of some of the unbending doctrines. But then I realized that no Church is perfect and if change is going to occur, it can do so from within the Church itself. I do love it’s history.
LikeLike
We must insist on blaming Republicans, they are charge now. They own it. They are forcing through cabinet nominees clearly unqualified and invetted. They should pay the price, not Trump.
LikeLike
Agreed. The Democrats failed and are failing to pin bad polices on Republicans. Everything in Bannon’s ideology re: govt is pure Republicanism. Paul Ryan & MItch MConnell have wanted to privatize Social Security, Medicare, all of education, all social services, roads, bridges, and deregulate all industry & financial system FOR YEARS.
Have the Democrats learned nothing from their failure to defeat this clown & his team of anarchists? The republicans control 23 state houses & all 3 federal branches of government. I heard one of HRC’s campaign directors on TV last week (sorry I can’t recall her name). She said most people in the country wanted politicians to stay the same course as the last 8 years. I was shocked, to say the least. People are angry. They don’t believe they have a future beyond debt & uncertainty. Despite HRC’s meaningless win of the popular vote count, people wanted more dramatic changes than they’ve were promised by Democrats. If Dems have nothing progressive to offer than “more of the same” than they should expect voters to reject them in blue states, as well.
LikeLike
Disruption is one thing, treason is another.
LikeLike
Commonweal?
Umwelt!
LikeLike
Can’t believe this guy isn’t impeached yet.
LikeLike
Okay, hasn’t been.
LikeLike
You made me smile
LikeLike
Prepare the padded room with the iridescent gold foil.
LikeLike
This is sick. Sticking the press, US and Japanese, in a basement with doors and windows covered in black plastic. Is this Russia? Is this China half a century ago? Everyone supporting Trump should go to federal prison. Trump needs to be sedated and monitored in a special facility.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/onpolitics/2017/02/11/black-plastic-covers-windows-blocking-reporters-views-trump-golfing/97787920/
LikeLike
Whoa! Pathetic!
LikeLike
This post makes me proud to be a Catholic! Could it be we’re returning to the invigorating theo-political times of the ’60’s? Justsig ed up for Commonweal for the 1st time in 20 yrs.
LikeLike
This is funny.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2017/02/11/trump-baldwin-dominican-paper-gets-wrong/97799548/
LikeLike
Commonweal editors point out that a key strategy of the Trump Administration is to wear down any resistance from simple fatigue resulting from the constant barrage of diverse actions from the Administration.
Don’t succumb to emotional fatigue — keep this target date constantly in mind: November 6, 2018. That’s only 21 months from now and counting down, and on that date all 435 members of the House of Representatives, plus 33 Senators, and 14 state governors can be voted out of the hands of extremists. It only takes gaining a few seats in the Senate to gain a simple majority that will completely stop all the unfair and insane legislation because any legislation needs the agreement of both Houses of Congress. So keep fighting, keep speaking out — relentlessly! relentlessly! relentlessly! — because in the 2018 Congressional elections there is no Electoral College scheme that can save them from the pure majority vote of We the People. And We are the majority.
So, let your mental mantra throughout each day be:
11/6/18…11/6/18…11/6/18…11/6/18…11/6/18…11/6/18….
Meanwhile: Be relentless. Relentless.
And never! Never! Never give up!
LikeLike
Being POTUS is a sure way of revealing anyone’s mental health issues . . .
DJT, please take that long beautiful vacation! Add a dose of sanity to the rest of your life.
https://www.aol.com/article/news/2017/02/12/report-trump-may-be-getting-frustrated-with-the-challenges-of-being-president/21711773/
LikeLike
Help me here. I want to start a “send Betsy pencil” Campaign. We can send our stubby used pencils to DOE, Rauner, Rahm, Trump, etc. Lets spread the word
LikeLike
And/or start a meme:
“Ah, Betsy. Education. Right?”
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/news/answer-sheet/wp/2017/01/22/what-trump-said-when-he-signed-the-executive-order-on-betsy-devos-his-education-nominee/?client=safari
LikeLike
Appealing headline, but should be more like “White House: Fiscal Train Wreck”
https://www.google.com/amp/www.cnbc.com/amp/2017/02/12/trump-administration-is-complete-insanity–and-the-markets-are-in-a-fantasy-land-stockman.html?client=safari
LikeLike
Give me a break. Trump is the reason the WH is INSANE, not merely rocky.
Everyone else is a fully culpable enabler that deserves prison time for treason.
http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_58a0aac9e4b094a129ec0be9
LikeLike
More Fake news Tweeted by our fake president as he claims the media is fake and dishonest. He is fake and dishonest. And 100% hypocrite.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.rawstory.com/2017/02/trump-rips-fake-news-media-for-not-covering-hundreds-of-fl-protesters-as-crowds-of-supporters/amp/?client=safari
LikeLike
This is big, and dead serious.
https://www.google.com/amp/observer.com/2017/02/donald-trump-administration-mike-flynn-russian-embassy/amp/?client=safari
LikeLike