Ellen Lubic is a professor of public policy and a frequent commenter on this blog. This article appeared in City Watch in Los Angeles.
She writes:
Many of us in this election season have referred to the Trump ‘anshluss’ as a world of ‘smoke and mirrors’, and we were correct. But now we know from the twisted mouth of his hired gun, KellyAnne Conway, that it is really not so much calculated duplicity, but rather it is a presentation of “alternative facts.” She says we must look at the news as “BROADcast, not NARROWcast.” A whole new political vocabulary has emerged from the Trumpists in our new ‘post factual’ world. Veracity is now in the eyes and ears of the beholder.
As a student, and then a professor, of public policy, I learned early on that a fact was considered true when, as a thesis, it was proven by non biased investigation. However, we have changed course in epistemology and linguistics to find that we now live in a world where there is a sliding scale of what registers as fact and what is fiction, and either or both can come out in every sentence of the limited vocabulary spouting from Donald Trump’s mouth.
As I listened carefully, admittedly with tears in my eyes, to the inauguration speech of this deplorable new President of the US, and leader of the Free World, who was standing only feet from four of our past Presidents as he defamed each of them with his rhetoric about how he finally, for the first time, is giving the nation back to the people, I was amazed at his bizarre gall, his ignorance, and his despicable manners to insult Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Carter, by asserting that they were all inept, uncaring, and failing in their duty to America. He vilified them in so many ways that it was mind blowing, and watching their faces, the faces of their wives, and the others on the dais, I came to finally understand what a villainous demagogue this new President is, and how dangerous he is, and what is even worse, how dangerous and uninformed his followers are.
I have read much in these past weeks since he won this questionable election by a fluke of the Electoral College, but without the popular vote, and with the interference of both Russian hacking and Comey’s false Clinton report and the NY Times knowing about it all for weeks before the election but choosing not to report any of it. Much has been written by groups of psychiatrists who go beyond his personality disorders like Narcissism and megalomania, to discuss his potential brain dysfunction and the possibility of dementia which rules his lies and loss of control as with the endless tweets at the smallest and the most inconsequential of slights. Yesterday, sending his lackey, now known as Afghanistan Sean Spicer, in to the first formal White House press announcement only to admonish the media for “fake” reporting on how many people were standing to watch this nonsensical reality show of an inauguration was incomprehensible and will be recorded in the history books for posterity. This man continues to make himself, and America, the laughing stock of the planet.
Facts on the emerging Russian connection now being investigated by the CIA and the FBI, not only with the Putin hacking of the US election process, but with the years of contact and ‘deals’ between Trump and Putin and Manafort, and the Russian Oligarchs who now seem to be bankers to Trump, and all of them also possible black mailers of Trump, and purveyors of films of “golden showers” which is a topic most never heard of before this election, all of this boggles the mind of voters and citizens of the US and is even more terrifying to the other nations of the world which have to deal with his nuclear threats and the angst of being his target if he gets insulted. I suspect his family knows how deranged he is and that is why they have Jared Kushner, who is evidently the smartest among them, posted in the West Wing as his closest advisor. Jared strikes me as playing Iago to his father-in-laws madman, Othello.
Not only do we Americans have to worry about his little fingers on the button of the cataclysmic nuclear coded football, but the world now wonders who he will blow up first.
Democrats are asked by Republicans to foster unity and support him…to give him a chance, yet everything he says brings us back to his lack of intellectual stature, lack of political experience, lack of calm judgment, and his over arching greed, mendacity, and self aggrandizement. It is not rational to support anything or anyone he recommends for his edicts do mirror the manipulating and false populist claims of tyrants from Nero to Hitler. His speeches about giving the decision making “to the people” are almost word for word the speeches of the Third Reich and they are a page out of his favorite bedside book, Mein Kampf. The Drumpf family has long been known known to consort with others of the underworld like Roy Cohn, and their Mafia ties, and most probably the similar Russian mob. Why would anyone think that due to this ‘trumped up’ election, Donald has changed from his lifelong playboy, misogynistic, self serving, highly bigoted persona?
Just look carefully at those he has chosen to run OUR country with him as their leader, their Commander in Chief. Keep wearing the pussy cat hats and speaking up without fear. Keep Rex Tillerson at Exxon Mobil instead of in the role of the US Sect. of State where he will be dropping US sanctions (to insure vast profits for the oil barons) against an aggressive Putin Kremlin which is committing war crimes, and keep the ignorant and spoiled, religious ideologue debutante, Betsy DeVos, out of the Dept. of Education, and keep the well determined bigot, Jeff Sessions, from being America’s AG … and send all the rest of this crew of US oligarchs back to their well padded nests under the rocks from which they crawled into Drumpf’s daylight including HUD, Labor, Health and Human Services et al. What a bunch of over privileged thugs they all are.
What can you do about it? For one thing, join the over 100,000 people that have signed the ‘Impeach Donald Trump Now’ petition and get your voice on record.
(Ellen Lubic is Director of Joining Forces for Education, a public policy educator and journalist and an occasional CityWatch contributor.)

Well said!
LikeLike
Agree. You write for many of us!
LikeLike
yes
LikeLike
Joel, hope you saw Charles Blow’s piece in yesterday’s NYT. He channeled you.
LikeLike
Greg I did, but I thought with out rereading it, there was a push for identity politics in it . I would have to go back and reread it .
My gut tells me the answer has always been economic . That identity politics should only come in when it comes to equal access to the economy .
To quote Jefferson
“It does me no harm for my neighbor to believe in many Gods or no God. It neither robs my pocket nor breaks my leg.”
Apply that to race, Gender, sexual orientation , and all the other side issues .
The real question then becomes who does your government work for . .
But like I said that interpretation was as I quickly read him and Krugman yesterday. I’ll go reread Blow .
LikeLike
As I remembered .
“There has been much hand-wringing and navel gazing since the election about how liberalism was blind to a rising and hidden populism, about how identity politics were liberals’ fatal flaw, about how Democrats needed to attract voters who were willing to ignore Trump’s racial, ethnic and religious bigotry, his misogyny, and his xenophobia.”
No wrong Charles we do not forgive their racism, misogyny ,and xenophobia. But we ignored their economic pain at a tremendous price .
One can attend the women’s march, support their goals for equality , and control of their own bodies . One can fight for racial justice in the workplace, streets and criminal justice system , one can support gay rights to equality in marriage, at the work place or in public;
but those workers in those mid western states (the country ) who have been abandoned by Clinton and Obama by the party as a whole can not be dismissed. This was not a quirk of capitalism. It was an intentional redistribution of wealth to the very top . A 30 year project that has left the bottom 80% in the gutter, losing Unions pensions, healthcare.
It is easy to focus on identity politics it costs the Oligarchy nothing . That is why the Republicans have chosen to make this the battle.
As I said I spent the morning going back and forth with an educated union activist who was fed up with the Democrats and with Labor’s thirty year alliance with them . Using four letter words to describe both the Democrats and the leadership of American Labor . What could I say other than you are jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire. This was not your typical uneducated worker . As he pointed out that Clinton did more damage to organized labor than Reagan could have dreamed of .
But I have stated here those devastated workers were by no means the majority who voted for Trump they were the voters that should have turned this country into a European style Social democracy years ago and would have if the had a party to vote for. Certainly 2008 with the collapse of capitalism as we knew it immanent they voted for just that a Black Man who promised hope and change.
So here we are Greg. I am still praying for the meteor strike.
LikeLike
It is hard, Joel. A friend of mine wrote me recently and commented, “For the first time in my life I feel like I’m living history. I don’t like it.”
LikeLike
Joel, in case you missed it, check out the two videos posted by Mate on https://dianeravitch.net/2017/01/23/can-you-diagram-this-sentence-spoken-by-donald-trump/
Scroll down to the bottom, one from the Netherlands, one epic rant from Britain. It’ll release a little pressure.
LikeLike
Thanks guys…here is another notice from our dictator just now. Please sign the petition too and pass it on to all your lists.
Very scary stuff to put his imprimatur on shutting down media and creating a blackout of the EPA…………….
“President Trump just instituted a media blackout to all employees in the Environmental Protection Agency.
That means scientists are barred from communicating with the public about taxpayer-funded work.
It’s ridiculous, and we must stand against this”.
SIGN YOUR NAME:
Demand President Trump retracts his media blackout on the EPA >>
LikeLike
More shutting down of media…
More agencies are on lockdown – USDA, HHS, and more:
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/trump_issues_media_blackout_at_multiple_federal_agencies_20170124
LikeLike
And real facts from my fave Ca. Congressman who should be the first Asian Prez…
https://lieu.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/congressman-lieu-statement-house-gop-vote-attack-women-s-reproductive
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: January 24, 2016
CONTACT: Jack d’Annibale | jack.dannibale@mail.house.gov | 202-225-3976
CONGRESSMAN LIEU STATEMENT ON HOUSE GOP VOTE TO ATTACK WOMEN’S REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS
WASHINGTON – Today, Congressman Ted W. Lieu (D | Los Angeles County) issued the following statement on the House Republican Majority’s vote on H.R. 7, the No Taxpayer Funding for Abortion and Abortion Insurance Full Disclosure Act of 2017.
“Today, just two days after the 44th anniversary of the Roe v. Wade Supreme Court ruling that protects the rights of women to control their own bodies, House Republicans have once again taken up a vote attacking the constitutionally-protected reproductive rights of women all across the nation.”
“As if this past weekend’s Women’s March on Washington (which was far more attended than President Trump’s*** inauguration) didn’t signal anything to our elected leaders, President Trump took the GOP’s war on women’s rights and health a step further by signing an executive order reinstating the ‘global gag rule’ and blocking foreign aid for international non-governmental organizations that provide basic reproductive health services globally. This decision not only increases abortion rates, it will cause more maternal complications, injuries, and unintended pregnancies and provide less information on HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment programs worldwide.”
“Republicans continue their shameful, radical assault on women’s reproductive health with today’s vote on H.R. 7, a discriminatory bill that among other things would prohibit the use of federal funds to pay for any abortion services. Despite the fact that current law already requires that federal funds not be spent on abortions, this bill would prohibit individuals and small businesses from claiming tax credits for any private insurance plans obtained through the ACA Marketplace that include abortion coverage. Families buying their insurance in the Marketplace would also be ineligible to receive a premium tax credits if they enrolled in a health plan that covers abortion, likely resulting in no abortion coverage policies being offered in the Marketplaces. Furthermore, it undermines the District of Columbia’s home rule, which allows D.C. to use it’s own Medicaid funds to offer abortion services. This is despite the fact that 17 states, including California, are currently allowed to do so.”
“Women should be able to make their own decisions about reproductive health care with dignity and respect, without the interference of politicians or their employers. We should not be in the business of telling women what they can and cannot do with their own bodies. Today’s vote is just another step forward in the Republican party’s plan to Make America Sick Again and take away the comprehensive care women deserve.”
###
***In addition to losing the popular vote, Trump – as of January 20, 2017 – is in violation of the Emolument’s Clause set forth in Article I, Section 9 of the U.S. Constitution due to massive conflicts of interests and his refusal to put his global business holdings in blind trusts. Trump also benefitted from Vladimir Putin ordering a multifaceted and brazen Russian influence and cyber hacking campaign with the goals of undermining faith in the U.S. democratic process, denigrating Secretary Clinton’s electability, and helping Trump’s election chances.
###
Congressman Lieu is a member of the House Foreign Affairs and House Judiciary Committees.
Mr. Lieu is also an Assistant Whip for the Democratic Caucus and a Colonel in the Air Force Reserves.
LIEU.HOUSE.GOV
LikeLike
If Littlefingers Donald Trump and his administration continue down this path with no limits and supported by the GOP, I think a bloody Civil War and/or concentration camps, where anyone who does not comply with the Liar-Groper in Chief, will be labeled a traitor, is inevitable.
LikeLike
Today’s Acronym — PAARTY ❢
President Apprentice Alternate Reality TV Yuckfest ❢
LikeLike
“…and what is even worse, how dangerous and uninformed his followers are.”
LikeLike
To Ellen Lubic:
IMHO, We all need to well plan with a solid step by step strategy.
According to Dr. Ravitch, VP Mike Pence is much more clever and vile than P. Trump. Do we agree with Dr. Ravitch?
To me, we NOT ONLY need to impeach the new President for his secrete business with Russia and China, BUT ALSO how do we have the support from the power in all three: GOP, Senator and House of Congress?
What is the time frame and what is the union of people and conscientious politicians?
We need to have a solid plan before we can huff and puff the impeach plan. May.
LikeLike
May…many highly respected experts in jurisprudence have been working on impeachment for some time. Hope you watched Lawrence O’Donnell interview one of my heroes, Laurence Tribe, last night and last week in the law suit Tribe filed this week based on the ’emolument’s clause.’ If you google reasons to impeach Trump, they include treason. Also research the many outstanding lawyers who have been doing their homework on impeachment proceedings.
LikeLike
Also, May, in doing your own homework, watch some of the youtubes on proceedings to identify Trump’s mental health….many of them are by noted experts in that field of study. If he is proven to be not of sound mind, he can be impeached. Yes, the backup of Pence and Ryan is bad…but they do not seem crazed megalomaniacs, and they do understand government.
LikeLike
http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/Ftrials/impeach/constitution.html
It is a political process . The high crime of lying about a sex affair ?. The Misdemeanor or felony of 1 hotel room rented to a foreign official in the last four days.
LikeLike
Yes, Joel…it was not the cigar that got Bill impeached, but it was lying about it to Congress. Here, under a dictatorial unhinged man, there is so much more evidence of wrong doing than what “is” is..
LikeLike
I made this comment elsewhere in this blog today.
The loss of the search for “truth” is in my mind one if not THE most damning things that can happen to democratic governance.
Fashists througout history have distorted or put forth their own version of facts.
post-truth supplants intellectualism. How can that not be a humongous factor not onlyh to education but to society at large?
Some “news” organizations have made millions by distorting or putting forth their own version of facts or pushing half truths.
LikeLike
Again, Gordon, I agree with you…and here is a statement by my most revered Congressman Ted Lieu who supports John Lewis and TRUTH. I hope May takes notice, since she seems not to know that many outstanding legislators and lawyers and professors have done much studying on issues of impeachment and of other areas where Trump blatantly breaks laws that he does not feel apply to him. Many are standing up to him (and Pence and Ryan and O’Connell) to their own peril.
“CONGRESSMAN LIEU STATEMENT ON HIS DECISION TO NOT ATTEND THE INAUGURATION
January 14, 2017
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Washington – Today, Congressman Ted W. Lieu (D | Los Angeles County) issued the following statement on his decision to not attend Donald Trump’s Inauguration on January 20, 2017.
“I respect Members of Congress who choose to attend the Inauguration of President-elect Donald Trump or choose not to, just as I respect Members of Congress who attended or did not attend the two Inaugurations of President Barack Obama. I view this as a personal decision because no votes are being taken and no policies will be enacted at this ceremony. While I do not dispute that Trump won the Electoral College, I cannot normalize his behavior or the disparaging and un-American statements he has made.”
“Trump–who lost the popular vote–has made a series of racist, sexist and bigoted statements. In addition, he has attacked Gold Star parents, veterans such as John McCain and now civil rights icon John Lewis.”
“Trump has made statements denigrating the patriotic and professional men and women of our intelligence services, many of whom risk their lives in service to our nation. He also continues to believe Vladimir Putin over our intelligence services and is actively misleading the American people when he denies Putin ordered a brazen, multifaceted cyberattack on America to benefit Trump.”
“On January 20, Trump will be in violation of Article 1, Section 9 of the Constitution because of the massive conflicts of interests he has with his global business holdings. That provision of the Constitution was designed to prevent foreign influence over American elected officials. Trump can cure this Constitutional defect by divesting his holdings or putting them into a blind trust, but so far has been unwilling to do so. “
“Can a man such as Trump have a good idea? The answer is yes. And if the next Administration has a good policy, such as withdrawing from the flawed Trans-Pacific Partnership, I will support it. But if Trump has unconstitutional or bad ideas, such as creating a registry based on religion or gutting Social Security and Medicare, I will oppose them.”
“I can only hope that Trump will govern differently than he has campaigned. For me, the personal decision not to attend Inauguration is quite simple: Do I stand with Donald Trump, or do I stand with John Lewis? I am standing with John Lewis.”
###
Issues: Civil Rights and Civil Liberties, Local Issues, National Security and Foreign Policy
BTW..it was just mentioned on MSNBC that the Keystone and the Indian Reservation pipelines are owned by an oil company in which Trump has a financial interest. Since it is a Canadian company, it falls into the emoluments law and Trump can be charged with impeachment for that alone…but then, he owns shares in many hundreds of companies, and many of them are overseas…multiplying the charges Tribe can bring against him. Tillerson probably also owns shares in the oil companies, and he is now our Sect. of State with the power to feather his own Exxon Mobil nest and he will surely eradicate sanctions on Putin’s Russia for endless profit to all of them.
LikeLike
Yet clever as he is, or more likely his handlers are, he is now playing the construction trades against he rest of labor and the progressive coalition . None of those Unions represented manufacturing workers yesterday . He signed an executive order this morning that green lights Keystone and Dakota, this will divide much of labor from environmental groups.
Notice how carefully he words his trade policy. “You will not leave” but if you are gone already who cares. So one can expect to preserve jobs for the robots to come , while expanding overseas. But what did Obama do for all his Harvard polish. He ignored the political realities and delivered the mid west to the republicans dozens of state legislatures at least a half dozen new Right to Work laws. This was not due to the magic of ALEC or the BRT. It was solely the failure of the Democratic party. It was predictable and predicted.
I spent the morning arguing with a Union member on Face book who is through with democrats. In shock with the pro American labor show Trump is putting on. After all the years that labor fought for Democrats to get kicked in the ass time and time again.
I find myself thinking the only chance to stop what is coming, will be a collapsed economy or worse .
LikeLike
Tell your friend there are still some ballsy Dems. And don’t forget my Senator Harris and Congressman Lieu.
This just came in.
Shared from the Studio City, CA Patch | Politics & Government
Trump’s EPA Freeze and Media Blackout Triggers Instant Backlash
“California and Oregon lawmakers are calling the new administration’s ban on new environmental projects and communication “dangerous.”
By Paige Austin (Patch Staff) – January 24, 2017 8:47 pm ET
Trump’s EPA Freeze and Media Blackout Triggers Instant Backlash
LOS ANGELES, CA — In office less than a week, President Donald Trump triggered outcry from California leaders Tuesday by barring any new Environmental Protection Agency contracts or grants. The administration also instituted a media blackout that prohibits the agency’s staff from communicating to reporters or to the public through blog posts and social media.
The EPA, long a target of Republicans who believe it over-regulates industry, is responsible for helping to ensure clean drinking water and cleaning up the nation’s most polluted toxic waste sites, 94 of which are in California. A spokesman for the Trump transition team said the blackout and freeze on new projects would be temporary, according to the Associated Press.
Still, it set off alarms in California, where state leaders have positioned themselves at the vanguard of the opposition to Trump’s environmental policies.
“This administration is launching direct attacks on truth and transparency in our gov’t. Very troubling — and honestly, anti-democratic,” tweeted Sen. Kamala Harris.
“President Trump is putting California communities at risk,” California Lt. Gov Gavin Newsom said.
“In 2016, EPA provided California with $182 million for drinking water and waste water infrastructure,” he said in a written release. “These funds go to small and large communities who need to build or rebuild their aging systems. This money helps prevent a future Flint from happening.”
The agency also enforces cleanup at toxic “Superfund” sites where pollution threatens surrounding communities and drinking water supplies. Neighborhood gas stations that leaked cancer causing chemicals into the ground, major manufacturers that illegally dispose of industrial solvents, and leaky toxic waste storage facilities are just some of the types of Superfund sites that the EPA handles in California.”
Click here to find the Superfund sites near you.
LikeLike
Those of us that have been students of “ed reform” have been living with fake news as a way of life. First, we heard about all the “failing” schools and those out of control “union thug” teachers. Then, we heard that “reform” is the civil rights issue of our times while the media has largely praised all the benefits of choice in education.
Teachers are told to prepare students to be “college and career ready.” Useless standardized testing is sold as “accountability.” “Value Add” is supposed to weed out all the “bad teachers.” Our schools are “failure factories.” We need to “modernize for the next gen learners” equals computer instruction. We could go on and on about all the lies and false assumptions made by privateers.
“Reformers” engage in both lies of commission and omission. Jersey Jazzman has specialized in ferreting out fake research in which charter school data is cherry picked while less flattering data is not reported. Another research method of “reform” is to compare apples to oranges, which may work in a fruit salad, but is useless in reporting data. Today’s “reformers” have created their own parallel universe school leaders called Broadies, and they even have their own fake training schools like Relay. How many “miracles” have turned out to be nothing more than hype and spin?
Teachers are familiar with the fake news of “reform” ever since NCLB. We are well prepared for people like Trump, DeVos and Conway as we have become experts in BS detection. We can smell hyberbole and fabrication a mile away. After all, teachers have been living in a lengthy fake news cycle for some time.
LikeLike
retired teacher: neither overstatement nor understatement; someone needed to explicitly say what you said.
Thank you.
😎
LikeLike
There is a difference between fake News and Media group think provided by special interests and distributed to pursue their agenda .
I think we are prepared for the right wing assault that has relied on ownership of the media and lack of investigative journalism . To twist complex statistical analysis. I do not believe anything prepares us for what we are seeing except perhaps Orwell.
The president (piece of turd ) tweets out a picture of the Inauguration, that shows the Immediate vicinity of the podium packed with perhaps 50,000 people leaving out the Mall, as a counter narrative to the sea of white behind him revealed in the CNN photo . It gets redistributed by rt wing media and a delusional base as truth, “alternative fact.”. That is something we used to laugh about when we witnessed it in other authoritarian nations . The reference to Baghdad Bob works well
LikeLike
With the 24/7 news cycle now requiring filling CNN and MSNBC time slots, too many good journalists have succumbed to “media group think” and instead of in depth research, some have just dittoed in their stories. One more problem with technology.
LikeLike
You are right that alternative facts are not new, though the actual moniker may well be.
Some additional alternative facts that you probably never knew:
Suburban moms are not really concerned about too much testing. They just don’t wish to admit that their child is not as smart as they think he is.
You can fire your way to better schools.
Common Core was actually built in a garage.
No one gives a &%!T what you think.
LikeLike
Alternative facts, alternate realities, alternate universes. Every single day, Trump and his toadies say outrageous things that abuse and besmirch logic, reality, sanity, science and reason. It’s non stop, it’s significant and very dangerous. When this despicable demagogue spoke to the CIA, he said, in so many words, that we should go back into Iraq and take their oil. Just incredible, spectacularly stupid and destructive. He’s talking that way about an ally which is fighting ISIS. After his ignorant comments, maybe more Iraqis will defect to ISIS.
LikeLike
I agree Joe this is an experience that to my knowledge we have never seen before at this level of Government . Kim Jung Trump .
LikeLike
I think you just might be giving him too much credit to liken him to Kim Jong-un. I can see King Kong Trump on top of the White House being “spectacularly stupid and destructive.”
LikeLike
Actually I was envisioning the Capitol Building not the White House.
LikeLike
Stop wait you just gave me hope. Do you remember the end of that movie. Ivanka looking up with sad eyes as the US Air force saves the world.
LikeLike
Trump now bans information, until it can be contained.
https://www.google.com/amp/www.nydailynews.com/amp/news/politics/president-trump-institutes-media-blackouts-epa-usda-article-1.2954647?client=safari
LikeLike
Wow Akademos!
LikeLike
Time to go back into the streets. Target Wall Street and the Chicago trading floors . Shut them down with people this is a battle for Democracy
Next it will be the Bureau of labor statistics
Washington will be too dangerous unless you are willing to spend 10 years in Jail
Business as Usual has to stop . A National strike shutting down air travel . Subway and rail systems and American industry . But it wont happen
.
LikeLike
While you’re dreaming, and better yet, shut down the stock market. Ted Koppel predicts that the Russian hackers will shut down our three major grids and send us back to the Dark Ages.
LikeLike
Sorry…need to read more closely, Joel…shutting down the stock market is exactly what you suggested.
Maybe this time, do Occupy with everyone over 60, all ‘white’ heads doing the occupying instead of the majority of young people taking the battering. Maybe cops will not confront older men and women who look like their parents.
LikeLike
I am thinking the Mayor is not Bloomberg the President not Obama .
Federal troops will not be called in unless requested by Cuomo .
But I was not talking about kids . Chicago a little more dicey with a Republican Governor
Richard Trumka’s rise in labor was after the Republican Governor
of Pennsylvania refused to mobilize the National Guard to stop the violence started when mine owners brought in scabs. He turned to the owners and told them to settle or they are on their own . They settled .
So yes Governors don’t like having to assault older White people.
And in some States they may shoot back.
LikeLike
Akademos…Drumpf also was quoted yesterday as saying protesters should be arrested. So far, the police have not done that. I worry about the heat device that was built during the Obama administration to do crowd dispersal. It can generate and project enough heat from blocks away to burn protesters. This was designed after Occupy…and now that Joel keeps suggesting another Occupy movement, it will probably be used by Trump ordering the military to do it, if the police refuse. He has that authority under the Military Commissions Act.
Again, I harken you to remember the Arab Spring, and how it was put down in Egypt by the military overtaking the police, many of whom sided with the young protesters against the Muslim Brotherhood. We see this same scenario happening in Turkey.
Dictators pretty much use the same script to keep the population in line…and Drumpf has shown himself to be an aspiring dictator…especially today with his full speed ahead pipeline orders. No one shot Native Americans and their supporters when Obama was in office…doubt that this will be the case under Herr Drumpf.
LikeLike
According to The Guardian, sales of Orwell’s “Nineteen Eighty-Four” have surged now that we’re in the era of ‘Alternative Facts.’
LikeLike
It’s tough to effectively counter a bevy of ignorant entitled billionaires but here’s an idea: Use “The Fair Packaging and Labeling Act” to force these vapid sell-outs to sport a giant “Paid” sticker on their forehead. At least they’d be easier to spot.
LikeLike
Thank you, Ellen. I appreciate the thoughtfulness of your very well crafted article. I’m happy to sign. And I want to see more articles on this subject written by you in print. Keep ’em comin’! There is a tremendous roadblock to overcome, however. Whose responsibility is it to impeach if the POTUS has not the mental faculties to lead? It’s Congress, Republican dominated Congress — with W. Bush-appointed Chief Justice Roberts theoretically presiding. Petitions (and logic) are lost on Republican legislators. Just make sure those who will vote in purple districts in two years see it. Visibility, as in the Women’s Marches, as in the Bernie rallies, is the key. Sigh. It’s going to be a dangerous two years.
LikeLike
I think, dear Leftie…that Jared and Ivanka, with the help of Ryan, Pence, O’Connell, and even McCain and Graham, will lock Drumpf in his golden bedroom and padlock the doors if he should get wildly irrational and beyond their control. He is doing all that the Repubs have wanted for so many years, but when the day comes that he can no longer even have 5 clear minutes a day, they will step in and take over, with or without impeachment.
We had a few presidents wives do this over the centuries. These Republicans are evil and greedy, but they are not stupid, and they will look out for their own best interests. Right now it is having the dictator sign Executive Orders, and rescind those of Obama…but that is not a role that is sealed in concrete.
LikeLike
Very true. Nancy Reagan comes to mind. Ellen, you are tireless, and therefore, encyclopedic. I am too about teaching English, but when I come home from teaching these days, instead of reading and writing like I should be, I have been just nostalgically watching FOX for laughs, like Jon Stewart used to watch and joke for us. Donald Trump is bigly depressing. Hashtag it’s sad.
I am tired of crazy billionaires. You say Trump has a whole 5 minutes of lucidity a day? I think not. Five nanoseconds maybe. Maybe. I miss Jon Stewart putting corporate greed in perspective and making me laugh. I just heard on FOXNews that companies want to build factories in the U.S. because of Trump. Good news, right? No. Sad. An example of one of those companies purportedly planning to build here in the U.S., Foxconn. An oldie (relatively speaking) but a goodie:
http://www.cc.com/video-clips/24ekd8/the-daily-show-with-jon-stewart-fear-factory
Foxconn. In America. It’s our future. It’s a corporatocratic dream. And, thinking back to Nancy Reagan, whose husband suffered from Alzheimer’s in office, I realize that this is a nation at risk. It has been all along. The danger isn’t schools, though; it’s corporate greed. It still is. It has been all along.
LikeLike
Foxconn in China has had many suicides. It added nets around the building to prevent suicides. Workers live in dorms and are on call 24/7. At low pay.
LikeLike
Foxconn is a Japanese owned company.
“Rural suicide rates are three times greater than the urban rates. The rate averaged over the six years for the rural suicides is 26.4 per 100,000 rural population, while that for the urban is 8.7 per 100,000 urban population. Since rural people account for approximately 70% of the Chinese population, the absolute number of suicides in the countryside is much higher than in cities.”
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2913725/
Foxconn has 1 million workers in China
http://fortune.com/2013/11/27/by-the-numbers-how-foxconn-churns-out-apples-iphone-5s/
Wired reports 1 Million Workers, 90 Million iPhones, 17 Suicides.
https://www.wired.com/2011/02/ff_joelinchina/
Conclusion: the number of suicides at Foxconn is lower than the annual suicide rate in China.
LikeLike
35 hour shifts at 31 cents an hour is what Foxconn is used to getting from its workers. They live in and spend their 31 cents in company towns. They sleep in dorm rooms with strangers. There are nets around the buildings specifically to cut down on suicides. I’m guessing that in rural China they have no nets? I know Lloyd has far deeper knowledge and understanding of Asian countries than I do, but I feel that a company that takes advantage of a country’s outlawing of unions can stay where it is, suicides or not. And Trump can do away with a few trade deals, but we need to keep what few unions we have left. 35 hour shifts my eye!
LikeLike
China doesn’t outlaw labor unions, they restrict them, and they are not democratic like labor unions in the U.S.
In China everyone in a factory, and even in a Chinese Walmart (yes, Walmart stores are in China) belongs to a labor union because of the socialist state, but the unions, like all unions and corporations, are subject to greed-is great-corruption just like elected officials.
“Workers do not have the right to organize in trade unions of their choice. Legal trade unions have to be affiliated to the ACFTU and accept its control. Although there have been some efforts to establish collective wage consultation systems, the right to collective bargaining is restricted as is the right to strike, both in law and in practice. The lack of proper representation is reflected in the number of protests and labor disputes that have been rising over the years.” …
But “Despite the inadequacies of Chinese law, the government sometimes now allows strikes and plant-level collective bargaining. The government has also enacted improvements in workers’ rights in the past few years (for example, the 2008 Employee Contract Law), and created a policy favoring widespread ‘collective consultation’ over wages and working conditions. As a result, Chinese industrial wages are rising—a good thing for both Chinese working families and for workers in other countries that compete with China in a variety of industries.”
http://www.aflcio.org/Issues/Trade/China/Labor-Rights-in-China
If you want a better idea what it is like to work in one of those factories, I suggest reading Peter Hessler’s books on China. He lived there for years and made friends with factory workers and managers, who were surprisingly very open to answering his questions and showing him around inside the factories.
Through Hessler, we learn that even 31 cents an hour, if that’s accurate, is a lot more than what most of those workers were earning back on the rural farm. I question the allegation of a work shift that runs for 35-hours nonstop.
Read “Country Driving” by Peter Hessler and you will discover that the Chinese he met are not as upset about factor work as someone who is not Chinese and has never set foot in China. In fact, the Chiense Hessler met and got to know saw those jobs as an opportunity that didn’t exist in their rural villages.
What does that mean? Read what Bloomberg has to say about it.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-01-29/china-rural-income-gains-aid-shift-toward-consumption
And like many migrant workers in the U.S., legal and illegal, those factor workers manage to send money home to their family still living in the poorer rural village. Poverty in China isn’t like it is the U.S. In China, rural famlies do not pay rent or mortgage payments or property tax on the houses they live in. They also can’t sell the houses because they are jointly/cooperatively owned by the village and the central government.
Other books by Hessler on China”
“River Town”
“Oracle Bones”
LikeLike
That should have been with a comma: 35 hour shifts, my eye!
I know someone with a sweatshirt that reads:
Let’s eat grandma.
Let’s eat, grandma.
Punctuation saves lives.
She wore it Saturday marching against The Donald President.
LikeLike
This occurred to me tonight: Has Sean Spicer ever heard of Jerry terHorst?
LikeLike
Hello Diane: I am a long-time reader of your blog. Thank you for informing us. My novel, linked, has just been published this month. Mr. M. and his colleagues wrestle with standardized tests, eugenics, etc. Best wishes, John Splaine https://www.amazon.com/Mr-Ms-Notebook-Teachers-Life/dp/1944393250/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1485344727&sr=1-1&keywords=john+splaine+mr.+m%27s+notebook
Dr. John Splaine If this email was not intended for the recipient, please delete immediately.
LikeLike