Katherine Stewart has been writing for years about Christian nationalism and its pernicious influence on American society, especially public schools. Her latest book is The Power Worshippers: Inside the Dangerous World of Religious Nationalists.
She wrote this article about the January 6 insurrection for The New York Times:
The most serious attempt to overthrow the American constitutional system since the Civil War would not have been feasible without the influence of America’s Christian nationalist movement. One year later, the movement seems to have learned a lesson: If it tries harder next time, it may well succeed in making the promise of American democracy a relic of the past.
Christian nationalist symbolism was all over the events of Jan. 6, as observers have pointed out. But the movement’s contribution to the effort to overturn the 2020 election and install an unelected president goes much deeper than the activities of a few of its representatives on the day that marks the unsuccessful end (or at least a temporary setback) of an attempted coup.
A critical precondition for Donald Trump’s attempt to retain the presidency against the will of the people was the cultivation of a substantial population of voters prepared to believe his fraudulent claim that the election was stolen — a line of argument Mr. Trump began preparing well before the election, at the first presidential debate.
The role of social and right-wing media in priming the base for the claim that the election was fraudulent is by now well understood. The role of the faith-based messaging sphere is less well appreciated. Pastors, congregations and the religious media are among the most trusted sources of information for many voters. Christian nationalist leaders have established richly funded national organizations and initiatives to exploit this fact. The repeated message that they sought to deliver through these channels is that outside sources of information are simply not credible. The creation of an information bubble, impervious to correction, was the first prerequisite of Mr. Trump’s claim.
The coup attempt also would not have been possible without the unshakable sense of persecution that movement leaders have cultivated among the same base of voters. Christian nationalism today begins with the conviction that conservative Christians are the most oppressed group in American society. Among leaders of the movement, it is a matter of routine to hear talk that they are engaged in a “battle against tyranny,” and that the Bible may soon be outlawed.
A final precondition for the coup attempt was the belief, among the target population, that the legitimacy of the United States government derives from its commitment to a particular religious and cultural heritage, and not from its democratic form. It is astonishing to many that the leaders of the Jan. 6 attack on the constitutional electoral process styled themselves as “patriots.” But it makes a glimmer of sense once you understand that their allegiance is to a belief in blood, earth and religion, rather than to the mere idea of a government “of the people, by the people, for the people.”
Given the movement’s role in laying the groundwork for the coup attempt, its leaders faced a quandary when Mr. Trump began to push his repeatedly disproven claims — and that quandary turned into a test of character on Jan. 6. Would they go along with an attempt to overthrow America’s democratic system?
Some attempted to rewrite the facts about Jan. 6. The former Republican Representative Michele Bachmann suggested the riot was the work of “paid rabble rousers,” while the activist and author Lance Wallnau, who has praised Mr. Trump as “God’s chaos candidate,” blamed “the local antifa mob.” Many leaders, like Charlie Kirk, appeared to endorse Mr. Trump’s claims about a fraudulent election. Others, like Michael Farris, president and chief executive of the religious right legal advocacy group Alliance Defending Freedom, provided indirect but no less valuable support by concern-trolling about supposed “constitutional irregularities” in battleground states.
None appeared willing to condemn Mr. Trump for organizing an attempt to prevent the peaceful transfer of power to President-elect Joe Biden. On the contrary, the Rev. Franklin Graham, writing on Facebook, condemned “these ten” from Mr. Trump’s “own party” who voted to impeach him and mused, “It makes you wonder what the thirty pieces of silver were that Speaker Pelosi promised for this betrayal.”
At Christian nationalist conferences I have been reporting on, I have heard speakers go out of their way to defend and even lionize the Jan. 6 insurrectionists. At the Road to Majority conference, which was held in Central Florida in June 2021, the author and radio host Eric Metaxas said, “The reason I think we are being so persecuted, why the Jan. 6 folks are being persecuted, when you’re over the target like that, oh my.” At that same conference, the political commentator Dinesh D’Souza, in conversation with the religious right strategist Ralph Reed, said, “The people who are really getting shafted right now are the Jan. 6 protesters,” before adding, “We won’t defend our guys even when they’re good guys.” Mr. Reed nodded in response and replied, “I think Donald Trump taught our movement a lot.”
Movement leaders now appear to be working to prime the base for the next attempt to subvert the electoral process. At dozens of conservative churches in swing states this past year, groups of pastors were treated to presentations by an initiative called Faith Wins. Featuring speakers like David Barton, a key figure in the fabrication of Christian nationalist myths about history, and led by Chad Connelly, a Republican political veteran, Faith Wins serves up elections skepticism while demanding that pastors mobilize their flocks to vote “biblical” values. “Every pastor you know needs to make sure 100 percent of the people in their pews are voting, and voting biblical values,” Mr. Connelly told the assembled pastors at a Faith Wins event in Chantilly, Va. in September.
“The church is not a cruise ship, the church is a battleship,” added Byron Foxx, an evangelist touring with Faith Wins. The Faith Wins team also had at its side Hogan Gidley, a deputy press secretary in the Trump White House, who now runs the Center for Election Integrity, an initiative of the America First Policy Institute, a group led in part by former members of the Trump administration. Mr. Gidley informed the gathering that his group is “nonpartisan” — and then went on to mention that in the last election cycle there were “A lot of rogue secretaries of state, a lot of rogue governors.”
He was presumably referring to Brad Raffensperger, the Republican secretary of state of Georgia who earned the ire of Trumpists by rebuffing the former president’s request to find him an additional 11,780 votes. “You saw the stuff in Arizona, you’re going to see more stuff in Wisconsin, these are significant issues, and we can’t be dismissed out of hand anymore, the facts are too glaring,” Mr. Gidley said. In fact, the Republican-backed audit of votes in Arizona’s largest county confirmed that President Biden won Arizona by more votes than previously thought. But the persecution narrative is too politically useful to discard simply because it’s not true.
Even as movement leaders are preparing for a possible restoration of a Trumpist regime — a period they continue to regard as a golden age in retrospect — they are advancing in parallel on closely related fronts. Among the most important of these has to do with public education.
In the panic arising out of the claim that America’s schools are indoctrinating young children in critical race theory, or C.R.T., it isn’t hard to detect the ritualized workings of the same information bubble, persecution complex and sense of entitlement that powered the coup attempt. Whatever you make of the new efforts in state legislatures to impose new “anti-C.R.T.” restrictions on speech and teaching in public schools, the more important consequence is to extend the religious right’s longstanding program to undermine confidence in public education, an effort that religious right leaders see as essential both for the movement’s long-term funding prospects and for its antidemocratic agenda.
Opposition to public education is part of the DNA of America’s religious right. The movement came together in the 1970s not solely around abortion politics, as later mythmakers would have it, but around the outrage of the I.R.S. threatening to take away the tax-exempt status of church-led “segregation academies.” In 1979, Jerry Falwell said he hoped to see the day when there wouldn’t be “any public schools — the churches will have taken them over again and Christians will be running them.”
Today, movement leaders have their eye on the approximately $700 billion that federal, state, and local governments spend yearly on education. The case of Carson v. Makin, which is before the Supreme Court this term and involves a challenge, in Maine, to prohibitions on using state tuition aid to attend religious schools, could force taxpayers to fund sectarian schools no matter how discriminatory their policies or fanatical their teachings. The endgame is to get a chunk of this money with the help either of state legislatures or the Supreme Court, which in its current configuration might well be convinced that religious schools have a right to taxpayer funds.
This longstanding anti-public school agenda is the driving force behind the movement’s effort to orchestrate the anti-C.R.T. campaign. The small explosions of hate detonating in public school boards across the nation are not entirely coming from the grass roots up. The Family Research Council, a Washington, D.C.-based Christian right policy group, recently held an online School Board Boot Camp, a four-hour training session providing instruction on how to run for school boards and against C.R.T. and to recruit others to do so. The Bradley Foundation, Heritage Action for America, and The Manhattan Institute are among those providing support for groups on the forefront of the latest public school culture wars.
A decade ago, the radical aims at the ideological core of the Christian nationalist movement were there to see for anybody who looked. Not many bothered to look, and those who did were often dismissed as alarmist. More important, most Republican Party leaders at the time distanced themselves from theocratic extremists. They avoided the rhetoric of Seven Mountains dominionism, an ideology that calls explicitly for the domination of the seven “peaks” of modern civilization (including government and education) by Christians of the correct, supposedly biblical variety.
What a difference a decade makes. National organizations like the Faith & Freedom Coalition and the Ziklag Group, which bring together prominent Republican leaders with donors and religious right activists, feature “Seven Mountains” workshops and panels at their gatherings. Nationalist leaders and their political dependents in the Republican Party now state quite openly what before they whispered to one another over their prayer breakfasts. Whether the public will take notice remains to be seen.
Dear Diane Ravitch,
We constantly read about the problems of social adjustment of children in this time of Covid. I don’t follow the educational press, but I have not seen articles on how to work with groups of children who are meeting often for the first time. My daughter and her husband operate a summer camp. Can you point me to sources, books, articles, people who specialize in working with children in these strange times?
I throw this out to you and your wonderful readers.
Best regards, Robert I. Rhodes (Ph.D) robert.rhodes02@gmail.com
On Tue, Feb 15, 2022 at 9:00 AM Diane Ravitch’s blog wrote:
> dianeravitch posted: ” Katherine Stewart has been writing for years about > Christian nationalism and its pernicious influence on American society, > especially public schools. Her latest book is The Power Worshippers: Inside > the Dangerous World of Religious Nationalists. She w” >
“Today, movement leaders have their eye on the approximately $700 billion that federal, state, and local governments spend yearly on education.”
Rupert Murdoch in 2011: “When it comes to K through 12 education, we see a $500 billion sector in the US alone that is waiting desperately to be transformed by big breakthroughs that extend the reach of great teaching.”
No difference between these creatures who hide behind the flag, the bible and children.
“A decade ago, the radical aims at the ideological core of the Christian nationalist movement were there to see for anybody who looked.”
A decade ago???
Really???
I’d hate to tell Ms. Stewart that those aims have been out in the open since the 80s ‘for anybody who looked. Can you say Unca St. Ronnie? Continuing through the current times.
An xtian fundie reichwing caliphate is what they seek, their ‘radical aims’.
I agree. I think Roe V Wade helped to energize and mobilize evangelical, right wing Christians. At first, they rallied around this issue. Now they have aligned with radical right wing political groups and Donald Trump of all people. Strange “bedfellows,” a marriage of convenience. indeed. What they have in common is the belief that they are all victims of the “establishment.”
Actually most evangelicals at the time of RvW were for the decision. The abortion aspect came about later.
Stewart is well familiar with the history of the religious right. The decade reference was more about changes in what they actually believed was possible not what their aspirations were. About the total mainstreaming of the Timothy McVeigh wing into the Republican Party.
I stand by my statement.
key point: For anybody who LOOKED.
1980s?! I can trace it back to the antebellum period, through the Jim Crow era and the rise of the New Right, to the current moment. It’s all in my book, The Power Worshippers: Inside the Dangerous Rise of Religious Nationalism. You might pick it up!
How squares this with Sunni Islamic preacher Fethullah Gülen’s nationwide chain of charter schools, I wonder.
Oh, I know how. $$$
His case is probably unique.
He embodies a pro US “Turkish government in exile” that can be installed in Turkey on a moment’s notice should the opportunity arise.
It is pretty obvious that that is the reason he has been allowed to stay in the US (under the protection of the US government) and allowed to take millions of dollars of US public funds for what are effectively religious schools run by foreign nationals.
A wise man once said: “When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross.” The latter quote is attributed to James Waterman Wise. Father Coughlin would be quite happy with these present day religio-fascists.
Because these religious zealots don’t care to understand what faith is, that their beliefs are an act of faith, they lack respect for the beliefs of others. This kind of thinking is the source of the real threat to democracy. The United States has never been a single ethnic society, we have always been a nation of immigrants. The biased thinking exemplified by religious extremist is especially dangerous to our democratic form of government.
” “Every pastor you know needs to make sure 100 percent of the people in their pews are voting, and voting biblical values,” from a quote above…
I sure am glad to hear that. For a moment I though Christianity had gone away from the Jewish tradition of the year of jubilee, from Jesus and his radical outreach to the downtrodden. So many movements today seem to confuse nationalism with Christian values. I am glad that these guys will be selling all they have and following Jesus.
Yup. They also confuse capitalism with Christian values.
beautiful, Roy!
In the mid-1980’s, a parent appeared at my classroom door during lunchtime and asked if she could speak with me. As I approached her, she quickly closed the door and started sobbing. My first thought: “Holy cow, what have I done to Eugene to cause this?” But, no, it was something else. I helped her sit, placed a box of tissues nearby, and then she took my hand. The sobs subsided as she spoke: “Eugene loves you. We love you. We love everyone in this school. But, something terrible is happening. It’s my church! There is a meeting tonight you have to attend. Please come, because you have to know what is happening. Don’t show your ID, don’t tell them you’re a teacher, when you see me don’t respond.” I went; it was standing-room only. The guest speaker started jovially, slowly became conspiratorial, then ended in rousing evangelical revival mode. The crowd responded as he hoped. The message: “Godless government schools are ruining our children and destroying The United States of America! We have formed groups dedicated to grabbing schools from the clutches of Satan, and we have a plan! YOU must run for office, starting with school boards and municipal offices, then positions higher and higher until God takes back control, not only of our schools but of the whole country! We’ll teach you how to win! If asked devious questions such as ‘Do you believe students should be made to pray in school?’, say NO…that’s right, lie, LIE in Jesus’ name! You must win!” He saved his most vile accusations for teachers; however, he assured those present that teachers were good people possessed of the Devil–so taking over schools would save not only the children but also the hapless teachers. It was electric. It was horrific.
Lynchburg Virginia used to be a place of religious cooperation among the churches according to a friend of mine who grew up there. They conspired together to have Christmas observances and joint Easter services. Then a pastor learned that being divisive made more people come to his church. His movement became the national movement called the Moral Majority, paving the way for the modern fundamentalist surge of political activity that got us to where we are today.
Many ministers I know consider this movement the most insidious thing ever to attack American religion. They suggest that the motivation for most of these people is fundamentally anti-Christian beliefs cloaked in false ideas.
Now everything in Lynchburg is owned and operated by Liberty U…..real estate, restaurants, apartment complexes etc. They even defaced the side of a mountain with the logo! It’s a beautiful campus with lots of amenities if a one can tolerate the fundamentalist nature of the Christian Nationalists and their rules. What a shame when poor Jerry Jr got caught in his sex scandal and the University made him step away from his position. There seems to be “a theme” when it comes to the leaders of these movements…..and it’s not very Christian IMHO (for Duane….in my honest opinion!).
How awful.
Lie on Jesus’ name!
Pretty much says it all.
Anyone who lies in Jesus’ name had better hole there is no Hell.
Cuz if there is, they will burn there for sure.
A conservative friend of mine justifies the conservative alliance with Christianity on the basis that Black churches regularly have been the fulcrum for political activity that has benefitted the democrats. I find this a fascinating logic. Since Black churches were the only avenue open to African-American leadership, it is hard to imagine a different institution from which to launch a movement against a force that caused so much repression during the years of White Supremacy. To suggest that modern Christianity is under the same fire as the Black community was during White Supremacy might be the most false of the false equivalencies to which I have ever been exposed.
Nobody got the message when a major cable station started airing episodes of a reality TV show based on a large, Christian fundamentalist, Quiverfull family? The goal of the show was to “normalize” this faction of society and endear them to the public….and it seemed to work! I watched 1 or 2 episodes for curiosity and it made me sick. They shot their “golden arrow” Josh into DC to do great “Christian” work. Fortunately (or unfortunately for some children), he got caught in the creepy act of pedophilia and was ushered out of the spotlight. But these religious zealots will keep trying and trying to push their agenda, even though it has nothing to do with true Christianity or the teachings of Christ. It’s all about money and power and nothing more.
I was wondering who you were referring to, so I did some poking around on the Net and encountered the Willis Family. I expected to read one article and be done with it, but I ended up listening to several of their musical videos. Extremely talented kids. Here’s hoping that they will find healing and peace after what they’ve been through!!!|
I was referring to the Duggar family. 19 Kids and Counting.
The extremist billionaires in the U.S. — [think Walton, Koch, et al.] — that fund and control the puppet strings of the Religious Right are no different than ISIS, the Taliban or al-Qaida, and just as dangerous.
Years ago, Ronald Reagan described the folks he was funding to fight against the Russians in Afghanistan as “freedom fighters” and “good, God-fearing folks, just like us.” Those fighters were, of course, the Taliban, and one of the young resistance fighters who made a name for himself by using American, shoulder-held missile launchers to stop a convoy of Russian tanks was Osama bin Laden. This whole story is told in Lawrence Wright\s magnificent book The Looming Tower.
I’ve always found the American right-wing’s Islamophobia darkly amusing because, of course, the American right wing (excepting the oligarchs at the top) is indistinguishable from the most fanatical of the Islamist right-wing. Not a whit of difference.
If the American Christian nationalists ever figured out that they and the Taliban and Isis have exactly the same beliefs, values, ideas about how government and law–then we would really be in trouble. It’s hilarious that they are such idiots that they don’t see this.
Given the changing demographics of our country and the views of the young people coming up, the 2022-24 period is the Republican’s ONE SHOT at remaining at all viable. If they don’t seize this moment, they are history, and even Donald Trump, as feeble-minded as he is, knows this and has stated as much at length.
For the Republican Party, this is the do-or-die moment. They must suppress voting, seize power, and then enact laws and take actions to use violence to maintain themselves in power. Otherwise, they go they way of the Know-nothings.
cx: Republicans’
Christian Nationalism is oxymoronic.
yup
As someone who is considered by these “Christians” to not be Christian, I just have to ask: HOW IS ANY OF THIS CHRIST-LIKE?????
good question!!!
The IRS automatically considers churches 501(c)3 organizations, granting them exemption from federal income tax without having to apply. ”
“Under the Internal Revenue Code, all section 501(c)(3) organizations are absolutely prohibited from directly or indirectly participating in, or intervening in, any political campaign on behalf of (or in opposition to) any candidate for elective public office.Sep 23, 2021
Any church that engages in political activity should be reported to the IRS.
And have its tax empty status summarily yanked.
The New Yorker: You’ve used a phrase “if we have a democracy ten years from now.” Do you think we won’t?
Congresswoman Ocasio-Cortez: I think there’s a very real risk that we will not. What we risk is having a government that perhaps postures as a democracy, and may try to pretend that it is, but isn’t.
https://www.newyorker.com/culture/the-new-yorker-interview/is-alexandria-ocasio-cortez-an-insider-now
Great interview. AOC sounds wise. I didn’t post it because I assume it’s behind a pay wall.
Congress can and does vote against the will of the majority of the populace on many issues which already means our system is not a democracy.
But it’s actually even worse: one person (Manchin) can thwart the decision of the majority in Congress.
So we don’t have anything close to a democracy.
We don’t even have a minimally functioning government.
What is failing is not democracy because that already failed .
What is failing is our country.
I should have said the minority can thwart the decision of the majority in Congress via the filibuster.
When Manchin votes with Republicans, Democrats don’t have a majority.
The current Republican schism between the corporate McConnell faction and the culture warriors may bring this right wing dominance to an end. Corporate America is very leery of the impact of Christo-nationalists on the bottom line. Stay tuned…