Sometimes it is hard to believe that anyone cares anymore about old-fashioned things like integrity, honesty, accountability, and transparency, especially in the red red states where the charter chains have bought the legislature and the governor.
But look at this story. All of these schools are associated with the Gulen movement, a Turkish chain of charters, the largest in the U.S. They get high test scores. but apparently they crossed the line, wherever that is.
The Ohio Board of Education ordered an immediate investigation of a chain of 19 charter schools in the state today after hearing allegations of test cheating, attendance tampering, sexual misconduct and other misdeeds.
Former teachers from the Horizon Science Academy Dayton High School in Dayton testified at the board’s monthly meeting in Columbus about years of misconduct. Some said they had been afraid to come forward before finding new jobs.
One teacher said he’d made a previous complaint to the Department of Education but never heard back from agency officials.
“Your concerns have not fallen on deaf ears,” promised Board President Debe Terhar. “We hear you and we will move forward with making sure this is investigated.”
Other board members said they were outraged and disgusted. Some said they were taken aback because they’d visited the schools and observed nothing questionable.
“Inside my blood is boiling,” said Deborah Cain, a board member from Uniontown. “It is almost incomprehensible.”
Kellie Kochensparger, a teacher at the school until last year, told board members of an incident in which school officials failed to tell parents that their children were suspended for having oral sex while other students watched at a school festival. The activity was caught on surveillance cameras.
“The school told parents the suspensions were handed out because the kids were outside of their assigned areas,” she said. “As a teacher and parent, when I questioned further, I was told that I ask too many questions and the situation was being handled.”
On another occasion Kochensparger said she was asked to make sure students completed all questions on a standardized state exam before allowing them to turn it in. When she told an administrator that it was not permitted and she would inquire of the Department of Education, she was forbidden from contacting the state.
“I know of one student who failed the 7th grade and then had to repeat the year with the agreement with (an administrator) that she would be promoted to the 9th grade if she passed 7th grade during the second attempt. She indeed completely skipped 8th grade and all associated curriculum,” Kochensparger said.
“I don’t think parents had any idea what was going on at the school. There was great emphasis on keeping parents happy and there was a culture of intimidation intended to discourage teachers from doing anything that could adversely affect the school’s relationship with parents,” she said. “Any teacher who asked too many questions was at risk of getting fired.”
The Chicago-based Concept Schools operate 30 schools throughout the Midwest, including the 19 Horizon Science academies in Ohio. Four are in Columbus. Like all charter schools, they are publicly funded and privately operated.
Some of the schools, including some in Columbus, are part of a broader probe by the FBI.

OMG! This is a must read.
Breaking News: 19 Gulen Charter Schools in Ohio Under Investigation by State Board
LikeLike
At last, a Charter investigation! Closing the barn door after all the horses ran out. These times feel like the Gilded Age all over again.
LikeLike
There is much more here.
LikeLike
High test scores—now we’re talking large data sets that mean something!
😏
Anecdotes about, well, anything else—let’s curb our “psychological bias” to “focus on outliers” like those mentioned in the posting, e.g., “integrity, honesty, accountability, and transparency.” And that doesn’t include salacious defamatory anecdotal attacks on charter franchises like allegations of professional, academic and sexual misconduct carried out or condoned by administrators and managers.
😧
Dr Raj Chetty would be so proud of anyone who saw this posting and promptly buried his/her head in the sand of VAM and numerical accountability.
😳
Me? Not so much…
😡
But what do I know? I’m just your local neighborhood KrazyTA…
😎
LikeLike
Where is Campbell Brown when we need her?
LikeLike
Yes! Campbell Brown will not come out on this because this type of misconduct “only” takes place in public schools. Just think of the blow against her financial interests if she would climb out from behind her rock now.
She is a brazen individual who rubs shoulders with those who steal from children in order to make a profit. They should investigated, prosecuted if complicit in crimes against our nation, and then be thrown in jail. The keys to their cells should be strapped to the garbage Engage New York common core modules, dropped in the Pacific Ocean, near the Mariana Trench which holds the greatest depths, never to be found again!
LikeLike
What a bunch of turkeys.
LikeLike
I wrote an article last week for City Watch Today on the Gulen Movement, and lo and behold, here it is published almost verbatim by a leading Turkish news source. The article online has fascinating comments by Turkish writers, one pro Gulen calling me a liar…and others anti Gulen, giving extended information on him and his Gulen Movement. Well worth a read.
———————————————————————
GÜLEN CHARTER SCHOOLS SCRUTINIZED BY US MEDIA
Daily Sabah
Updated : 13.07.2014 12:58:45
Published : 13.07.2014 12:50:16
Gülen charter schools scrutinized by US media
ISTANBUL – Activities and operations of the Gülen Movement in the US and Turkey have recently been scrutinized by a number of American media outlets which question the movement’s motives, opacity and why the US government is providing refuge to Fethullah Gülen, who is currently facing numerous charges including treason and possibly extradition.
According to Citywatch which is a Los Angeles based website, the Gülen Movement has a secret agenda despite the fact that they describe themselves as a transformational and social movement. They compare it to the Catholic secret society, Opus Dei and claim that the movement is not solely funded by its members but is actually funded by American tax dollars since 1999 when Fethullah Gülen, the leader of the movement came to the US in self-imposed exile. Here, he has established over 147 charter schools with tens of thousands of students and has brought hundreds of teachers and organizational leaders from Turkey to contribute to the movement’s activities. It is claimed that the movement has a net income of about $500 million per year from taxpayer money while each school has between 300 – 800 students also financed by American tax money at about $7,000 per student.
Citywatch also touched upon the fact that there is very little media coverage of the Gülen Movement, which they accuse of “bleeding American public schools and filching the money for their own purposes, from the pockets of American tax payers.”
On the other hand, the News Outlet, a student journalism lab headquartered at Youngstown State University has criticized the Gülen Movement for its opaque nature after they attempted to contact the board members of Gülenist charter schools in Ohio. They question the fact that almost all board members are of Turkish background and claim many of these board members are new to the US unlike traditional American public school board members who cannot be elected without being registered voters. They highlight the fact that Horizon and Noble Academies in Ohio alone received $49,775,180 in taxpayer dollars. Interns at the News Outlet have attempted to get in touch with 20 board members at Concept schools but only received a few responses as only four of them provided partial answers and only two responded to all questions relating to citizenship, how they were elected to the board and experiences with the management company while three people gave the same response: “Horizon Science Academies and Concept Schools were initiated by a few Turkish-American educators who wanted to contribute, in their own capacity and expertise, to the solution of the problem that U.S. was falling behind in STEM education,” the statement reads. “Though an admittedly small group, Turkish Americans are like many other immigrant groups — they come from different backgrounds, but share a common experience and a common goal of contributing to their communities.”
One of the board members in a phone interview has claimed most staff in the charter schools are from Turkey because science and math dedication is apparently much higher than here in average American schools and there is a need for them to be here. Others have refused to respond to the questions on the grounds that they were “too personal” and have claimed they are not allowed to talk.
Some schools of the movement are currently facing closure in Turkey and the US. Recently, two charter schools affiliated with the Gülen Movement in Los Angeles have been ordered to be shut down while four schools in the Turkish city of Bolu were closed by municipal authorities last week. Their schools have also faced closure in Russia and Azerbaijan in the past for numerous reasons while In June, the Federal Bureau of Investigation has raided 19 charter schools affiliated with the Gülen Movement in Ohio, Indiana and Illinois.
Fethullah Gülen, who currently lives in self-imposed exile in Pennsylvania, leads the Gülen Movement. He is accused of orchestrating the Dec. 17 coup attempt and infiltrating Turkish state institutions through Gülenist agents.
LikeLike
This whole “STEM shortage” idea might do with a little investigation:
“Almost two-thirds of college students who graduate with a degree in a STEM field — science, technology, engineering and math — don’t find jobs in those industries.
That’s sobering news considering the nation is starving more than ever for more qualified STEM professionals.”
For goodness sakes. Do they even read this stuff when they churn it out? If they’re not working in STEM fields then where is the shortage? They don’t get hired?
http://www.bizjournals.com/stlouis/blog/biznext/2014/07/stem-grads-don-t-typically-work-in-stem-jobs.html
LikeLike
Here is my City Watch Today article that prompted the Daily Sabah article
——————————————————
Fetullah Gulen : Phantom of the Poconos
The Gulen Movement is advertised by its’ leader and his PR advisors as a “transformational and social movement led by Turkish Imam, scholar and preacher, Fetullah Gulem.” This highly secretive movement is often compared to the Catholic secret society, Opus Dei. Their goal is to be the world’s leading Muslim network, and although it advertises that “it is funded by its’ own members” it is actually funded by American tax payers.
In the real light of day, Fetullah Gulen, who is the single largest charter school operator in the U.S., was chased out of Turkey by current Prime Minister Erdogan and his forces in 1999 and was given refuge in the United States, first by Bill Clinton, then by George Bush, and now by Barak Obama. He lives in a large compound with a fortress-like surrounding and many armed guards in the Poconos Mountains in Pennsylvania. From this protected enclave, and with the further protection of our government, he is fomenting revolution in Turkey to turn his homeland from a secular nation into an Islamist state ruled by strict Sharia law. Even though the Turkish regime wants him extradited to stand trial for promoting insurrection and various other scandals, he is safe in America, calling the shots for extremists in Turkey. He sends huge amounts of money to the Middle East and Turkey to promote his cause.
And this prodigious donation to influence Turkish/Sharia politics is all paid for by We the People, the American taxpayers.
Gulen is the largest owner of charter schools in the U.S. He owns over 147 active charter schools with dozens more awaiting approval in many states including California, with tens of thousands of students who are taken out of public schools to attend his Islamic based charters which teach Turkish language as their prime language and their main focus on Turkish history. He used to also teach Sharia law in these gender segregated schools, but when that became a problem he focused on math and science instead, and now teaches Sharia law on weekend outings for his students. His plan is to educate all students to follow him as their religious and political leader of Turkey, and all of them to return to his homeland with him as his supporters.
Most of his teachers, and all of his principals and other organizational leaders are Middle Eastern men who are allowed into the U.S. on green cards to run this multi billion dollar operation. According to the tax research done by Sharon Higgins who is the best reporter on his activities, he nets about $500 million a year, all on the back of the American taxpayer. (google Sharon Higgins website for up to date facts on Gulen and his charter schools.) Each student gets ADA money, average daily attendance, which the school district is mandated to release since the money for education follows the student. Each school has between 300 – 800 students financed by American tax money at about $7,000 per student, which represents a huge fortune over the past 15 years.
It is this money that is paying for fomenting revolution in Turkey where Gulen plans to return soon to become the nation’s leader and make his country a true Sharia ruled state. This means that girls no longer will be going to school, and all will be forced to wear purdah. Boys will be studying mainly Koran as in madrassas world wide. In a addition to American charter schools, Gulen runs about 1,000 other schools world wide. His goal it would appear is to establish a second Ottoman Empire and all under rigid Sharia law.
Erdogan and his government see Gulen as a danger to their secular nation. He is pressing criminal charges against Gulen for a wire tapping scandal, and he feels that this is not only a religious movement, but it is also political and illegal. He accuses the U.S. of sheltering and supporting Gulen, and he wants him extradited to Turkey to face criminal charges. All of this is factual and further information can be found online(read the Washington Post article The Answer Sheet by Valerie Strauss 3/27/12 quoting Sharon Higgins).
So the questions are why would three consecutive American administrations let Gulen operate under the aegis of American protection? Also, why is there so little media attention paid to this secret group which, like leeches, is bleeding American public schools and filching the money for their own religous/political purposes, from the pockets of American tax payers?
The LA Times published a front page story on Gulen some months ago, but they did not print a single letter to the editor written by the many teachers in Joining Forces for Education, nor other members of the general reading public which asked these questions. When they got complaints and questions as to why they dropped the whole issue, they were totally and completely silent.
Why is the mainstream media avoiding reporting on all this public information?
Is it that they are colluding with our leaders to keep this man in a protected shell while he continues to be a main player in shaping the politics of the Middle East?
————————————————————————————————————–
Ellen Lubic, Director, Joining Forces for Education
Educational researcher
Public Policy university educator
LikeLike
Ms. Lubic,
I find your descriptions of the Gulen movement to be a bit hyperbolic and anxious. While I would not argue with your facts, I wonder about your sources for those facts.Can you document for me the sources that claim the movement’s intent to establish “Shariah” law in Turkey or anywhere else? I would also be interested in your sources that claim any funding provided from American tax payers apart from the support for the movement’s Charter Schools. That said, I agree that American tax dollars should NOT be used to support the Gulen Charter schools. No other religious based groups, especially Christian, woudl receive such support from public education funding. Thank you…
LikeLike
Ellen, my best guess as to why the United States continues to harbor Gulen is the same reason it hasn’t pushed Turkey to admit responsibility for the Armenian Genocide: we need our air bases there to help maintain and strengthen our foothold in the Middle East.
What do you think the odds are that the Armenian Genocide is ever taught in a Gulen school? Don’t hold your breath.
It’s not out of the realm of possibility that the American government sees Gulen as a potential Karzai-like figure they can install in Turkey at some point in the future. A puppet.
This stuff goes way beyond schools, which is why so much crap has been overlooked. In Los Angeles, the LA Unified School District’s Charter Division has published a scathing letter summarizing financial chicanery that has taken place at three Magnolia Educational and Research Foundation schools, which falls under the Gulen umbrella. This has come in advance of an IG audit, which is being held up by threat of injunction but which also has the potential to put MERF out of business in California for good.
Someone needs to submit a FOIA request for correspondence and records dealing with the relationship between LAUSD Supt. Deasy, Chief Counsel Homquist, Charter Division head Cole-Gutierrez and other top administrators and MERF. I don’t doubt that for a second that these people knew there was a lot of crap going on before last month.
Other than that, I have no opinion.
LikeLike
please watch these two videos:
the first video is a State Representative who took the $10,000 bribe:
http://www.newschannel5.com/story/25530882/lawmaker-says-10k-contribution-resolution-just-coincidence#.U3VzafVWIQI.gmail
and the next is a video of a commissioner who congratulates a dictator on his corrupt election:
http://www.newschannel5.com/story/25539383/tn-commissioner-offers-congrats-for-rigged-re-election?autoStart=true&topVideoCatNo=default&clipId=10171384
LikeLike
Not for nothing, why is America outsourcing charters to Turkey and giving work visas to Turks for jobs that are not a specialty, at charters that have long been suspect? Politics. When it is divulged just WHO the politicians are/were, they should be thrown out of office! Likely it goes all the way to Obama since Duncan and Obama love them some charters, regardless of impropriety. There is an agenda underfoot. “They” thought no one would ever uncover it.
There are plenty of teachers in America who could have filled the positions filled by Turks (let alone charters that could have been opened by locals). Why does America need to import charters from other countries? We have a lawyer here in Newark whose Visa from China was up, and he had to return to China for a full year because his job wasn’t proprietary only able to be done just by him in particular. The Turk teachers weren’t doing jobs that were proprietary, except for possibly Turkish language studies.
I’ve had enough of it. Enough. Time to expose it all, and let heads roll of the politicians who took bribes, looked away, aided and abetted the destruction of public schools in favor of thieving charters from other countries.
LikeLike
It’s so funny, because if this had been sold to the public honestly, if they had said “we’re bringing in Turkish teachers because there is no one in this state to fill these jobs” people in Ohio would have rejected it out of hand.
People here are very much “buy local”. I cannot imagine this would have flown, politically, which is why they were never informed.
LikeLike
Sorry but you are both wrong. The government and people who do intensive research and reporting like Sharon Higgins, and even me, have been notifying the public, and the members who comment here, for a long time on all these issues. Not much attention has been paid to particularly Sharon’s excellent reports…until lately. She has been interviewed at university conferences and on TV to little notice or avail. She is the foremost authority on Gulen and posts here often.
Stating here that one has “had enough of it” is not a solution. Everyone here must send this info to all your email lists, write all news sources, and make intense efforts to create change. Otherwise, it is just noise.
LikeLike
Ellen 60 minutes did a report on the Gulen Charter schools.
US Charter Schools tied to powerful Turkish Imam. http://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-charter-schools-tied-to-powerful-turkish-imam/
Requests should be made to a follow up to this report especially considering the legal investigations these charters are facing.
LikeLike
Two more Gulen schools were just closed in LA due to financial improprieties.
LikeLike
These schools were approved and allowed because there was a perceived STEM shortage. But that has also been covered on this blog. A must read for all :https://dianeravitch.net/2013/09/12/is-there-a-stem-shortage/
LikeLike
Another argument for due process (a.k.a. tenure): it protects whistleblowers and thereby deters these sorts of cover-ups and corruption. I wonder if the anti-tenure zealots ever factor this into their moral calculus.
LikeLike
“It is not the answer that enlightens, but the question.” [Ionesco]
But answers ain’t bad either. In this case, if teachers had sufficiently strong job protections then transparency, responsibility, accountability, ethical behavior and moral conduct might run amok, and as the Bee Eater Herself says—
“I reject that mind-set.”
Michelle Rhee—the grift that keeps on taking…
*Did I get the above maxim wrong?*
😎
LikeLike
And you know what is going to happen about this? Gulan schools will be cleared. Business as usual. That is the disgusting thought that just occurred to me.
This isn’t the first time Gulan has been investigated or raided. It has been ongoing for years. Why were these schools ever allowed? Money. They will likely be found “innocent” of everything, and will open even more schools.
LikeLike
The entire concept of charter schools is anti-democratic. My friend pays $1,000.00 participation fee to be in the marching band, while charter bandits make of with millions.
LikeLike
The 3 Concept Schools in Indianapolis (Indiana Math and Science Academy) appear to charge a $25 per student per year “enrollment fee” or “reenrollment fee” that must be submitted at the time of enrollment in order to “hold your spot” for the next school year. This means it must be paid as much as 5 months before the school year begins. No fee, no enroll. It looks like this is common practice in Concept Schools. There are also other irregularities in their enrollment documents here, which seem to result in a much lower free/reduced lunch rate than the nearby public schools. And they are mailing full color glossy brochures and 10 page plus booklets that prominently proclaim on the front page ” A rated school”, and then direct the parent to enroll their child in any of the 3 schools. In fact, one school is rated A, one is rated F, and the 3rd has only been in operation for 1 year and can’t be rated yet.
LikeLike
I can’t believe no one in Indianapolis is even noticing these things. Have you read the book The Hoosier School Heist?
LikeLike
I’m very familiar with the issues and the players. Media coverage of Indiana issues is drastically different in Indianapolis (very limited and one sided) as compared to Ft Wayne, Bloomington and Terre Haute. There are former parents at the IMSA schools who are very angry and willing to be interviewed. There is a major media story here, for the journalist willing to take it on.
LikeLike
A study on what parents in the affected neighborhoods believe are the effects of the massive Chicago public school closure program:
Click to access Root-Shock-Report-Compressed.pdf
LikeLike
The Ohio Department of Education finds itself in an unusual position, as reported in the news, today.
A judge ruled that the ODE must sponsor VLT Academy, a 600 student charter school.
ODE refused to do so earlier, citing academic performance and financial concerns. VLT was unable to find a sponsor so apparently, the ODE is sponsor of last resort.
Evidence of a quagmire, created in Columbus, by on again, off-again fiscal conservatives?
LikeLike
The Ravitch blog, June 19, had a post about VLT’s record, “Ohio: Another Charter School (may) be Closing.”
LikeLike
Oh, well. That’s what happens when lawmakers “relinquish” their role in public education. The contractor calls the shots.
They become irrelevant.
Too bad, too sad for Ohio lawmakers. Maybe they should have done their jobs instead of outsourcing it to contractors.
LikeLike
And, too bad for students, tax payers and society. Was there ever a time when Ohio decision-makers worked for the people?
LikeLike
Where has Ohio Attorney General Mike Dewine been while Ohio has amassed one of the worst records in the nation on charter school accountability? ABSENT.
I had the pleasure of meeting and talking with candidate David Pepper a few weeks ago and he was vowing to crack down on Ohio’s charters before even had a chance to mention it. It’s time for Ohioans to elect people who will support our public schools rather than undermine them. Pay to play politics is out of control in Ohio – education is sadly not immune.
LikeLike
All the top level administrators, CEO, CFO, CAO etc., should immediately be investigated and they should have thorough back ground checks completed. There may be relatives of “Dr.” Sharpe from CT employed there. Same scam just in a different state. Definitely check all the credentials of those that claim to have any type of doctorate.
LikeLike
I was there.
This morning I witnessed the unbelievably courageous testimony of 4 former Gulen Horizon Science Academy charter teachers at the State School Board meeting in Columbus, Ohio. These tragic transgressions are criminal actions funded by our taxpayer dollars. For the rest of their lives, children will be dealing with the trauma they have experienced in these schools from sexual harassment, racism and sexism sanctioned by Gulen’s administrators and selected teachers. These 4 teachers are Heroes; professionally, they each have moved on, but collectively, were morally compelled to seek justice for their former students and help prevent other innocent children from being victimized.
Where is the oversight?
Who is responsible for carte blanche charter operations funded by taxpayer dollars in Ohio?
Who will get to the bottom of this travesty?
Who will be the first to resign for looking the other way while our children suffered?
LikeLike
maureenreedy: your comments are the answer to the question—
Why do the self-styled “education reformers” want to shut teachers up?
Thank you for your comments.
😎
LikeLike
Thanks so much…
See comments below attached to Linda’s comments.
We are not shutting up, we are gaining volume, media attention, and strength in numbers.
Truth, integrity and justice for children, teachers, public ed and democracy is on our side.
Thank you, I always love your take on issues and comments.
LikeLike
maureenreedy,
Your attendance at the meeting tells the State Board that they are accountable to the public. Katie’s prior comment about getting support for David Pepper, to replace Atty. Gen. Dewine is important. Voting for Kasich’s opponent is vital.
Thanks for what you are doing.
LikeLike
Thanks Linda,
I am working with this group of courageous teachers, this is just the beginning, more to come.
YES! David Pepper is key, FitzGerald is running neck in neck with K, hugely important to band together in SB 5 fashion, across professions, across party lines, to preserve public ed, women’s rights, worker’s rights, environment, middle class… you name it.
Ohio Friends of Public Ed has 5 regional groups around the state currently and we are also working with other statewide advocacy groups to form Public Education Partnerships in Ohio (PEPO) to broaden our reaching to existing advocacy groups.
For example, this Gulen investigation is a result of Ohio Friends of Public Ed partnering with Progress Ohio, a stellar group with reporters, media infrastructure, research team, etc.
Good things happening.
Thanks for all you are doing to raise awareness for our kids, our teachers and teaching profession and public education across the board.
The tide is turning.
LikeLike
please watch these two videos:
the first video is a State Representative who took the $10,000 bribe:
http://www.newschannel5.com/story/25530882/lawmaker-says-10k-contribution-resolution-just-coincidence#.U3VzafVWIQI.gmail
and the next is a video of a commissioner who congratulates a dictator on his corrupt election:
http://www.newschannel5.com/story/25539383/tn-commissioner-offers-congrats-for-rigged-re-election?autoStart=true&topVideoCatNo=default&clipId=10171384
LikeLike
This particular charter group is very concerned with how female teachers dress (see their handbook) and at least one of their principals can not write literate English.
LikeLike
Just a reminder that the Gulen-sponsored charter schools have been under investiation in Louisiana – the one in New Orleans was shut down after an LDE official claimed they tried to bribe him. The one in Baton Rouge was raided by the FBI in December. Of course, our infamous Supt. of Ed – John White- and our Pres. of the State Board of Education (whose sister runs the largest charter school assoc. in the state) agreed to renew the charter for the B.R. School even after they knew about the FBI raid. And the reports out of the N.O. school about (turkish) teachers who never showed up for class or couldn’t speak English were just ridiculous.
Incidentally, the LDE whistleblower took the fall for the LDE and was fired after he reported the alleged bribing attempt. He soon showed up as a principal of another charter school in New Orleans. Coincidence?
http://www.nola.com/education/baton-rouge/index.ssf/2013/12/kenilworth_charter_school_subj.html
LikeLike