I have relived the story many times and probably told it here too.
On 9/11/01 I was sitting at my dining table reading the morning paper and enjoying a cup of coffee when I heard/felt a mighty crash. I live(d) in Brooklyn Heights, two blocks from the waterfront, and my first thought was that it must have been a horrendous crash on the Brooklyn/Queens Expressway. My partner Mary called from work and told me to turn on the TV, something terrible had happened at the World Trade Center. Some thought a small plane had crashed into one of the towers. I turned on CNN, and I saw the smoldering tower. I rushed out the door, ran the two blocks to the nearest point to view the harbor, and as I looked up, I saw the second plane hit the second tower. I saw it. I still see it. The first tower was burning, now the second was burning. I stood there with about half a dozen people and we were speechless. I ran home to listen to CNN and hear what they were saying. They were saying “Terrorism.” I ran back to the harbor front, but now there was a dense cloud of smoke coming my way. Soon, I could see nothing at all.
Mary came home. We walked to the nearest hospital to offer blood, but they said they weren’t accepting any. We saw streams of people walking from Manhattan over the Brooklyn Bridge, looking dazed. They were covered in soot. Some carried briefcases, some were shoeless. We wanted to help. There was nothing we could do.
Soot from the fires began to drizzle down on the neighborhood after the wind shifted our way. The cars were covered in soot. There was an acrid smell in the air, the smell of burning plastic, burning…steel, bodies, something awful. The smell lingered for weeks. The memories, forever.
In the backyard of our brownstone, tiny pieces of paper fluttered to the ground. It was a blizzard, almost like snow. Tiny pieces of paper that once had been in someone’s files, on their desk. One of them was intact, except for burn holes. It came from someone’s desk. I covered it in plastic and saved it. I don’t know why.
Soon, there was silence, eerie silence, punctuated only by the sound of jets overhead and sirens, endless sirens. All traffic, all subways, all buses, all movement stopped. Just sirens.
In the silence, everyone whispered. We learned what was happening by watching television, even though it was happening within our sight (when the wind shifted).
People stood along the Promenade, the beautiful walkway in Brooklyn on the Harbor with a full view of the Manhattan skyline, to see what could be seen. People brought candles and flowers, and left them there. Someone hung a photograph of the Twin Towers, preserved in hard plastic, and hung it on the fence along the Promenade. It remained there, undisturbed, undamaged, for over a year. One day it was gone.
On my block, a young couple with a child had recently moved to New Jersey to be in the suburbs, the leafy suburbs. The mom died in the Towers.
Everyone knew someone.
Mary’s niece worked in the second Tower. She got out before it collapsed, thank God, but she and her co-workers–in shock–started walking north and didn’t stop until they reached Harlem, where one of them lived (miles away). Her parents didn’t know if she was alive or dead for hours.
The neighborhood fire company was one of the first to respond. Most of them died.
It was a day I will never forget.
It was a day New Yorkers will never forget.
The fire stations in New York City have tributes to and photographs of the men who died that day.
I saw a bumper sticker a few days ago that said, “There is one hell of a fire department in Heaven.”
Thank you for sharing this…brought tears to my eyes. Trying to lift my heart off the ground as I send heartfelt prayers to everyone that was in NYC that day…
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education.
I was in Kuala Lumpur and it was my normal routine to turn on the TV while I did my morning exercises. I watched CNN International and saw a plane going into the World Trade Center. I called one of my girlfriends back in the States and said something like, “What is going on in the States?”. I found out.
At school, the teachers had an early meeting to decide what to do since the children obviously knew what had happened. Everyone was sad. As a music teacher, no children asked me anything. I’m glad since I don’t know what I would have said.
………………………….
This is Tweet from a fake, ignorant, unfeeling president. It is as if he is celebrating this date.
17 years since September 11th!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 11, 2018
…………………………….
This is how a REAL president speaks.
Barack Obama
@BarackObama
We will always remember everyone we
lost on 9/11, thank the first responders
who keep us safe, and honor all who
defend our country and the ideals
that bind us together, There’s nothing our
resilience and resolve can’t overcome,
and no act of terror can ever change
who we are.
9/11/18, 9:52 AM
34 replies90 retweets911 likes
Reply 34 Retweet 90
Yes, carolmalaysia, a trite & insulting statement.
This, from someone (not my president) who thinks he is “the Hemingway of 140 words” tweets the “covfefe” of such a tragic & catastrophic event for America.
Thank you for your memories. 9/11 is a “day of infamy” forever branded in our hearts.
Diane, thank you for relating your memory of, like the Pearl Harbor attack, a Day That Will Live In Infamy. You are one of many “primary sources”. I live in a suburb of Los Angeles and greatly appreciate the perspective of a New Yorker living through it. We must never forget that there are evil people in the world, and a continuing Holy War of those who would demand sharia law for the world, who oppose the very idea of religious liberty. Never forget on what principles the United States was founded. Liberty is and was not the norm for most of the world. It must be constantly defended and guarded. Never forget.
Oh for pity’s sake. They didn’t attack us for our freedom (of which we have far less than we think we do). They attacked us, as bin Laden specifically told us, because we attack them. Please recall that Madeleine Albright said that the deaths of 500,000 Iraqi children due to our sanctions was “worth it”.
Thanks Diane for this heartfelt remembrance. That day is certainly seared into my memory and I live in central NJ far from NYC, DC and Shanksville, PA. An initial radio report said that a small plane had crashed into the tower and then I flipped on the TV to see what was going on. It was far worse than some small plane and then when the 2nd plane struck the other tower, it was obviously a terrorist attack. My nephew, (who lived in Hoboken could see what was going on from his apartment window), called me and at that moment the 2nd plane struck. His wife was in the background and screamed that “they” had attacked the Pentagon, too.
It was stunning, shocking, tragic and saddening all at once. It was a huge blow to this country, thousands killed, many thousands more injured in mind and spirit. Those two magnificent towers leveled to the ground along with thousands of people. As if all this misery was not enough, then all the conspiracy theories flourished and proliferated non stop. They are almost as heinous as the act of terrorism itself.
I often wonder what if one of the planes had succeeded in crashing into the Capitol building or the White House?
My wife was in Moscow on 9/11. She was scheduled to fly into JFK on Sept 14. I did not know if she was going to get home, because all air traffic over the north Atlantic had been suspended. The FAA opened the New York airports , and she was able to fly in on schedule.
I will never forget driving across the Verrazano bridge, (Sep 14) and getting the view of lower Manhattan, covered in smoke. Maybe it was in my mind, but I could swear I saw the statue of Liberty weeping.
Thanks. After reading your description, I went to google maps and tried to imagine all those people walking across that bridge. I got the same feeling I had when I stood where Pickett’s charge had failed so miserably at Gettysburg. It is amazing how quickly our collective experience can be gone if we do not remember.
My Lord. This is beautifully written. What a moving tribute!
I agree with Bob Shepard.
I also watched the events of 9-11- 2001 on television. Later I heard first-person accounts from a former student who provided lodgingand TLC to a visitor who was wandering uptown and clearly disoriented. A second report came from a friend who was driving toward NYC. He was in New Jersey and saw the two planes hit the towers.
I was in New York City in the Spring of 2004. Almost everywhere there were daffodils in bloom. The city was heartbreakingly beautiful. I went to my old haunts near NYU, Washington Park, and then to the great gaping hole were the twin towers once stood. Architects had designed a simple viewing platform for visitors to see the site. Workman were still digging deep inside the cavernous hole, loading trucks with debris. Chain link and plywood fencing led up to platform. These had become one of many outdoor galleries near the site,still filled with home-made cards, banners, photographs, poems, posters, and autographed flags.
http://www.citizenship-aei.org/2013/09/the-story-behind-the-first-public-memorial-at-ground-zero/
http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/ten-years-9-11-10-million-yellow-daffodils-bloom-remembrance-article-1.945803
You reminded me of the flyers posted all over town, near the WTC site, and elsewhere, with photos of lost relatives and friends. “Have you seen…?” They were everywhere for many many weeks. Heartbreaking. Father’s, Mother’s, sons, daughters, friends. Lost. Missing.
Thank you for this. From far away in California, we, too, were horrified and frightened. And our fears were weaponized into an apparently never- ending war. A good friend lost a kid in it. Endless tragedy.
“Soon, there was silence, eerie silence, punctuated only by the sound of jets overhead…”
When it happened, I was in Chicago and we were struck by that eerie silence, too, only it was because no airplanes were allowed to fly anywhere near the city, which went on for days, and local news reports said that was for fear of the Sears Tower being struck next. I believe the FAA shut down flights for the whole country though.
Reteach 4 America: I was overseas and the phone lines were also cut off. I felt really isolated and fearful living in a moderate Muslim country. The US embassy had traveling security experts giving lectures about how to spot terrorists. It was a really creepy time.
I lived near an Air Force base, and the silence was eerie, as no jets took off for several days afterwards And I’m in nowhere-ville, Utah. A friend of the family took very sick the day of 9/11, and Life Flight had to get special permission from the FAA to get her to the hospital that night.
My 28 year old daughter remembers being in 5th grade. She attended school in a suburb close to NYC. Many parents in our town work(ed) in the financial industry. Many worked in the World Trade Center. She remembers the rumors and hushed tones swirling around the school. Finally, the entire school was led to the auditorium where it was announced that the names of parents who were ok would be called it alphabetical order. I don’t know who came up with this idea, but as parents’ names were skipped there were wails of grief. One student lost both her parents. My daughter will never forget.
Thank you, RL.
Of course, Americans and even non-Americans should honor the dead and mourn all the innocent victims of such unspeakable horror and terror that occurred on 9-11-01. Several questions still remain — why did these people commit such crimes? Who were they? Who financed them? And, why were they willing to kill themselves and so many innocent human beings? Why did they hate us so much? What, if anything, had the US government and its military done to them to justify such deadly attacks? On another note, 17 years of using military forces in Afghanistan has resulted in the deaths of many innocent Afghans. When, if ever, is revenge justified? Too many innocents have been murdered and maimed. Isn’t it time for US forces to leave the “graveyard of empires?”
William Thomas: “On another note, 17 years of using military forces in Afghanistan has resulted in the deaths of many innocent Afghans.”
I agree with you. We cannot kill our way to peace. This money for war should be used to help the people. Guess there is no profit for the industrial military complex in helping.
I was teaching college full time then and the next president who was hired there often talked about how he was in NYC on 9/11. He said he rushed over to see if he could help out at a local hospital and stayed there for a long time, but no one was brought in for treatment…
No End in Sight
An American soldier killed in Afghanistan this summer wasn’t yet 3 when the war began. Seventeen years after 9/11, America still seems determined to keep fighting.
…Seventeen years and tens of billions of dollars later, the conflict is at a stalemate: At least as long as the U.S. remains in the country, the Afghan government will remain in charge even as the Taliban continues to showcase its ability to carry out attacks seemingly at will. The duration of that war, and the U.S. war in Iraq, has meant repeated deployments for some U.S. military personnel, the psychological cost of which the Army was already warning about a decade ago. One of the most recent American fatalities in Afghanistan, from just this month, was on his seventh combat deployment. The continuation of the conflict, now nearly a generation long, also means that people who can’t even remember the attacks are old enough to deploy—a 20-year-old soldier killed in Afghanistan this summer wasn’t yet 3 years old on September 11, 2001. Soon people who weren’t even born then will be old enough to go fight…
Read More:
http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2018/09/9-11-us-troops-afghanistan/569803/?utm_source=eb
In a speech yesterday, National Security Adviser John Bolton “said the Hague-based International Criminal Court had no jurisdiction to investigate U.S. officials and soldiers for their actions in Afghanistan,” Dan Boylan reports for The Washington Times. “If the court comes after us, Israel or any of our other allies, we will not sit quietly,” Ambassador Bolton said.
I just read an article in the Chicago Sun-Times this morning w/the title, “Deaths From 9/11
Diseases Will Soon Outnumber Those Lost on That Day.”
“17 years out from the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, nearly 10,000 first responders & others who were in the World Trade Center area have been diagnosed w/cancer. More than 2,000 deaths have been attributed to 9/11 illnesses. It will get worse. By the end of 2018, many expect that more people will have died from their toxic exposure from 9/11 than were killed on that terrible Tuesday.”
The article goes on to quote confirmations of those predictions from the CDC, a retired FDNY first responder, John Feal, founder of a foundation “that supports 9/11 rescue & recovery workers & a Middletown, NY internist,, volunteer firefighter & medical professor.
In a recent discussion, I was also surprised to hear people answer that the day of an historic (tragic or otherwise) they most remembered where they were/what they were doing was the day President Kennedy was assassinated. I would have thought it would have been September 11, 2001.
I remember both.
I remember being on Capitol Hill on September 11th and a few days later telling a colleague that I thought the long-term death toll from the attacks would be much greater than the deaths of that day. For people who work with cancer and respiratory disease patients, this was an easy prediction. When I saw the pictures of people covered in dust, I knew that many of them were ingesting disease time bombs. When I asked a friend of mine who went on a business trip to NYC a few months later if he could still smell the aftermath, he said yes. My response was, you need to get the hell out of there. Millions of you did not have that luxury.
If you were in the area; if you could, as Diane writes, smell the smells for prolonged periods; if you or anyone you know has been diagnosed with cancer or a respiratory disease, then you should ask if exposure to toxins on September 11 might have triggered the disease. The list of diseases covered can be found at https://www.cdc.gov/wtc/conditions.html. If one of those disease’s rings a bell for you or someone you know, you can find the procedures to access funds from the Victim’s Compensation Fund can be found at https://www.vcf.gov. According to a law firm that represents many victims, “since the towers were on fire for 99 days, there is a presumption that exposure to the toxic dust caused respiratory illnesses and cancers.” The precedent for this program is the Agent Orange compensation and benefits allowance for many veterans who were exposed to it and contracted diseases later.
There is also a long term issue that must be addressed legislatively. Under the current law, the deadline for submitting a claim is December 18, 2020. While this limits the fund’s liability, it is unrealistic for the people affected. Many cancers will not express themselves until decades after exposure. For example, we all know of women who smoked for a year or two in college who are diagnosed with lung cancer as long as four decades later. Jon Stewart has been on the forefront to lobby for changes in this law.
So if you lived in the area on September 11, have some discussions with your neighbors about diseases contracted since then. The toll will only grow.
Greg,
We tried to get out of town, away from the dust. All the gas stations were dry. I learned a lesson. Keep the gas tank at least half full. Just in case.
I posted this Browning poem last year. Here it is again. “Heaven looks from its towers.”
I wonder do you feel to-day
As I have felt since, hand in hand,
We sat down on the grass, to stray
In spirit better through the land,
This morn of Rome and May?
For me, I touched a thought, I know,
Has tantalized me many times,
(Like turns of thread the spiders throw
Mocking across our path) for rhymes
To catch at and let go.
Help me to hold it! First it left
The yellowing fennel, run to seed
There, branching from the brickwork’s cleft,
Some old tomb’s ruin: yonder weed
Took up the floating wet,
Where one small orange cup amassed
Five beetles, blind and green they grope
Among the honey-meal; and last,
Everywhere on the grassy slope
I traced it. Hold it fast!
The champaign with its endless fleece
Of feathery grasses everywhere!
Silence and passion, joy and peace,
An everlasting wash of air —
Rome’s ghost since her decease.
Such life here, through such lengths of hours,
Such miracles performed in play,
Such primal naked forms of flowers,
Such letting nature have her way
While heaven looks from its towers.
How say you? Let us, O my dove,
Let us be unashamed of soul,
As earth lies bare to heaven above!
How is it under our control
To love or not to love?
I would that you were all to me,
You that are just so much, no more.
Nor yours nor mine, nor slave nor free!
Where does the fault lie? What the core
O’ the wound, since wound must be?
I would I could adopt your will,
See with your eyes, and set my heart
Beating by yours, and drink my fill
At your soul’s springs, — your part my part
In life, for good and ill.
No. I yearn upward, touch you close,
Then stand away. I kiss your cheek,
Catch your soul’s warmth, — I pluck the rose
And love it more than tongue can speak —
Then the good minute goes.
Already how am I so far
Out of that minute? Must I go
Still like the thistle-ball, no bar,
Onward, whenever light winds blow,
Fixed by no friendly star?
Just when I seemed about to learn!
Where is the thread now? Off again!
The old trick! Only I discern —
Infinite passion, and the pain
Of finite hearts that yearn.
Never forget. I lost several kids that I coached when they were in middle school. The heroism that was displayed continues to inspire.
I watched the North Tower collapse from the roof of my school in Queens with some of my colleagues, and my knees buckled, because of the horror and because my younger daughter went to school ten blocks north of the WTC, and I could see the cloud racing toward it (she and her classmates outraced it, while being evacuated as the tower collapsed).
Shortly after, I walked across the 59th Bridge, since subway service into Manhattan was stopped, and only emergency vehicles were allowed onto the bridge westbound into the city.
Thousands of people and vehicles were streaming east into Queens, away from Manhattan. People were literally crowded onto and hanging off the sides of flatbed trucks to get away, images you usually associate with disasters in developing countries.
My first thought was, “So, this is what it’s like to be on the receiving end of history…”
Trump could speak in complete sentences in 2001. He actually sounds like he knows what he is talking about. Now he can’t. He repeats himself, has broken sentences, skips topics and rambles. Dementia?? Or early alzheimer’s??
………………………………………..
Video: Trump saw on 9/11/2001: bombs were used in WTC
TruthMakesPeace
Published on Sep 16, 2016
President Donald Trump saw the same day that bombs must have been used on the WTC towers on 9/11/2001.
Yesterday he said the the hurricane would be “tremendously big and tremendously wet.”
Who knew that rain was wet?
Oh my Lord. Rolling on the floor laughing here.
We live just a couple of blocks from you, Diane. Your piece reminded me anew of those awful days.
I was filling in at a middle school high on a hill in Brooklyn for a Principal who was out at a meeting. Sunset Park is the highest point in Brooklyn and the school had an (unfortunately) unobstructed, all too clear, perfectly framed view of lower Manhattan and the towers. A security officer came to get me after the first plane hit and we watched together as events unfolded.
The hours following were a blur – pulling down shades and moving classrooms to the other side of the bldg away from the perfect view of horror, trying to calm hysterical parents who appeared almost en masse to collect their kids (and making arrangements late into the afternoon/evening when some, tragically, never showed), frantically trying to reach my husband in Midtown Manhattan and my mother on the Upper West Side, when pretty much all the cell lines were down and land lines too busy to get a call through.
I, too, perfectly remember the bright blue, crisp sky of that morning. I also remember the smoke and smell from the fires that continued to drift over Brooklyn Heights for almost a year afterwards. Surely due to those many months of toxic smoke drifting directly over us – my husband and I, along with so many others in our neighborhood, now deal daily with sinus, allergy and other ailments that have developed since.
We share those awful memories. The smell. The fear. The sirens.
A heartfelt piece; it could only be written by one who was so close to that event.
From where we were here in Texas, most people seemed to be speechless, speaking only to express bewilderment. It just did not sink in quickly what was happening; like our minds did not want to accept what we saw.
For those who experienced it firsthand it can only leave an indelible imprint on their minds. Still, those who are alive have to continue to make the world a better place.
I was in Houston yesterday. I encountered a retiree originally from Dayton, now working in retirement in a service position. I asked him the date, and he told me, in a tone I found a little too officious for my taste, “It’s September 11,” and then aggressively added “Where were you on September 11?”
“On Wall Street,” I said. “Where were you?”
“I was having breakfast with my wife when we saw the attacks on TV,” he said.
“Boy, that’s a great story,” I said.
I’ve never stopped being angry about 9/11. Angry for all kinds of reasons—initial anger over the loss of friends and the complete destruction of a neighborhood (oddly, I did not and still have never wept for any of them, while I would weep at the evening news stories about total strangers who had died); the blind rage over the complete mess of a work commute I had to undergo daily after moving to Brooklyn; the disdain I felt (unfairly, I always knew) toward the people from the Midwest who came to “help” with the cleanup effort, which to me seemed like a kind of extended vacation to a grief theme park; and most of all, anger at outsiders who try to insert themselves into this experience, followed by anger at myself for being petty and territorial. I’m feeling all of this anger again, reading this post and these comments here.
I woke up on 9/11 planning for my husband’s birthday celebration that evening. Then went to work in the next county where I was teaching first grade. That evening the celebration never happened. He swore he would change his birthday to the 12th. My students now are 5 and 6, special ed. I briefly talked about it as history. But on the next day I read a book called “September 12th” that had been written and illustrated by a first grade class about things will be ok.
Thank you, Diane, for your story.